Mr M Dickson v RATP Dev: 2200022/2021
Employment Tribunal
Published on 09 September 2022, 08:59
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
unlawful-deduction-from-wages
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2022-05-10
Change History
-
Reconsideration added
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No: 2200022/2021
6.2 Strike out Judgment – claim - rule 37
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr M Dickson
Respondent: RATP DEV
JUDGMENT
The claim is struck out.
REASONS
1. The claimant failed to attend the hearing that was due to take place in this
case on 20 April 2022.
2. By a letter dated 20 April 2022 the Tribunal gave the claimant an
opportunity to make representations or to request a hearing, as to why the
claim should not be struck out because it has not been actively pursued.
3. The claimant has failed to respond to the letter. The claim is therefore struck
out.
_____________________________
Employment Judge E Burns
10 May 2022
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
10/05/2022.
FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Case No: 2200022/2021
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr Dickinson
Respondent: RAPT DEV London Limited
Heard at: London Central by video (CVP)
On: 9 August 2022
Before: Employment Judge E Burns (sitting alone)
Appearances:
For the Claimant: in person
For the Respondent: Sophie Smith, Solicitor
RECONSIDERATION JUDGMENT
1. The judgment dated 10 March 2022 striking out the claimant’s claim is
revoked.
2. The claim will not proceed in the employment tribunal, however, because
the claimant wishes to pursue the same claim in the county court.
REASONS
3. The claimant works as a bus driver for London United Busways Limited. In
order to do his job he needs a licence to drive a Passenger Carrying Vehicle,
commonly referred to as a PCV licence.
4. In 2020, he took a holiday abroad and got stuck there due to the pandemic.
While he was away, his PCV licence expired. This meant that when he was
able to return to the UK, he was not able to drive buses until it was renewed.
5. London United Busways Limited was supportive of his position and he was
placed on furlough to enable him to apply to the DVLA to rectify the problem.
He had been unable to do this while he was away.
Case No: 2200022/2021
6. The claimant’s license was returned to him by the DVLA on 3 July 2020.
The DVLA made a mistake, however, and failed to endorse it correctly. This
led to London United Busways refusing to allow him to work between 7 July
and 28 August 2020.
7. The claimant is paid weekly in arrears. His last wages form which
deductions were taken were due to be paid to him on 4 September 2020.
8. The claimant presented a claim to the employment tribunal on 5 January
2021 for the unpaid wages. In Box 2.2 he named Victor Sabberton as the
respondent and cited the ACAS certificate number R232075/20/23.
9. In fact, the ACAS certificate bearing this number was issued in the name of
RAPT DEV London. RAPT Dev Transit London Limited is the parent
company of London United Busways Limited. RAPT DEV London is a
trading name it uses. The certificate gave the dates of conciliation as having
started on 21 December 2020 and ended on 31 December 2022.
10. It appears that the tribunal rejected the claim because the name of the
respondent on the EC certificate did not match the name of the respondent
in the claim form. It wrote to the claimant to tell him this on 15 March 2021.
11. He replied on 25 March and 30 March to ask how he could remedy the
defect. The tribunal did not respond until 23 July 201. He was asked if he
would like to substitute RATP DEV London as the respondent to the claim.
12. It appears the claimant replied on 6 August 2021 confirming that he did want
to do this as the tribunal updated its records and recorded the respondent
as having the name RAPT DEV London. There is no record of the claim
having been served on RAPT DEV London at this time, however. Thew
respondent did not present a Response.
13. The case was listed for a hearing on 20 April 2022. The tribunal wrote to the
claimant on 14 April 2022 to ask him if he wanted to continue with the claim
because the tribunal had heard nothing further from him since 6 August
2021. The letter was sent by email. The claimant did not reply.
14. The hearing took place on 20 April 2022, but was not attended by either the
claimant or the respondent. Employment Judge Sullivan wrote to both
parties proposing to strike the claim out as it was not being actively pursued.
