Mr K McCarthy v AB Agri Ltd : 2500595/2017
Employment Tribunal
Published on 04 December 2017, 16:15
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
unfair-dismissal
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2017-10-20
Official Documents
-
Mr K McCarthy v AB Agri Ltd : 2500595/2017 - Reserved Judgment
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
RESERVED JUDGMENT
The claimant’s complaint of unfair dismissal is not well-founded and is dismissed.
REASONS
1 The claimant in this case was represented by his lay representative Mr J Moores,
who called the claimant to give evidence. The respondent was represented by
its solicitor Miss O’Neill who called to give evidence Mr Rob Casson (Operations
Manager), Mr Nick Vogels (Operations Manager) and Mr Brian Sutlieff
(Operations Manager). There was an agreed bundle of documents marked R1,
comprising an A4 ring binder containing 201 pages of documents. On the
morning of the second day there were added to that bundle further documents
numbered 201-208 inclusive.
2 The claimant and the three witnesses for the respondent had all prepared typed
and signed witness statements. Those statements were taken “as read” by the
Case Number: 2500595/2017
2
Employment Tribunal, subject to questions in cross-examination and questions
from the Tribunal Judge.
3 By claim form presented on 9 June 2017, the claimant brought a complaint of
unfair dismissal. The respondent defended the claim. In essence it arises out of
the claimant’s dismissal on or about 28 April 2017, for reasons which the
respondent says related to his conduct. The respondent alleges in simple terms
that the claimant entered a wrong computer code for a production run of animal
feed and thereafter, having been told that there may have been an error,
released the product to the customer without undertaking further checks and/or
investigations as to the integrity of the product. The issues to be decided by the
Tribunal were identified as:-
3.1 What was the respondent’s reason for dismissing the claimant?
3.2 If misconduct:-
(a) did the respondent genuinely believe that the claimant had
committed an act or acts of misconduct?
(b) were there reasonable grounds for that belief?
(c) had the respondent carried out an investigation which was
reasonable in the circumstances?
3.3 Did the respondent follow a fair procedure before deciding to dismiss the
claimant?
3.4 Was the decision to dismiss the claimant one which fell within the range of
reasonable responses, open to a reasonable employer in all the
circumstances?
3.5 If the dismissal was unfair because of a procedural defect, would the
claimant have been dismissed in any event had a fair procedure been
followed?
3.6 If the dismissal was unfair, to what extent if any did the claimant contribute
towards his dismissal by his own conduct?
4 Before any evidence was given, the Tribunal explored with Mr Moores on behalf
of the claimant as to whether there was any particular challenge (and if so what)
to any of the issues at 3.2(a)-(c) inclusive above. Mr Moores conceded that the
claimant had admitted entering the wrong code for the production of the animal
feed and had thereafter authorised the release of that feed, having been notified
of the possibility of an error. Mr Moores accepted that the respondent’s
witnesses did genuinely believe that the claimant had done so. Mr Moores
conceded that there were reasonable grounds for that belief, particularly because
the claimant had readily admitted the error in entering the wrong computer code
and again readily admitted releasing the product thereafter. In terms of the
subsequent investigation, Mr Moores was asked to identify anything which the
Case Number: 2500595/2017
3
respondent had done, which it should not have done, or anything which it had not
done, but should have done. Again Mr Moores accepted that the investigation
carried out by the respondent was reasonable in all the circumstances. Mr
Moores’ challenge to the process which led to the claimant being dismissed was
agreed to be based upon whether that decision to dismiss was one which fell
within the range of reasonable responses. Mr Moores indicated that there was
an element of inconsistency of treatment between the claimant and at least one
other employee who had been treated differently in similar circumstances and
also that the respondent’s offer of a final written warning and demotion as an
alternative to dismissal, had been withdrawn before the claimant had been given
a reasonable opportunity to consider it.
