Mr E Ali v Johnson Controls: 3305685/2024
Employment Tribunal
Published on 19 September 2025, 10:08
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
unfair-dismissal
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2025-06-24
Change History
-
Reconsideration
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No.: 3305685/2024
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr E Ali
Respondent: Johnson Controls
Heard at: Reading On: 23-24 June 2025
Before: Employment Judge Anstis (sitting alone)
Representation:
Claimant: In person
Respondent: Miss A Smith (counsel)
JUDGMENT
The claimant’s claim of unfair dismissal is dismissed.
REASONS
1. These written reasons were requested by the claimant at the conclusion of the
hearing, after oral reasons had been given.
2. The claimant was employed as a sales coordinator. He has brought his claim
against “Johnson Controls” but Johnson Controls says that he was employed
by ADT Fire and Security plc.
3. His employment started on 27 June 2011 and ended by reason of his dismissal
on 12 April 2024. He says that his dismissal was unfair, and a claim of unfair
dismissal is the only claim he has made to the tribunal. The respondent says
that he was dismissed by reason of redundancy. Redundancy is a potentially
fair reason for dismissal. The claimant has never suggested that the reason for
his dismissal was anything other than redundancy, and the evidence points
overwhelmingly to this being the reason for his dismissal. I find that the
respondent has established that this was the reason for his dismissal.
4. According to s98(4) of the Employment Rights Act 1996, once the respondent
has established a potentially fair reason for dismissal, such as redundancy:
Case No.: 3305685/2024
2
“the determination of the question whether the dismissal is fair or unfair
(having regard to the reason shown by the employer):
(a) depends on whether in the circumstances (including the size and
administrative resources of the employer’s undertaking) the
employer acted reasonably or unreasonably in treating it as a
sufficient reason for dismissing the employee, and
(b) shall be determined in accordance with equity and the substantial
merits of the case.”
5. While the burden of proof on such a point is neutral, in circumstances where
the respondent appears to have conducted an orthodox redundancy selection
process it is likely that the identification by the claimant of any points of
unfairness will be particularly influential in my decision.
6. At least the claimant’s starting position for this is set out in his witness
statement. His concerns in that witness statement primarily arise in the period
of a year or more running up to his dismissal rather than relating to the process
or scoring adopted during the redundancy process. His point is that (unfair)
events prior to the redundancy process meant that he scored badly and was
dismissed, and that he was not at any point prior to his redundancy aware that
the respondent regarded his performance as below others in his team.
7. It was not suggested in the claimant’s witness statement either that the scoring
criteria used were unfair or that he had been inaccurately scored against that
criteria.
8. A number of other matters were raised by the claimant during the hearing, some
for the first time. I was keen to ensure that I did not miss any way in which the
claimant said that his dismissal was unfair, and invited him in his closing
submissions to set out by way of bullet points or general headings the full scope
of his allegations of unfairness. He did this in an email, which I cite in full below.
The page references are to pages of the tribunal bundle:
“✓ Improvement however that can be interspersed in so my way as
it doesn't explain what the improvement is required.
✓ I have challenged my scoring and numbers not being accurate
including advising having more holiday than everyone else in the
team over the course of the year in my email to Paige which
confirm I only work a 5 day week one month of the 12 months of
Johnson Controls financial year which was used for the scoring &
number, I challenged it in my consultation meeting with Nick
however it was quickly shut down and appeal meeting with
Stephen (Page 138)
✓ Other reason why my contribution number is low split accounts
meaning the account manager i support I don't get all their work
Case No.: 3305685/2024
3
(Page 128, 129, 130 131) and some account manager raising
who enquiries (Page 136, 137) colleagues start work early, whilst
I'm on break, Paige revising (Page 134, 135) my Customer
Ordered work to get the number. I do believe James Curtis was
deliberately remove from the account and replace with Chris who
don't bring in numbers on the Asda, James Curtis (Page 132) is
back on the Asda however this was after the Johnson controls
financial year ending and all numbers that will be required for
redundancy has already been accounted for. (Page 123 , 124,
128 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178, 189 196, 202, 203)
✓ From cross examination I believe Nick advised he don't see the
numbers however Paige email confirms as a minimum it is send
across every quarter.
