Mr D Thomas v Delta Plus (U.K.) Ltd: 2500068/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 20 May 2019, 10:17
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract redundancy unfair-dismissal unlawful-deduction-from-wages working-time-regulations
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2018-06-18
Official Documents
-
Mr D Thomas v Delta Plus (U.K.) Ltd: 2500068/2018 - Judgment
-
Mr D Thomas v Delta Plus (U.K.) Ltd: 2500068/2018 - Reasons
Decision Content
Read the full decision in .
Read the full decision in .
Change History
-
New Judgment
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No: 2500068/2018
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr D Thomas
Respondent: Delta Plus (U.K.) Limited
Heard at: Teesside Justice Centre On: 8 May 2018
Before: Employment Judge S A Shore
Representation:
Claimant: In person
Respondent: Mr J Anderson of Counsel
JUDGMENT
1. The claimant’s claims of unfair dismissal and breach of contract (nonpayment
of notice pay) fail.
2. The claimant’s claims of unauthorised deduction from wages, failure to
pay holiday pay and for a redundancy payment are dismissed upon
withdrawal.
3. The claimant shall pay the respondent a contribution to its legal fees of
£350.
Employment Judge S A Shore
Date 8 May 2018
Note
Reasons for the judgment having been given orally at the hearing, written reasons will not
be provided unless a request was made by either party at the hearing or a written request
is presented by either party within 14 days of the sending of this written record of the
decision.
Case No: 2500068/2018
Public access to employment tribunal decisions
Judgments and reasons for the judgments are published, in full, online at
www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions shortly after a copy has been sent to the claimant(s)
and respondent(s) in a case.
Case No: 2500068/2018
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr D Thomas
Respondent: Delta Plus (U.K.) Limited
Heard at: Teesside Justice Centre On: 8 May 2018
Before: Employment Judge S A Shore
Representation:
Claimant: In person
Respondent: Mr J Anderson of Counsel
REASONS
1 I delivered an oral judgment in this case on 8 May 2018 dismissing the
claimant’s claims of unfair dismissal and breach of contract and ordering
the claimant to pay the respondent a contribution to its legal fees of £350.
2 The claimant requested written reasons for my decision by letter dated 19
May 2018 and these are those reasons.
3 As I explained to the parties when I delivered my oral judgment, I had not
been provided with a digital voice recorder upon which to record my
decision on 8 May, so these reasons may contain some material
differences from the oral decision that I gave.
Background
4 The claimant, David Thomas, was employed by the respondent, Delta
Plus (U.K.) Limited as Area Sales Manager from 9 December 2011 until
his summary dismissal on 5 April 2016. He brought claims to the
Employment Tribunal which were struck out for non-payment of fees.
Following the well-publicised judgment in the Unison case, the claimant’s
claim was reinstated and listed for a one-day hearing on 8 May 2018.
Claims
5 At the start of the hearing I discussed his claims with the claimant. In his
ET1, he had indicated claims of unfair dismissal, failure to make a
redundancy payment, breach of contract (failure to pay notice pay), failure
to pay holiday pay and unauthorised deduction of wages.
6 The claimant accepted that his holiday pay and unauthorised deduction of
wages claims were errors and withdrew them. I discussed with him his
redundancy pay claim. He said he was making this claim because if he
Case No: 2500068/2018
had been made redundant, he would have received a redundancy
payment. On the basis that he accepted that he was dismissed for
misconduct and that redundancy was never an issue, he asked to
withdraw this claim also. The withdrawal was noted on my judgment.
Issues
7 I then discussed the issues with the parties. In the unfair dismissal claim it
was agreed that the claimant was an employee, had at least two years
continuous service and had not lost the right to claim. There was a short
discussion with Mr Anderson about the date that the ET1 was submitted,
but it was accepted that the claim was in time.
8 The following issues were agreed:-
8.1 What was the reason for dismissal? The burden for showing the
reason for dismissal is on the respondent.
8.2 Is the dismissal one of the five potentially fair reasons for
dismissal? If not, the dismissal is automatically unfair.
8.3 If the dismissal is for the reason of misconduct, the determination of
the question whether the dismissal is fair or unfair (having regard to
the reason shown by the respondent) will depend on whether in the
circumstances, (including the size and administrative resources of
the respondent’s undertaking) the respondent acted reasonably or
unreasonably in treating it as sufficient reason for dismissing the
claimant and shall be determined in accordance with equity and the
substantial merits of the case.