5 Having heard the evidence of the claimant and the three witnesses for the
respondent, having examined the documents to which it was referred and having
carefully considered the closing submissions of Miss O’Neill and Mr Moores, the
Tribunal made the following findings of fact on a balance of probabilities:-
5.1 The respondent company is engaged in the production of feed for
agriculture, particularly for poultry and livestock. It has a number of
manufacturing plants in the country, including one at Northallerton in North
Yorkshire. That plant primarily manufactures bulk feed for pigs and
poultry. It manufactures approximately 3,500 tonnes of feed each week in
3 tonne batches. The plant runs 24 hours a day, six days a week. The
plant is heavily automated, with the weighing and the mixing and addition
of ingredients controlled by a software programme called “Datastor”. That
is controlled and monitored by Process Control Operators in a control
room.
5.2 The claimant was employed as a Production Manager at the Northallerton
plant, reporting directly to the Site Operations Manager Mr Rob Casson.
The claimant’s role involved responsibility for eleven Process Operators
and three Engineers, working on two shifts, six days a week. The
claimant’s duties included preparing production schedules based upon
customer orders which were then passed on to the Control Room
Operators who would programme Datastore to produce the required
products batch by batch for the customer orders based upon the
claimant’s production schedules.
5.3 The claimant’s employment with the respondent commenced on 18
August 2008. He was generally regarded as a loyal and competent
employee, although he had something of a reputation as being somewhat
“difficult” from time to time in terms of his attitude towards other
employees. He had a clean disciplinary record.
5.4 One of the nutritional additives used in the production of pig feed is known
as “Quantum Blue”. The manner in which Quantum Blue is added to the
production process, depends upon whether the end product is to be in
meal form, or pellet form. When making pellets, the Quantum Blue is
added at the fats coating stage, whereas if making meal there is no such
stage and the Quantum Blue is added at the mixing stage. Because
Case Number: 2500595/2017
4
Quantum Blue is an enzyme additive which helps release nutrients in the
feed, the implications of it not being properly included in the mix are that
the animal is unable to fully release the nutrients in the feed, which may
result in malnourished animals.
5.5 In 2015, an error had been made in the production process which led to a
failure to Quantum Blue being added to the production process. The feed
was then despatched to the customer (Westgarth Brothers) and then fed
to the customer’s livestock. As a result, a large volume of livestock had to
be slaughtered and a “multi million pound” claim was brought against the
respondent. The employee within the respondent’s organisation who was
found to have been responsible for the original error was Mr Andrew
Saddler. He was dismissed from his managerial post, but on appeal
reinstated to a role which did not carry any supervisory or managerial
responsibility.
5.6 Following on from that “Saddler” incident, the respondent embarked upon
a retraining exercise for its production and managerial staff. Talks were
given by nutritional experts with regard to the importance of ensuring that
the correct additives were included and by manufacturing experts as to the
stage at which they should be included. Whilst the precise details of the
Saddler incident were only known to members of the management team,
the Tribunal found that all of the production staff at Northallerton were
likely to have been aware of the incident, its impact and the consequences
for the staff at the Northallerton plant.
5.7 The claimant was somewhat disparaging of this retraining exercise,
regarding the same as no more than “talks”, which to him had little value.
5.8 On Monday, 12 December 2016 the claimant was at work in his capacity
as Production Manager. One of the orders for which he was responsible
was for pig feed for the Westgarth Brothers. The order was for 24 tonnes
of pig feed in the formula DM65M + HL8. By genuine mistake, the
claimant inserted into Datastor the code DM65P + HL8. The “M” code
was for meal, whereas the “P” code was for pellet. The order was for
meal, whereas the production code would produce pellet. The effect of
this error was that Quantum Blue required in the product would not be
added, as the Datastor system would not call for Quantum Blue until the
fats coating stage of production. Because meal production does not go
through that stage, then the Quantum Blue would not be added at all.