He gave the claimant until 29 April 2022 to respond and in the meantime,
listed a further hearing on 13 May 2022. The letter was against sent by
email.
15. As the claimant had not responded by 29 April 2022, I struck his claim out
in a judgment dated 10 May 2022.
16. Unbeknownst to me the respondent had on 6 May 2022 contacted the
tribunal to ask for a copy of the claim to be sent to it. Rather than simply
send it by email, the tribunal served the claim at this time. This was done on
21 July 2022, even though the claim had been struck out by this date.
Case No: 2200022/2021
17. On 20 May 2022, the claimant applied for a reconsideration of the decision
to strike his claim out. In his application he explained that he had not
received a notice of hearing for 20 April 2022 hearing. He had received the
notice of hearing for the 13 May 2022 hearing, but not the other
correspondence. He discovered the letters of 14 April and 29 April 2022 in
his email junk box when searching for video joining instructions for the
hearing of 13 May. He had rung the tribunal only to be told the hearing had
been cancelled and the claim struck out. The tribunal has a record of this
telephone conversation.
18. At today’s reconsideration hearing, the claimant had prepared a detailed
witness statement explaining the position. With the agreement of the
parties, I did not hear that evidence.
19. Instead, I explained to the parties that it seemed to me that the claim had
been presented out of time. This was on the basis that normal time limit for
a claim of unauthorised deductions of wages is found in section 23(2) of the
Employment Rights Act 1996. That section provides that a claim must be
brought before the end of the period of three months. Section 23(3) goes on
to say that the three months runs from the date the last payment was meant
to be made. In this case that date was 4 September 2020.
20. The normal time limit is extended by section 270B of the Employment Rights
Act 1996 to take account of the obligation to enter into early conciliation
facilitated by ACAS.
21. Based on the date of 4 September 2020, the claimant would have had to
commence ACAS early conciliation by 3 December 2022, but according to
the ACAS certificate he referred to his claim form did not commence early
conciliation until 21 December 2021. The result was that his claim was out
of time, even disregarding the fact that the claim had been rejected for a
defect that had not been remedied until 16 August 2022.
22. I also explained tribunal may still consider a claim presented outside the
normal time limit if it is satisfied that:
• it was not reasonably practicable for the claim to be presented within
the normal time limited; and
• the claimant has presented it within such further period as the tribunal
considers reasonable.
I explained this was a very strict test.
23. The claimant then said he had begun the Acas conciliation process on 2
December 2020. He provided email evidence that he had contacted Acas
on 2 December 2022 using the respondent’s correct name of London
United. He did not appear to have been issued a certificate however and I
note that the reference number on the email is R225896/20. This is a
different number to the one in the claim form.
Case No: 2200022/2021
24. I explained to the parties that I was not deciding the time point, as I had not
heard any witness evidence on it. However, it appeared to me, based on
seeing the documents, unlikely that the claimant would be able to rely on
this earlier contact with Acas. This was because if he had been issued with
an Acas certificate it would have had a different number. He would need to
overcome the hurdle of having not presented a claim form using the correct
Acas reference number and having not tried to remedy this defect by
amending his claim form to change the Acas number until over 18 months
later.
25. Having heard this explanation, and having taken time to discuss the position
with the person assisting him, the claimant indicated that he would like to
withdraw his claim in order to pursue it in a county court where there is a
much longer time-limit of 6 years for bringing claims for unpaid wages.
26. In order to enable him to do that I suggested I revoke the strike out judgment
I had made and not issue a judgment dismissing the claim on withdrawal
under Rule 52 of the Tribunal rules. The parties were in agreement with this
suggestion, which is why I have proceeded as I have.
27. I note that the claimant has subsequently requested written reasons for why
the claim was held to be out of time. As noted in this judgment, I did not
actually decide that his claim was out of time. I gave him a clear indication
that I thought it would be held to be out of time however for the reasons set
out above.
__________________________________
Employment Judge E Burns
25 August 2022
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
.25/08/2022
FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.