8.4 In determining the fairness of the dismissal, the Tribunal will
consider the rule in British Home Stores Limited v Burchell
[1978] IRLR 379:-
8.4.1 Did the respondent have a genuine belief in the claimant’s
guilt?
8.4.2 Was that belief based on reasonable grounds; and
8.4.3 Did those grounds follow a reasonable investigation?
8.5 The Tribunal would also have to consider the rule in Iceland
Frozen Foods Limited v Jones [1983] ICR 17:-
8.5.1 I cannot substitute my decision for that of the respondent,
and;
8.5.2 The decision to dismiss has to fall within a band of
reasonable responses.
8.6 If I find in favour of the claimant on liability, should any reduction in
compensation be awarded because of contributory conduct?
8.7 If I find in favour of the claimant on liability, should any deduction be
made following the principle in Polkey v AE Dayton Services
Limited [1987] UKHL8?
8.8 What amount of compensation is just and equitable?
9 In respect of the claim of breach of contract, the test is not the same as
that for unfair dismissal. The issue that I would have to determine is
whether the claimant committed an act of gross misconduct which justified
summary dismissal.
Case No: 2500068/2018
Housekeeping
10 I noted that a previous order had been made amending the name of the
respondent. I noted that I had done a check on Companies House myself
and noticed that the correct name of the respondent was Delta Plus (U.K.)
Limited. Mr Anderson took instructions and it was agreed this was the
correct legal name of the respondent, so I made an order amending the
respondent’s name.
11 The claimant and respondent have both produced bundles. Mr Anderson
only had a copy of what he referred to as the agreed bundle (i.e. the
respondent’s bundle). I asked the claimant to check whether any of the
documents in his bundle were not in the respondent’s bundle. He checked
and confirmed that he was happy that the documents he had sent in were
all in the agreed bundle.
12 I noted that I had witness statements from Sam Hill, the Managing Director
of the respondent and Jeanette Tuplin, the HR Manager of the
respondent. The claimant had not produced a witness statement. He said
that he had done a statement in his ET1. I explained to him that that was
not a statement for our purposes and referred him to the standard case
management order that had been sent out to the parties. I felt that that
gave a clear indication of what was required.
13 The claimant said that all his statements were in his bundle, so I asked
him at what pages in the bundle his statements appear. He said that they
were at pages 46, 47, 48, 74, 75-77, 80 and 83 of the agreed bundle. I
agreed to accept these documents as the claimant’s witness evidence
along with his statement of claim and his ET1.
14 Prior to the hearing, my clerk had handed me an envelope from the
claimant. I asked him to explain what the contents of the envelope were.
He said that he had received the respondent’s witness statement late the
previous week. Some of the evidence in the respondent’s statements was
inaccurate so he had produced documents that proved the inaccuracies in
the statements. Mr Anderson said that his client had not received those
documents.
15 There were three documents; an e-mail from Jon Hudson to the claimant
dated 3 May 2018, the claimant’s full year performance for 2014 and 2015
and the same document in respect of one of the claimant’s colleagues,
Andy Ponder. I gave these documents page numbers 109, 110 and 111
respectively.
16 I reminded the parties of the overriding objective of the Employment
Tribunal to achieve a fair and just hearing and stressed to the claimant that
although he was not represented, the requirement for the parties to be on
an equal footing put an onus on me to ensure that he was not
disadvantaged because he was not legally represented and that I should
ensure that I explained the process of the Tribunal and the legal issues
that the Tribunal operates by to him.
17 Mr Anderson submitted that I needed to make a decision regarding the
claimant’s witness evidence. His starting point was the order sent out with
the notice of hearing dated 15 January 2018. That required the claimant
and the respondent to prepare full written statements of the evidence they
and their witnesses intended to give at the hearing. It warned that no
additional witness evidence may be allowed at the hearing without
Case No: 2500068/2018
permission of the Tribunal.
18 The matter had come before Employment Judge Shepherd for a
preliminary hearing on 21 February 2018 at which the claimant appeared
in person and Ms Tuplin appeared on behalf of the respondent. Mr
Anderson submitted that the same conversation regarding witness
statements had happened at the preliminary hearing and Employment
Judge Shepherd had affirmed the case management order of 15 January
2018. Mr Anderson said that the Employment Judge had been at pains to
tell the claimant that reliance on the documents would be insufficient.
19 Mr Anderson said that there were a range of judicial options available to
me. He acknowledged that the respondent has the burden of showing the
reason for dismissal for unfair dismissal so he cannot make an application
for strike out. However, he can make an application relating to a breach of
the Tribunal’s order and can make a decision on the extent to which the
claimant is allowed to give evidence.
