Back to Search

Escapade 912(1), G-CDLE, 4 April 2009

Air Accidents (AAIB)

Published on 10 December 2014, 22:07

Summary
aircraft category
sport-aviation-and-balloons
aircraft type
Escapade 912(1)
bulk published
1
date of occurrence
2009-04-04
location
Shobdon Airfield, Herefordshire
registration
G-CDLE
report type
field-investigation

Report Overview

Escapade 912(1), G-CDLE

Summary:

While positioning to join the visual circuit, G-CDLE took avoiding action on a departing aircraft. G-CDLE subsequently entered a spin from about 500 ft aal and crashed onto land adjacent to the airfield. Both occupants were fatally injured on impact.

Download report:

Escapade 912(1), G-CDLE 01-10.pdfDownload (385.73 kb)

This overview has been truncated. Please refer to the official documents below for the complete canonical report.

Official Documents

Document Content Preview

Extracted text from the first few pages of the official documents.

Escapade 912(1), G-CDLE 01-10.pdf

53 © Crown copyright 2010 AAIB Bulletin: 1/2010 G-CDLE EW/C2009/04/02 ACCIDENT Aircraft Type and Registration: Escapade 912(1), G-CDLE No & Type of Engines: 1 Rotax 912-UL piston engine Year of Manufacture: 2005 Date & Time (UTC): 4 April 2009 at 1435 hrs Location: Shobdon Airfield, Herefordshire Type of Flight: Private Persons on Board: Crew - 1 Passengers - 1 Injuries: Crew - 1 (Fatal) Passengers - 1 (Fatal) Nature of Damage: Destroyed Commander’s Licence: Private Pilot’s Licence Commander’s Age: 56 years Commander’s Flying Experience: 86 hours (of which 77 were on type) Last 90 days - 2 hours Last 28 days - 1 hour Information Source: AAIB Field Investigation Synopsis While positioning to join the visual circuit, G-CDLE took avoiding action on a departing aircraft. G-CDLE subsequently entered a spin from about 500  ft aal and crashed onto land adjacent to the airfield. Both occupants were fatally injured on impact. History of the flight The aircraft took off from its base at Eastbach Farm Airfield, near Lydbrook, Gloucestershire, at about 1045 hrs with the pilot and a passenger on board. It flew to Over Farm Airstrip, near Gloucester, before landing at Rodley Airstrip, 5 nm south-east of Gloucester, at about 1140 hrs. People who spoke to both occupants at Rodley stated that they “were both their normal selves and were both in good spirits”. The aircraft departed Rodley at 1340 hrs destined for Shobdon Airfield, Herefordshire, where it is believed the occupants planned to take lunch. Shobdon were using Runway 27 where the weather was CAVOK with a surface wind of 270º/15-20 kt. The pilot made contact with Shobdon radio at approximately 1400 hrs and told the Flight Information Service Officer (FISO) that he was 3 nm south of the airfield at 1,400 ft aal. When asked by the FISO if he was familiar with the circuit at Shobdon the pilot replied “affirmative” and said he would join the microlight circuit at 1,500 ft. At 1425 hrs the pilot reported “descending dead side ”, to which the FISO advised “not below 1,500 ft due to gliding”; this was 54 © Crown copyright 2010 AAIB Bulletin: 1/2010 G-CDLE EW/C2009/04/02 acknowledged by the pilot. A visitor to the air traffic control tower brought the FISO’s attention to an aircraft in a spiral descent at about 500 ft aal. The FISO saw the spiral descent develop into a nose-low vertical descent before it impacted a field about 150 m north of the runway. There was a post-impact fire. The AFRS were quickly on scene and extinguished the fire with foam. Paramedics from a visiting Air Ambulance declared both occupants dead at the scene. Witness accounts Several witnesses on the ground saw the final moments of the aircraft’s flight. They all described seeing the aircraft in a vertical spiral dive/spin. One pilot witness on the ground described seeing the aircraft at “no more than 500 ft and quite slow.” Having taken his eyes off the aircraft for a few moments this witness next observed the aircraft’s left wing drop, followed by the nose as it entered a vertical dive and went into a spin. An airborne pilot in another microlight passed adjacent to G-CDLE soon after he had taken off from Shobdon whilst still on the runway centreline, heading west. He stated that he first saw G-CDLE after his passenger brought it to his attention as his aircraft climbed through 400 ft aal. G-CDLE was about 400 m away at his two o’clock position, approximately 50 ft above him and on a conflicting track. He closed the throttle and pushed the control column forward to pass