Mr D McDonald v Structural Timber Systems Ltd and NE Foundry Ltd: 2503671/2019
Employment Tribunal
Published on 05 August 2020, 11:00
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
contract-of-employment unlawful-deduction-from-wages working-time-regulations
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2020-03-12
Official Documents
-
Mr D McDonald v Structural Timber Systems Ltd and NE Foundry Ltd: 2503671/2019 - Rule 21
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number: 2503671/2019
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr D McDonald
1st Respondent: Structural Timber Systems Ltd
2nd Respondent: NE Foundry Ltd
Heard at: Newcastle On: 11 March 2020
Before: Employment Judge Sweeney
Appearances:
For the Claimant: In person
For the Respondents: No appearance
JUDGMENT
Employment Tribunals Rules of Procedure 2013 – Rule 21
The judgment of the Tribunal is that:
1. The claim of unlawful deductions in respect of arrears of pay against the Second
Respondent s well founded and succeeds. The Second Respondent is ordered to
pay the Claimant the gross sum of £103.94.
2. The claim for payment of outstanding holiday pay against the Second
Respondent is well founded and succeeds. The Second Respondent is ordered
to pay the Claimant the gross sum of £295.56.
Case Number: 2503671/2019
3. The Second Respondent is ordered pursuant to section 38 Employment Act 2002
to pay the Claimant £1,313.60 equivalent to 4 weeks’ gross pay at the weekly
rate of £328.40.
4. The total amount to be paid to the Claimant is £1,713.10.
REASONS
Background and history of the proceedings
5. As judgment was given in the absence of the respondents, full and proportionate
reasons are provided below.
6. On 25 October 2019, the Claimant, Mr McDonald presented a complaint against
Structural Timber Systems Ltd (the First Respondent) in which he sought payment
of arrears of pay and payment in respect of accrued but untaken holiday. The
proceedings were properly served on the Frist Respondent and a response was
due by 02 December 2019. The case was listed for a hearing on 03 January 2020.
7. The Respondent did not serve a response by the required date. Accordingly, the
Tribunal was considering issuing a judgment against the First Respondent under
rule 21 of the Tribunal Rules of Procedure 2013. The Tribunal wrote to the Claimant
on 04 December 2019 saying that a response had not been served, that a rule 21
judgment could be issues but that some further information as to what was being
claimed was needed. Accordingly, the parties were informed that the case
remained listed on 03 January 2020.
8. The Claimant provided further information as requested by the Tribunal and he
attended the hearing on 03 January. Part of the documentation provided by the
Claimant showed payments by a company called NE Foundry Ltd. Therefore, the
Tribunal wrote to the Claimant on 18 December 2019 asking him to bring with him
documents from his employment with a view to establishing the correct identity of
his employer.
9. It was on that date, 18th December 2019, that the Tribunal received contact from
Mr Richard Bailey, director of Structural Timber Systems Ltd and also of NE
Foundry Ltd. In his letter, Mr Bailey wrote that the claims were fraudulent on the
basis that Structural Timber Systems Ltd employed no employees. Mr Bailey did
not say who employed the Claimant, simply that he was not – according to him –
employed by Structural Timber Systems Ltd.
10. That letter was treated as the First Respondent attempting to enter a response to
the claim, albeit late. It was, however, rejected by letter dated 24 December 2019
as it was not presented on a prescribed form as required by rule 16 of the Tribunal
Rules of Procedure. Mr Bailey was advised that he must apply to the Tribunal in
writing for an extension of time to present his response. The letter clearly set out
precisely what Mr Bailey was to do.
Case Number: 2503671/2019
11. Mr Bailey then presented a response using the prescribed form on 30 December
2019. He maintained the claims were false and attached the same letter that he
had sent on 18 December 2019 only with a different date, that being 30 December
2019. He did not ask for an extension of time, nor did he explain why he had not
originally responded in time. Accordingly, the Tribunal wrote on 31 December 2019
to say that the response remained rejected and that he would be permitted to
participate at the hearing on 03 January 2020 only to the extent permitted by the
Employment Judge who hears the case.