20 The substantive case concerns the alleged fraud of the claimant and all
the pages referred to by the claimant as being his witness statement relate
to collateral matters. Nowhere does the claimant comment on the
allegation of fraud made against him.
21 Mr Anderson submitted that if I do allow the claimant to adduce evidence,
he would wish to have some leeway because cross-examination would be
without a witness statement to refer to.
22 I considered Mr Anderson’s application and said that I would consider it
with the documents that are listed above to be the claimant’s witness
statement. I would then read all the documents in the bundle and return to
commence the hearing and give a determination on Mr Anderson’s
application.
23 On my return, I advised the parties that the overriding objective requires a
fair hearing. I felt that it would be wrong to deny the claimant the
opportunity to put his claim, even though it would be reasonable to deny
him that opportunity, given the history of the matter.
24 The documents he had produced did not affect the issues in the case. It is
irrelevant what the claimant was paid compared to his colleagues. The email
from John Hodson [109] is not relevant evidence. Neither were the
performance figures of the Appellant and his colleague [110-111] I
therefore was not going to allow those documents to be entered in
evidence.
25 I decided I was going to give Mr Anderson latitude to ask questions as I
found it implausible that the claimant would not have understood that a
witness statement was required by the case management order of 15
January and the order of the Tribunal of 1 May 2018.
26 The claimant said that the real reason for his dismissal was not the alleged
fraud. That was just a smokescreen to dismiss him. The respondent
wanted to replace him and subjected him to psychological bullying and a
trumped-up charge in order to replace him with someone that they had
already approached.
27 I pointed out to the claimant that that was not put in any of the allegedly
contemporaneous documents that he had produced as his witness
statement or any of the other documents.
Case No: 2500068/2018
28 The first witness for the respondent was Jeanette Tuplin, who has been
employed by the respondent as HR Manager since February 2007. Part of
her responsibilities is to prepare the staff handbook policies and ensure
that they are communicated to employees. One of these policies is the
business expenses policy that appeared at page 106 of the bundle. She
distributed this to the sales team (including the claimant) on 3 October
2013 [44].
29 In February 2016, Ms Tuplin was approached by the respondent’s Finance
Manager Veelas Vekria to explain that she had some concerns regarding
a number of anomalies with the claimant’s fuel purchase and mileage
records for January 2016.
30 The practice at the respondent was for relevant members of staff to
forward a business expense form to the Finance Manager monthly
together with supporting receipts and mileage record form. These were
then checked for mistakes and inaccuracies.
31 The agreement that the respondent had with relevant employees was that
private mileage was deducted at an agreed rate from employees on a
monthly basis. Therefore, the lower the private mileage that the employee
recorded, less money would be deducted from their salary. The corollary
of that situation is that the higher the business mileage that was recorded,
the lower the private mileage (and hence the deduction) would be.
32 In response to the concerns of the Finance Manager, Ms Tuplin decided to
look into matters and conduct an initial investigation. She was provided
with a bundle of documents concerning the claimant’s expenses claims for
2016 that included his business expense form, his mileage record forms
[68], fuel receipts and activity reports from the respondent’s customer
relationship management (CRM) system [69].
33 Members in the respondent’s sales team were required to enter details of
customers and prospects that they had visited on the CRM system.
34 Each Area Sales Manager (the role undertaken by the claimant) was
provided with a company credit card used to purchase fuel. Employees
were required to record all mileage travel visiting clients on the mileage
record form. In addition to this, the employee must submit details of
personal mileage travelled each month. The personal mileage is deducted
at a rate of 15p per mile from the employee’s monthly salary.
35 Ms Tuplin initially cross-referenced the claimant’s mileage record form with
the CRM system and found that no visits had been mis-reported. The trips
and destinations in both documents matched.
36 Ms Tuplin then used the postcodes that appeared on the CRM system to
calculate the mileage each journey would have involved using Google
maps. She discovered that the distance travelled on a number of the trips
recorded had been grossly inflated.
37 She created the document that appears at page 70 of the bundle that
shows the exaggerated mileage claims. She then created a summary
sheet that appears at page 71 of the bundle that calculates that the
claimant had overclaimed mileage for January 2016 by 267 miles.
