David Fallon and others v Hidden Assets Ltd: 2203487/2019
Employment Tribunal
Published on 06 August 2020, 11:48
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
unlawful-deduction-from-wages
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2020-03-10
Change History
-
Reconsideration added
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number: 2203487/2019
1 of 1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: David Fallon
Respondent: Hidden Assets Limited
Heard at: London Central (in private) On: 10 March 2020
Before: Employment Judge Stout (sitting alone)
Appearances
For the Claimant: No appearance
For the Respondent: Mr Goldup (consultant)
JUDGMENT ON COSTS
The Claimant’s application for costs of 9 March 2020 is dismissed.
_____________________________________________
Employment Judge Stout
10 March 2020
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
11 March 2020
FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Where reasons were given orally at the hearing, written reasons will not be provided unless they are asked for by a request in writing presented by any party under Rule 62(3) within 14 days of the sending of this judgment.
Case Number: 2203487/2019
HC
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr D Fallon and others
Respondent: Hidden Assets Limited
Heard at: London Central Employment Tribunal On: 26 June 2020
Before: Employment Judge H Clark (sitting alone)
RECONSIDERATION
The Claimants’ (Mr Dean Fallon and Mr Ashley Dixon) applications for a
reconsideration of the rejection of their claims on 3 June 2020 is refused.
REASONS
1. By an email dated 17 June 2020 the Claimant asked for a reconsideration of the
Tribunal’s rejection of Ashley Dixon and Dean Fallon’s claims pursuant to rule
13(1)(b) of the Employment Tribunal (Constitution and Rules of Procedure)
Regulations 2013. The Respondent opposes the application for reasons set out
in an email dated 23 June 2020.
The Law
2. The Tribunal has the power to reconsider the rejection of a Claim Form
under rule 13 of the 2013 Regulations, which provides as follows:
“13.—(1) A claimant whose claim has been rejected (in whole or in part) under
rule 10 or 12 may apply for a reconsideration on the basis that either—
(a)the decision to reject was wrong; or
(b)the notified defect can be rectified.
(2) The application shall be in writing and presented to the Tribunal within 14
days of the date that the notice of rejection was sent. It shall explain why the
decision is said to have been wrong or rectify the defect and if the claimant
wishes to request a hearing this shall be requested in the application.
(3) If the claimant does not request a hearing, or an Employment Judge decides,
on considering the application, that the claim shall be accepted in full, the Judge
Case Numbers: 2200339/2019
2
shall determine the application without a hearing. Otherwise the application shall
be considered at a hearing attended only by the claimant.
(4) If the Judge decides that the original rejection was correct but that the defect
has been rectified, the claim shall be treated as presented on the date that the
defect was rectified.”
The Application
3. The Claimants’ applications are made on the basis that the reason for the
Tribunal’s rejection of the Claim Form was that the wrong form had been used
(an ET1 as opposed to an ET1A Form). It is pointed out that the omission of the
Claimants’ addresses from the Claim Form has now been rectified. The other
reasons put forward for why the Tribunal should accept the Claims is that it was
a technical point only and there would be no prejudice to the Respondent in
adding additional Claimants, the pleadings have addressed all three Claims and
the Respondent was given leave to file its Response Form out of time. The
Claimants did not request a hearing to determine this application.
4. The application was copied to the Respondent (who would not normally receive
it, as Claim Forms are normally rejected before the involvement of the
Respondent). Accordingly, the Respondent has made submissions as to why
the Claimants’ applications should be rejected. Firstly, it is said that the
Claimant has misunderstood the basis for the rejection of the Claims and, thus,
has not addressed matters relevant to the rejection. Further, the Respondent
points out there will be implications in terms of costs and time in hearing three
claims rather than one. The fact that the Respondent obtained an extension of
time is irrelevant to this application and the Claimants’ claims are now
substantially out of time (an issue which is not addressed in the Claimants’
submissions). The Claimants were professionally represented at the time the
defect in their claims occurred and, as such, any remedy for a failure to file a
timely claim should lie against their representative (Dedman v British Building
and Engineering Appliances Ltd [1973] IRLR 379). Although Mr Whalley
appears to be a non-practising Solicitor, pursuant to Ashcroft v Haberdashers
Askes’ Boys School UKEAT/0151/07, a remedy lies against the Claimants’
representative. The Respondent suggests that there are public policy reasons
why the Claimants’ potential remedy should lie against Edgecote & Co, on the
basis that, it is said, the latter are “operating unregulated and without exemption
and failing to conduct litigation to the standard required and expected of a
professional legal service.” In the alternative, the additional Claimants’ claims
should be struck out for being significantly out of time in circumstances when it
was reasonably practicable for them to be submitted earlier.