5.9 The meal was produced and at the end of the process loaded into a
finished product bin designated as pellet product. In other words, there
was meal in a pellet bin. The operative responsible for outloading,
informed the claimant that there was meal in the pellet bin. Because
Westgarth Brothers ordered both meal and pellet from time to time, the
claimant authorised the release of the product as meal and it was
despatched to the customer.
Case Number: 2500595/2017
5
5.10 The claimant’s case was that the Control Room Production Operator
spotted his mistake and having confirmed with the Outloading Operators
that the order was for meal rather than pellet, they switched the production
mid-run, thereby by-passing the pellet compression process, so that the
order remained as meal. They did not tell the claimant about the nature of
the change they had carried out. However, the claimant accepted that he
had been told about the original error and of the fact that meal had ended
up in the pellet bin. The claimant accepted that he had not carried out any
further investigation as to what had happened or how it may have
impacted upon the finished product. He did not raise the matter with his
Line Manager or anyone else in a position of authority before authorising
release of the product. The claimant insisted that the Datastor process
control batch records confirmed that the batches had been manufactured
within specification and with all ingredients added within tolerance.
5.11 At the end of December the monthly stock-take disclosed that switching
production mid-run meant that the Quantum Blue enzyme had been
omitted from the formula, as it could only have been added after the
pelletisation process, which does not take place in the production of meal.
5.12 The respondent decided to carry out a formal investigation into what had
happened. Statements were obtained from two Control Room Operatives
and from the Outloader Operative. Their statements were consistent as to
what had happened. The error in the code had been recognised and
those in the control room adjusted the process “to make it as meal to save
on time and cover the mistake in production planning.” It was said that the
claimant had shown the Production Operatives how that could be done on
an earlier occasion. It was acknowledged that Quantum Blue had not
been added to the process and the Outloader stated that he informed the
claimant that the product had been marked as pellet but should be meal
and he then asked the claimant whether it should be loaded as meal and
despatched. The claimant had told him that he should “go ahead and load
it and despatch it”.
5.13 By letter dated 26 January 2017 the claimant was suspended pending an
investigation into the incident. He was invited to intend an investigation
meeting on Monday, 30 January. The allegations were that he had put the
company’s reputation at risk by planning a product incorrectly, leaving the
customer to receive something which had not been ordered. He had done
so without checking and investigating, having known that the product may
have been manufactured incorrectly.
5.14 The claimant prepared a formal statement for that investigation, a copy of
which appears at page 97 in the bundle. The relevant extracts are as
follows:-
“1 It is clear I confused the codes and I accept responsibility for
this.
Case Number: 2500595/2017
6
2 I did not release the product to the customer. Despatch did
not notice the mistake either and allowed the product to be
delivered.
3 At worst I produced product that was not required at that
point in time for customer order.
4 The product codes are very similar and easy to confuse.”
The claimant goes on to acknowledge his confusion of the product codes
but maintained that the formula was identical apart from the process to
compress the meal into pellets. He accepted that the Quantum Blue had
not been added, even though the batch card indicated that it had been
added. The claimant maintained that he had never received detailed
training about this and was not aware of the subtle difference in the
production process. He insisted that it was incorrect to suggest that he
had sanctioned the despatch of the product without checking and
investigating with the full knowledge that the product had been
manufactured incorrectly.
5.15 The investigation was carried out by the claimant’s Line Manager, Mr Rob
Casson. He arranged a further investigation meeting with the claimant at
his home on 7 February. The purpose of that meeting was to further
address something which had been said by the claimant at the first
meeting, namely that he may suffer from dyslexia. Mr Casson then
arranged for the claimant to see a specialist so that a report could be
prepared into whether or not the claimant did indeed suffer from dyslexia
and if so whether that may have impacted upon the incident. The dyslexia
assessment was produced on 20 February and concluded that, whilst the
claimant did show some signs of dyslexia, it was not severe and would not
appear to have had any influence on the incident which happened.
