Mr G Brown v DEF Software Ltd: 2503465/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 31 May 2019, 15:48
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
unfair-dismissal unlawful-deduction-from-wages working-time-regulations written-statements
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2019-05-07
Official Documents
-
Mr G Brown v DEF Software Ltd: 2503465/2018 - Preliminary
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Numbers: 2503465/2018
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr G Brown
Respondent: DEF Software Limited
PUBLIC PRELIMINARY HEARING
Heard at: North Shields On: 2 May, 2019
Before: Employment Judge Nicol
Representation
Claimant: appeared in person
Respondent: Mr P Morgan, Counsel
JUDGMENT
After hearing the parties, the judgment of the Tribunal is that
1 the correct name of the respondent is DEF Software Limited and
2 the claimant’s complaints should be dismissed in their entirety on the basis that
2.1 the effective date of termination of the claimant’s employment with the
respondent was on or about 29 August, 2018,
2.2 if that is not correct, then the effective date of termination was still less than
three months before ACAS was consulted and these proceedings were
presented
2.3 although the complaint that the claimant was unfairly dismissed was
presented within the prescribed time limit, he is not entitled to pursue that
complaint as he does not have the prescribed length of continuous
employment with the respondent and he has not shown that one of the
exceptions to that requirement applies so that that complaint is dismissed
2.4 although the complaint that the claimant was not dismissed in accordance
Case Numbers: 2503465/2018
2
with the terms of his contract of employment was presented within the
prescribed time limit, the nature and extent of the breach is such that having
regard to the complexity and importance of the issues it is not proportionate
to allow this complaint to proceed and it is dismissed
2.5 although the claimant’s complaint that he did not receive all of the holiday
pay to which he was entitled was submitted within the prescribed time limit,
the claimant has received all of the holiday pay to which he was entitled so
that this complaint is not well founded and is dismissed
REASONS
1 At the end of the hearing, the Tribunal gave its Judgment and Reasons for the
Judgment. The claimant indicated that he would consider appealing against the
Tribunal’s decision. As the claimant is not represented, the Tribunal invited the
claimant to request that the Tribunal should set out its Reasons in writing, which he did
and the Tribunal agreed to provide them. Accordingly, these Reasons set out the
Tribunal’s findings in support of its Judgment. Whilst the wording and order may differ
from the announced version, this is with the benefit of more preparation time and is not
the result of further deliberations by the Tribunal.
2 These are complaints by Gary Brown, the claimant, against DEF Software
Limited, the respondent, named in the application as DEF Software, arising out of his
employment by the respondent as a junior developer. The claimant’s employment with
the respondent commenced on 11 June, 2018, and the effective date of termination is
to be decided by this Tribunal. However, it is agreed that the claimant had been in
continuous employment for less than one complete year.
3 The claimant contends that he was called to a meeting on 21 August, 2018,
when he was told that his employment was being terminated. The respondent
contends that this was a summary dismissal with immediate effect for poor
performance and accepts that it did not comply with the claimant’s contract of
employment. The claimant further contends that he requested representation at the
meeting, which the respondent denies, and that this was the reason or part of the
reason for his dismissal. The respondent contends that it paid the claimant to the end
of the month and paid him the holiday pay to which he was entitled. The claimant
accepts that he was paid but alleges that he was not paid all of the holiday pay to
which he was entitled.
4 By a Notice dated 1 April, 2019, issued on the direction of a different
Employment Judge, the parties were informed that this Tribunal would deal with the
following issues, which are set out briefly,
4.1 To determine the effective date of termination of the claimant’s employment
4.2 To determine whether it was reasonably practicable for the claimant to present
his claim for unfair dismissal before the end of the period of three months
beginning with the effective date of termination of his employment and, if not,
whether the claim had been submitted within such further period as is
reasonable
Case Numbers: 2503465/2018
3
4.3 To determine how the claim for unfair dismissal is advanced and whether or not
the claimant has the right to advance such a claim given that he lacks the
qualifying service
4.4 To determine whether it was reasonably practicable for the claimant to present
his claim for breach of contract (wrongful dismissal) before the end of the period
of three months beginning with the effective date to termination of his
employment and, if not, whether the claim has been presented within such
further period as is reasonable
4.5 To determine how the claim for unpaid holiday pay is advanced and whether or
not it has been filed in time.
5 The respondent conceded that any sum due in respect of holiday pay should
have been paid on 24 August, 2018, which is less than three months before ACAS was
consulted so that that complaint was brought within the prescribed period.
6 It should be noted that the claimant is not alleging that he requested but did not
receive written reasons for his dismissal and he does not make any claim for unpaid
wages or holiday pay, as such, in respect of the period from the end of August, 2018,
until 26 October, 2018, when his contract of employment, if still in existence, was
terminated by a letter dated 24, September, 2018, which will be referred to below.