38 Ms Tuplin then compared this travel to the fuel purchased by the claimant
that month, details of which were recorded at page 71 of the bundle. By
Ms Tuplin’s calculation, the claimant had travelled 666 miles on £55 of
Case No: 2500068/2018
petrol. She considered that to be an unlikely statistic. Ms Tuplin then
carried out the same exercise for the months of October, November and
December 2015. Those documents appeared at pages 51-60 and 61-67
of the bundle. Ms Tuplin found that a significant amount of business
mileage had been overclaimed. None of the journeys recorded by the
claimant had been underestimated. She calculated that the claimant had
overclaimed 234.5 miles in October 2015 [54], 842.5 miles in November
2015 [60] and 655.5 miles in December 2015 [67]. She came to the
conclusion that the claimant was attempting to disguise personal mileage
as business mileage to therefore avoid deduction of 15p per mile from his
salary payment. Ms Tuplin calculated that if she recorded his business
mileage correctly, then he would have incurred significantly more personal
mileage. She calculated that he would have had additional deductions of
£35.18 for October 2015, £126.38 for November 2015, £98.33 for
December 2015 and £40.05 for January 2016. The total under-reported
personal mileage cost was therefore £299.94.
39 Ms Tuplin also compared the mileage claims to the fuel purchased and
found a huge anomaly between the amount of fuel purchased and the
miles recorded on the fuel purchased.
40 Ms Tuplin prepared a summary document that appears at page 72 in the
bundle and informed the Managing Director of the respondent, Sam Hill,
that a disciplinary matter should be convened.
41 The claimant was sent a disciplinary invite letter on 11 March 2016 [78].
She next heard from the claimant when he e-mailed her on 18 March 2016
to advise that he had submitted a grievance to Herve Zippel, the
respondent’s European Director, in relation to Sam Hill’s conduct.
42 Mr Zippel asked Ms Tuplin to conduct an investigation into the grievance.
She acknowledged the grievance on 21 March 2015 [84] and spoke to
Sam Hill and Helen Crompton, who had brought the customer complaint
that was part of the claimant’s grievance to the attention of Mr Hill.
43 She looked at the company’s payroll records to determine whether the
claimant was paid disproportionately compared to colleagues. Her
investigation revealed that the claimant was paid in line with the other
members of the sales team and there was no evidence of disproportionate
treatment.
44 She fed all the information back to Mr Zippel verbally and via e-mail. The
claimant was invited to a grievance hearing on 24 March 2016. The
grievance investigation hearing took place on 30 March 2016 but no copy
of the notes has been retained. Mr Zippel heard the claimant’s grievance
and rejected it. The claimant did not appeal the decision to reject his
grievance. Ms Tuplin attended the disciplinary hearing but did not provide
any evidence of what happened there.
45 The claimant asked Ms Tuplin a number of questions upon crossexamination.
She confirmed that she was notified in February 2016 of a
discrepancy in the claimant’s mileage claims. She also confirmed that the
main issue was an alleged excess claim of 842 miles in November 2015.
Ms Tuplin did not know what the claimant’s average monthly private
mileage was for 2014. He said it was 200 miles per month. She was not
aware of this.
46 He asked if she was aware of his average private mileage in 2015 but she
Case No: 2500068/2018
again said that she did not. It was put to her that it was 245 miles. He put
to Ms Tuplin that she had said he had done 842 private miles in
November. He had done approximately 200 on average, so he would have
had to travel to London and back every weekend. Ms Tuplin referred to
page 58 of the bundle where personal mileage was recorded as 134 miles.
47 The claimant took Ms Tuplin to pages 62 and 68 of the bundle which were
his December mileage submitted on 17 December 2015 and his January
mileage submitted on 8 January 2016. He said he could not put all his
mileage on the CRM report.
48 Ms Tuplin referred back to page 60, the claimant’s mileage claim for
November 2015 that showed excess mileage of 842.5 miles. She said
that when questioned, the claimant had no explanation for this at the time.
49 I asked Ms Tuplin if the CRM system did not allow you to make new
entries. She said she did not believe so.
50 The second witness for the respondent was Sam Hill, its Managing
Director, who said that he has been in the role since February 2010. He
manages the respondent’s workforce in the UK, which comprises of over
20 employees, five of whom were sales employees. He was surprised to
be the subject of a grievance by the claimant as he believed he had a
great working relationship with him prior to that. He referred to
encouraging and friendly e-mails, at pages 49 and 50 of the bundle, that
he had sent the claimant. They had attended music events together and
had purchased a football shirt signed by a Liverpool FC player for him.