5.16 Mr Casson concluded that there was a case to answer and decided that
the matter should be referred for a disciplinary hearing. By letter dated 21
February Mr Casson invited the claimant to attend a disciplinary hearing
on 27 February to answer allegations which Mr Casson advised may be
regarded as “potential gross misconduct”.
5.17 Mr Casson did not prepare a formal investigation report. He simply sent to
Mr Vogels (the disciplinary officer) all of the statements and documents
which he had examined himself and which he had gone through with the
claimant. In cross-examination by Mr Moores, Mr Casson confirmed that
he did not consider the claimant’s behaviour to be a capability issue, but a
“bad decision”, which should properly be categorised as misconduct. Mr
Casson accepted that all people make mistakes from time to time, but he
regarded this as being a very serious matter, particularly because of the
earlier Andrew Saddler incident in 2015. Mr Casson accepted that there
was a difference between the original error in putting the wrong code into
the Datastor and the subsequent conscious decision by the claimant to
release the product, once the possibility of an error had been identified.
Case Number: 2500595/2017
7
5.18 The disciplinary hearing was conducted before Mr Vogels, Operations
Manager. He received the pack of information from Mr Casson and read
that before the hearing itself. The claimant had again prepared a
statement for the disciplinary hearing, a copy of which is at page 125-128
in the bundle. The contents were much the same as the one prepared for
the investigation, but this time the claimant set out specific points in
mitigation. Those include:-
“1 I do not believe I have committed any acts that could be
constituted as either gross misconduct or misconduct.
2 I do not believe I have been negligent.
3 I have never done anything intentionally to risk the
company’s reputation.
4 I have made mistakes in confusing product codes which
does concern me. I have thought long and hard about why
this could have happened. Possible contributory factors
are:-
(a) I have been working under a lot of pressure and
stress;
(b) they are to some extent typing errors which we all
make from time to time;
(c) the codes are very similar and I am aware that others
have confused them.”
The claimant goes on to refer to his eight years’ previous good service
and that he has always until then acted with the best interests of the
company at heart and acted with honesty and integrity at all times.
5.19 Mr Vogels examined all of the evidence submitted by Mr Casson and also
considered everything that was said to him by the claimant. There was no
challenge by Mr Moores to the fairness of the procedure adopted by Mr
Vogels. The claimant had originally asked for Mr Moores to attend the
hearing with him, but that had been refused because Mr Moores was
neither a work colleague nor a trade union representative. The claimant
was accompanied by Mr Ian Watson, a work colleague. It is clear from the
extensive notes of the meeting that the claimant was given a fair hearing.
He was given the opportunity to challenge all of the evidence submitted by
Mr Casson, to explain what had happened and to put forward his
mitigation. The meeting lasted from 3:41pm until 5:55pm. Mr Vogels
postponed the meeting so as to enable him to consider the evidence and
decide upon the outcome. Having done so, he wrote to the claimant by
letter dated 21 March (page 146-148). Mr Vogels concluded that the first
allegation relating to the mistaken entry of the wrong code did not amount
Case Number: 2500595/2017
8
to an act of gross misconduct, but rather an incident of poor planning.
However, he considered the second allegation, relating to the release of
the material, to be an act of gross negligence which amounted to gross
misconduct. Mr Vogels then had to decide upon the sanction to be
imposed upon the claimant. He was satisfied that the claimant’s conduct
would justify dismissal, but as an alternative he proposed that the claimant
be given a final written warning together with a demotion which “would
allow Kevin time to meet the standards required by the company.”
5.20 The claimant was advised of his right to appeal and did so by letter dated
29 March 2017 (page 154-155). By then the claimant had not received
details of any alternative role which was to be offered to him by way of
demotion. A further meeting took place on 27 March 2017, at which the
claimant was offered a role as a “Hygiene Operative”. The claimant
regarded that position as being one of a “Cleaner”. In his appeal letter the
claimant deals with “the job offer” as follows:-
“At the meeting on Monday 27 March 2017 Rob Casson and Karen
Ellin offered and proposed I accept a demotion to a job as a
cleaner.