7 The Tribunal heard evidence from the claimant and from John Rollins, technical
director, and Graeme Cooke, commercial director, on behalf of the respondent. The
Tribunal heard oral submissions by both parties. The Tribunal had before it a bundle of
documents submitted by the respondent, marked exhibit ‘R1’. From the evidence and
arguments that it heard and the documents that it has seen, the Tribunal finds the
following facts.
8 ACAS received early conciliation notice on 23 November, 2018, and these
complaints were presented to the Tribunal on 26 November, 2018. In them, the
claimant claims in respect of unfair dismissal, holiday pay and breach of contract –
failure to send notice of termination.
9 The claimant’s employment with the respondent commenced on 11 June, 2018,
and he was given a written contract setting out the terms and conditions of his
employment. The first three months of employment were to be treated as a
probationary period which could be terminated by the employer ‘on one weeks’ notice
in writing at any time during or at the end of that period without adherence to the
grievance or disciplinary procedures’. The contract also provided that the claimant ‘was
entitled in addition to statutory holidays to take 25 working days as holiday in each
year’.
10 It was in dispute whether the claimant had been made aware during the course
of his employment that his performance was not to the required standard. However, the
Tribunal was satisfied that the respondent, through its directors, including Mr Rollins
and Mr Cooke, decided that the claimant’s employment should be terminated and the
reason given was his level of performance.
Case Numbers: 2503465/2018
4
11 Towards the end of the working day on 21 August, 2018, Mr Rollins asked the
claimant to go with him into a room away from the main work area where they could
talk in private. The claimant was not given any indication of the purpose of the meeting
or offered the opportunity to be accompanied. Mr Rollins opened their discussion by
saying that the respondent was going to let the claimant go, meaning that he was to be
dismissed. The claimant alleges that he then asked to be accompanied but Mr Rollins
denied that this happened. In any event, the discussion continued and no one was
present.
12 In a reply to a request for comments dated 5 March, 2019, the claimant states
‘…I was given no prior warning or notice of the meeting…There was no indication of
what the reason for the conversation was. Because of this exercising the right to be
accompanied…was taken away from me…Once I became aware of what this meeting
was about I stated that I would want to have someone present at the meeting as my
witness…’. Broadly, this accords with the respondent’s version, except for the request
to be accompanied.
13 Mr Rollins informed the claimant that this was his last day at work but that he
would be paid until the end of the month. According to Mr Rollins, the claimant asked if
he was being placed on garden leave and was told that he could call it what he liked.
At the end of the discussion, they returned to the main work area and the claimant
cleared his desk. He said goodbye to Mr Cooke and left the premises.
14 On 28 August, 2018, the claimant received his P45 by email. He replied asking
‘what will be happening about the ecrued (sic) holidays im (sic) entitled to? 25 days/4
(1/4 of the year) minus the 1 day I took off for the dentist. I would also like to know what
my official leave date will be’. The Tribunal construed this as showing that the claimant
was only asking about his contractual leave of 25 days in addition to public holidays.
15 The claimant accepted in evidence that during his employment he had
understood that he was only entitled to bank holidays plus twenty five days and that
this was similar to what he had been entitled to in previous employments. The
respondent stated that its holiday provision was in accordance with the normal industry
practice but was slightly more generous than what it considered to be the industry
average.
16 There is then a string of emails between the two of them, including one in which
the claimant states ‘I can agree on the amount of holidays owed being 5 days’.
17 The string also includes arguments on various points, including the claimant
requesting a week’s written notice. Mr Rollins sought to put forward his view of when
the contract of employment had ended.
18 In a letter dated 19 September, 2018, the claimant sets out various demands
including stating that he was still in employment, that his probation period had ended
and that he was entitled to one month’s written notice. He also advances the argument
that he is entitled to twenty eight days statutory holiday plus twenty five contractual
days. The respondent responded in a letter dated 24 September, 2018, by denying
what the claimant suggested but giving him one month’s written notice as a precaution.
On any assessment, this is the latest possible date on which the claimant was
Case Numbers: 2503465/2018
5
employed but it seems to have been ignored. In a letter dated 29 October, 2018, the
claimant sets out further arguments.
19 The claimant has provided a schedule of loss under various headings. Under
‘illegal deduction of holiday pay’, he claims that he was forced to take a holiday for a
public holiday after 21 August, 2019. However, he has accepted that he was paid to
the end of the month and that he has received all of the holiday pay to which he was
entitled on the respondent’s version of his total entitlement. Under ‘failure to provide a
notice of termination (breach of contract)’, His claim is for a global sum relation to one
year’s remuneration but this is not justified by reference to loss or any damage
suffered. Under a further heading of ‘no disciplinary procedure was followed at all
(breach of contract)’, this follows then earlier heading of ‘failure to provide a notice of
termination (breach of contract)’ and is, in effect duplication. In any event, if it is
accepted that the dismissal was without written notice, that it is dismissal was effective
but without written notice, then the failure to follow a procedure was in accordance with
the contractual provisions in relation to the probationary period. The total amount
claimed is £95725.14.