51 He had reviewed the documents at pages 46, 47, 48, 75, 80 and 83 of the
bundle and effectively rejected allegations that were made by the claimant
therein. The grievance raised by the claimant had been rejected. The
claimant did not appeal, so the disciplinary process continued. A
disciplinary meeting was convened for 5 April 2016 [87] and the minutes of
the meeting appear at page 91 of the bundle. During the disciplinary
hearing, the claimant was taken through each of the inaccuracies in the
mileage claims set out above and asked for comment. Mr Hill said the
claimant made a number of generalised excuses such as the distances on
Google Map being inaccurate but when compared to other Sales
Managers, the discrepancies in the mileage claimed by the claimant were
significantly higher. A specific instance was pointed out to the claimant
that on 6 and 9 October 2015 [53] he made the same journey between
Middlesbrough and Blackburn which Google Maps calculated to be 91
miles. The claimant had claimed 167 miles. The return journey was
calculated as being 122 miles. The claimant had claimed 171 miles. Mr
Hill said the claimant could not offer any explanation for discrepancies
other than he must have deviated from his route. He was not able to detail
where he went. The claimant had explained an excess of 62 miles
claimed on 26 October 2016 as additional miles because he had been
prospecting for business.
52 The excess mileage claimed in November as detailed on page 60 was not
explained by the claimant who vaguely referred to being in hotels and
admitted that he was guilty of not completing the forms correctly.
53 The claimant said that he kept all his prospecting information in his head
so there was no way of evidencing what work he had carried out. Mr Hill
recalled that the claimant’s trade union representative stated that the
Case No: 2500068/2018
figures produced by the claimant looked irregular.
54 Mr Hill turned to the issue of the discrepancies in fuel purchased and
consumed and could not understand how the figures were arrived at. He
asked the claimant for mitigating factors in response to which the claimant
simply acknowledged that the figures looked odd and irregular. Mr Hill
adjourned the meeting and took some time to consider the evidence he
had heard. He concluded there was no further reasonable investigative
steps that could be taken and decided that the claimant had not been able
to provide a reasonable explanation for the significant discrepancies in the
mileage claimed for a number of months. The fuel consumption figures
simply did not stack up. As a result, Mr Hill found that the claimant had
committed the alleged misconduct. Under the respondent’s disciplinary
procedure, theft and failure to follow policies amount to gross misconduct,
so the decision was to dismiss summarily. The claimant was informed of
his right of appeal but did not lodge an appeal.
55 Mr Hill has been involved in the dismissal of two other employees over the
years for also falsifying mileage, fuel allowance and expenses claims.
56 In cross-examination, the claimant put to Mr Hill that he had admitted to
the claimant that he could get rid of anyone on 19 June 2015 [46]. Mr Hill
denied that. The claimant’s record in which Mr Hill referred to instruction
from Mr Zipper on 22 September 2015 [47] were denied. Mr Hill said that
Mr Zipper was not that involved. He is a Sales Director of a £235 million
turnover company with responsibility for Europe and the USA. He has 400
people doing the same job as the claimant did, so he would not have tried
to micromanage the claimant as alleged. Mr Hill denied saying the words
that the claimant had recorded. Mr Zipper had not said the words to him.
Mr Hill denied telling the claimant about other peoples’ earnings.
Specifically, he denied telling the claimant what Jon Hodson was earning.
The claimant and Mr Hodson were good friends and they may have
discussed it between them. Mr Hodson had a different role within the
company. He was Mr Hill’s second in command and had 20 years’
continuous service. The claimant then showed Mr Hill page 109 of the
bundle. I intervened as I had already found that that new document
showed nothing of relevance to the issues. Mr Hill confirmed that no
bonus had been paid to the claimant because his performance had not
warranted it. It was put to Mr Hill that at paragraph 38 of his witness
statement Mr Hill had admitted that he had praised the claimant’s
performance. Mr Hill accepted this but the performance parameters for
bonus payments were in black and white. They are signed off against
agreed KPIs. The claimant did not earn a bonus because he did not
achieve the financial or non-financial indications. The bonus is
contractual. Everyone knows whether they will hit it or not.
57 The claimant put some bonus figures to Mr Hill. Mr Hill said that staff had
given the claimant false information. The claimant then said that he
wanted to see payslips and P60s but they were never forthcoming. I said
that this had been argued before Employment Judge Garnon and the
claimant’s application for specific disclosure of documents had been
rejected.
58 The claimant then put to Mr Hill that Andy Ponder had been paid a bonus.
Mr Hill accepted this but said that the bonus was for non-financial
indicators. Mr Hill did not know if Mr Ponder had received 1.79% bonus
Case No: 2500068/2018
but accepted that the claimant did not receive a pay rise and that he had
been paid in line with market rates.
59 The claimant put it to Mr Hill that not every single journey was inaccurate
on Google Maps. Mr Hill pointed to page 72 and confirmed that every
single journey was overclaimed. I asked Mr Hill about the CRM system
and he confirmed that you could select a new prospect on the system and
enter the date and time of the visit. That had always been the case.
