Mr A Sinharay v Massive Analytic Ltd: 3307197/2022
Employment Tribunal
Published on 28 July 2023, 10:42
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract unlawful-deduction-from-wages
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2023-01-11
Change History
-
Reasons added
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number: 3307197/2022
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Mr Avijnan Sinharay v Massive Analytic Limited
Heard at: Reading On: 11 January 2023
Before: Employment Judge Talbot-Ponsonby
Appearances
For the Claimant: Mr Kawasar Zaman (C)
For the Respondent: No appearance
JUDGMENT
1. The claimant’s claim for deductions of wages is well founded and the claimant
is awarded the gross sum of £55,084.34 as set out in the claimant’s schedule
of loss, together with compensation in the sum of £2,500 in respect of the
additional tax that the claimant will have to pay once the sums are received.
The claimant may need to account for tax and NI on this sum.
2. The respondent is in breach of contract by failing to contribute to the
claimant’s pension and the claimant is awarded the sum of £487.47 as set
out in the claimant’s schedule of loss.
3. The respondent shall pay a contribution to the claimant’s costs in the sum of
£6,720 by 25 January 2023
_____________________________
Employment Judge
Date: 11th January 2023
Sent to the parties on: 4th Feb 2023
GDJ
For the Tribunal Office
.
Case Number: 3307197/2022
2
Note
Reasons for the judgment having been given orally at the hearing, written reasons will not be provided
unless a request was made by either party at the hearing or a written request is presented by either party
within 14 days of the sending of this written record of the decision.
Case No: 3307197/2022
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Mr Avijnan Sinharay v Massive Analytic Limited
Heard at: Reading On: 11 January 2023
Before: Employment Judge Talbot-Ponsonby
Appearances:
For the Claimant: Mr Kawasar Zaman (C)
For the Respondent: No appearance
JUDGMENT having been sent to the parties on 4 February 2023 and
reasons having been requested in accordance with Rule 62(3) of the Rules of
Procedure 2013, the following reasons are provided:
REASONS
Introduction
1. This is a claim by the claimant, Mr Avijnan Sinharay, against the
respondent, Massive Analytic Limited, for wages and other sums that he
says he has not been paid.
Claims and issues
2. The claimant was employed by the respondent from 14 December 2020
until he resigned with immediate effect on 29 April 2022. From June 2021
onwards, the claimant says that the respondent made a series of
deductions from his pay, and failed to pay his pension contributions. Some
months he was not paid at all, sometimes he was paid in part, and in
October 2021 the claimant was paid in full.
3. The claimant claims these sums from the employer.
4. At the commencement of the hearing, it was agreed that the following
issues required determination:
5. Preliminary issues
5.1 Does the tribunal have jurisdiction in the light of the email dated 10
January 2023 (referred to at paragraph 9 below)
5.2 Was the claim brought in time? It is now accepted by the respondent
that it was
Case No: 3307197/2022
2
5.3 Was the claimant employed by the respondent? It is agreed that he
was.
6. Substantive issues
6.1 Have there been deductions from the claimant’s wages and, if so,
was there a series of deductions?
6.2 Was there a lawful reason for the deduction?
6.3 Was any deduction agreed?
7 If the claimant is successful, the following will need to be considered by way
of remedy:
7.1 Amount of unpaid wages
7.2 Pension contributions
7.3 Any consequential loss
Procedure, documents and evidence
8 The claim was heard in the Reading Employment Tribunal by me sitting
alone, with parties attending by CVP. The claimant attended and was
represented by his solicitor, Mr Jonathan Hare. The respondent did not
attend.
9 On 10 January 2023, Mr George Frankou, the CEO of the respondent,
wrote to the tribunal to say that the respondent was insolvent and would be
filing a notice of intention to appoint an administrator within the following 24-
48 hours, and would not be represented at the hearing.
10 If a notice of intention to appointment an administrator were filed, the effect
of paragraph 44(2) of schedule B1 to the Insolvency Act 1986 is that an
interim moratorium would exist, under which these proceedings would be
stayed. I note from the file that the respondent has on two previous
occasions filed notice of an intention to appoint an administrator but, on
each occasion, no administrator has been appointed.
11 Notwithstanding the email from Mr Frankou, there was no evidence before
the tribunal that the respondent had in fact filed notice of an intention to
appoint an administrator. In the absence of any such evidence, it was
appropriate for the hearing to continue.
12 The respondent did not attend. Notice of the hearing was sent to the
respondent’s solicitors by a notice dated 17 September 2022. The
respondent’s email of 10 January 2023 clearly indicated that the respondent
was aware of the hearing and had chosen not to attend. In the
circumstances, taking into account the overriding objective, I considered
that it was in the interests of justice to proceed with the hearing in the
absence of the respondent accordance with rule 47.
13 I had before me a bundle of documents prepared by the claimant, including
in particular the ET1, ET3, the claimant’s employment contract,
Case No: 3307197/2022
3
correspondence, and the claimant’s payslips and schedule of loss. I also
had a witness statement from the claimant.
14 I heard oral evidence from the claimant and submissions from Mr Hare, for
which I am grateful.