5. The Respondent objects to the tone in parts of the Claimants’ application, which
implies that the Respondent “opportunistically” seized on a technical point and
put the Tribunal under “considerable pressure” in its submissions. For the
avoidance of doubt, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent’s representative
has acted entirely properly in furtherance of his client’s interests and in
accordance with his duty to the Tribunal in this context.
Conclusions
Case Numbers: 2200339/2019
3
6. Paragraph 9 of the record of the telephone case management hearing dated 3
June 2020 provided, “Although the additional Claimants have since provided
their addresses (on 27 March 2020), if they wish to apply for a reconsideration
of the rejection, they will have to do so in accordance with rule 13, which will
include providing their addresses inserted on form ET1A.” It is noted that this
does not appear to have been done. Further, the Claimants’ representative has
made no submissions concerning the effect of their default on the primary time
limit for the claims.
7. In reaching a decision under the 2013 Rules, the Tribunal must give effect to the
overriding objective in Rule 2 to deal with cases fairly and justly. This includes
avoiding unnecessary formality and seeking flexibility in the proceedings, saving
expense and avoiding delay.
8. The Tribunal does not accept the Respondent’s submission that the addition of
two Claimants will materially increase the length of the final hearing or the costs
of defending the claims, subject to what appears below in relation to
jurisdictional issues (time limits). There is nothing in the pleadings which
suggests that the three individual Claimants (who are all related) were treated
any differently by the Respondent in relation to their terms of engagement and
they appear to have been dealt with consistently by the Respondent in relation
to any alleged deductions from their pay. Whilst there may be a marginal
difference in relation to the payment figures, the alternative to hearing all three
cases together in the Employment Tribunal will be for one claim to be
determined in the Employment Tribunal and the other two in the County Court.
As such, it would save both parties expense and avoid delay for all three claims
to be heard together in one forum.
9. The fact that the Respondent was granted an extension of time to file a
Response Form is not a relevant consideration in the context of this
reconsideration. It merely demonstrates a circumstance in which the Tribunal
has exercised a discretion under the Rules. The primary difficulty with the
Claimants’ application relates to their own delay in rectifying the original defect,
which has meant that their claims are many months out of time. Whilst it is right
for the Tribunal to take account of the fact that it appears that the prospective
Claimants’ Claim Forms were not formally rejected and returned to them by the
Tribunal when they were presented on 15 September 2019, the Tribunal has
been provided with no explanation for the original default.
10. The two additional Claim Forms were rejected due to the omission of the
prospective Claimants’ addresses. This defect was rectified on 27 March 2020,
following a hearing before EJ Stout on 10 March 2020, when they were ordered
to provide confirmation of their contact details, including their addresses, by 27
March 2020. 27 March 2020 is deemed to be the date of presentation of the
prospective Claimants’ claims (rule 13(4) of the 2013 Rules). The Claimants’
claims relate to deductions which were made from their pay in April 2019,
therefore, so their claims are substantially out of time.
11. The claims are subject to the time limit set out in section 23 of the Employment
Rights Act 1996 of 3 months (as extended by section 207B to allow for early
Case Numbers: 2200339/2019
4
conciliation) unless it was “not reasonably practicable” for them to have been
presented within that limit, in which case they can be considered if “presented
within such further period as the Tribunal considers reasonable.”
