Mr M Carr v Engineered Fabrication Solutions Ltd: 1405708/2023
Employment Tribunal
Published on 25 April 2024, 09:12
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract unlawful-deduction-from-wages
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2024-03-28
Official Documents
-
Mr M Carr v Engineered Fabrication Solutions Ltd: 1405708/2023 - Judgment with Reasons
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No: 1405708/2023
---1---
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
BETWEEN
Claimant Respondent
MR M CARR
AND ENGINEERED FABRICATION
SOLUTIONS LTD
JUDGMENT OF THE EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNAL
HELD AT: BRISTOL ON: 22ND MARCH 2024
EMPLOYMENT JUDGE MR P CADNEY
(SITTING ALONE)
MEMBERS:
APPEARANCES:-
FOR THE CLAIMANT:- IN PERSON
FOR THE RESPONDENT:- MS P HALL (SOLICITOR)
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the tribunal is that:-
i) The claimant’s claim for damages for breach of contract is dismissed on the grounds that
all sums previously owing have been paid.
ii) The respondent’s application for costs is dismissed.
Reasons
1. By a claim form submitted on 31st October 2023 the claimant brought a claim for
unlawful deduction from wages and/or breach of contract.
2. The claimant was employed by the respondent from 30th May 2023 until 6th
September 2023, having resigned 31st August 2023. The claim related to three day’s
pay he claimed he was still owed for 30th and 31st May 2023 and 1st September 2023.
Case No: 1405708/2023
---2---
He set out in both in his ET1/claim form and Schedule of Loss a claim for a total of
£251.97 in unpaid wages.
3. That claim was initially defended and liability denied, but by 3rd January 2024 the
respondent accepted that sum was owed, and paid it to the claimant. In addition on
17th January 2024 it paid interest on the unpaid amounts.
Remaining Claims
4. As a consequence the respondent invited the claimant to withdraw his claim on the
basis that any sums owed had been paid in full. The claimant declined to do so
saying that he was still pursuing claims for “breach of contract” and “compensation”.
5. At the beginning of the hearing I clarified with the claimant what claims, if any, were
still outstanding given that sums claimed in the claim form and Schedule of Loss had
been paid. The claimant asserted that he was still bringing claims for breach of
contract, and compensation for the behaviour of the respondent. He contended that
before bringing his claim he had set out precisely what was owed and how it was
calculated. The respondent rejected this and refused to pay him, putting them in
breach of contract. They refused to settle through ACAS and originally defended the
claim before finally admitting it in January 2024. Even when they did so they did not
formally admit the claim, or even apologise to him, but simply paid the money into his
bank account without even any notification to him that were going to do so, or had
done so. As a result he contends that the respondent was in breach of contract at
least until 3rd January 2024, during which time they in fact had no defence to the
claim or any basis for refusing to pay the wages owed. He contends that he is the
wronged party and has been treated appallingly by the respondent, and invites the
tribunal to award any compensation it believes appropriate for the ongoing breach of
contract and the respondent’s behaviour.
6. The respondent submits that the tribunal has no jurisdiction to award any further
compensation. The measure of damages for a claim for breach of contract in the
failure to pay sums owed is the payment of those sums. Even viewed as a claim for
unlawful deduction from wages, there is no allegation of any consequential loss
which the tribunal would have jurisdiction to award. The claimant is effectively inviting
the tribunal either to make an award for some form of injury to feelings, or an award
to punish the respondent for failing to admit the claim sooner, neither of which are
within its jurisdiction. However it is viewed, the tribunal has no jurisdiction to make
any further award to the claimant arising out of his claim for unpaid wages.
7. In my judgement the respondent’s submissions are correct and I have no jurisdiction
to make any further award to the claimant. It follows that the claimant’s claim must be
dismissed as, as at the date of the hearing, there is no sum outstanding which the
tribunal could award him.
Case No: 1405708/2023
---3---
Respondent’s Costs Application
8. The respondent has made a costs application on the basis that by 3rd January 2024 it
had paid the claim in full, and on paying interest on the sums owed the claimant had
in fact received more from the respondent than he could have been awarded by the
tribunal. In those circumstances it was unreasonable conduct of the proceedings
within the meaning of rule 76(1)(a) to continue with the claim and put the respondent
to the expense of attending a hearing when it had already paid the claim in full.
