Mr D Paton v Winchmore Brickwork Ltd: 3327070/2017
Employment Tribunal
Published on 15 November 2019, 14:03
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
disability-discrimination race-discrimination
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2019-11-11
Change History
-
Dismissal judgment attached.
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number: 3327070/2017
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Mr D Paton v Winchmore Brickwork Ltd
Heard at: Watford On: 10 September 2018
Before: Employment Judge A B Clarke QC
Members: Mr D Sutton
Mr R Clifton
Appearances
For the Claimant: In Person
For the Respondent: Unrepresented
---
JUDGMENT
1. The hearing of this case is adjourned to be heard before any Tribunal for
three days on 1, 2 and 3 April 2019 at the Cambridge Employment
Tribunal, 197 East Road, Cambridge CB1 1BA.
REASONS
1. The claimant presented a claim form to the Tribunal on 14 August 2017.
His complaint was for race discrimination. That claim was defended.
2. On 18 January 2018 a preliminary hearing took place before Employment
Judge Henry at which the claimant appeared in person and the
respondent appeared by its Managing Director, Mr Yianni. At that
hearing the present respondent was substituted for Mr Yianni as the sole
respondent to the proceedings. The Judge also made a series of Orders
relating to the production of further particulars of the claim (by 1 February
2018), for the respondent to respond to those particulars (21 days
thereafter) and for disclosure of documents, production of bundles and
witness statements and the provision of a Schedule of Loss. It is
necessary to review what happened thereafter in order to understand
why it became necessary for the Tribunal which was intended to hear this
case over three days had to adjourn it.
3. The Tribunal file contains a copy of an email dated 12 February 2018
attaching the Case Management Orders made by Employment Judge
Case Number: 3327070/2017
2
Henry. From subsequent correspondence it is clear that the respondent
received that email. However, the claimant has no recollection of
receiving it.
4. I need to refer to one further paragraph of the document in question.
When describing the listing of the hearing it notes that it had been agreed
that the hearing “would be completed within four days” and, in the usual
way, goes on to say that the hearing will start “at 10.00am or soon
thereafter as possible on 10, to end on 12 September 2018.” The
listing was, in fact, a three-day listing. Recent correspondence from the
respondent suggests that the respondent may have understood what was
said as determining that a four-day hearing would commence on either
the 10, 11 or 12 September. The confusion which may have been
caused by that minor error on the face of the case management
summary has to be seen against the background of the events which
unfolded after 12 February.
5. The claimant did not produce the further particulars which he had been
ordered to produce by 1 February. The respondent wrote to the Tribunal
pointing out that he had received no particulars by 13 February and noted
that the consequent Order for it to respond now appeared “obsolete”.
The respondent asked for the matter to be referred to Judge Henry.
Hence, the matter was referred to Judge Henry who asked that a letter in
the standard form for “Non-Compliance with Case Management Orders”
be sent. The gaps in the standard form were to be completed so as to
require an explanation in writing by 29 March as to why there had been
no compliance. In the meantime, the Tribunal had received further
chasing correspondence from the respondent asking what was
happening.
6. That correspondence from the respondent was then passed to Judge
Henry with a note to the effect that the letter that he had asked for had
not been sent before the date which he had suggested had expired.
Hence, Judge Henry directed that the date in his draft letter be changed
from 29 March to 23 April 2018. He also asked that apologies been
given to the respondent for the failure to action his previous instruction,
which apology should note that the new date “for compliance” was to be
23 April 2018.
7. The result was that a letter was sent to the claimant, copied to the
respondent, which required an explanation for non-compliance with the
original Order, which explanation was to be given by 16 May 2018. That
letter did not set a new date for compliance with the original Order. A
further letter was sent to the respondent (but not copied to the claimant)
which apologised for Judge Henry’s instruction (which instruction was not
explained) not being actioned and stated that an Order was now being
sent out for compliance by 16 May. Subsequent correspondence from
the respondent shows that the respondent understood the letter to it as
indicating that the time for compliance with the original Order had been
changed from 1 February to 16 May 2018.
