Mr M Lidbetter v Automobile Association Developments Ltd: 1404988/2019
Employment Tribunal
Published on 25 August 2021, 08:52
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
age-discrimination disability-discrimination public-interest-disclosure unfair-dismissal
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2021-08-09
Change History
-
Judgment added
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr M Lidbetter
Respondent: Automobile Association Developments Ltd
Heard at: by CVP On: 16 March 2021
Before: Employment Judge Craft
Member:
Representation
Claimant: Mr J Bradbury, TU Representative
Respondent: Mr C Ludlow, Counsel
RESERVED JUDGMENT
FOLLOWING A PRELIMINARY HEARING
1. The Claimant was not disabled within the terms of s.6 Equality Act 2010 at
the material time.
2. The Claimant's claims of disability discrimination are dismissed.
3. The remaining claims in these proceedings will now proceed to the full
hearing before a Judge and Members that has already been fixed and
notified to the parties who have confirmed to the Tribunal that no further
Directions / Orders for preparation for that hearing are required.
REASONS
Introduction
1. The Claimant commenced employment with the Respondent as a Recovery
Patrol Officer on 18 November 2018. He was dismissed by the Respondent
by reason of capability on 5 August 2019. At the Preliminary Hearing held on
8 April 2020 it was confirmed that the Claimant was pursuing claims of
detriment and automatically unfair dismissal for making a protected
disclosures; direct disability and age discrimination; discrimination arising
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
from a disability; failure to make reasonable adjustments; and harassment
related to disability and age
2. The Claimant suffers from diabetes and is disable within the terms of the
Equality Act 2010 ("EqA") by reason of that illness. However, he does not
rely on diabetes in pursuing his disability claims in these proceedings. He
relies on a physical ailment which can be broadly described as a
musculoskeletal condition affecting his back. The Respondent submits that
the Claimant was not disabled within the terms of the EqA at the material
time and that his claims for disability discrimination should be dismissed for
that reason. The parties have agreed that the material time is the period from
11 April to 5 August 2019. Therefore, the preliminary issue before this
Tribunal is to determine whether the Claimant was a disabled person within
the meaning of s.6 EqA at the material time.
The Law
3. The EqA defines a "disabled person" as a person who has a "disability" (S.6)
(2)). A person has a disability if she or she has "a physical or mental
impairment" which has a "substantial and long-term adverse effect on his or
her ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities" (S.6) (1)]. The burden of
proof is on a Claimant to show that he or she satisfies this definition. This
definition is the starting point for establishing the meaning of "disability".
However it is not the only source that must be considered. The
supplementary provisions for determining whether a person has a disability
are found in Part 1 of Schedule 1 to the EqA. In addition, the Government
has issued Guidance on Matters to be taken into account in determining
questions relating to the definition of disability (2010)" ("The Guidance")
under s.6(5) EqA. The Guidance does not impose any legal obligations in
itself but courts and tribunals must take account of it where relevant. Finally,
the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has published a Code
of Practice on Employment ("the EHRC Employment Code") that has some
bearing on the meaning of disability under the EqA. Like The Guidance, the
Code does not impose legal obligations but tribunals and courts must take
into account any part of the Code that appears to them relevant to any
questions arising in proceedings.
4. The time at which to assess the disability (ie whether there is an impairment
which has a substantial adverse effect on normal day-to-day activities) is the
date of the alleged discriminatory act. This is also the material time when
determining whether the impairment has a long term effect.
5. There is no statutory definition of either a "physical impairment" or a "mental
impairment" and nor is there any definition in The Guidance or the EHRC
Employment Code. The Court of Appeal has held that impairment should
bear its ordinary and natural meaning. It has also stated: "It is left to the good
sense of the tribunal to make a decision in each case and whether the
evidence available establishes that the applicant has a physical or mental
impairment with the stated effects." It is generally accepted the term is meant
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
to have a broad application and Part A3 of The Guidance tends to support
this view. It states that in many cases there will be no dispute as to whether a
person has an impairment, adding that any disagreement is more likely to be
about whether the effects of the impairment are sufficient to fall within the
definition. It is the degree to which a person is affected by a particular
impairment that in most cases will determine whether that person is afforded
the protection of the EqA.
6. The impairment must have a "substantial adverse effect" on the person's
ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities. Substantial is defined in
S.212(1) EqA as meaning "more than minor or trivial". Appendix 1 to the
EHRC Employment Code provides guidance on the meaning of "substantial".
