Mr M Langley v FDM Group Ltd: 2302392/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 02 December 2019, 11:51
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
sex-discrimination
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2019-09-29
Change History
-
Reconsideration added
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number: 2302392/2018
1
THE EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNAL
SITTING AT: LONDON SOUTH
BEFORE: EMPLOYMENT JUDGE MORTON
Ms J Forecast
Ms C Edwards
BETWEEN:
Mr M Langley Claimant
AND
FDM Group Limited Respondent
ON: 25 June 2019
Appearances:
For the Claimant: In person
For the Respondent: Mr J Bellm (Solicitor)
JUDGMENT ON LIABILITY
1. The Respondent did not discriminate against the Claimant because of his sex.
2. The Claimant’s claim under s13 and 39 Equality Act 2010 is therefore
dismissed.
Employment Judge Morton
Date: 25 June 2019
Note
Reasons for the judgment having been given orally at the hearing, written reasons will not be
provided unless a request was made by either party at the hearing or a written request is
presented by either party within 14 days of the sending of this written record of the decision.
Case Number: 2302392/2018
1
THE EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNAL
SITTING AT: LONDON SOUTH
BEFORE: EMPLOYMENT JUDGE MORTON
Ms J Forecast
Ms C Edwards
BETWEEN:
Mr M Langley Claimant
AND
FDM Group Limited Respondent
ON: 25 June 2019
Appearances:
For the Claimant: In person
For the Respondent: Mr J Bellm (Solicitor)
Written Reasons Produced Pursuant to a Request by the
Claimant
1. By a claim form presented on 25 June 2018 the Claimant brought a claim of
sex discrimination which the Respondent resisted. At a case management
preliminary hearing on 14 September 2018 it was determined that there was a
single issue for the full hearing, namely whether the Respondent had
subjected the Claimant to the treatment of adopting a prejudicial approach
and applying a negative assessment of the Claimant’s input and conduct on
the day of an assessment for its Getting Back to Business Programme. The
Claimant confirmed to this tribunal that he relied on a hypothetical
comparator.
Case Number: 2302392/2018
2
The relevant law
2. The relevant law is set out in sections 13 and 39 Equality Act 2010 which
provide as follows:
13 Direct discrimination
(1) A person (A) discriminates against another (B) if, because of a protected
characteristic, A treats B less favourably than A treats or would treat others.
39 Employees and applicants
(1) An employer (A) must not discriminate against a person (B)-
(a) in the arrangements A makes for deciding to whom to offer employment;
(b) as to the terms on which A offers B employment;
(c) by not offering B employment.
3. It is also relevant to consider the law on the burden of proof which is set out in
section 136 of the Equality Act. In summary, if there are facts from which the
tribunal could decide in the absence of any other explanation that the
Claimant has been discriminated against, then the tribunal must find that
discrimination has occurred unless the Respondent shows the contrary. It is
generally recognised that it is unusual for there to be clear evidence of
discrimination and that the tribunal should expect to consider matters in
accordance with the relevant provisions in respect of the burden of proof and
the guidance in respect thereof set out in Igen v Wong and others [2005] IRLR
258 confirmed by the Court of Appeal in Madarassy v Nomura International
plc [2007] IRLR 246. In the latter case it was also confirmed, albeit applying
the pre-Equality Act wording, that a simple difference in status (related to a
protected characteristic) and a difference in treatment is not enough in itself to
shift the burden of proof to the Respondent; something more is needed.
4. We heard evidence from the Claimant and from the Respondent’s witnesses
Jennifer Holme, Head of the Getting Back to Business Programme and Sarah
Parkinson, the Recruitment Manager. There was a bundle of documents
comprising 266 pages in addition to the pleadings.
Findings of fact
5. The Respondent is a global professional services provider with an emphasis
on IT and business consultancy. The factual background to the Programme is
set out in paragraphs two to eight of Ms Holmes’s witness statement which
were not challenged by the Claimant. Ms Holmes provided the Tribunal with
additional factual information about the size and composition of its workforce,
also unchallenged.
