Back to Search

AS355F2 Twin Squirrel, G-SEWP, 28 October 2010

Air Accidents (AAIB)

Published on 10 December 2014, 22:27

Summary
aircraft category
commercial-rotorcraft
aircraft type
AS355F2 Twin Squirrel
bulk published
1
date of occurrence
2010-10-28
location
31 nm south of Belfast Aldergrove Airport, Northern Ireland
registration
G-SEWP
report type
field-investigation

Report Overview

AS355F2 Twin Squirrel, G-SEWP

Summary:

The pilot lost control of the helicopter whilst manoeuvring at low speed to approach a hilltop landing site in quite strong wind conditions. It descended rapidly with increasing forward ground speed, before striking the ground short of the point of intended landing and passing through a substantial stone wall. The helicopter was destroyed but the occupants suffered only minor injuries. The investigation determined that an error of judgement or perception led the pilot to attempt a downwind approach. A combination of human factors was thought to have contributed to the accident.

This overview has been truncated. Please refer to the official documents below for the complete canonical report.

Official Documents

  • AS355F2 Twin Squirrel, G-SEWP 06-11.pdf

Document Content Preview

Extracted text from the first few pages of the official documents.

AS355F2 Twin Squirrel, G-SEWP 06-11.pdf

43 © Crown copyright 2011 AAIB Bulletin: 6/2011 G-SEWP EW/C2010/10/03 ACCIDENT Aircraft Type and Registration: AS355F2 Twin Squirrel, G-SEWP No & Type of Engines: 2 Allison 250-C20F turboshaft engines Constructor’s Serial No: 5480 Year of Manufacture: 1991 Date & Time (UTC): 28 October 2010 at 0950 hrs Location: 31 nm south of Belfast Aldergrove Airport, Northern Ireland Type of Flight: Commercial Air Transport (Passenger) Persons on Board: Crew - 1 Passengers - 3 Injuries: Crew - 1 (Minor) Passengers - 3 (Minor) Nature of Damage: Aircraft destroyed Commander’s Licence: Commercial Pilot’s Licence (Helicopter) Commander’s Age: 42 years Commander’s Flying Experience: 2,045 hours (of which 185 were on type) Last 90 days - 47 hours Last 28 days - 21 hours Information Source: AAIB Field Investigation Synopsis The pilot lost control of the helicopter whilst manoeuvring at low speed to approach a hilltop landing site in quite strong wind conditions. It descended rapidly with increasing forward ground speed, before striking the ground short of the point of intended landing and passing through a substantial stone wall. The helicopter was destroyed but the occupants suffered only minor injuries. The investigation determined that an error of judgement or perception led the pilot to attempt a downwind approach. A combination of human factors was thought to have contributed to the accident. History of the flight The helicopter was engaged on a task for the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI), ferrying personnel and equipment to and from the site of a helicopter accident which had occurred 5 days earlier, on 23 October 2010. The site was in the Mourne Mountains, near to the top of the 626 m (2,054 ft) amsl Shanlieve hill. A PSNI control point, from where passengers embarked for the ferry flights, had been established in a valley about 3 km from the site. G-SEWP had been similarly tasked the day before, completing seven round trips. The same pilot operated the task, but with a different observer than on the day of 44 © Crown copyright 2011 AAIB Bulletin: 6/2011 G-SEWP EW/C2010/10/03 the accident. Cloud affected the hilltop on occasions and the first three flights terminated at an alternative landing site lower down the hill. On the day of the accident, the pilot and observer commenced their pre-flight duties at 0700 hrs at their Aldergrove base. A ‘check A’ was made on the helicopter and the fuel state was confirmed at 65% (about 475 litres). A weather report showed that a warm front was forecast to cross the area, giving rise to cloud on the hilltops. It was thought that a workable period should be available prior to the weather front’s passage at about lunchtime, and possibly afterwards as well. Surface winds were expected to be about 10 kt at the surface, and about 20 kt on the hilltops, generally from the south-west. The helicopter departed Aldergrove at 0744 hrs and flew to the accident area, where the pilot carried out a weather check. Cloud was affecting the hilltops and the helicopter circled the area without overflying the primary landing site near the summit. The helicopter then landed and shut down adjacent to the police control point. A plan for the morning’s task was agreed and passengers were briefed accordingly. It was decided that ‘rotors running’ turn-rounds would be made, with the observer escorting passengers to and from the