Case Number: 3327070/2017
3
8. The respondent continued to chase the Tribunal after the 16 May
deadline had passed. Ultimately, the file was passed to Employment
Judge Manley who made an Unless Order to the effect that unless the
claimant complied with the original Order for providing particulars by 2
July 2018, the claim would be struck out. That Order was sent to the
claimant and the respondent by email of 20 June 2018.
9. Having heard nothing by 11 July 2018 the respondent wrote, once again,
to the Tribunal (following up on telephone calls) asking for confirmation
that the claim had been struck out. That letter was passed to an
Employment Judge on 25 July who instructed that a letter be sent to the
respondent indicating that the claim had indeed been struck out.
However, before that letter could be sent, the Tribunal realised that it had
received particulars from the claimant on 1 July by email. Hence, he had
complied with the Unless Order.
10. The matter was then referred back to an Employment Judge who
instructed that the document complying with the Order be sent to the
respondent. An email attaching the claimant’s email of 1 July and an
exchange between him and the Tribunal relating to it was copied to the
respondent on 10 August. The email simply said, “please see attached
correspondence.” Of course, the claimant had complied with the Unless
Order, but he had still not explained his failure to comply with the original
Order as he had been ordered to do by the letter of 2 May 2018, which
gave him until 16 May 2018 to do so. Furthermore, no thought had been
given to amending the timetable relating to the respondent’s answer to
the allegations, disclosure and witness statements.
11. Subsequent correspondence shows that the respondent contacted the
Tribunal on 28 August in order to try to understand the current status of
the case and what needed to be done. The respondent was advised
“that this case was still to be passed on to the Judge” and that the
Tribunal could say nothing more until the matter had been “processed by
the Judge.” The respondent heard nothing more from the Tribunal until a
telephone call on the afternoon of Friday 7 September, being the usual
call to establish whether the respondent was attending the hearing the
following Monday. The respondent’s answer to this was, in summary,
that they were uncertain as to the status of the case, that they had
assiduously corresponded with the Tribunal in order to understand the
status of the case at various times since shortly after receipt of the Case
Management Orders on 12 February, that they had understood that the
case was to start one on of the 10, 11 or 12 September and that they
would be told which, but that they had heard nothing in that regard. It is
not surprising, given the events described above, that the respondent
was in a state of some confusion. Indeed, it is clear that they understood
that the matter was being put before an Employment Judge to determine
how matters should proceed.
12. The respondent did not attend today. Its principle witness, Mr Yianni, is
engaged elsewhere. That is so for some time into the future.
Case Number: 3327070/2017
4
13. In all of those circumstances we consider that the only just course of
action is to adjourn the hearing of this case. Leaving aside the confused
state in which the respondent has been placed, the case is simply not
ready to proceed. As the original Orders from Employment Judge Henry
foreshadowed, before it can be ready to proceed the respondent has to
answer the particularised allegations made by the claimant and (among
other things) witness statements need to be produced and exchanged
relating to those allegations and answers.
14. In all of the circumstances we have decided to adjourn this case to be
heard by any Tribunal from 1 April 2019 for three days. The venue of
the hearing has been changed to Cambridge, because that offered the
opportunity for earlier hearing dates. We bear in mind that the
respondent has not attended today, but the dates are so far into the
future (and considerably beyond the period during which it was said that
Mr Yianni was otherwise engaged) that we consider that the case can be
safely listed for those dates without reference to the respondent. We
have also made various Case Management Orders directed, in the main,
to bringing Employment Judge Henry’s Orders up-to-date.
_____________________________
Employment Judge A B Clarke QC
Date: ……21/9/18……………………..
Sent to the parties on: .......................
............................................................
For the Tribunal Office
Case No:3327070/2017
6.2 Strike out Judgment – claim - rule 37
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Mr D Paton v Winchmore Brickwork Ltd
Heard at: Cambridge Employment Tribunal On: 11 November 2019
Before: Employment Judge King
Members: Mr Vaghela and Mrs Gaywood
Appearances
For the Claimant: Failed to attend
For the Respondent: Mr T Yianni
JUDGMENT
The claim is dismissed.
REASONS
1. The Claimant failed to attend the full merits hearing listed for three days
commencing on 11th November 2019. The Respondent was in attendance
and enquiries were made as to the Claimant’s whereabouts who told the
clerk that he was at work and could come tomorrow if needed.