1 I am shocked that they consider this to be a suitable job for
me. It is inappropriate and inconsistent with sanctions given
to other people for similar but significantly more serious
problems. I believe it to be grossly unfair.
2 I have not yet received a letter detailing the proposed job
and its terms and conditions which I did not fully understand
at the meeting.
3 I have worked for the company for over 8 years now and
have an exemplary record. I genuinely want to continue
working for the company. I went to the meeting believing
that I would be offered an alternative management position
that I was prepared to give serious consideration to.”
In his summary the claimant again refers to the job offer as “completely
inappropriate”.
5.21 By letter dated 30 March, Mr Casson set out proposals with regard to the
alternative role. Mr Casson’s letter includes the following:-
“In the meeting, I reiterated to you that Nick has found that your
actions were serious enough to constitute gross misconduct and/or
gross negligence and that there was a significant failure on your
part in taking management responsibility. You are fully aware of
the importance of formulations in animal feed and the massive risk
to the Northallerton mill and the business as a whole for failure to
operate a diligent production operation. The sanctions available to
you were summary dismissal, dismissal with notice or demotion
Case Number: 2500595/2017
9
with a final written warning. As you are aware for the reasons set
out in his letter, he wanted to offer you a chance of remaining in
employment notwithstanding the seriousness of your actions. His
view however was that the role of Production Manager is too
business critical to risk such a significant lapse of judgment and
chain of events occurring again in the future and that for the
reasons he set out, you cannot currently be trusted to remain in a
management role. I have therefore been identifying alternative
roles which we may be able to offer you within the constraints set
out above. As you are aware, the mill is operated with a lean
staffing structure and the only vacancy I currently have available to
offer you is that of a Hygiene Operator.”
Mr Casson’s letter concludes on page 159 with the following:-
“I explained that should you refuse to accept this role, then the
alternative sanction of dismissal will be substituted. Please let me
know by Friday, 31 March 2017 of your decision.”
Friday, 31 March was of course only one day after this letter was sent to
the claimant by e-mail on 30 March.
5.22 The claimant’s appeal was listed to be heard before Mr Sutlieff on 10 April.
The claimant again submitted a detailed written statement, a copy of
which appears at page 167-172 in the bundle. In his “summary”, the
claimant states:-
“1 I strongly believe that the gross misconduct/gross
negligence is a very unfair conclusion to draw given the facts
and the evidence presented.
2 The alternative job offer is completely inappropriate and no
attempt seems to have been made to find a suitable
alternative job elsewhere in the company or to make any
reasonable adjustments to take into account my dyslexia.
3 The sanctions proposed against me are totally inconsistent
compared with other similar but serious cases.
4 The whole disciplinary process has been flawed and in clear
breach of the company’s disciplinary procedure. It has been
extremely protracted unnecessarily.
5 I have a good record working for the company and yet this
has not been taken into account at all.”
5.23 The appeal meeting took place on 13 April. Minutes appear at page 173-
183 in the bundle. Again, it is clear from those minutes that Mr Sutlieff
conducted a thorough re-examination of all of the evidence presented by
both Mr Casson and the claimant. Again, Mr Moores did not challenge the
Case Number: 2500595/2017
10
fairness of the hearing before Mr Sutlieff. The Tribunal found that the
claimant was again given every opportunity to challenge the evidence
against him, to present his own evidence and to put forward his mitigation.
