Mr D Draper v Broadley Group Ltd: 1811175/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 30 January 2019, 12:19
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2019-01-17
Official Documents
-
Mr D Draper v Broadley Group Ltd: 1811175/2018 - Reserved Judgment
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number: 1811175/2018
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Mr D Draper v Broadley Group Ltd
Heard at: Leeds On: 14 January 2019
Before: Employment Judge Knowles
Appearances:
For the Claimant: In person
For the Respondent: Mr P Crowe, Solicitor
RESERVED JUDGMENT
1. The Claimant’s claim of constructive dismissal in breach of contract is well
founded and succeeds.
2. The Claimant suffered no financial or other recoverable loss in law therefore no
damages for breach of contract are award.
RESERVED REASONS
Issues
1. The Claimant claims that he has no choice but to resign from his employment
due to the Respondent being in breach of the Claimant’s express terms of
employment, namely the work he was doing was not his contracted duties, or in
the alternative that there was a culmination of events that caused him to resign.
2. The latter part of the Claimant’s claim is one of a breach of the implied term of
mutual trust and confidence.
3. The questions for me to determine are:
a. What was the conduct of the employer that is complained of?
b. Was an express term of the Claimant’s contract breached?
Case Number: 1811175/2018
2
c. Did the employer have reasonable and proper cause for that conduct?
d. Was the conduct complained of calculated or likely to destroy or
seriously damage the employer/employee relationship of trust and
confidence?
e. Did the Claimant leave because of the breach or because of some other
unconnected reason?
f. Did the Claimant delay in resigning, thereby waiving any breach and
agreeing to vary the contract?
Evidence
4. I heard evidence from the Claimant and from Mr T McEvoy who is the
Respondent’s Commercial Manager. The Respondent produced a bundle of
documents (76 pages). References in this judgment to page numbers are to
those in the Respondent’s bundle.
Findings of fact
5. I make the following findings of fact on the balance of probabilities. This is not a
summary of the total evidence presented. These are my core findings related
to the issues.
6. I found both the Claimant and Mr McEvoy credible and straightforward
witnesses and appreciated their frank answers to questions in tribunal. There
was little dispute between the parties on the facts and few questions for either
witness in cross examination. The dispute between the parties is, in the main,
whether the circumstances they describe amount to a constructive dismissal as
claimed, or do not.
7. The Claimant commenced employment for the Respondent 9 January 2017 as
a Joinery Manager. He was issued with a contract of employment (page 31).
8. The employment contract states that the Claimant’s job title is joinery manager
(clause1), that his place of work is site based across the UK (clause 6), and that
between one month and two years’ service the contract may be terminated by
either party giving to the other a week’s notice (clause 24).
9. The employment contract also sets out that the Respondent reserves the right
to vary the terms of employment contained in this Agreement (clause 33).
10. The contract is signed by the Claimant (page 34) and the Claimant
acknowledges that this is the contract of employment that applied when he
resigned.
11. The relevant background to the Claimant’s resignation is that there had been
some discussions between the Claimant and Respondent about his duties and
role in Leeds and he had been sent on 27 April 2018 a job description headed
“Joinery Manager” but later referring to “Bespoke Joinery Manager” which he
Case Number: 1811175/2018
3
was happy with (pages 39-41). There is more than one reference to project
management responsibilities in the job description.
12. On 11 June 2018 the Claimant was asked to meet Mr McEvoy. He did so. He
was asked to move from the Leeds site to the site at Dewsbury. He agreed to
move. He asked what his job title and role would be and was told that those
matters would be settled later but he should do whatever is required. He asked
how a selection had been made for the move between him and Mr Conway,
Joinery Manager / Joinery Director also at Leeds, and was told a selection had
not been made it was just happening. He told Mr McEvoy he did not wish to do
project management. He reported for work in Dewsbury the following day.
13. The Claimant states that 8 weeks passed and he had no role profile and was
unhappy with being asked to undertake project management duties. He asked
to meet Mr McEvoy again and they met 27 July 2018. He told Mr McEvoy at
that meeting that he felt it was unfair that he did not know what his job or role
were, and that he felt he was being duties consistent of those of a project
manager.
14. On 31 July 2018 the Claimant again asked what his role was and Mr McEvoy
sent him a job description headed “Project Leader” (pages 53-56).
15. The Claimant downloaded the Respondent’s grievance procedure and sent a
grievance to the Respondent dated 7 August 2018 (pages 61-62). In the letter
he states that his grievance is about his job role. He recites circumstances
concerning his role.