2. The Claimant’s emails to the Tribunal (said to be further and better
particulars) have confirmed that the claims are all prior to 3rd May 2017.
ACAS early conciliation was not commenced until 7th August 2017 and the
certificate issued on the 9th August 2017 with the claim being presented on
14th August 2017. As identified in the earlier case management orders the
claim is out of time and the claimant was to set out in his witness
statement the reasons for the late submission so the full hearing could
consider whether it was just and equitable to extend time.
Case No:3327070/2017
6.2 Strike out Judgment – claim - rule 37
3. The case has had a long and checkered history in the tribunal. There was
one unless order issued against the Claimant for non-compliance with
orders on 18th June 2018.
4. The case was not ready to proceed for the originally listed hearing in
September 2018. On 18th January 2018, a case management hearing
was held in person and directions made to May 2018. Another case
management hearing took place on the first day of the September 2018
listing and the earlier orders were varied due to non-compliance. The
case was almost struck out on 1st July 2018 for non-compliance.
5. The hearing was relisted for 1/2/3 April 2019 but once again the matter
had to be listed for a case management hearing on 26th February 2019 by
telephone as directions were not being complied with by the Claimant.
6. On 28th April 2019 a notice of hearing was sent to the parties by email.
This was the correct email address for the Claimant listing the matter for
three days starting today.
7. Again following the Respondent’s application for a strike out for the
Claimant’s non-compliance with directions, the matter was referred to a
Judge. On the 11th September 2019 an order a letter was sent to the
parties to say that no order for a strike out was made. On the 5th October
2019 the respondent’s application for strike out was refused as the
claimant was saying he had not received documents. The respondent’s
agreed to send the documents yet again by recorded delivery.
8. By email the Claimant acknowledged the receipt of the bundle on 19th
October 2019. This is the same email address with which the Tribunal has
been corresponding.
9. By letter dated 3rd November 2019 the Claimant was told that the full
merits hearing remained listed to start today.
10. The clerk to the Tribunal called both parties on Friday 8th November 2019
to confirm attendance but the Claimant did not answer the call and there
was no facility to leave a voicemail. The Respondent confirmed his
attendance.
11. The Tribunal had to decide today how to proceed. In accordance with
Rule 47 we could dismiss the claim or proceed without the Claimant. We
could grant a postponement until tomorrow, until the next available date
after 29th June 2020 or strike out the claim. The Respondent confirmed it
had not heard the audio recording referred to by the Claimant in the
papers, not received a witness statement from the Claimant or any
disclosure.
12. The Respondent requested a strike out again orally at the hearing. The
Tribunal has the power to strike out a claim under Rule 37 on the
application of the party or on its own initiative.
13. Rule 37 Employment Tribunal (Constitution & Rules of Procedure)
Regulations 2013 states:
Case No:3327070/2017
6.2 Strike out Judgment – claim - rule 37
37.—(1) At any stage of the proceedings, either on its own initiative or on the
application of a party, a Tribunal may strike out all or part of a claim or response
on any of the following grounds—
(a)that it is scandalous or vexatious or has no reasonable prospect of success;
(b)that the manner in which the proceedings have been conducted by or on behalf
of the claimant or the respondent (as the case may be) has been scandalous,
unreasonable or vexatious;
(c)for non-compliance with any of these Rules or with an order of the Tribunal;
(d)that it has not been actively pursued;
(e)that the Tribunal considers that it is no longer possible to have a fair hearing
in respect of the claim or response (or the part to be struck out).
14. The Tribunal must consider the Overriding Objective as contained in Rule
2 Employment Tribunal (Constitution & Rules of Procedure) Regulations
2013 which states as follows:
2. The overriding objective of these Rules is to enable Employment Tribunals to deal with cases
fairly and justly. Dealing with a case fairly and justly includes, so far as practicable—
(a)ensuring that the parties are on an equal footing;
(b)dealing with cases in ways which are proportionate to the complexity and importance of the
issues;
(c)avoiding unnecessary formality and seeking flexibility in the proceedings;
(d)avoiding delay, so far as compatible with proper consideration of the issues; and
(e)saving expense.