20 The claimant accepted that during the period following his dismissal, he was
aware that there were time limits within which proceedings had to be commenced but
that he delayed presenting them because he hoped that this could be avoided by a
negotiated settlement. He did not put forward any reason as to why it was not
reasonably practicable to have presented his complaints within the prescribed time
period if it was found that he had not done so.
21 The claimant contends that the respondent unfairly dismissed him because it
failed to allow him to be accompanied at the meeting when he was dismissed, that his
contract of employment was breached in the manner of his dismissal, that he did not
receive the holiday pay to which he was entitled on the termination of his employment
and that all of his complaints were submitted within the prescribed time limits. The
respondent contends that the complaints were all submitted out of time, except in
relation to holiday pay, that the claimant was not unfairly dismissed for the reason
alleged and that he has received all of the holiday pay to which he was entitled.
22 The time limits for presenting complaints to a Tribunal and the extent to which a
Tribunal has discretion to extend them are set out in Sections 111 (unfair dismissal)
and 207B of the Employment Rights Act, 1966, Regulation 7 (breach of contract) of the
Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) Order, 1994, and
Regulation 30 of the Working Time Regulations, 1998. In each case the prescribed
time is three months or such further period as the Tribunal considers reasonable in a
case where it is satisfied that it was not reasonably practicable for the complaint to be
presented before the end of that period of three months. However, in relation to alleged
unfair dismissal, the Tribunal also had regard to Section 108 of the Employment Rights
Act, 1996, and Sections 10 and 12 of the Employment Relations Act, 1999.
23 The Tribunal also had regard to Rules 2 and 37 in Schedule 1 to the
Employment Tribunals (Constitution and Rules of Procedure) Regulations, 2013, which
deal with the overriding objective and striking out proceedings.
24 The Tribunal finds that the respondent’s approach to the meeting on 21 August,
2018, to have been, at best confused, it had failed to have any regard to the procedure
Case Numbers: 2503465/2018
6
that might be required and how the meeting should be handled. Whether by accident or
design the respondent failed to follow any recognised procedure and failed to offer the
claimant the chance to be accompanied or to appeal. The contract of employment does
appear to permit the respondent to dismiss ‘without adherence to the grievance or
disciplinary procedures’ but this should not have been construed as entitling the
respondent to disregard statutory provisions or the ACAS Code of Conduct.
Nevertheless, those were not the issues before this Tribunal.
25 It is clear that 21 August, 2018, was intended by the respondent to be the
claimant’s last day in work for the respondent but that he was to be paid to the end of
the month on the normal payroll run. When the claimant asked about his status
between the meeting and the end of the month, on the respondent’s own evidence, he
was told that he could treat it how he liked. This is not consistent with a complete break
on 21 August, 2018, as the claimant could have simply been told that he was no longer
an employee and was free to do what he liked in terms of employment. Whatever the
intention of Mr Rollins was, the Tribunal finds that his conduct amounted to giving the
claimant notice of the termination of his employment, such notice to expire when he
ceased being paid. For some reason, this was described as being 29 August, 2018,
but, even if that date is wrong, the intended end of payment was within the three month
period before ACAS was consulted and/or these proceedings were commenced.
26 On this basis, the claimant’s complaint that he was unfairly dismissed was
presented within the prescribed time for presenting such claims and can proceed.
27 It is not necessary to consider the issue of reasonable practicability in relation to
the complaint of unfair dismissal. However, if the Tribunal is wrong about the effective
date of termination, it would have found that it was reasonably practicable for the
claimant to have commenced these proceedings within the prescribed period. He did
not put forward any reason why he would have been unable to commence these
proceedings within the prescribed period. He stated that he knew the length of the
prescribed period but delayed commencing proceedings in the hope that agreement
could be reached and the need for proceedings avoided. On that basis, this complaint
would have been dismissed.
28 However, the claimant’s length of service must be considered. He had not been
in continuous employment for the required period of two years. The claimant did not
put forward grounds on which he could rely on Section 108 of the Employment Rights
Act, 1996, but sought to rely on Section 12 of the Employment Relations Act, 1999.