Alternatively from the point at which the claim was paid in full there was no remaining
claim with any reasonable prospect of success (r76(1)(b). On either basis it is entitled
to its costs from 3rd January 2024. The amount claimed is ten hours work, including
the final hearing, being £1020.00 plus VAT. In my judgement if in principle I decide to
make a costs order, and subject to taking into consideration the claimant’s means in
deciding the amount, that the amount claimed is in and of itself reasonable.
9. By an email of 9th January 2024 the respondent asserted that the payment was in full
and final settlement of the claim, and put the claimant on notice of its costs
application. In his reply the claimant disputed the fact that any payment was in full
and final settlement of the claim as he had never agreed, or been asked to agree,
this. He interpreted the payment as an admission of liability, “guilt” as he put it, and
stated “ I will not be withdrawing my claim unless an agreed amount of compensation
is offered.”, and “..the payment was…over four months late not to mention the time
effort and emotional stress caused in pursuing what I work so hard for in the first
place..”.
10. The claimant is, to put it mildly, outraged that there should be any question of him
paying the respondents costs. For the reasons set out above he contends that he has
behaved entirely reasonably, and that even if he is wrong to assert that he is entitled
to any further compensation arising out of the delay in payment or the respondent’s
behaviour that he brought and pursued the claim in good faith at all times. As a
litigant in person, and not a lawyer, he fully accepts that he will be bound by any
decision of the tribunal as to whether it can or will order any further compensation.
However, he does not accept that he should be ordered to pay the respondent’s
costs, or even that here should be any consideration of the respondent’s costs
application. I explained that as the application had been made I was bound to
consider it, and ask him questions as to his means, but this did not mean that I had
decided in principle that I intended to make a costs order.
11. The issues I have to decide are:
i) Whether the threshold for making an order for costs has been crossed;
ii) If so whether I would in principle make an order for costs (the discretion still exists
even if the threshold has been crossed);
iii) If so the amount of any award taking into account the claimant’s means.
Case No: 1405708/2023
---4---
12. The fact that the claimant is a litigant in person is a factor I am entitled to take into
account (See AQ Ltd v Holden 2012 IRLR 648, EAT:
i) The threshold tests governing the award of costs or a preparation time order in rule
76(1) of the Tribunal Rules 2013 are the same whether the claimant is or is not
professionally represented, but that the application of those tests should take this
factor into account;.
ii) “An employment tribunal cannot and should not judge a litigant in person by the
standards of a professional representative. Lay people are entitled to represent
themselves in tribunals and, since legal aid is not available and they will not
usually recover costs if they are successful, it is inevitable that many lay people
will represent themselves. Justice requires that tribunals do not apply professional
standards to lay people, who may be involved in legal proceedings for the only
time in their life. Lay people are likely to lack the objectivity and knowledge of law
and practice brought by a professional legal adviser. Furthermore, the EAT
observed, even if the threshold tests for an order for costs are met, the tribunal
has discretion whether to make an order, which will be exercised having regard to
all the circumstances. In its view, ‘it is not irrelevant that a lay person may have
brought proceedings with little or no access to specialist help and advice’.
(Summary quoted taken IDS Handbook Volume 9 para 18.130).
13. It is clearly correct that a professional representative would be expected to recognise
that the respondent’s assertion that as it had paid the claim in full the litigation was,
or should have been, at an end was correct. However it is not at all clear to me that a
litigant in person should necessarily have appreciated that, or to understand that he
was not entitled to compensation for the delay in payment, or the fact of the
respondent at least initially defending a meritorious claim.
14. In those circumstances I am not satisfied that it was unreasonable to proceed or that
he should necessarily have appreciated that he no longer had any claim with any
reasonable prospect of success. Even had I concluded that one or both of the
threshold tests had been crossed for the same reason I would not have exercised my
discretion to make an award of costs in this case in any event.
15. It follows that the respondent’s application is dismissed.
Case No: 1405708/2023
---5---
_______________________
Employment Judge Cadney
Dated: 28th March 2024
Judgment sent to the parties on 17 April 2024
For the Tribunal Office
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.