6. The Claimant applied to the Programme in April 2018 (pages 1-3). His
application was initially rejected because he did not appear to meet the
Case Number: 2302392/2018
3
criterion of having been out of work for at least a year. His CV suggested that
he was currently engaged on an ongoing project. The Claimant had seen the
advertisement on Mumsnet and he complained about his rejection on 1 May
2018 suggesting that he might have been discriminated against (page 16) on
the basis that he had seen the advertisement on Mumsnet and returnees after
absence are often women. The Respondent’s Senior Legal Counsel Victoria
Penfold replied on 14 May resisting the suggestion that there had been any
unlawful discrimination in the way that the Programme had been advertised or
selections made. She invited the Claimant to tell the Respondent if it had
misunderstood his circumstances in any way. The Claimant replied explaining
that contrary to appearances he had in fact been unemployed and seeking
work since 2008. The Programme team then reassessed his application and
he was interviewed by telephone at the end of May. Following that call he was
invited to an assessment centre at which a number of candidates would be
selected for participation in the Programme.
7. There were nine participants in the assessment centre of which five were
women and four were men. Participants were invited by a letter (page 25)
which stipulated that they should dress in smart business attire and bring a
passport and proof of address not more than three months old. It also set out
the criteria that would be used to select individuals for inclusion in the
Programme. There were three elements to the assessment – two 15 minute
interviews on sales and culture, a 45 minute written test and a group exercise.
There was also a lunch at which participants were encouraged to network with
each other. The letter explained in some detail the criteria that would be
applied in assessing performance in the tests. Ms Holmes’ evidence was that
the Respondent was testing a candidate’s previous experience and aptitude,
career aspirations, transferable skills, motivations for returning to work, their
ability to work in a team and their ability to lead and support others. Even
allowing for the fact that the Claimant was not professionally represented we
accepted Ms Holmes evidence about the purposes of the assessment.
8. The Claimant took part in the assessment day on 18 June 2018. He was
unsuccessful. Out of the nine participants two women and two men were
chosen. We accepted Ms Holmes’ evidence that there was no restriction on
the number of candidates who could be selected but to be selected
candidates needed to meet the published criteria.
9. The assessments were recorded on printed forms. The interview forms
included standard questions that were intended to be put to all candidates and
set out the competency expected in relation to each question. The Claimant’s
interview forms were at pages 28 to 30 (sales) and 31 to 33 (culture). A
different person conducted each interview. The Tribunal noted that the form
relating to the Claimant’s sales interview was not properly completed and the
Respondent acknowledged that this had led to the interviewer concerned
being given additional training. The form merely recorded that the Claimant
had struggled to answer questions and that each one was answered with a
‘story’.
10. The Claimant’s written assessment was at page 34 – 36 and notes from the
Case Number: 2302392/2018
4
Claimant’s group task at pages 151-153. The bundle contained redacted
copies of the paperwork relating to the other eight candidates. A summary of
the Claimant’s overall performance prepared after the ‘wash-up’ session was
at page 27. The outcome, which was communicated to the Claimant on 20
June 2018 was at page 159.
11. The Respondent’s reasons for rejecting the Claimant as set out at page 27
were as follows:
a. Poor attitude evidenced by a negative question - Ms Holmes said that
his question was about how to leave the programme;
b. Not mingling with the other participants over lunch but sitting apart from
them;
c. Not listening to the questions put to him;
d. Coming across as negative and flippant;
e. Giving technical answers that were poor on methodologies, risks and
systems;
f. Not being able to articulate his strong technical experience;
g. Not giving specific examples;
h. Being negative, confrontational and lacking in collaborative skills in
group work;
i. Sitting away from the stage during the presentation at the end of the
group work;
j. Being unsuitably dressed in a leather jacket;
k. Presenting unprofessionally with a joke about ‘Cillit Bang’ and
demanding that the audience ‘pay attention to me’;
l. Giving a weak answer to an audience question; and
m. Not completing the written assessment and using unprofessional
language without insights or recommendations.