16. On 8 August 2018 Mr McEvoy wrote an email to Mr Broadley raising “issues
relating to Dean” and listing 10 instances of poor performance (page 63).
17. The Claimant received a telephone call from Mr G Broadley, Chairman of the
Respondent. Mr Broadley told him he had the Claimant’s letter in front of him
and that HR had told him it could cost a lot of money. The Claimant stated that
Mr Broadley’s manner was aggressive but they concluded agreeing to meet the
following day.
18. On 9 August 2018 the Claimant met Mr Broadley. Mr Broadley showed him a
list of jobs that he alleged the Claimant had lost money on. The Claimant asked
him why he was showing him this the day after he submitted his grievance. The
Claimant told Mr Broadley his grievance needed addressing. They discussed
why Mr Conway had remained Joinery Manager in Leeds and the Claimant
asked for details of the selection process followed. Mr Boardley told the
Claimant that he is Mr Broadley and did not to follow process. The Claimant
states that the conversation took a downward turn and Mr Broadley became
more aggressive and said “it seems to me our relationship has become
untenable”. The Claimant was not challenged on his account in evidence. Mr
Broadley has not given evidence in tribunal.
Case Number: 1811175/2018
4
19. Mr Broadley wrote to the Claimant a grievance outcome on 9 August 2018,
page 65-66. The responses are stated to be without prejudice. The response
does not engage with core points that the Claimant complained about. Many of
the complaints are simply ‘noted’ in the response.
20. On 13 August 2018 the Claimant handed in one week’s notice “due to
documented events” to expire on the final working day that week, 17 August
2018.
21. The Claimant worked his notice period and receive pay for his notice period.
22. The Claimant again met Mr Broadley on his last day of work but Mr Broadley
did not conclude any of the Claimant’s complaints.
23. The Claimant’s net earnings after ordinary deductions is £576.92 per week.
24. In answer to questions in tribunal the claimant confirmed that he began to kep
an eye on alternative employment from 11 June 2018 and applied for a role
during the week of 7 August 2018 (after submitting his grievance), and attended
an interview on 8 or 9 August 2018. He secured an offer of employment with
that other employer which he accepted 11 August 2018 and commenced work
28 August 2018. He left after 4 weeks.
25. The Claimant states that he suffered emotionally, his well-being deteriorated
along with his health following the meeting 11 June 2018. He states that he
suffered poor sleep and anxiety. He did visit his GP but only to have his blood
pressure checked and it had raised. He has no medical evidence.
Submissions
26. The Respondent submitted that the change in location to Dewsbury had been
agreed and that the Claimant agreed that on termination of employment there
had been discussions about a change in job title but he was still employed as
Joinery Manager. The Respondent submitted that if there had been any
variation to his contract then that is permitted under the variation clause in the
contract, clause 33. The Claimant affirmed the role by working for the next 8
weeks without complaint. There was no breach of any express term in his
contract.
27. In relation to trust and confidence, the Respondent submitted that the Project
Manager role did not happen. The Claimant’s grievance was answered. The
Claimant was offered an appeal. He left not because of the problems he raises
but to work elsewhere. In any event he was paid his notice and is not entitled to
any damages.
28. The Claimant submitted that he loved his job in Leeds, loved the company,
gave his best, but that no process was followed in moving him to Dewsbury, the
Respondent did not follow any performance management process and
Case Number: 1811175/2018
5
compiled performance concerns the day after he wrote his grievance, telling
him the relationship was untenable. He had no option other than to resign.
The Law
29. The principles of constructive dismissal have developed over many years and
consequently there are many authorities that guide employment tribunals in
determining these claims. Harvey on Industrial Relations and Employment Law
puts the position as follows. ‘In order for the employee to be able to claim
constructive dismissal, four conditions must be met:
(i) There must be a breach of contract by the employer. This may be either
an actual breach or an anticipatory breach.
(ii) That breach must be sufficiently important to justify the employee
resigning, or else it must be the last in a series of incidents which justify
his leaving. Possibly a genuine, albeit erroneous, interpretation of the
contract by the employer will not be capable of constituting a repudiation
in law.
(iii) He must leave in response to the breach and not for some other,
unconnected reason.
(iv) He must not delay too long in terminating the contract in response to the
employer's breach, otherwise he may be deemed to have waived the
breach and agreed to vary the contract.’
