Mr E Mehmet v Tanber Solutions Ltd (T/a Tanber Solutions Ltd HL Services): 3200930/2019
Employment Tribunal
Published on 26 February 2020, 12:03
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
working-time-regulations
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2019-07-29
Change History
-
Reconsideration
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No:3200930/2019
4.17 Rule 21 judgment – universal template. September 2017
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr E Mehmet
Respondent: Tanber Solutions Limited
(trading as Tanber Solutions Limited HL Services)
JUDGMENT
Upon the Respondent failing to file an ET3 within the time limit imposed by rule 16 of the Employment Tribunals (Constitution and Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2013
AND Upon considering the evidence provided by the Claimant
1. The Tribunal was satisfied that:
a. between 6 August 2018 and 31 December 2018 the Claimant was prevented from exercising his right to paid annual leave pursuant to the Working Time Regulations 1998 by being told that he had no separate right to be paid for such leave; and
b. Where the Claimant took leave on ordinary working days (in particular on 25 December 2018) he received no separate remuneration; and
c. That the Claimant’s payslips did not disclose any separate sum in respect of holiday pay.
2. Accordingly the Claimant is entitled to be is entitled to paid for the annual leave he took (limited to public and some bank holidays) and the annual leave he was prevented from taking.
3. The Claimant was entitled to take 11.12 days of annual leave for the period 6 August 2018 to 31 December 2018. His hourly rate was £10.20 and he worked for 7 paid hours per day. He is therefore entitled to the sum of £794.20 less any deductions required by law.
Case No:3200930/2019
4.17 Rule 21 judgment – universal template. September 2017
4. The Respondent is ordered to pay the Claimant the sum of £794.20 less any proper deductions.
Employment Judge John Crosfill
29 July 2019
Case Number: 3200930/2019
RM
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr E Mehmet
Respondent: Tanber Solutions Limited
(trading as Tanber Solutions Limited HL Services)
Heard at : East London Hearing Centre
Before: Employment Judge John Crosfill
On: 22 January 2020
Appearances
Claimant: In person
Respondent: No appearance or representation
RECONSIDERATION JUDGMENT
1. The Respondent’s application for a reconsideration of the judgment dated 29 July
2019 is dismissed.
REASONS
1. The matter was listed before me to consider the Respondent’s application for a
reconsideration of my judgment signed on 29 July 2019 and sent to the parties on 22 August
2019.
2. The Claimant presented his ET1 on 8 April 2019 in which he complained that the
Respondent had failed to pay him holiday pay for the period from the commencement of his
employment to 31 December 2018. He said that he had been told that the sum he was paid
included holiday pay but that nothing appeared on his payslip.
Case Number: 3200930/2019
3. He gave an address in Ilford for the Respondent and the ET1 was duly served upon
that address. No ET3 was filed on behalf of the Respondent. Upon consideration of whether
to enter judgment under rule 21 a decision was made to await the final hearing on 29 July
2019.
4. The matter came before me on 29 July 2019. The Claimant attended but the
Respondent did not. I had no reason to believe that the Respondent had not been properly
served. I therefore decided to proceed in the absence of the Respondent. The Claimant was
able to show me one pay slip sent electronically which did not disclose any payment of
holiday pay. I accepted his account that he had been told that he was not entitled to separate
pay for annual leave. He told me that on Christmas day he had not worked and had not been
paid. He told me that he had not taken other leave because he did not know if he would be
paid. I concluded that the Claimant had been prevented from taking leave. I found that
applying the reasoning in King v Sash Windows C-214/16 CJEU I was obliged to interpret
the Working Time Regulations 1999 in accordance with EU law. As such I held that the
Claimant was entitled to pay in respect of the annual leave he took and ought to have been
permitted to take.
5. On 11 October 2019 the Tribunal received an e-mail from Hazel Lee on behalf of the
Respondent. She suggested that as the Claimant had commenced trading on 7 February
2019 it could not be liable for any payment of holiday pay predating that date. I caused a letter
to be written asking whether the Respondent wished to apply for a reconsideration. I pointed
out hat on the brief facts set out in the e-mail it was possible that the Transfer of Undertakings
(Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 (‘TUPE’) might apply and suggested that the
Respondent make its’ position clear. That letter was sent by e-mail and was clearly received
because it was acted upon.
6. On 18 October 2019 Hazel Lee sent a further e-mail saying that she was making a
request for a reconsideration. She suggested that TUPE could not apply because the contract
under which the Respondent supplied services makes no mention of TUPE. Plainly this is
wrong. She further asserted that the proceedings had not been served. She says that the
address given had never been the address of the Respondent. I note that it was not the
Registered Address which is in Market Harborough.
7. I considered that the Respondent’s assertion that it had not been served could only
be resolved at a hearing. In addition, I considered that the issue of whether TUPE applied
was arguable. Finally there were arguable points on time limits and the proper interpretation
of the Working Time Regulations 1999. As such I decided to list the matter for a hearing. It
was listed for today. The notice of hearing was sent to the parties by e-mail to the same
address used by Hazel Lee. I am satisfied that the Respondent knew of the hearing.
8. I had directed that 7 days before the hearing the Respondent file a draft ET3 setting
out its defence to the claim. The Respondent failed to comply with my order.
9. On 22 January 2020 the Claimant attended but the Respondent failed to attend.
When the Tribunal clerk rang the mobile telephone number given by Hazel Lee in her
correspondence it was answered by ‘Michael’. He said Hazel Lee was off sick and he knew
nothing of the proceedings.
Case Number: 3200930/2019
10. The Claimant told me and I accept that the address that the Respondent operated out
of was the one he had given. He had taken the time to send a copy of my Judgment by a
signed for postal service and says that it had been signed for.
11. I am satisfied that the Respondent was aware of the hearing but has chosen not to
attend. I therefore proceeded in the absence of the Respondent.
12. Nothing that the Respondent has written contradicted the Claimant’s case that he was
told that he would receive no separate pay for holiday. The Respondent appears to blame a
predecessor. I note that the Respondent was incorporated throughout the period of the
Claimant’s employment. The Claimant says that he worked for that company continuously.
The documents supplied by the Respondent do not contradict that.
13. The Respondent has not satisfied me that it was not properly served.
14. There may have been an arguable defence to the claim but the failure of the
Respondent to participate at each stage means that no defence has ever been properly
formulated.
15. It would be for the Respondent to establish that it is in the interests of justice to
reconsider my judgment. I find that the Respondent has shown no good reason why I should.
16. In the circumstances I dismiss the Respondent’s application.
Employment Judge John Crosfill
Date: 4 February 2020
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.