(The Tribunal apologises for the manner in which this was described in the Reasons
when given orally.) The claimant alleges that he was dismissed because he asserted a
statutory right by requesting that someone accompanied him at the meeting and that
this was refused. The Tribunal was satisfied that the respondent wanted the meeting
with the claimant on 21 August, 2018, in order to dismiss the claimant and that this
decision was made before the meeting took place. It was disputed whether claimant
ever asked to be accompanied. Even on his own evidence, he was told at the start of
the meeting that his employment was being terminated before he had a chance to say
anything. Accordingly, the claimant would have been dismissed whether he asserted a
statutory right or not and it cannot be said that his assertion, even if made, had any
effect on the decision to dismiss. It follows that the claimant is not entitled to pursue a
complaint that he was unfairly dismissed and that complaint should be dismissed.
Case Numbers: 2503465/2018
7
29 For the same reasons as set out above in relation to the alleged unfair
dismissal, the complaint that the claimant suffered a breach of contract was presented
within the prescribed time limit. With regard to notice, as set out above, the effect of the
meeting on 21 August, 2018, was to give the claimant notice of, at least, one week. To
that extent, the respondent did comply with its contractual obligation. It did fail to give
written notice. However, the intentions of the respondent were clear and were
understood by the claimant – his employment was being terminated. The claimant
received a P45 so that he could produce it to his next employer and he received the
payments due to him. It is clear from the emails that the claimant knew that his
employment was being terminated, at the latest, by the end of August, 2018. Whilst he
has insisted on being given specific written notice, the Tribunal considers that this is a
comparatively minor matter which did not have any consequences, whether financial or
otherwise so that the claimant did not suffer anything in respect of which he might
receive an award of damages. On that basis, even if he is entitled to anything, he
would only be entitled to the award of the most nominal compensation at a level that
would not justify the time and expense for the parties and the Tribunal required to hear
this complaint. Having regard to this and the overriding principle, it is not appropriate to
allow this complaint to proceed and it is dismissed.
30 Again, if the Tribunal is wrong on this and the effective date of termination is
earlier so that this complaint was presented out of time, it would have been reasonably
practicable for the claimant to have commenced these proceedings within the
prescribed period and this complaint would have been dismissed.
31 In respect of holiday pay, the claimant accepted that during the course of his
employment he had understood that he was entitled to take twenty five days leave plus
eight public holidays. This is confirmed by his agreement to the respondent’s
calculation of his outstanding holiday entitlement in an email. He only raised his current
argument at a much later date and the Tribunal did not accept that this was a
reasonable interpretation of the contractual provisions. The expression ‘statutory
holidays’ is a poor one to use and the respondent accepted this. However, the intention
was clear and complied with the norm within the industry and within the claimant’s own
previous experience. His argument that he was entitled to leave as set out in the
Working Time Regulations, 1998, plus contractual leave of 25 days does not have any
reasonable prospect of success. Further, he received all of the holiday pay to which he
was actually entitled so that this complaint is not well founded and should be
dismissed.
32 Having regard to all of the above, the Tribunal finds that all of the current
proceedings should be dismissed in their entirety.
33 Whilst this Tribunal was not asked to do so, if it had not decided that the
proceedings should be dismissed as above, it would have considered whether, in
whole or in part, they were vexatious or without any reasonable prospect of success. It
has to be accepted that the respondent did not handle the matter well and is open to
criticism for the way in which the claimant was dismissed. However, the claimant’s own
evidence suggested that his complaint of unfair dismissal did not have any reasonable
prospect of success. He knew that he had not asserted a statutory right before he had
knowledge of his dismissal so that he did not have grounds on which to argue that he
was entitled to pursue the complaint notwithstanding his lack of service. In respect of
his claim to holiday pay, he had agreed a figure with the respondent before he raised
Case Numbers: 2503465/2018
8
any argument about how many days leave he was entitled to. He knew what there
common understanding was and so this complaint did not have any reasonable
prospect of success. With regard to his complaint of breach of contract, there is some
merit in the argument that he did not receive written notice in accordance with his
contract of employment. However, even in his schedule of loss, he does not show any
consequences that flow from this and his claim for one year’s remuneration is entirely
without foundation. If he is entitled to any compensation under this heading, which is
doubtful, it would only be of an entirely nominal amount. In total, the schedule of loss
shows a claim for £95725.14, which the claimant knew or ought to have known that he
had no real prospect of achieving. Taking all three complaints together, they appear to
have been commenced with the intention of harassing the respondent and causing it
embarrassment and the expense of defending the proceedings and so were vexatious
and/r without reasonable prospect of success. Accordingly, it is likely that, if this had
been considered, the complaints would have been struck out on these grounds.
_______________________________________
Employment Judge Nicol
Date _7 May, 2019_______________________
Public access to employment tribunal decisions
Judgments and reasons for the judgments are published, in full, online at
www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions shortly after a copy has been sent to the
claimant(s) and respondent(s) in a case.
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.