30. In this claim the claimant claims that the implied term of trust and confidence
had been breached by the respondent. That term was refined by the House of
Lords in Mahmud v Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA [1997] ICR
606, [1997] IRLR 462 as providing that 'the employer shall not without
reasonable and proper cause conduct itself in a manner calculated [or] likely to
destroy or seriously damage the relationship of confidence and trust between
employer and employee.' From Mahmud we note that if the breach is not
discovered until after the employment ends, the employee could not rely upon
this as a ground for terminating the contract (since he is unaware of it). We
also note that this term may be broken even if subjectively the employee's trust
and confidence is not undermined in fact. It is enough that, viewed objectively,
the conduct is likely to destroy or seriously damage the trust and confidence.
Mahmud therefore confirms the formulation applied earlier in the cases of
Woods v W M Car Services (Peterborough) Ltd [1981] ICR 666, which was
approved by the Court of Appeal in Lewis v Motorworld Garages Ltd [1986] ICR
157.
31. In Lewis it was held that the breach of this implied obligation of trust and
confidence may consist of a series of actions on the part of the employer which
cumulatively amount to a breach of the term, though each individual incident
may not do so. In London Borough of Waltham Forest v. Omilaju [2005] IRLR
35, the Court of Appeal held that in order to result in a breach of the implied
term of trust and confidence, a “final straw”, not itself a breach of contract, must
be an act in a series of earlier acts which cumulatively amount to a breach of
Case Number: 1811175/2018
6
the implied term. The act does not have to be of the same character as the
earlier acts. Its essential quality is that, when taken in conjunction with the
earlier acts on which the employee relies, it amounts to a breach of the implied
term of trust and confidence. It must contribute something to that breach,
although what it adds may be relatively insignificant so long as it is not utterly
trivial. The final straw, viewed in isolation, need not be unreasonable or
blameworthy conduct. However, an entirely innocuous act on the part of the
employer cannot be a final straw, even if the employee genuinely, but
mistakenly, interprets the act as hurtful and destructive of his trust and
confidence in the employer. The test of whether the employee’s trust and
confidence has been undermined is objective.
32. In Walker v. Josiah Wedgwood & Sons Ltd [1978] IRLR 105, Mr Justice Arnold
commented that ‘there are circumstances which can very easily be envisaged in
which the making of an unjustified complaint or the giving of an unjustified
warning or, still more, series of warnings would be or could be a matter of which
legitimate complaint could be made by a person who says that he has been
constructively dismissed, particularly and most obviously if the case which he
seeks to make is a case based on the view that those warnings were given not
really with a view to improving his conduct and performance, but with a view to
disheartening him and driving him out. In any case in which that sort of claim is
made, it seems to us to be abundantly plain that nothing less than a full
investigation of the merits of the warnings is required.’
33. The principles from Mahmud and Woods were recently confirmed in GAB
Robins (UK) Limited v. Triggs [2007] EAT/0111/07/RN, from which it may be
read that the three questions to be asked in a constructive dismissal case (in
which the claimant relies upon the trust and confidence term) are:
(i) What was the conduct of the employer that is complained of?
(ii) Did the employer have reasonable and proper cause for that conduct?
(iii) Was the conduct complained of calculated or likely to destroy or seriously
damage the employer/employee relationship of trust and confidence?
Conclusions
34. Was an express term of the Claimant’s contract breached?
35. I do not consider that there was any breach of any express term in the contract
of employment. The Claimant was employed as a Joinery Manager and
discussions concerning the Project Leader role were ongoing. He accepts he
was still employed as a Joinery Manager under the Job Profile at page 39, subheaded
Bespoke Joinery Manager and containing references to project
management responsibilities. He had agreed the move to work from the
Dewsbury site. The Claimant has not identified any written express term that
has been breached by the Respondent.
36. What was the conduct of the employer that is complained of?
Case Number: 1811175/2018
7
37. It appears clear on the evidence that the Claimant was unhappy with the
amount of project management he was required to do in Dewsbury and
remained dissatisfied that he was required to move not Mr Conway. When he
raised the lack of clarity on his job role and how he had been selection the
actions from the Respondent were to compile a list of poor performance
allegations against him. When he queried the process that had been followed
he was told the “relationship had become untenable” by the Respondent’s
Chairman. The grievance outcome was incomplete and did not engage with the
matters he complained about. This is the conduct the Claimant is complaining
about.
38. Did the employer have reasonable and proper cause for that conduct?
39. The Claimant had set out a complaint under the Respondent’s disciplinary
process and was met with poor performance allegations in return, was told the
Respondent did not have to follow procedures in moving him, and was told by
the Chairman that their relationship had become untenable. He then received a
written grievance outcome which did not engage with many of his core
complaints. The Respondent may have had performance concerns concerning
the Claimant, and may have had good reason not to require Mr Conway to
move to Dewsbury, but it has given no reasonable and proper cause for the
high-handed manner in which the Respondent answered the Claimant’s
complaints.