It states:
"The requirement that an effect must be substantial reflects the general
understanding of a disability's limitation going beyond the normal differences
in ability which might exist among people. Account should also be taken of
where a person avoids doing things which, for example, causes pain, fatigue
or substantial social embarrassment; or because of a loss of energy and
motivation."
7. In Goodwin v Patent Office 1999 ICR 302 EAT, the EAT said that, of the
four component parts to the definition of a disability in what was then the
Disability Discrimination Act 1998, judging whether the effects of a condition
are substantial is the most difficult. In its explanation of the requirement the
EAT stated, inter alia, as follows:
"What the Act is concerned with is an impairment on the person's ability to
carry out activities. The fact that a person can carry out such activities does
not mean that his ability to carry them out has not been impaired. Thus, for
example, a person may be able to cook, but only with the greatest difficulty.
In order to constitute an adverse effect, it is not the doing of the act which is
the focus of attention but rather the ability to do (or not to do) the acts.
Experience shows that disabled persons often adjust their lives and
circumstances to enable them to cope for themselves."
8. When determining whether a person meets the definition of disability under
the EqA, the Guidance emphasises that it is important to focus on what an
individual cannot do or can only do with difficulty rather than on the things
that he or she can do. As the EAT also pointed out in the Goodwin case,
even though a Claimant may be able to perform a lot of activities, the
impairment may still have a substantial adverse effect on other activities, with
the result that a Claimant is quite probably to be regarded as meeting the
statutory definition of disability. Equally, where a person can carry out an act,
but only with great difficulty, that person's ability has been impaired.
9. The Goodwin case also gave tribunals guidance on the proper approach to
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
adopt when applying the provisions of the previous Act. This guidance
remains equally relevant today in interpreting the meaning of S.6 EqA. The
EAT said that the words used to define disability require a tribunal to look at
the evidence by reference to four different questions as follows:
(a) Did the Claimant have a mental and / or physical impairment?
(b) Did the impairment affect the Claimant's ability to carry out normal dayto-
day activities?
(c) Was the adverse condition substantial?
(d) Was the adverse condition long term?
These four questions should be posed sequentially.
10. This means that for current impairments that have not lasted 12 months the
Tribunal will have to decide if the substantial adverse effects on the condition
are likely to last for at least 12 months. The Guidance stipulates that an event
is likely to happen if it "could well happen". This definition of the word likely
reflects the House of Lords' decision in SCA Packaging Ltd. That case
according to Baroness Hale, the word "likely" in each of the relevant
provisions of the Disability Discrimination Act (now Equality Act) simply
meant something that is a real possibility, in the sense that it "could well
happen" rather than something that is probable or "more likely than not", it is
important to note that the issue how long an impairment is likely to last
should be determined at the date of the discriminatory act and not the date of
the Tribunal Hearing. The Guidance stresses that anything that occurs after
the date of the discriminatory act will not be relevant.
The Evidence
11. There was an agreed Bundle of Documents consisting of 192 pages (Exhibit
R1). The Employment Tribunal received oral evidence from the Claimant who
had prepared a Disability Impact Statement (Exhibit C1). The Employment
Tribunal reserved its decision on the Preliminary Issue having received oral
submissions from Mr Ludlow and Mr Bradbury, which in Mr Bradbury's case
was supported by written submissions (Exhibit C2).
12. The Respondent was required to set out its position in respect of the
Claimant's alleged disability following receipt of the medical evidence he
relied upon and his Impact Statement. This explanation was set out in a letter
from its solicitors dated 17 August 2020. The relevant part of this letter states
as follows:
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
"The Respondent's position is that the date upon which the Claimant
was/became disabled for these purposes was 7 August 2019, the date of his
MRI results which confirmed a degenerative disc disease. This date was
when it became likely that his condition would last more than 12 months as
before this date, there was no indication of this with all the medical evidence
suggesting that the Claimant was expected to make a full recovery and the
OH reports confirming that they did not consider the Claimant's condition to
constitute a disability."