60 The claimant put a number of questions to Mr Hill about prospecting visits
but Mr Hill said that in order to qualify for non-financial KPIs, it was about
end user business not distributive business. The claimant then asked how
long it had taken the business to replace members of the sales team who
had left. Mr Hill was unsure about Jeff Crowe and it was put to him that it
was six to nine months. Mr Hill was not sure. It was put to Mr Hill that
Peter Fenton was dismissed for mileage abuse and it took six to nine
months to replace him. Mr Hill said that his replacement was very quick;
within four weeks. The claimant asked Mr Hill how long it had taken to
replace him. Mr Hill said it was six weeks. The claimant put it to him that
it was seven weeks. Mr Hill said that the candidate only had a week’s
notice and worked for one of their customers. It was put to Mr Hill that his
replacement had already been identified and they were looking to get rid
of him in order to accommodate his replacement. Mr Hill denied this and
said that they had no accounts in Yorkshire, where the replacement was
based.
61 The claimant gave evidence by adopting the documents at pages 8, 46,
47, 48, 74,75-77, 80 and 83. These were largely concerning his
grievances with Mr Hill and did not address the matters that were
determined at the disciplinary hearing. In cross-examination, the claimant
admitted that he used a company credit card to purchase fuel and that he
was required to record mileage of trips to and from customers. He was
also required to record all personal mileage. He was shown the business
expenses policy at page 107 and the procedure at page 106 and agreed
that the business and personal mileage policy at 107 applied to everyone.
The claimant accepted that the personal mileage of employees was
deducted at 15p a mile from salary. He also agreed that if personal
mileage was not recorded and therefore not deducted from salary, that
would be flawed. The claimant did not accept this and said that it was
about putting wrong information in. The claimant accepted that the CRM
data was cross-checked with the mileage data and agreed that Google
Maps search produced different results to the mileage recorded by him.
He said this was because he did not include cold calls and the CRM could
not deal with the calls to companies he had not dealt with previously. The
claimant was taken to page 53 which showed Sunderland Council on the
CRM system; Sunderland Council was not a customer. He said that
Sunderland Council was a named user and had gone through a period of
name change. It was put to him that Mr Hill had given evidence that
prospects could be put into the system but the claimant said this was only
after the fact. The claimant’s journey on 5 January 2016 was put to him,
(page 11 of Ms Tuplin’s witness statement [70]) and it was noted there
was a difference of 63 miles on the journey. The claimant said that this
was an example of Google Maps being wrong. He went round the long
way not via the Transporter Bridge, which Google Maps had used to
calculate his mileage.
Case No: 2500068/2018
62 He was then taken to page 71 and the calculation that he had overcharged
for 267 in the month. That was not explainable by the bridge in the month
of January 2016. Did he agree? The claimant said that “that was
according to the paperwork”.
63 Mr Anderson then asked the claimant to compare the record with the fuel
purchased that seemingly he had done 666 miles on a £55 tank of petrol.
The claimant said he had filled up twice so had done an extra 238 miles
after he had filled up as it stated on page 71.
64 I put it to the claimant that the respondent’s case is that 900 miles were
claimed in respect of fill ups on 5 January 2016 and 8 January 2016. The
claimant said he had filled up twice and done 234 miles on 8 January
2016. Mr Anderson said that he needed to take instructions on this new
information and we broke for him to do this.
65 When we restarted, Mr Anderson took the claimant to paragraph 16 of Ms
Tuplin’s witness statement relating to overclaims of 234.5 miles in
October, 842.5 miles in November and 655 miles in December. He asked
the claimant if he accepted that this was a correct arithmetical calculation.
The claimant agreed that it was. The claimant was then asked about
December 2015 and taken to page 67. The claimant confirmed that he
had bought £54.77 of fuel and travelled about 216 miles on that day. He
agreed he had travelled 178 miles on 17 December 2015 and had put
£45.64 of fuel in the car on 18 December 2015 but had only done 178
miles. The claimant said that the records did not show what he had done
on 19, 20, 21 and 22 December. Mr Anderson said it was not on that
record but the claimant said he did personal mileage to cover it. Mr
Anderson said that the personal mileage for the claimant for December
was 49 miles. The claimant said this private mileage would have gone in
his January claim. We then had a long discussion between Mr Anderson
and the claimant about the dates of claims and amounts of mileage
claimed. It was then put to the claimant that his only mitigating
circumstances were that the figures were odd and irregular. The claimant
said he agreed if that was what was in the minutes. It was put to him that
he had claimed that he had been prospecting, accepted that the figures
were odd and irregular, and said that he had not made fraudulent claims.