The hearing on 03 January 2020
12. The matter was listed before me on 03 January 2020. Mr McDonald represented
himself and Mr Bailey attended to represent the First Respondent. I explained why
the Response had been rejected and asked Mr Bailey if he wished to apply for an
extension of time. He said that he did. The explanation for not responding was
weak. Mr Bailey said that he was busy as he had to cover for someone. However,
he said that Structural Timber Systems Ltd was not the company which employed
the Claimant.
13. Mr Bailey was extremely reticent to say anything other than that Structural Timber
Systems Ltd was not the employer. Eventually, and only through questioning by
me, he said that NE Foundry Ltd was the company that employed Mr Donaldson.
He said that some payments had recently been made which would satisfy Mr
Donaldson’s claims. He was also reticent as to whether he had received the Claim
Form but eventually said that he had done. I allowed than extension of time to the
First Respondent to 31 December 2019 for service of the response and added NE
Foundry Ltd as the Second Respondent.
14. The hearing was adjourned to enable the Second Respondent to enter a response,
which Mr Bailey agreed would be done by 31 January 2020. Also, in light of the
recent payments which had been made to Mr Donaldson, it was hoped that a
resolution of the proceedings would ensue. I raised the issue of section 38
Employment Act 2002 and the powers of the tribunal to award 2 to 4 weeks pay in
cases where there was a failure, when the proceedings were brought, on the part
of the employer to provide written particulars. It was not disputed that the Claimant
had never been provided with written particulars of employment. It was not
disputed that the Claimant had never been provided with payslips.
15. The Second Respondent served a response by 31 January 2020. It consisted of
the prescribed form and an attached letter in which the Second Respondent
accepted that the Claimant was owed £229.88. It also had attached to it a ‘time
sheet’ summary and documents which purported to be payslips.
The issues to be decided at the hearing
16. The issues to be determined at the resumed hearing were set out in paragraph 11
of the case management summary of the hearing of 03 January 2020, namely:
16.1. Which of the two respondents employed the Claimant?
Case Number: 2503671/2019
16.2. What amount of money by way of unpaid wages were outstanding to the
Claimant? What was properly payable? Was there a deduction?
16.3. How many days accrued but untaken holiday was due to the Claimant
on termination of his employment?
17. A notice of hearing was sent to all the parties on 18 February 2020. The matter
was re-listed for 10am on 11 March 2020.
The Hearing on 11 March 2020
18. Mr Donaldson appeared again to represent himself. Mr Bailey did not attend. There
was no attendance by either respondent. The clerk made contact with Mr Bailey to
ask why neither respondent had attended the hearing. The clerk reported back that
Mr Bailey had said he did not know about the hearing.
19. I made inquiries of the tribunal office to establish that the notice of hearing had
been sent to the respondents at the correct address. I sought Mr McDonald’s views
as to whether the matter should be postponed or proceed. He did not accept that
Mr Bailey was unaware of the proceedings. He pointed out that he, Mr McDonald,
was made aware and submitted that Mr Bailey had a track record of obscuring and
delaying matters. He wished to proceed.
20. Having considered rule 47 of the Rules of Procedure, I concluded that it was in the
interests of justice to proceed with the hearing in that:
20.1. The notice of hearing had been sent to the correct address and not
returned to the tribunal;
20.2. There had been significant delay to date and any further delay would be
unfair to Mr McDonald;
20.3. There was no dispute that he had not been paid his wages by the time
Mr McDonald had commenced the proceedings and the only issue was what
he had been paid since then;
20.4. There was no dispute that Mr McDonald was owed holiday pay and the
only issue was how much;
20.5. NE Foundry Ltd accepted that it was the Claimant’s employer;
20.6. There was no dispute that the Claimant had never received any written
particulars of employment from NE Foundry Ltd;
20.7. It would be disproportionate and not in accordance with the overriding
objective to delay matters further;
21. I heard from Mr McDonald who took me through the purported pay slips. I say
‘purported’ because they were only sent to Mr McDonald after the hearing on 03
January 2020. He also took me through the time sheet summary prepared by the
Second Respondent.
Who employed the Claimant?