Mr Sutlieff accepted that he conducted the appeal by way of a complete
rehearing of the disciplinary hearing itself, rather than reconsidering the
claimant’s grounds of appeal. Having done so, Mr Sutlieff was satisfied
that the claimant had not produced any new facts or information which
were any different to those presented by him at the original disciplinary
hearing. Mr Sutlieff too was concerned about the severity of the allegation
but particularly with regard to the potential for further reputational damage
to the respondent’s business following on from the Andy Saddler incident
in 2015. Mr Sutlieff’s concern was again not so much directed towards the
original error of inputting the wrong code, but the subsequent conscious
decision by the claimant to release the product, knowing that there may
have been an error in the production process.
5.24 Mr Sutlieff also considered the claimant’s response to the offer of the
alternative role. Mr Sutlieff accepted in cross-examination that nowhere in
the minutes of the appeal hearing does the claimant actually say that he
was not prepared to accept the alternative role. Similarly, nowhere does it
say that the claimant was prepared to accept the role. Mr Sutlieff’s
evidence was that the claimant knew that he had until 31 March in which
to either accept or reject the offer. The claimant knew that by rejecting the
offer, he would be dismissed. Mr Sutlieff drew the Tribunal’s attention to
the claimant’s consistent reference to the job offer as being “wholly
inappropriate”.
5.25 Mr Sutlieff dismissed the claimant’s appeal and informed him of that by
letter dated 25 April. Mr Sutlieff sets out in his letter the grounds of appeal
and his reasons for dismissing the appeal. The Tribunal found that Mr
Sutlieff had conducted a fair, reasonable and thorough appeal hearing at
which he had addressed his mind fairly to all of the points raised by the
claimant. Mr Sutlieff’s conclusion at page 189 is as follows:-
“For all of these reasons I consider that your actions did constitute
gross misconduct/gross negligence, that there is insufficient
mitigation to warrant a sanction less than dismissal and I therefore,
having regard to your decision not to accept the alternative that was
put to you – uphold the decision to terminate your employment.”
5.26 The claimant presented his complaint to the Employment Tribunal on 9
June 2017.
The law
6 The statutory provisions engaged by the claimant’s claim of unfair dismissal are
set out in sections 94 and 98 of the Employment Rights Act 1996:-
S.94 The right
Case Number: 2500595/2017
11
(1) An employee has the right not to be unfairly dismissed by his employer.
(2) Subsection (1) has effect subject to the following provisions of this Part (in
particular sections 108 to 110) and to the provisions of the Trade Union and Labour
Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 (in particular sections 237 to 239).
S.98 General
(1) In determining for the purposes of this Part whether the dismissal of an employee
is fair or unfair, it is for the employer to show--
(a) the reason (or, if more than one, the principal reason) for the
dismissal, and
(b) that it is either a reason falling within subsection (2) or some other
substantial reason of a kind such as to justify the dismissal of an employee
holding the position which the employee held.
(2) A reason falls within this subsection if it--
(a) relates to the capability or qualifications of the employee for performing
work of the kind which he was employed by the employer to do,
(b) relates to the conduct of the employee,
(c) is that the employee was redundant, or
(d) is that the employee could not continue to work in the position which
he held without contravention (either on his part or on that of his employer)
of a duty or restriction imposed by or under an enactment.
(3) In subsection (2)(a)--
(a) "capability", in relation to an employee, means his capability assessed
by reference to skill, aptitude, health or any other physical or mental quality,
and
(b) "qualifications", in relation to an employee, means any degree,
diploma or other academic, technical or professional qualification relevant to
the position which he held.
(4) Where the employer has fulfilled the requirements of subsection (1), the
determination of the question whether the dismissal is fair or unfair (having regard to the
reason shown by the employer)--
(a) depends on whether in the circumstances (including the size and
administrative resources of the employer's undertaking) the employer acted
reasonably or unreasonably in treating it as a sufficient reason for dismissing
the employee, and
(b) shall be determined in accordance with equity and the substantial
merits of the case.”