12. These points were summarised in the outcome letter. The Claimant’s
response, which he admitted in evidence was sarcastic and insulting, was at
page 161.
Conclusions
13. This case is about the Claimant’s perception of the manner in which he was
evaluated by the Respondent during its assessment day. The issue we need
Case Number: 2302392/2018
5
to decide is whether the Respondent had discriminated against him under
sections 13 and 39 Equality Act by adopting a prejudicial approach and
applying a negative assessment of the Claimant’s input and conduct on the
day. If the Claimant was advancing a claim of direct discrimination based only
on the outcome of the day it would have been bound to fail because two men
were put forward at the end of the day as well as two women. The decision
not to choose the Claimant cannot therefore have been merely because he
was a man – other men were chosen for the programme. As we understand
the Claimant’s case he is alleging instead that the negative assessment of his
performance was stereotypical and involved discriminatory assumptions
related to his sex.
14. We do not find that to have been the case. We asked ourselves whether the
assessment of the Claimant involved any conscious or unconscious bias and
whether there was any evidence that the Claimant was unfairly marked and if
so whether that arose because of any discrimination in the thought process of
the decision makers. Notwithstanding that there were gaps in the
documentation relating to the Claimant’s performance and allowing for the fact
that processes of this nature are bound to involve a degree of subjectivity,
were satisfied that the process overall as described to us was sufficiently
objective and robust and contained sufficient safeguards to prevent decision
being tainted by discrimination in the way suggested by the Claimant. There
was a moderation process at the end of the day which was an important
safeguard. There were clear and objective criteria. Although all of the
assessors were female, two of those who assessed the Claimant also
assessed another male candidate who was chosen for the Programme.
15. We accepted Ms Parkinson’s evidence that the confrontational stance taken
by the Claimant during the group exercise was very unusual. A hypothetical
female candidate who had conducted herself in a similar way would in our
judgment have received a similarly poor assessment. We do not accept the
Claimant’s assertion that there was a prejudicial misinterpretation of his
conduct. If it is the Claimant’s case that he was deliberately marked down in
other areas of the assessment because of his sex that case is undermined by
the fact that two male candidates were chosen. If it is his case that
discriminatory assumptions were at work in the way that his performance was
evaluated that is also undermined by the fact that two men were chosen. It
must therefore have been the nature of the Claimant’s conduct and
performance during the day itself rather than the fact that it was assumed to
be stereotypically male, that led to the decision not to offer him a place on the
programme.
16. At its highest the Claimant’s case was that the criteria used were not objective
at all but tainted by discriminatory assumptions about male behaviour. Again
the truth of that assertion is belied by the fact that the successful candidates
included both men and women. That shows that the Respondent was not
making any assumptions about whether men or women would be better able
to demonstrate the kinds of behaviour or aptitudes that it sought in candidates
for its programme. On the contrary it designed a selection process that
allowed all candidates to demonstrate their potential.
Case Number: 2302392/2018
6
17. For all these reasons the Claimant’s claim of sex discrimination fails and is
dismissed.
__________________________
Employment Judge Morton
Date: 12 July 2019
Case No: 2302392/2018
11.6C Judgment – Reconsideration refused – claimant - rule 72
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr M Langley
Respondent: FDM Group Limited
JUDGMENT
The claimant’s application dated 29 July 2019 for reconsideration of the judgment
sent to the parties on 20 July 2019 is refused.
REASONS
There is no reasonable prospect of the original decision being varied or revoked. The
Claimant does not agree with the Tribunal’s judgment. The Tribunal’s judgment was that
the decision not to accept the Claimant onto the Respondent’s programme was not taken
because of his sex but because he did not meet the Respondent’s criteria. The Tribunal
also decided that the criteria adopted were not inherently discriminatory against men
because some men were successful in being selected.
The fact that the Claimant does not agree with the Tribunal’s conclusion does not mean
that it would be in the interests of justice to revoke or vary the decision. No new evidence
has come to light and the Claimant does not put forward any other ground for his
application.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Morton
Date 29 September 2019
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.