22. Mr McDonald conceded that he was employed by NE Foundry Ltd. This was,
therefore, no longer an issue between the parties.
Case Number: 2503671/2019
How much by way of wages had not been paid to the Claimant by NE Foundry
Ltd? (unlawful deductions claim)
23. Having been taken very carefully through the payslips and the time sheet, I was
satisfied that the following payments were properly payable and due to Mr
McDonald:
23.1. In respect of the pay date 31 May 2019, 2 extra hours overtime at time
and a third, totaling £21.84. Mr McDonald relied on the evidence produced by
NE Foundry, consisting of the time-sheet summary which identified the 2 hours
which were not accounted for on the payslip;
23.2. In respect of the pay date 30 June 2019, the payment should have been
in respect of 159.50 hours rather than (as appeared on the payslip) 149.50
hours. This resulted in a shortfall of 10 hours x £8.21, or £82.10. Once again,
Mr McDonald was able to take me to the time sheet summary produced by the
Second Respondent and which clearly shows 159.50 hours worked, whereas
the pay slip only pays for 149.50 hours.
24. Applying section 13 ERA 1996, I was satisfied that there was a series of unlawful
deductions of wages totaling £103.94 and that there was no authorization to do so
by virtue of any relevant provision of the Claimant’s contract of employment nor
was there any previous written agreement to do so.
Holiday pay claim
25. It was established on the last occasion (03 January 2020) that Mr McDonald’s claim
was for 3.5 days unpaid holiday at £65.68 a day, totaling £229.88. However, that
was on the understanding that he had in fact been paid for the bank holidays that
he had taken. Since that hearing, Mr Bailey, on behalf of the Second Respondent
accepted that the Second Respondent was liable for that amount.
26. In fact, as he demonstrated from the payslips and timesheet summary prepared by
the Second Respondent, he had not been paid for Good Friday. Therefore, his
claim was payment in respect of 3.5 days accrued but untaken and for 1 day taken
but not paid.
27. I was satisfied that Mr McDonald had not been paid for the Good Friday bank
holiday and that he was entitled to a an additional payment of £65.68 and that his
claim for holiday pay was under regulation 30(1)(b) Working Time Regulations
1998 in respect of that bank holiday.
28. Therefore, he is entitled to payment in respect of untaken holidays by virtue of
regulation 14(3) Working Time Regulations 1998 (£229.88). He is also entitled to
be paid in respect of the one day holiday which he took but received no payment
(£65.68) making a total claim under regulation 30 WTR of £295.56.
Case Number: 2503671/2019
Section 38 Employment Act 2002 (‘EA’)
29. Mr McDonald told me – and it was not disputed in any event – that NE Foundry Ltd
never provided him with written statement of particulars, as it is obliged to do under
section 4 Employment Rights Act 1996.
30. The claims which Mr McDonald brings are within schedule 5 of the EA. I have found
his claims to be made out. I find that the Second Respondent was in breach of its
obligations under section 4 ERA at the time the proceedings were brought. I must,
therefore, make a minimum award of 2 weeks’ gross pay (a week’s pay being
£328.40) unless it would be unjust and inequitable to do so.
31. In my judgment it would not be unjust and inequitable to make an award against
the Second Respondent.
32. I may make an award of a higher amount (up to the equivalent of 4 weeks’ gross
pay) if I consider it just and equitable to do so. I consider that, in all the
circumstances, it is just and equitable to make the higher award in the sum of
£1,313.60. The arrangements of Mr McDonald’s employment have been shrouded
in obscurity. It has been quite a challenge even to get the Second Respondent to
admit that it employed Mr McDonald. Mr Bailey, as its director, never provided him
with any documentation and never provided him with any pay-slips. There has
been no attempt at an explanation as to why written particulars were not provided.
Mr McDonald told me, and I accept, that the monies deducted by NE Foundry Ltd
in respect of his tax and national insurance were never paid to HMRC. I am in no
doubt whatsoever that it is just and equitable to make an award of the higher
amount as the Second Respondent appears to ignore the most basic requirements
and obligations of an employer.
Employment Judge Sweeney
12 March 2020
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.