Fact finding
15 The respondent is a company that provides data analysis services. The
claimant was employed by the respondent from 14 December 2020 until he
resigned with immediate effect on 29 April 2022. The claimant was first
employed as “Centre of Excellence Head”; with effect from 1 May 2021, he
was appointed as Vice President of Product Operations; he entered into a
new employment contract with an annual salary of £125,000. The salary is
set out at clause 8.1 of the employment contract.
16 At around this time, the claimant became aware that the respondent was
suffering from cash flow difficulties.
17 In June 2021, the respondent did not pay the claimant’s salary at all.
18 Thereafter, until January 2022, the claimant was paid some money each
month. The claimant’s schedule of loss indicates that in July, August,
September, November and December 2021, there was a shortfall in what
the claimant was paid. In October 2021 and January 2022, the claimant was
paid in full and, in January 2022, the respondent paid a small amount
towards the arrears of the claimant’s salary.
19 In February and March 2022, the claimant was paid no money at all. The
total arrears of salary are set out in the claimant’s schedule of loss and
amount to £55,084.34.
20 In addition to his salary, the respondent is required by clause 8.3 of the
employment contract to pay an amount equal to the statutory minimum
requirements of the claimant’s gross basic salary into the respondent’s
pension scheme each month. Except in December 2021, when a limited
contribution was made, the respondent did not do this.
21 The claimant repeatedly asked the respondent to pay his salary, and for
details of when the arrears would be paid. The respondent gave repeated
assurances that they would be paid but this was not forthcoming.
22 Mr Frankou did raise the possibility of giving share options to employees of
the respondent, possibly in lieu of salary, but no details of this were given
and no contract entered into.
23 After receiving no payments at all in February and March 2022, the claimant
tendered his resignation on 29 April 2022 with immediate effect. By email
dated 3 May 2022, Mr Frankou confirmed that he accepted the resignation.
24 By letter dated 6 May 2022, Bolt Burdon, the respondent’s then solicitors,
accepted that the claimant was owed the sum of £55,084.34 by way of
arrears of salary and confirmed that the respondent would pay this to the
claimant. They proposed that the sum be paid over 6 months commencing
Case No: 3307197/2022
4
in May 2022. Notwithstanding that it is now January 2023, the respondent
has not paid any money to the claimant.
25 Accordingly, on 27 May 2022 the claimant entered early conciliation with
ACAS, which concluded on 30 May 2022; proceedings were commenced in
this tribunal on 21 June 2022.
Law
26 If an employee believes that his employer has made an unlawful deduction
from his wages, he may apply to the tribunal. By section 23(2)(a) of the
Employment Rights Act 1996 (“the Act”), any such application must be
made within 3 months of the deduction, subject to any extension of time
allowed for early conciliation pursuant to section 207B of the Act. Pursuant
to section 23(2)(a) of the Act, if there is a series of deductions, the claim
must be brought within 3 months of the last deduction in the series, again
subject to any extension of time.
27 In Bear Scotland Ltd v Fulton [2015] ICR 221 (EAT) Langstaff J held that
whether there is a series of deductions is a question of fact, requiring a
sufficient factual and temporal link between the underpayments. He went on
to say that there must be a sufficient similarity of subject matter, so that
each event is factually linked, and a sufficient frequency of repetition. Any
gap of more than 3 months between 2 deductions will break the series.
28 By section 13(1) of the Act, deductions from wages are unlawful unless they
authorised by statute, by a relevant provision of the worker’s contract, or
because the worker has previously agreed in writing. Section 14 of the Act
sets out deductions that are excepted from section 13 , being a
reimbursement of an overpayment of wages or of expenses, a certain other
limited exceptions.
29 For deductions to be authorised under an employment contract (section
13(1)(a) of the Act), section 13(2) requires that the authorisation must be in
a written contract that the employee has previously received or, if in other
terms of the contract (whether express or implied and, if express, whether
oral or written) the existence and effect, or combined effect, of which in
relation to the worker the employer has notified to the worker in writing on
such an occasion.
30 If the employer wishes to rely on the worker’s agreement under section
13(1)(b) of the Act, the written agreement must be obtained before the
event giving rise to the deduction.
31 Wages are defined in section 27 of the Act. Section 27(1) “wages” means
“any sums payable to the worker in connection with his employment” and
then sets out a non-exhaustive list of what is included.
32 Section 27(2) excludes various payments from the definition of wages
including, in particular, under section 27(c), “any payment by way of a
pension, allowance or gratuity in connection with the worker's retirement or
as compensation for loss of office”. In the case of University of Sunderland
v Drossou [2017] IRLR 1087), Slade J confirmed that employer’s pension
contributions do not fall within wages as defined in section 27 of the Act.
Case No: 3307197/2022
5
33 As a matter of general contract law, if one party is in breach of contract, the
innocent arty may bring a claim against the other to recover any loss
suffered as a result of that breach. The measure of damages is the amount
required to put the innocent party in the position he would have been in if
there had been no breach of contract, i.e. an obligation to pay the relevant
sums.