40. Was the conduct complained of calculated or likely to destroy or seriously
damage the employer/employee relationship of trust and confidence?
41. In my conclusion the Chairman of the Respondent would more likely than not
know that handling the Claimant in the manner described about would destroy
or seriously damage the relationship of trust and confidence between the
Respondent and the Claimant. Even were I wrong on that, I have no hesitation
in concluding that it was ‘likely’ too have that effect.
42. Did the Claimant leave because of the breach or because of some other
unconnected reason?
43. In my conclusion the Claimant did not leave because of the job offer, the reason
for resigning was the conduct he has described. It is widely accepted that
seeking to maintain a livelihood by taking steps to find alternative employment
will not automatically defeat a claim of constructive dismissal. In my conclusion
in the balance of probabilities the reason for resignation was the conduct
complained of and the seeking and securing of employment was simply another
further response by the Claimant in addition to his resignation, it was not the
cause of his resignation.
44. Did the Claimant delay in resigning, thereby waiving any breach and agreeing
to vary the contract?
45. I do not consider that to be the case. The Claimant may rely on the
circumstances beginning in June 2018 but is are significant contributing conduct
Case Number: 1811175/2018
8
from the Respondent, particularly from the Respondent’s Chairman, which
appears to have occurred between 7 and 13 August 2018. The Claimant did
not, in my conclusion, delay too long in handing in his resignation and is not to
be taken to have affirmed Mr Broadley’s conduct between 7 and 13 August
2018 by not resigning until 13 August 2018.
46. Was the Claimant constructively dismissed?
47. In the light of the above conclusions I conclude that the Claimant was
constructively dismissed in breach of the implied term of trust and confidence.
48. What damages are due to the Claimant?
49. The starting point for damages for breach of contract is what damages are
necessary to put the Claimant back in the position he would have been in had
the Respondent complied with their obligations under the contract of
employment. Financial awards of damages are therefore normally limited to the
notice period, the period of time in which the Respondent could have lawfully
terminated the contract.
50. The Claimant has accepted that he resigned on notice and was paid for working
his notice period. In these circumstances I conclude that the Claimant suffered
no losses from a financial perspective. The Respondent, had they terminated
the contract lawfully on 13 August 2018, would have paid to him the same
amount.
51. The Claimant put in his damages claim a request for a redundancy payment.
He has not claimed a redundancy payment. Even if he had, he concedes there
are no express terms concerning redundancy payments and therefore he
would, under the statutory scheme, not be entitled to a redundancy payment
having less than two years continuous employment.
52. The Claimant also put in his damages claim loss of employment rights. He
stated he had been advised to. It seems probable that the person giving that
advice was referring to the inclusion of a payment for loss of statutory rights in a
claim of unfair dismissal. However, this is not a claim of unfair dismissal. The
Claimant has not set out any employment rights he has lost. He may later have
accrued rights such as ordinary unfair dismissal protection, the right to a
redundancy pay and other rights at 2 years’ service, but he would not have
acquired such rights within the period in which the Respondent could lawfully
have terminated his contract on 13 August 2018, i.e. one week’s notice.
53. The Claimant has referred to anxiety, sleeplessness and an increase in his
blood pressure but he has not referred to seeking assistance other than to
attend the doctors for a blood pressure check. He has produced no medical
evidence. I don’t doubt that he found the conduct of the Respondent which
caused the resignation distressing
54. However in Addis v Gramophone Co Ltd 1909 AC 488, HL, the House of Lords
ruled that an employee who was wrongfully dismissed without notice could not
recover damages to compensate him or her for the manner of the dismissal, for
Case Number: 1811175/2018
9
his or her injured feelings, or for the loss he or she may sustain from the fact
that the dismissal itself makes it more difficult to obtain fresh employment.
55. There are limited circumstances in which non-pecuniary loss can be claimed at
all. But there are two reasons these do not assist the Claimant. Firstly, the
conduct he has complained of forms the dismissal. Damages for non-pecuniary
losses cannot be claimed in relation to the termination of employment or
manner of termination. Secondly, the Claimant has referred to issues I
conclude are hurt feelings and distress from the Respondent’s conduct. There
is no claim of or evidence of any psychiatric injury.
56. In all of the circumstances, I make no award of damages for breach of contract.
Employment Judge Knowles
Date 17 January 2019
Note
Reasons for the judgment having been given orally at the hearing, written reasons will
not be provided unless a request was made by either party at the hearing or a written
request is presented by either party within 14 days of the sending of this written record
of the decision.
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.