13. Mr Bradbury and Mr Ludlow each referred to the Guidance on the Definition
of Disability (2011). They also referred the Employment Tribunal to a number
of cases. Mr Bradbury referred to: Donelin v Liberata UK Ltd
[2018]IRLR535; Gallop v Newport City Council [2014]IRLR211; SCA
Packaging Ltd [2009]UKHL(NI)37; and Nissa v Waverley Education
Foundation Ltd EAT/0135/118/DA. Mr Ludlow referred to: Bourne v ECT
Bus EAT 2009 0288/08; Stafford v Focus Hotels Management Ltd ET
1200256/10 and O'Donnell v Ministry of Defence ET 3103421/97.
14. The Employment Tribunal has made the following findings of fact after
considering all the oral and documentary evidence referred to it and the
closing submissions it received.
The Facts
15. The Claimant was based at the Respondent's Ealing Depot where he worked
on late shifts driving Canter vans. On 11 April 2019 the van he was driving
drove over a pothole which caused his seat to break. The Respondent
completed a comprehensive Incident Report in respect of this accident. The
Claimant suffered pain to his left hip and lower back. He was able to return to
Ealing Depot and then drive home. He was able to report for work on the
following day when he informed his manager that he had not attended on his
GP. He confirmed that he had taken painkillers to address the discomfort he
felt in his left hip and lower back following the accident.
16. The Claimant had undergone a surgical procedure in February related to a
problem with his bowel. Shortly after the accident he obtained a Fit Note from
his GP for "pain post surgery" for the period from 18 to 25 April. This Fit Note
was unconnected to the injury and pain he had suffered on 11 April.
17. However, towards the end of April, the Claimant took two days' sick leave
because of lower back pain which he attributed to the accident on 11 April.
The Respondent arranged for an Occupational Health Assessment by
telephone. This took place on 30 April. By then the Claimant had suffered a
further incident when his van jumped out of gear when he was reversing
which has caused further pain in his back. The Claimant informed
Occupational Health that the pain in his neck and back was improving.
However he did not consider that he was fit to return to work on that evening.
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
He told Occupational Health that he did intend to return to work on 3 May. He
duly did so.
18. The Occupational Health Report which was prepared after the telephone
assessment states, inter alia, as follows:
"Mr Lidbetter has no known prior musculoskeletal issues or underlying back
conditions, therefore it is expected that he will make a full recovery as he is
not reporting any red flag symptoms; however I have advised him that if his
pain is not improving or getting worse he should see his GP initially and also
ask to be referred back to Occupational Health for Physiotherapy referral."
19. The Report made a number of recommendations. These were the provision
of adequate and secure seating in his van; flexible mobility; regular micro
breaks (couple of minutes each hour); regular meetings with his manager;
and that the Claimant should undertake manual handling refresher training.
20. Three weeks later on 23 May the Claimant's GP issued a Fit Note for lower
back pain. This indicated that the Claimant might be fit for work and made
recommendations for him to work reduced hours on his late shift and micro
breaks during shifts. His GP issued further Fit Notes with the same
recommendations for the periods from 1 to 15 June, 13 to 27 June (recording
ongoing lower back pain running down his left leg, but no pins and needles);
27 June to 4 July; 8 to 23 July (after the Claimant had been hit on his hip by a
car when directing traffic); and on 25 July for a further six weeks. On 8 July
his GP made arrangements for the Claimant to undertake an MRI lumbar
scan because of his continuing lower back pain.
21. After a meeting with held with the Claimant on 31 May the Respondent
referred him to an in person Occupational Health consultation. This took
place on 10 July following which a report was issued by Occupational Health
on 19 July 2019. This explains that the Claimant is currently at work, has
been restricted to an eight hour shift and continues to struggle with aspects
of his job because of his ongoing symptoms. The report also records that the
physical examination revealed evidence of lower back muscle spasm which
was more prominent on his right side; muscle spasms were also noted
between his left shoulder and his neck; and the Claimant found it more
uncomfortable to turn his neck to the right.
22. The Report states, inter alia, as follows:
"I reviewed Mr Lidbetter's duties with him. He is currently struggling with
lifting and handling of the ramps on trucks. I would therefore recommend the
management to provide him with a truck that has a remote control for the
ramp, as well as air suspension, which would hopefully assist his comfort
levels and allow him to remain at work while his symptoms are prominent.
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
The MRI scan results will clearly need to be awaited and following this
physiotherapy can be arranged if appropriate. In the meantime, I recommend
for his working hours to be maintained to no more than eight per day, at least
until he is reviewed again through a further Occupational Health assessment
in a month's time . . .