underneath G-CDLE. As he did so, G-CDLE turned sharply to the left and appeared to stall almost immediately. The left wing “dropped sharply” and the aircraft rotated anti-clockwise through about 180° in a near vertical attitude before he lost sight of it. His passenger subsequently reported that the aircraft had crashed adjacent to the airfield near the upwind end of the active runway. Aircraft details The Escapade is a three-axis microlight aircraft. Certification flight testing of the Escapade reported that 400-600 ft was required to recover from a one-turn spin or a spiral dive. An aircraft checklist recovered from the accident site stated that the clean stall speed was 30 mph. Occupants’ details The pilot’s logbook showed that he had previously visited Shobdon on six occasions, the last time being in August  2008. The passenger was an experienced qualified flex-wing microlight pilot. Medical information Post mortem reports on both occupants stated that they received severe injuries as a result of a relatively high speed impact. Toxicology revealed no evidence of alcohol or drugs in either occupant. Airfield details The following information on Shobdon Airfield is published in the UK Aeronautical Information Publication and pilots’ flight guides. ‘Circuit directions: Runway 27 – LH [Left Hand]; Runway 09 – RH [Right Hand]. Overhead joins: Descend not below 1,500 ft aal dead side, further descent to circuit height when south of runway. Circuit heights: Powered fixed-wing circuits at 1,000 ft QFE to the south of the villages; 55 © Crown copyright 2010 AAIB Bulletin: 1/2010 G-CDLE EW/C2009/04/02 Microlight circuits at 500 ft QFE; Helicopter circuits at 700 ft QFE inside the normal circuit pattern.’ A copy of a flight guide for Shobdon Airfield was found on the pilot’s knee board. Engineering The aircraft wreckage came to rest approximately 150 m north of the Runway 09 threshold. A substantial post-impact fire had destroyed the fabric covering, the fuel system and most of the combustible components. The tubular aluminium alloy wing spars were partly melted. The firm dry crop surface, coupled with the low mass of most of the aircraft components, resulted in no ground markings of the extremities of the aircraft being identifiable at the impact site. The left landing gear leg and nose leg had both been displaced substantially to the right by the impact, being positioned beneath the centre fuselage, whilst the right main gear was almost undamaged. The left tail-plane was deflected upwards from a station just outboard of the bracing tube, although it was not in contact with the ground after the aircraft came to rest. The complete wing structure had migrated forward, rotated to the left relative to the fuselage and rotated in a leading-edge, nose‑down sense. The leading edge had been crushed, in the plane of the structure, over its entire span, as a result of its ground impact. The displacement of the complete wing structure had resulted in the right Glass Reinforced Plastic (GRP) fuel tank, positioned within the wing structure, coming into forceful contact with the top of the engine cowling. This appeared to have punctured the lower surface of the tank, allowing fuel to spill onto the engine. The fuselage structure below the seats and engine was considerably crushed. On removal of the aircraft from the site, a slight ground impression was observed below the area previously occupied by the engine and centre fuselage structure. No evidence was observed of damage or failure within the flying control system which could not be attributed to the effects of impact or fire. The aircraft was fitted with a three-bladed propeller, each blade having carbon composite skins with a foam core. Two of the blades had failed, but had not separated, close to the roots as a result of backward bending, whilst the third blade had shattered. Areas of carbon composite and fragments of foam were distributed in approximately a straight line at right-angles to the propeller shaft axis. None of the aircraft’s flight instruments were identifiable from the wreckage. Analysis Engineering The general condition of the aircraft was consistent with it having suffered an impact at a high vertical speed whilst banked to the left with low forward speed. The bent state of the left tail-plane, which did not remain in contact with the ground, further indicates a high descent rat

Change History

  • First published.

Related Entities

Search the database for other reports involving these entities.