A Tribunal shall seek to give effect to the overriding objective in interpreting, or exercising any
power given to it by, these Rules. The parties and their representatives shall assist the Tribunal to
further the overriding objective and in particular shall co-operate generally with each other and with
the Tribunal.
15. Rule 47 Employment Tribunal (Constitution & Rules of Procedure)
Regulations 2013 deals with non-attendance as follows:
47. If a party fails to attend or to be represented at the hearing, the Tribunal may dismiss the claim
or proceed with the hearing in the absence of that party. Before doing so, it shall consider any
information which is available to it, after any enquiries that may be practicable, about the reasons
for the party’s absence.
16. It is clear to us that there is no guarantee that if we postponed until
tomorrow the case would be any different. It is clearly not in a position
(despite having had a disproportionate amount of judicial input to date) to
proceed. The Respondent has not seen any of the Claimant’s evidence or
heard any recording. The Claimant has failed to comply with orders made
on multiple occasions for disclosure and exchange of witness statements
and there is no schedule of loss on file. Even if the Respondent felt it
Case No:3327070/2017
6.2 Strike out Judgment – claim - rule 37
could proceed tomorrow given the late disclosure and exchange, we are
not confident that given the parties are unrepresented that the case would
conclude within the remaining two days listed. Any part-heard case would
likely now be listed for 2020.
17. We have considered whether the hearing should be postponed for a third
occasion which would be not before 2020. However, we are concerned
that given in over 12 months the case is still not ready for a hearing, that
this would not change and further judicial resources would be wasted on a
hearing which would be ineffective for the fourth time.
18. We have considered whether Rule 30A Employment Tribunal (Constitution
& Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2013 also applies to this claim. Whilst
the previous postponements have not been expressly applications by the
Claimant they have nevertheless been because of the claimant’s inability
to actively pursue his claim. The respondent does not consent to a further
postponement and in our view the exceptional circumstances provisions
would not apply. Even if the Claimant had requested postponements
(rather than just not attending) Rule 30A Employment Tribunal
(Constitution & Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2013 would have
prevented us from granting a postponement in this case.
19. We have therefore decided to dismiss the claim as the claimant has failed
to attend under Rule 47 Employment Tribunal (Constitution & Rules of
Procedure) Regulations 2013. Had the Claimant attended today and not
prepared his case we would have been equally minded to strike out the
claim.
20. As set out above had the claim not been dismissed for non-attendance
given the history a strike out under Rule 37 would have been appropriate.
The manner in which the proceedings have been conducted by the
Claimant has been unreasonable under Rule 37(1)(b) Employment
Tribunal (Constitution & Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2013. Further,
the Claimant has failed to comply on multiple occasions with orders of the
Employment Tribunal. He has been given an unless order and the case
was almost struck out last year. This would have been further grounds to
strike out the claim under Rule 37(1)(c) Employment Tribunal (Constitution
& Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2013.
21. In addition, the claimant has taken no steps to prepare his case that either
the respondent or the Tribunal has seen. The Claimant (despite having
received two notifications of the listing for today) has failed to attend. This
would have been further grounds to strike out the claim under Rule
37(1)(d) Employment Tribunal (Constitution & Rules of Procedure)
Regulations 2013. We also have concerns as to the delay in ordering
another postponement and whether it would be possible to have a fair
hearing under Rule 37(1)(e) Employment Tribunal (Constitution & Rules of
Procedure) Regulations 2013 as by the time the case is heard the
claimant’s allegations would be over three years old.
22. We have considered the Overriding objective in Rule 2 and that to proceed
tomorrow would not have put the parties on an equal footing, the hearing
would have been ineffective and this would have resulted in further delays
for the parties and further expense for the Respondent. The Claimant has
Case No:3327070/2017
6.2 Strike out Judgment – claim - rule 37
had ample time and directions to properly prepare his case. At a time
when the Tribunal Service is experiencing a backlog in its hearing times
this is unacceptable. The Claimant has been given multiple chances to
advance his case and prepare his case to be heard.
23. It is for these reasons that it is the unanimous decision of this Tribunal that
the claim be dismissed.
.
_____________________________
Employment Judge King
11/11/19
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
........................................................................
........................................................................
FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.