With regards to the diagnosis, as noted above, he is noted to be suffering
with significant muscle spasm in his upper and lower back. However, the MRI
scan will identify whether any spinal issues are also involved.
In the meantime, therefore, Mr Lidbetter is fit for work subject to the
adjustments made above. The outlook is likely to be favourable at this point.
However the MRI scan will determine the nature and scope of any further
treatment which may be required. Mr Lidbetter's response to this treatment
will determine the outlook over the coming weeks and months, including his
ability to render regular and efficient service in the future.
In my opinion the Equality Act 2010 is currently likely to apply with regards
Mr Lidbetter's background diabetes. However it is unlikely to apply at this
point to his musculoskeletal problems as they have been present for less
than 12 months."
23. The Claimant wanted to keep working and to keep moving as much as
possible. The Respondent made adjustments to working hours as
recommended by his GP and the Claimant told the Tribunal the Respondent
had also provided him with support from other employees when this was
needed to assist him in moving and collecting vehicles.
24. The Claimant gave no evidence to the Tribunal about the meetings he
attended with the Respondent in this period. However, the Agreed Bundle
contains the Respondent's minutes of the meetings which its managers held
with him following his accident on 11 April. The Tribunal briefly summarises
below the Respondent's records of what was discussed at those meetings
and the outcome of them.
25. At a Step 1 Absence meeting held with the Claimant and his Trade Union
representative on 31 May it was agreed that the Respondent should
investigate the potential benefits of transferring the Claimant to a vacancy on
a late shift at its Heathrow site where it was anticipated that he would be able
to drive a Prestige, rather than Canter, van / truck. Unfortunately, the
Respondent's enquiries confirmed that the vacancy had already been filled
and that, in any event, the job would have involved the Claimant in driving
Canter trucks from time to time, which he wanted to avoid. After this meeting
the Respondent made arrangements for the Claimant to attend an
Occupational Health meeting in person on 10 July for further assessment of
his injury the report from which has been referred to above.
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
26. A further meeting was held with the Claimant and his Trade Union
representative on 24 July after receipt of this report. At this meeting the
Claimant advised the Respondent that he did not consider he was fit to drive
a Canter vehicle. Mr Hale, who chaired this meeting then tabled four options
for the Claimant one of which was for the Claimant to transfer to the
Respondent's Wimbledon site where he would be able to work in a different
vehicle. The Claimant indicated that he was not prepared to transfer to
Wimbledon for two reasons: firstly the length of the journey from his home to
that site; and, secondly, because he did not get on with the Performance
Leader who would be managing him there. Mr Hale agreed to give the
Claimant 48 hours to consider his position in respect of the options presented
to him. Subsequently, the Claimant submitted a grievance making allegations
of bullying.
27. A third meeting was held with the Claimant on 5 August. This was chaired by
Mr Masoero. The Claimant was informed that this was a capability meeting
which the Claimant attended with his Trade Union representative. Mr
Masoero also considered the Claimant's grievance at this meeting and after
discussing the grievance with the Claimant rejected the allegations of bullying
which he had made. The Claimant's current medical condition was then
discussed. The Claimant told Mr Masoero that he was in some pain. He said
he was "in a bad way" and was awaiting an MRI scan following which he
would be attending a further meeting with Occupational Health.
28. Mr Masoero advised the Claimant he could be transferred to Wimbledon
where he would be provided with a truck with a seat supported by air
suspension, equipped with remote control of the lifting ramp as the Claimant
had requested. Mr Masoero also confirmed that the Respondent would allow
him to continue working reduced hours on the basis that his position would
be reviewed by Occupational Health after six weeks in accordance with the
his GP's last Fit Note which had been extended for a six week period.
29. The Claimant rejected the proposed transfer to Wimbledon for the same
reasons as he had given to Mr Hale. Mr Masoero them made the same offer
to the Claimant on the basis that he would be managed by another
Performance Leader which the Claimant also rejected. The eventual outcome
of this discussion was an impasse as a result of which the Claimant was
dismissed by reason of capability.
30. Two days after his dismissal the Claimant attended on a consultant
radiologist to discuss the results of the MRI scan which had been arranged
by his GP. He was informed that this scan confirmed no vertebral fractures
could be seen. However it did disclose degenerative disc disease. The note
states as follows:
"Findings: No vertebral fractures seen. There is degenerative disc disease
with marked disc height reduction and minor posterior disc bulging at L3 – 4.
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
No significant root entrapment or spinal stenosis seen at L3 – 4.