✓ If my suspicion is correct that it is Julia that was made redundant
out of the team it would go to show that this was a deliberate
attempt to exits us from the business because aside of myself the
other person that wasn't equally getting relocation of work
distributed was Julia. We will be looking at a case of
discrimination & we need to being back the settlement
agreements element back on the table, probably is the reason the
business are reluctant to reveal this information I respectfully
request that the tribunal grant us the right to have this information.
✓ During my appeal Stephen had Bluetooth headphones on which
I believe was private communication link with others privately
invited to the meeting. (Page 125,126 127)
✓ Delinking of account was used to further justify redundancy
however it has now been confirmed this didn't happen and maybe
the forecast / reduction of possible workload wasn't bad as
predicted.
✓ The business confirmed / adviced no alternative / suitable
vacancy was available.”
9. The respondent has explained, and it does not seem to be challenged by the
claimant, that there was a projection of a 7% decrease in workload for the team
of which the claimant was a part. In consequence of that, on 12 March 2024 the
respondent announced in a presentation to the relevant team that they were
planning to reduce the number of sales coordinators from 7 to 5. I was told, and
accept, that this took account of staff absences for maternity leave and sick
leave. The claimant was present at the meeting at which the presentation was
delivered. It was said that “all employees at risk will be measured against a set
selection matrix and the results of this will be discussed during consultation”.
Case No.: 3305685/2024
4
10. The claimant’s first individual consultation meeting took place on 14 March
2024 with Paige Nicholls (his manager) and Nick Tarbuck (his manager’s
manager). The claimant is noted as having requested a copy of the presentation
previously used and as making a point about a colleague who was on maternity
leave. His second consultation meeting took place on 18 March 2024, at which
he was provided with the selection criteria and his score. He was told that he
had been selected for redundancy and he was subsequently issued with notice
of dismissal. I was told that he had scored lowest of those scored.
11. The claimant appealed against his dismissal, and undertook a lengthy appeal
meeting on 5 April 2024 with Stephen Waldron, a manager from another part of
the business. The notes of the meetings prior to his dismissal suggest that the
claimant had at that time taken a largely passive role in the redundancy
consultation process, but the same could not be said of his appeal, at which he
made a number of points that he has subsequently repeated in these
proceedings. His appeal was unsuccessful.
12. Thus we appear to have a fairly orthodox redundancy selection exercise and
procedure. It is somewhat surprising to see that the claimant was dismissed so
shortly after being presented with the scoring criteria and his scores, but it has
not been part of his claim that that made his dismissal unfair.
13. I will now work through the factors that the claimant relies upon as making his
dismissal unfair.
14. The first point made by the claimant is “Improvement however that can be
interspersed in so my way as it doesn't explain what the improvement is
required.” I think his point here is that it is unfair to dismiss him for having the
lowest level of performance when he had not previously been told that his
performance was the lowest of the team and had not been given any ideas on
how to improve.
15. The first problem with this is that there is no principle in redundancy dismissals
that an individual should be given a warning that they must improve prior to any
scoring. It will not be unusual for an individual to be taken by surprise by their
relatively low score. What matters is, as Miss Smith puts it, that the respondent
has properly applied its mind to the scoring. The second problem is that the
claimant’s annual reviews, which Miss Smith went through with him in crossexamination, do suggest that the claimant’s performance was not as good as
he saw it to be and offer suggestions for improvement. Notably in his most
recent performance review a few months prior to the redundancy he had been
told that he was 8th out of 8 in the department (although it seems still performing
satisfactorily).
16. The claimant then speaks of challenging his scoring in particular on the basis
that he had had more holiday than others, due to carrying over holiday from the
Covid pandemic. To some extent on this point the claimant relies on an email
he had sent to his manager which was disclosed only on the morning of final
submissions. Miss Smith says this should not be admitted in evidence, and I
Case No.: 3305685/2024
5
agree. It should have been disclosed earlier and to disclose it and attempt to
rely on it only at the time of closing submissions prevents the respondent from
properly addressing it in their evidence.
17. The claimant’s point here is that he raised this in one of his initial consultation
meetings, but he does not say anything about raising anything to do with holiday
in his witness statement. In his submissions he says this is mentioned at p138
(within the appeal notes) but I see no mention of it there. I do not accept that
the claimant challenged his scoring and numbers.