34 Pursuant to section 3 of the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 and Article 2 of
the Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales)
Order 1994, the tribunal has jurisdiction to hear a claim for damages for
breach of contract by an employer if the claim arises or is outstanding on
the termination of their employment.
35 Accordingly, to the extent that any of the amounts claimed by the claimant
are not wages, the tribunal has jurisdiction to hear the claim as a breach of
contract claim.
36 Pursuant to section 24(2) of the Act, if the worker has suffered financial loss
attributable to the underpayment of wages, the tribunal may award such
amount as it considers appropriate in all the circumstances to compensate
the worker for that loss.
Conclusions
37 The preliminary issues have been addressed above. I now address the
substantive issues
Have there been deductions from the claimant’s wages and, if so, was there a
series of deductions?
38 It is clear from the claimant’s unchallenged evidence that the respondent
has made deductions from the claimant’s wages.
39 There have been repeated deductions, with 9 months from the first
deduction to the last. There has never been a gap of more than three
months between the deductions and the essential reason for the deductions
given by the claimant, and not challenged by the respondent, was the same
in every case: namely, that the respondent was suffering from cash flow
difficulties and said that it could not afford to pay the claimant. I therefore
find that this amounts to a series of deductions.
Was there a lawful reason for the deduction?
40 The reason given, of cash flow difficulties, is not a lawful reason under
section 14 of the Act.
Was any deduction agreed?
41 Section 8.1 of the claimant’s contract of employment obliges the respondent
to pay the claimant monthly in arrears. The provides that the respondent will
use reasonable endeavours to ensure the salary is paid on time, but will not
be responsible if it is paid late because of bank transfer delays or other
circumstances outside the respondent’s control.
Case No: 3307197/2022
6
42 I do not find that the cash flow difficulties are circumstances outside the
respondent’s control.
43 Clause 10 of the contract permits the respondent to deduct the following
from the salary:
43.1 amounts required by law to be deducted
43.2 any sum that the claimant has previously agreed may be deducted
43.3 any sums that the claimant owes the respondent
44 The respondent’s cash flow shortfall does not fall into any of these
categories. There was no evidence before me of any agreement by the
claimant for the deductions to be made. Nor was this pleaded; paragraph 11
of the grounds of response states that the respondent explained to staff the
difficulties it was experiencing, and that it would not be able to meet its
payroll obligations, but this falls far short of asking the staff to agree to a
deduction. Paragraph 17 of the grounds of response states, “The Claimant
was aware of the reasons why the Respondent was not able to pay his full
monthly salary payments and did not complain. The Claimant accepted the
position […]”. Again, this falls far short of asserting that the claimant agreed
to any deduction in writing.
45 Accordingly, I find that the deductions were not agreed.
46 Considering the remedy which is awarded, the claimant is entitled to the
gross sum of £55,084.34 for deductions from his wages, as set out in his
schedule of loss. He may need to account for tax and NI on this sum.
47 As set out above, the respondent is in breach of contract by failing to
contribute to the claimant’s pension, and the claimant is entitled to the sum
of £487.47 as set out in the claimant’s schedule of loss.
48 The claimant has sought interest on these sums but the tribunal does not
have jurisdiction to award interest on a claim such as this.
49 The claimant confirmed in cross examination that he is working and will
therefore pay higher rate tax on all sums received. He is awarded
compensation of £2,500 in respect of the additional tax that the claimant will
have to pay once the sums are received, calculated as set out in his
schedule of loss.
50 Finally, the claimant sought an order that the respondent paid his costs of
pursuing these proceedings in the tribunal.
51 Rule 76 of the Employment Tribunal rules provides, so far as relevant:
“76 When a costs order or a preparation time order may or shall be made
(1) A Tribunal may make a costs order or a preparation time order, and
shall consider whether to do so, where it considers that—
(a) a party (or that party's representative) has acted vexatiously,
abusively, disruptively or otherwise unreasonably in either
Case No: 3307197/2022
7
the bringing of the proceedings (or part) or the way that the
proceedings (or part) have been conducted; or
(b) any claim or response had no reasonable prospect of success;
[or
[…]”
52 It is clear that the respondent had no reasonable prospect of success in
these proceedings. Not only do the grounds of response as pleaded
disclose no substantive defence to the claim, the letter from the
respondent’s solicitors dated 6 May 2022 admitted that the arrears of salary
were due and stated that the respondent would pay the relevant money to
the claimant. No such payment has been made and the claimant has had to
apply to the tribunal for judgment and has incurred costs in doing so.
53 In the circumstances, I consider it appropriate that to make an order that the
respondent pay the claimant’s costs of these proceedings.
54 I do not have a schedule of costs, but I am told that the claimant has been
invoiced the sum of £4,350 plus VAT by his solicitors, and counsel’s fees for
today are £1,250 plus VAT. The claimant states that he expects to receive a
further invoice from his solicitors but does not know the amount of this.
55 I therefore award the claimant his costs in the sum of £5,600 plus VAT,
being £6,720, which I consider a reasonable amount.
___________________________
Employment Judge Talbot-Ponsonby
Date: 13 July 2023
Judgment sent to the parties on
14 July 2023
For the Tribunal office
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.