helicopter. The observer normally occupied the front left seat in the helicopter, but for mass and balance purposes he occupied the rear right seat for the ferry flights. This also allowed better monitoring and supervision of the passengers. While the pilot and observer wore safety helmets, only headsets were available to the passengers. The first flight could not be made to the hilltop because of cloud, so the passengers were disembarked at the alternative landing site. However, the next four flights were able to reach the primary landing site, situated a few metres from the summit of the hill, near to a substantial stone wall and a little way upslope from the earlier accident area. The accident occurred on the last planned ferry flight of the morning. It appeared that the summit was affected by cloud so the pilot initially routed towards the alternative landing site. However, it then became apparent that the summit was clear of cloud, so the pilot continued towards it. The four previous approaches had been made from the north-east, approximately into wind. Whilst at the summit on the previous flight the pilot thought that the wind had backed and reduced in strength. On the accident flight, because of the possible drop-off at the alternative site, the helicopter approached the hilltop from a westerly direction. It overflew the landing site and started a right turn back towards it (Figure 1). The pilot’s recollection was that he had completed at least a full orbit and was approaching the landing site substantially into wind, although this time on a more south or south-easterly track. With the landing site in view ahead, and whilst making his final approach at about 40 kt IAS, the pilot sensed a sudden loss of airspeed and lift, which he regarded as being due to windshear. The helicopter began to sink rapidly, accompanied by some instability in yaw. The pilot checked forward with the cyclic control in an attempt to gain airspeed and fly out of the situation. The helicopter continued to sink as the pilot raised the collective lever to apply power. With the helicopter descending rapidly and now with significant forward speed, the pilot flared the helicopter just before it struck the ground. He recalled that it struck the ground a short distance before the intended landing site. The occupants sensed that the rear of the helicopter 45 © Crown copyright 2011 AAIB Bulletin: 6/2011 G-SEWP EW/C2010/10/03 struck the ground first, followed by the main cabin, in a substantial (though essentially upright) impact. The helicopter bounced and continued forward as it started to break up. It passed through the upper portion of the stone wall and came to rest some 36 m beyond. The pilot and observer extricated themselves from the largely inverted wreckage of the main cabin. The observer then assisted the first of the passengers out, who had been seated in the left middle of the four-place rear seat. The second passenger, who had been seated in the left-most rear seat, was the most severely injured, suffering cuts and bruises which included a laceration of his scalp. He was also helped from the wreckage by the observer. The survivors were taken to a tent being used by recovery teams working on the original accident site, where they were given first aid. The weather worsened soon after the accident, which initially prevented Figure 1 Sketch of accident location 46 © Crown copyright 2011 AAIB Bulletin: 6/2011 G-SEWP EW/C2010/10/03 further airborne access to the scene, so a rescue effort was launched on foot by mountain rescue personnel and paramedics. After some time, an RAF Sea King rescue helicopter was able to get to the scene and airlifted the survivors off the hillside. Paramedics arrived with the mountain rescue teams at about the same time as the rescue helicopter. Accident site information The helicopter struck approximately level ground in an erect attitude. The softness of the ground, the remoteness of the site and the adverse weather during the subsequent investigation limited the extent of the assessment of the ground markings which could be made. The general condition of the helicopter, however, suggested a reasonably low rate of descent at initial ground contact. Absence of any earth deposits on the tail-skid (despite the soft peaty soil of the area) indicated no excessively nose-up attitude at initial ground contact. Rapid upset of the aircraft from the level attitude (as a consequence of forward motion with the skids in contact with a soft peaty surface) appeared to have result

Text truncated. The original document has 9 pages.

Read the full text here

Change History

  • First published.

Related Entities

Search the database for other reports involving these entities.