The claimant again accepted that that was what the minutes had said. It
was put to the claimant that he could not possibly have genuinely done
1,500 miles of prospecting. He said that it was possible and it depended
where he was. It was put to him then at page 95 he was recorded as
saying that he could not give specific information and that he would not
give detail. He accepted that he should have put down every inch of
mileage that he had done. It was put to him again that he was unable to
give any detail and said that he had compliments slips and business cards
at home to evidence the prospecting visits he had made. It was put to him
that the details that he now says he has would have enabled his employer
to check up his alleged prospecting and he accepted that they probably
would. The claimant said the whole thing was a shambles. It was put to
him that his account was not credible and his response was that it
sounded a bit “uncredible.” The claimant accepted that the was given the
right of appeal but did not appeal. He blamed his union representative
who said that the union would take the appeal on. He said the union had
let him down badly. It was put to the claimant that he never previously
complained that his union failed to appeal. He accepted this. It was put to
Case No: 2500068/2018
the claimant that if he knew he had evidence of his innocence he should
have put it and agreed with this. The claimant said that he was only guilty
of not recording every single mile he drove in the car.
66 Mr Anderson then switched to the claimant’s relationship with Mr Hill. The
claimant reluctantly agreed that he had a great working relationship with
Mr Hill up to June 2015 and it was put to him that Mr Hill’s evidence was
not the action of a man out to get him. The claimant was then taken to the
notes that he said were contemporaneous. He said he had written page
25 on Thursday, 10 March and then changed his account to say that he
had written it either on the Friday or the Saturday when he had got home.
It was put to him therefore that he was writing it in full knowledge of the
disciplinary proceedings that had started. He said he had already written
most of it when he got the disciplinary notice on 12 March and then added
the last two lines. It was put to the claimant that he had submitted false
mileage. He denied this. It was put to him that when he was asked for an
explanation at the time he gave no explanation or no adequate
explanation. His response to this was that that was according to the
notes. He asked him what he meant. He said that he did not give any
explanation.
67 The claimant said that he had proof that the notes that he had made were
contemporaneous because he had sent copies of them to himself via
recorded delivery. I asked him where the recorded delivery proofs of
posting were and he said that he did not have them. He said that he
wanted to surprise the respondent with the evidence at the hearing. I was
therefore somewhat surprised that he had not brought the evidence with
him.
68 In closing, the claimant said that he felt that he was unfairly dismissed on
trumped up charges. Mr Hill had admitted that he used to dismiss other
people for the thing that he was dismissed for. He was incredibly upset
that he had been dismissed. His dismissal was nothing to do with
business mileage. It was an easy way to get people out. Mr Hill had
admitted that it was a charge dreamt up to falsify business mileage.
69 Mr Anderson submitted that the reason for dismissal had been discussed
at the preliminary hearing before Employment Judge Garnon and that
reference had been made to ASLEF v Brady. The reason for dismissal is
a set of facts known to the employer. The Employment Tribunal would
have to make a series of findings that Mr Hill used subterfuge to get rid of
the claimant.
70 Ms Tuplin was approached by the Finance Manager. She investigated
and referred the matter to Mr Hill. Mr Hill was not the genesis of the
disciplinary process and that is why I can make a finding that the matter
relates to conduct. The respondent was entitled to form a view, the
subterfuge argument lacks cogency compared with Mr Hill’s and Mr
Tuplin’s cogent and consistent evidence. The documents provided by the
claimant only deal with the grievance and the grievance was only raised
after the disciplinary process had started. The contemporaneous
documents show a good relationship between Mr Hill and the claimant.
There is no corroboration of the claimant’s claim that the documents he
produced were created contemporaneously. In considering the case of
Burchell, the investigation is thorough. Mileage records were crossreferenced
using postcodes and checked on Google Maps. Information
Case No: 2500068/2018
was checked against the claimant’s own information. The claimant
benefits if personal mileage was recorded as business mileage. The
claimant only produced two explanations. The first is that he was
prospecting for business, which is not accepted because his mileage
discrepancy was more than 1,500 miles. The second explanation was in
the minutes of the meeting at page 95. He had stated he could not give
specific information and needed to see his records. If he had made a
mistake and failed to bring evidence, he could have appealed. He failed to
do so. The evidence that he was talking about in the disciplinary hearing
was never produced for this Tribunal hearing either.