Case Number: 2500595/2017
12
7 The case law on the interpretation and application of section 98 was summarised
by Lord Justice Aikens in Orr v Milton Keynes Council [2011] EWCA-Civ-62
where he said:-
“(1) The reason for the dismissal of an employee is a set of facts known
to an employer, or it may be a set of beliefs held by him, which
causes him to dismiss the employee.
(2) An employer cannot rely on facts of which he did not know at the
time of the dismissal of an employee to establish that the real
reason for dismissing the employee was one of those set out in the
statute, or was of a kind that justified the dismissal of the employee
holding the position he did.
(3) Once the employer has established before the employment tribunal
that the real reason for dismissing the employee was one within
section 98(1)(d) ie that it was a valid reason, the tribunal has to go
on to decide whether the dismissal was fair or unfair. That requires
first and foremost the application of the statutory test set out in
section 98(4)(a).
(4) In applying that subsection, the employment tribunal must decide
on the reasonableness of an employer’s decision to dismiss for the
real reason. That involves a consideration, at least in misconduct
cases, of three aspects of the employer’s conduct. First, did the
employer carry out an investigation into the matter that was
reasonable in the circumstances of the case; secondly, did the
employer believe that the employee was guilty of the misconduct
complained of and thirdly, did the employer have reasonable
grounds for that belief. If the answer to each of those questions is
“Yes”, then the employment tribunal must decide on the
reasonableness of the response of the employer.
(5) In doing the exercise set out at (4) above, the employment tribunal
must consider, by the objective standards of the hypothetical
reasonable employer, rather than by reference to its own subjective
views, whether the employer has acted within a “band or range of
reasonable responses” to the particular misconduct found of the
particular employee. If it has, then the employer’s decision to
dismiss would be reasonable. But that is not the same thing as
saying that a decision of an employer to dismiss will only be
regarded as unreasonable if it can be shown to be perverse.
(6) The employment tribunal must not simply consider whether they
think that the dismissal was fair and thereby substitute their
decision as to what was the right course to adopt, for that of the
employer. The employment tribunal must determine whether the
decision of the employer to dismiss the employee fell within the
band of reasonable responses which “a reasonable employer might
have adopted.”
Case Number: 2500595/2017
13
8 It was established in Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Limited v Hitt [2002] EWCACiv-
1588 that what is now known as the “range of reasonable responses” test,
applies as much to the investigation into alleged misconduct as it does to the
decision to dismiss the employee. In A v B [2003] IRLR 405 the Employment
Appeal Tribunal held that it is particularly important that employers take seriously
their responsibilities to conduct a fair investigation where the employee’s
reputation or ability to work in his or her chosen field of employment is potentially
at risk. Whilst it is unrealistic and quite inappropriate to require the safeguard of
a criminal trial, it is necessary to have a careful and conscientious investigation of
the facts and the investigator charged with carrying out the enquiry should focus
no less on any potential evidence that may exculpate or at least point towards
the innocence of the employee, as he should on the evidence directed towards
proving the charges against the employee.
10 It was suggested in the claimant’s case that there was an element of overlap
between an incident of poor performance or incapability and an act of
misconduct. The possibility of such an overlap was recognised by the
Employment Appeal Tribunal in Sutton & Gates (Luton) Limited v Boxall
[1979] ICR 67, when it was said that “capability” should be treated as applying to
those cases in which the incapability was due to inherent incapacity, but, “Where
someone fails to come up to standard through his or her own carelessness,
negligence or idleness, this is not incapability but misconduct.”
11 The possibility of this overlap was put to the respondent’s witnesses by the
Tribunal Judge. Their response was that they accepted that the claimant had
made a mistake when he put the wrong computer code into the Datastor system.