18. The claimant’s next point involves a range of complicated reasons why the
assessment or scoring undertaken by the respondent may not have captured
the full extent of his work. Few specifics of this were given by the claimant in
his evidence and it has been not entirely clear what he means by this. It ranges
from concepts of him not working exclusively for particular account managers,
through to one of his account managers being removed from the Asda account,
and others taking work from private emails rather than the communal inbox. But
for the claimant (at least in his oral submissions) it goes further than that. This
is not simply an accident but a deliberate attempt by Nick Tarbuck to undermine
his work and limit his ability to work over a period of two years with a view to
eventually dismissing him as redundant. There has been a flavour of that to
some of the things the claimant has said before, but he only really put it that
way and identified Mr Tarbuck as being responsible for it in his oral closing
submissions. None of this was ever put to Mr Tarbuck during his evidence, and
as I indicated to the claimant I viewed that as being a substantial problem rather
than simply a matter of form. It is not just a formal matter of putting his case,
and I do not see how I can properly make the finding that the claimant wants –
that Mr Tarbuck through various means limited the claimant’s work so as to be
able to dismiss him as redundant – without Mr Tarbuck being given the
opportunity to respond to this. In those circumstances I do not think it is a matter
I can properly consider. I am also bound to say that I saw no evidence of this
happening beyond the claimant’s assertion in his oral closing submissions.
19. The claimant says “From cross examination I believe Nick advised he don't see
the numbers however Paige email confirms as a minimum it is send across
every quarter.” I believe this is about the question of whether the scores used
were the result of a bespoke analysis of the data for the purposes of redundancy
scoring (as the respondent says) or whether the figures were previously
available (which the claimant seems to say in this submission). I do not accept
that the figures used for the scoring were previously available, although
perhaps there were some similar figures used for internal analysis, but either
way I do not see that it affects the fairness of the claimant’s dismissal.
20. The next point relates to whether it was “Julia” who was dismissed alongside
the claimant. I do not know whether it was Julia who was dismissed. The first
time this name has come up was in the claimant’s closing submissions. The
claimant’s position seems to be that if it was Julia there were some other
arguments he may want to make, but it seems to me that it is too late at this
Case No.: 3305685/2024
6
stage to speculate who the other person was or cite unknown arguments that
may arise from that.
21. Then we have a point, arising for the first time in the claimant’s crossexamination, that Mr Waldron’s appeal was unfair as he had a Bluetooth
headset used as a “private communication link with others”. As with the point in
relation to Mr Tarbuck, if this was an important part of the claimant’s case I
would have expected it at least to be in his witness statement and put by him
to Mr Waldron, but he did not do so. He refers to the appeal notes, where Mr
Waldron talks of “feedback in the background” on his earpiece, which someone
else identifies as possibly being “a window or something”. I do not see how that
identifies the private communication link the claimant relies on.
22. I think the claimant’s next point is that the expected 7% reduction in work did
not transpire, but that is not to say that it was not expected, and a business
must plan based on what is expected, not what actually ends up happening (by
which time it would be too late to plan).
23. Finally the claimant says no suitable alternative vacancy was available. I see
that the respondent referred the claimant to their lists of vacancies, but if no
vacancy was then available I do not see how that make the claimant’s dismissal
unfair. The respondent may be obliged to offer such suitable available vacancy
as there is, but if there is none there is no obligation to offer it.
24. The claimant’s dismissal was not unfair.
Approved by Employment Judge Anstis
24 June 2025
Judgment sent to the parties on:
29 July 2025
For the Tribunal:
……………………………………
Notes
All judgments (apart from judgments under Rule 51) and any written reasons for the judgments are
published, in full, online at https://www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions shortly after a copy has
been sent to the claimants and respondents.
If a Tribunal hearing has been recorded, you may request a transcript of the recording. Unless there
are exceptional circumstances, you will have to pay for it. If a transcript is produced it will not include
any oral judgment or reasons given at the hearing. The transcript will not be checked, approved or
verified by a judge. There is more information in the joint Presidential Practice Direction on the
Recording and Transcription of Hearings and accompanying Guidance, which can be found at
www.judiciary.uk/guidance-and-resources/employment-rules-and-legislation-practice-directions/
Case Number: 3305685/2024
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr E Ali
Respondent: Johnson Controls
JUDGMENT
The claimant’s application dated 11 August 2025 for reconsideration of the
judgment sent to the parties on 29 July 2025 is refused.
REASONS
There is no reasonable prospect of the original decision being varied or revoked,
because the claimant’s application is an impermissible attempt to re-argue
matters previously before the tribunal.
Date: 29 August 2025
Approved by Employment Judge Anstis
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
15 September 2025
FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.