Mr D Robinson v Burtech Engineering Ltd and Burtech Precision Ltd: 1802971/2021
Employment Tribunal
Published on 18 November 2022, 10:47
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
transfer-of-undertakings unlawful-deduction-from-wages
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2022-05-13
Official Documents
-
Mr D Robinson v Burtech Engineering Ltd and Burtech Precision Ltd: 1802971/2021 - Judgment with Reasons
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No:1802971/2021
1
/
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr Dale Robinson
Respondents: (1) Burtech Engineering Ltd
(2) Burtech Precision Ltd
Heard at: Leeds (by video link) On: 13 May 2022
Before: Employment Judge R S Drake
Representation:
Claimant: In Person
Respondent: Mr K Burnett (Director)
JUDGMENT
1. Under Rules 75 and 76 I award to the Respondents and the Claimant
shall pay to them solicitors the sum of £584.25.68 for preparation time
costs incurred from the commencement on 22 May 2021 and pursuit of
his claims vexatiously and unreasonably upto the date of their dismissal
by withdrawal on 21 September 2021
REASONS
2. I heard oral evidence from the Claimant in person (both in response to
the costs claim and his ability to meet it and his income and means) and
from the Respondents’ director Mr K Burnett who both gave their
testimony in solemn form on Affirmation and did so candidly.
3. The relevant law enshrined in the Employment Tribunals (Constitution
and Rules) Regulations 2013 provides as follows:
“Rule 75(2) - a preparation time order is an order that a party make a
payment to another party in respect of the receiving parties preparation
time while not legally represented. Preparation time means time spent
by the receiving party in working on the case except for the time spent
at any final hearing.”
“Rule 76(1) - A Tribunal may make a costs order or a preparation time
order and shall consider whether to do so where it considers that –
Case No:1802971/2021
2
/
… a party (or its representative) has acted vexatiously, abusively,
disruptively, or otherwise unreasonably in either the bringing of the
proceedings or the way that the proceedings have been conducted”
(my emphases relevant to this case as per my findings below)”
4. The facts I found and the findings I make in applying the Rules are as
follows:-
4.1 Before the claim was commenced by the Claimant, he was advised
by an accredited representative of a trades union called Unionline and
he continued to be advised by different representatives of that
organisation up to the point in time in September 2021 when they
declined to act for him because they advised him that his claims had no
merit. Only evidence I find that they could have advised him of this
before he commenced his claims and therefore should have done so.
Furthermore, he is fixed with the fact that because he was represented
in the issuing of his claim, he can be construed as understanding
everything which his representative understood or should have
understood.
4.2 The substantial bundle of documentary evidence made available by
with the Respondents early this year related mainly to the issues in the
claim but not the issues as to the costs they had incurred once the claim
was commenced. Therefore, the absence of that evidence in
documentary form today has no bearing on the key issues of what I had
to determine
4.3 The key issues for me were whether the Claimant in issuing or
concluding his claim had acted vexatiously, abusively, disruptively, or
otherwise unreasonably, and if so whether I should therefore consider
making a costs order against him, which in this case would be limited to
preparation time costs because the Respondents were not
professionally represented.
4.4 I concluded on the basis of the evidence before me that the
complaints were doomed from the start eventually to fail, that his union
had advised him of this part way through the proceedings and should
have known to advise him of this before the proceedings were
commenced. I therefore conclude that though he did not act abusively
his doomed claim isn't and he continued to pursue it unreasonably Up
to the point when he withdrew and his claims were dismissed on
withdrawal.
4.5 The Respondents’ claim for preparation time costs is fully set out in
their letter to the Tribunal dated 5 October 2021. I concluded that it is
clear that they are claiming for time engaged in investigating the basis
of what they perceived to be a counterclaim for overpaid wages. I had
already advised that because the Claimant was not pursuing a breach
of contract claim, the Respondents could not pursue a counterclaim in
this Tribunal for breach of contract claim themselves, and that much of
the time they claimed for preparing their response was not allowable. I
Case No:1802971/2021
3
/
assessed that of the 18 hours claimed, they could reasonably be
attributed to 6 hours to their ET3 response pure and simple.
4.6 the respondents also claimed 14.5 hours four time engaged in
surveillance of the claimant but I concluded that again this related to their
counterclaim and their reason for dismissing the claimant but not to the
claims he is actually pursuing in these proceedings. However, I
concluded that beyond preparation of the response, the respondents
were entitled to claim further 4 hours of preparation time to get the case
ready for hearing and a further 4.25 hours 4 finished with a CAS and
preparation for today's hearing.
4.7 thus that it was reasonable to allow costs for preparation time be
assessed for a total of 14.25 hours at the current maximum statutory
rate of £41.00 per hour and thus a total of £584.25
5. Accordingly, having assessed ability to pay and after limiting the
Respondent’s claims purely and only to time engaged in responding to
the claim as distinct from researching the basis of the counterclaim the
Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to hear, I assessed the Respondents’
allowable preparation time cost that the Claimant shall pay to them in
the total sum of £584.25. I give Judgment accordingly.
.
Employment Judge R S Drake
Date 13 May 2022
Note
Reasons for the judgment having been given orally at the hearing, written reasons will not be
provided unless a request was made by either party at the hearing, or a written request is presented
by either party within 14 days of the sending of this written record of the decision.
Public access to employment tribunal decisions
Judgments and reasons for the judgments are published, in full, online at www.gov.uk/employmenttribunal-
decisions shortly after a copy has been sent to the Claimant(s) and Respondent(s) in a
case.
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.