At L4 – 5 there is mild disc degeneration with minor posterior disc bulge
causing mild indentation on the anterior theca. The disc height is maintained.
No significant root entrapment or spinal stenosis seen.
31. At L5 – S1 there is a defect in the pars interarticularis of L5. There is
spondylolsisthesis of 25 – 30% with marked disc height reduction. The
combination of the changes causes moderately severe narrowing of the root
canals bilaterally. The central spinal canal at this level remains adequate.
Mild soft tissue swelling due to stress response is seen in the soft tissue
surrounding the L5 – S1 facet joint."
Consideration and Conclusions
32. The Claimant had no previous history of lower back pain before the accident
on 11 April. He was able to continue working with the adjustments that had
been recommended by his GP, which were endorsed by Occupational
Health. His impact statement, the Occupational Health Reports and the oral
evidence which he gave to the Tribunal established that he was experiencing
some restricted movement and discomfort when driving at the material time.
He confirmed that he had been able to work shifts of eight hours and
attributed the discomfort when driving at this time to the seating in the Canter
van. The particular difficulty at this time which he described to the Tribunal
was lifting and using ramps when collecting vehicles. He did not describe
other difficulties in undertaking day to day activities during the material time.
33. The Respondent arranged for two assessments to be undertaken by its
Occupational Health advisers. The first report indicated that the Claimant was
expected to make a full recovery. Their second report concluded that he was
not disabled because his musculoskeletal problems had been present for
less than 12 months. The report also explained that the exploratory MRI scan
arranged by his GP would determine whether any spinal issues were
involved and the extent and nature of further treatment he required. The
notes of the results of the scan provide no prognosis, or recommendations
for treatment, of the degenerative disc disease it found and describes.
34. The Claimant's Impact Statement describes how his condition has worsened
since the scan and the physiotherapy provided to him following it. He
describes pain from three hours driving as very bad indeed and explains that
walking can be painful, with pain increasing with distance, and waking during
the night. Sadly, it also appears from his statement that he is no longer able
to undertake a driving job.
35. Obviously, such unfortunate developments had not been predicted by either
his GP or Occupational Health, and could not have been known, during the
Case No: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61
material time. Furthermore, the evidence before the Tribunal is that the
impact of the physical impairments caused by the accident suffered by the
Claimant were limited to the aspects of his job which he has described. The
physical impairments and their impact as described by the Claimant did not
have a substantial adverse affect on his day to day activities.
36. The Tribunal, having made this finding, does not have to go any further to
determine the preliminary issue before it. However, it is clear that neither his
GP nor Occupational Health had formed a view that the exploratory MR scan
would disclose a degenerative disc disease, or that there were grounds for a
prognosis of a substantial and continuing deterioration in the Claimant's
previously unknown medical condition that by reason of recent accidents
were likely to result in a long term adverse condition that would be a disability
within the terms of the EqA.
37. It is for these reasons that the Tribunal has found that the Claimant was not
disabled within the terms of the EqA during the material time. This means
that the Claimant's claims of disability discrimination must be dismissed.
Employment Judge Craft
Date: 14 April 2021
Judgment sent to the parties: 15 April 2021
FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Case Number: 1404988/2019
10.2 Judgment - rule 61 1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Mr M Lidbetter
Respondent: Automobile Association Developments Ltd
Heard at: Southampton by Cloud video On: 04 August 2021
Before: Employment Judge Reed sitting alone
Representation
Claimant: Mr P Lidbetter, Father
Respondent: Mr C Ludlow, Counsel
JUDGMENT
The Judgment of the Tribunal is that:
1. The claimant’s claim is not struck out for breach of the directions of the
Tribunal.
2. In relation to the claimant’s claims of detriment and dismissal for making a
protected disclosure, there is no strike out or deposit order.
3. In relation to the claimant’s claims of age discrimination, there is no strike
out order but a deposit order is made.
Employment Judge Reed
Date: 09 August 2021
Sent to the Parties: 17 August 2021
FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Note
Reasons for the judgment having been given orally at the hearing, written reasons will not be
provided unless a request was made by either party at the hearing or a written request is
presented by either party within 14 days of the sending of this written record of the decision.
Public access to employment tribunal decisions
Judgments and reasons for the judgments are published, in full, online at
www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions shortly after a copy has been sent to the claimant(s)
and respondent(s) in a case.
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.