71 On the second leg of the Burchell test Mr Anderson invites me to accept
the answer to the cross-examination question that where the claimant said
that he could see why the respondent dismissed him. The claimant does
not admit anything in the minutes but does not offer any explanation. I
need to assess the respondent’s position at the time of the decision to
dismiss, at which point no or no adequate explanation was offered.
72 The claimant had caused a £350 loss to the respondent and therefore
destroyed the trust that the respondent had in the claimant.
73 It was obvious that the claimant had reasonable grounds.
74 It was also submitted that notice pay claims should fail because there was
evidence of gross misconduct. Every mileage claim was incorrect. They
are not only wrong but fraudulent.
75 I retired to consider my decision.
76 In general terms, I found the evidence of Ms Tuplin and Mr Hill to be
largely credible and that they can rely on the accuracy of the documents
that they provided.
77 I found the claimant to be an unreliable witness and find that he did not
meet the required standard of proof to show that the documents he
produced as being contemporaneous were such.
78 Unfortunately, the claimant appears to have got hold of the wrong end of
the stick with this case. He alleged some form of conspiracy or subterfuge
on the part of Mr Hill to remove him from his job and replace him with
someone else. None of that allegation was proven so I have no hesitation
in finding that the respondent has discharged the burden of proof to show
the reason for dismissal and that the reason for dismissal was misconduct.
79 I find that the respondent has a genuine belief in the claimant’s guilt. This
was obvious from the evidence of Ms Tuplin and Mr Hill. I find that the
decision to dismiss was based upon reasonable grounds because of the
evidence of Ms Tuplin and Mr Hill. I also find that the documents provided
by Ms Tuplin were evidence of her investigation into the claimant’s
mileage records and can be relied upon and demonstrate that the four
months for which she undertook an investigation showed that the claimant
had overclaimed business mileage by more than 1,500 miles at a cost to
the respondent of over £350. He offered no explanation or no adequate
explanation for the figures at the disciplinary. He said that he had more
information at the disciplinary but failed to appeal and failed to produce
that information at this hearing. I find that Ms Tuplin’s investigation was
adequate for the purposes and that dismissal was in a band of reasonable
responses.
Case No: 2500068/2018
80 The claimant’s claim of unfair dismissal therefore fails.
81 I find that the claimant committed gross misconduct and that the
respondent was justified in dismissing him summarily and without payment
of notice. His breach of contract claim therefore fails.
82 On delivering my decision, Mr Anderson made an application for a
contribution towards the respondent’s costs from the claimant in the sum
of £1,250 (his brief fee, ex-VAT).
83 The application was submitted on the grounds that the Claimant’s case
had no reasonable prospect and he asked me to look at the crossexamination,
particularly the claimant’s answer to the last question when
he admitted that he could see why the respondent thought he had
committed gross misconduct.
84 Secondly that the application was based on the claimant’s unreasonable
conduct and he asked me to look at the cases of Yerrakalva v Barnsley
Borough Council. The claimant would have known what his own case
was and knew what his own problems were regarding the fraud case. He
passed the threshold for unreasonable conduct.
85 The claimant knew the requirement to file a witness statement and failed
to do it.
86 I took details of the claimant’s current income from him. He earned
£31,000 a year which is £800 per month net. From that he had outgoings
of £500 per month rent, £135 council tax, bills of £150 per month,
broadband at £80 per month, food of £300 or £400 a month and other
expenses of £54 per month. He had no savings.
87 I considered this case carefully and felt that given the claimant’s answer to
the final question asked of him by Mr Anderson, I could not see how even
he thought his claim had a reasonable prospect of success. If he thought
it was reasonable for his employer to think that he had committed an act of
gross misconduct, I cannot see how he could possibly think that his claim
had reasonable prospects of success. The allegation by the claimant that
he was the victim of some form of subterfuge or conspiracy was not
backed up by any evidence other than his assertion. The documents that
he wished to rely upon I found not to be contemporaneous and not to be
reliable. The witness evidence of the claimant himself was vague,
inconsistent and unreliable. I therefore find that the claimant’s claim had
no reasonable prospect of success from the outset.
88 On the issue of his unreasonable conduct, I gave the claimant the benefit
of the doubt.
89 Given a brief analysis of the claimant’s means, I find that the appropriate
amount for him to contribute towards the respondent’s costs is £350.
Employment Judge S A Shore
Date 18 June 2018
Case No: 2500068/2018
Public access to employment tribunal decisions
Judgments and reasons for the judgments are published, in full, online at
www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions shortly after a copy has been sent to the claimant(s)
and respondent(s) in a case.
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.