12. The interplay between the substantive time limits and rules 10 and 12 of the
2013 Regulations have been considered by the Employment Appeal Tribunal in
two cases, namely, Adams v British Telecommunications PLC
UKEAT/0342/15/LA and North East London NHS Foundation Trust v Zhou
UKEAT/0066/18. In the former, a claim was filed with the incorrect EC number
and defect was corrected but the claim was 2 days outside the time limit. It was
held that the Tribunal should have focused on whether there was any
impediment to the timely presentation of the second claim. It does not
automatically follow that a represented Claimant who presents a defective timely
claim, will fall foul of the test of reasonable practicability in relation to a corrected
but late claim. In Zhou the facts were similar, although the remedied Claim
Form was only 1 day out of time. In that case the EAT applied the principle in
Dedman v British Building and Engineering Appliances Ltd [1973] IRLR 379 to
the effect that where a Claimant is professionally represented, they are bound
by the conduct of their professional representatives. If the latter’s conduct was
unreasonable in failing to file an accurate and timely claim, the Claimant will be
fixed with that conduct. The Tribunal is unclear whether Mr Whalley of Edgcote
& Co is acting in his capacity as a Solicitor, but as Ashcroft v Haberdashers
Aske’s Boys School UKEAT/0151/07 makes clear, the Dedman principle still
applies.
13. The fact that the prospective Claimants’ Claim Forms were presented out of
time is not necessarily a barrier to the Tribunal’s accepting their Claims, subject
to the jurisdictional issue being determined in the usual way at an Open
Preliminary Hearing or at the full merits hearing. However, it is clearly a relevant
consideration in the exercise of the Tribunal’s discretion at this stage. The
prospective Claimants’ have been professionally represented throughout and
the burden lies on them to prove either that it was not reasonably practicable to
have presented a timely claim or that if it was, the defect in the original claim
was remedied within a reasonable time. Mr Whalley has offered no explanation
in his application for reconsideration either for the original default (indeed he has
partially mischaracterised the default) or for the delay in remedying it. Failing to
provide the addresses for two of three Claimants, when that is prescribed
information is a qualitatively different default than a typing error in relation to an
EC Certificate (the default in the two reported cases referred to above).
14. When the Claimants received a copy of the proposed Response Form on 6
March 2020, they would have been alerted to the Respondent’s position that
there was only one Claim properly made. The prospective Claimants were then
given until 27 March 2020 to confirm whether they were pursuing their claims
and to provide their addresses. It was left until 27 March 2020 to provide these
details and no explanation has been provided for this further delay.
15. Accepting the two additional Claims following a reconsideration would involve a
further hearing to determine the Tribunal’s jurisdiction to hear them, given they
were presented out of time. This, in itself, will create additional delay and cost
to both parties. In the absence of any reasons put forward by the Claimants as
Case Numbers: 2200339/2019
5
to why it was not reasonably practicable for them to have filed timely claims or
as to why they waited until 27 March 2020 to correct the default, there is nothing
to suggest that the Claimants would succeed in demonstrating that the Tribunal
has jurisdiction to hear their claims. Whereas, refusing the request for
reconsideration will not prevent the existing Claimant, Mr David Fallon, from
pursuing his claim in the Employment Tribunal. If he is successful in his claim, it
is likely to strengthen any potential claim by the prospective Claimants in the
County Court. The balance of cost and delay, therefore, points to refusing the
application for reconsideration. It is hoped that it would not be necessary for the
prospective Claimants to issue such proceedings in the event that the
Respondent is unsuccessful in defending the Employment Tribunal claim of Mr
David Fallon.
16. The Tribunal is invited to find that Mr Whalley is operating unlawfully by charging
the Claimants for his services and that this gives rise to public policy reasons for
refusing the application for reconsideration. The basis on which Mr Whalley is
representing the Claimants was a concern raised by EJ Stout in the record of
her case management hearing. Given the possibility that the FCA will need to
investigate this, the Tribunal declines to make a finding about the basis on which
Mr Whalley is representing the Claimants purely based on inference. This has
not, therefore, formed part of the exercise of the Tribunal’s discretion in refusing
the Claimants’ request for reconsideration.
………………………………………………………….
Employment Judge Clark
Dated: 29 June 2020
DECISION SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
07/07/2020
............................................................................................................
FOR THE SECRETARY OF EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.