They all agreed that this was not a matter which would have led to the claimant
being dismissed. Their concern was that the claimant subsequently authorised
the release of the product, in the knowledge that there had been some kind of
error which may have impacted upon the production process. It was the
claimant’s failure to investigate or at least refer to a more senior manager, which
they regarded as an act of gross negligence which they described as a
“dereliction of duty and managerial responsibility”. It was for that that the
claimant was dismissed. The Tribunal found that it was reasonable for the
respondent to have treated the claimant’s acts or omissions as those of gross
negligence amounting to gross misconduct. Categorisation by the respondent
must be seen in the context of all the circumstances of the case. Those include
the seniority of the claimant’s position and in particular the impact of the Andrew
Saddler incident in 2015, of which the claimant was fully aware. The Tribunal
found that some reasonable employers may have decided that this was one of
those cases in which the inadequacy of the performance was so extreme that
there was n irredeemable incapability. In those circumstances, a warning and
opportunity for improvement would be of no benefit to the employee and may
constitute an unfair burden on the business. (James v Waltham Holy Cross
UDC [1973] ICR 398). The gravity with which the respondent viewed the
claimant’s conduct was reasonable in all the circumstances.
12 The Tribunal then had to consider the respondent’s response to that conduct.
The claimant had eight years continuous service and had a clean disciplinary
Case Number: 2500595/2017
14
record. The Tribunal found that Mr Vogels and Mr Sutlieff had both addressed
their minds to that mitigating factor and that both addressed their minds to the
alternatives to dismissal. Mr Vogels in particular concluded that, whilst the
incident justified summary dismissal, he would be willing to offer the claimant an
alternative role in the respondent’s undertaking. The role offered to the claimant
was that of a “Hygiene Operator” and was one which the claimant maintained
throughout as being “wholly inappropriate”. It was argued by Mr Moores and
indeed by the claimant himself, that he never actually rejected that offer, although
both also conceded that the claimant never actually accepted the offer. The
claimant’s evidence to the Tribunal was that, once his appeal had been
dismissed and he realised that he was not going to be reinstated to his role as
Production Manager, then he would have accepted the alternative role. The
claimant accepted that he had never made this clear to the respondent. Even
after he received the outcome of his appeal, he did not respond by telling Mr
Sutlieff or anybody else that he was then prepared to accept the alternative role.
The claimant accepted that he had been informed that he had until 31 March in
which to make up his mind, although he maintained his argument that one day to
do so was insufficient in all the circumstances.
13 The question for the Tribunal is whether it was reasonable for the respondent in
all the circumstances of this case, to conclude that by the time of the appeal
being dismissed, the claimant had not accepted the alternative role and could
thereby be deemed to have rejected it. The point was further explored in the
additional documents introduced by the claimant on the morning of the second
hearing and which now appear at page 202-208 in the bundle. Those are a letter
from Mr Sutlieff to the claimant dated 5 May, and the minutes of the meeting
where the outcome of the appeal was delivered, on 28 May. It is clear from the
minutes of that meeting at page 205, that Mr Sutlieff informed the claimant that
Mr Vogel had decided that he “was going to summarily dismiss you – the
alternative role was offered as a substitute to this however, but you did not take
this.” The claimant replied “OK”. At page 207 Mr Sutlieff refers to the claimant’s
comment that the “alternative role is inappropriate”. Mr Sutlieff is recorded as
having said, “I also respect and accept your decision to not take up the offer of
this alternative employment.” That again was not challenged by Mr McCarthy.
The respondent in fact continued to pay the claimant until his appeal was
dismissed on 28 April.
14 The Tribunal concluded that some reasonable employers in all the circumstances
of this case would have concluded that the claimant’s failure to accept the
alternative role could properly and fairly be regarded as his rejection of that role.
15 For those reasons the claimant’s complaint of unfair dismissal is not well-founded
and is dismissed.
___________________________________
EMPLOYMENT JUDGE JOHNSON
JUDGMENT SIGNED BY EMPLOYMENT
JUDGE ON
20 October 2017
Case Number: 2500595/2017
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
24 October 2017
AND ENTERED IN THE REGISTER
G Palmer
FOR THE TRIBUNAL
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.