Mr R Gerard Sharp v Emcor Group (UK) plc: 3352830/2017
Employment Tribunal
Published on 09 September 2019, 15:20
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract disability-discrimination unfair-dismissal
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2019-08-15
Official Documents
-
Mr R Gerard-Sharp v Emcor Group (UK) plc: 3352830/2017 - Preliminary.
-
Mr R Gerard Sharp v Emcor Group (UK) plc: 3352830/2017 - Preliminary Hearing
-
Mr R Gerard Sharp v Emcor Group (UK) plc: 3352830/2017 - Partial Withdrawal
Decision Content
Read the full decision in
Read the full decision in .
Read the full decision in .
Change History
-
Partial Withdrawal judgment attached.
-
Preliminary Hearing
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No: 3352830/2017
Page 1 of 1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
BETWEEN
Claimant Respondents
Mr R Gerard-Sharp and R1 – Emcor Group (UK) plc
R2 – Siemens UK plc
Preliminary Hearing (Case
Management) held at Reading on:
18 July 2018
Appearances:
For the Claimant: Mr A Rozycki, counsel
For the 1st Respondent:
For the 2nd Respondent:
Employment Judge:
Mr M Potter, solicitor
Did not attend and not represented
Mr SG Vowles
JUDGMENT
Dismissal of 2nd Respondent
1. On 17 July 2018 the Claimant withdrew his claim against the 2nd Respondent.
2. Accordingly the 2nd Respondent is dismissed from the proceedings.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Vowles
Date: 2 August 2018
Sent to the parties on:
…02.08.18...................
.......................................
For the Tribunals Office
Case Number: 3352830/2017
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Mr R Gerard-Sharp v EMCOR Group UK Plc.
Heard at: Norwich On: 10 December 2018
Before: Employment Judge Postle
Appearances
For the Claimant: Mr Rozycki, Counsel
For the Respondent: Mr Hobbs, Counsel
PRELIMINARY HEARING JUDGMENT
1. Although it is accepted the claimant has a disability of epilepsy, the
question of the respondent’s knowledge is yet to be determined at the full
merits hearing.
2. The claimant does not have a disability of anxiety, stress or depression
within the meaning of section 6 of the Equality Act 2010.
REASONS
1. This is a preliminary hearing to determine whether the claimant has a
disability of stress / anxiety / depression within the meaning of section 6 of
the Equality Act 2010. The respondent accepts the claimant does have a
disability of epilepsy and that satisfies the definition under the Act,
although the issue of knowledge remains to be determined at a full merits
hearing as agreed by both Counsel at the outset of this preliminary
hearing.
2. In this tribunal we heard evidence from the claimant through a prepared
witness statement and also from his wife through a prepared witness
statement.
Case Number: 3352830/2017
2
3. The tribunal also had the benefit of a bundle of documents consisting of
450 pages.
4. The law, section 6 defines the definition of disability as, ‘a person has a
disability if he or she has a physical or mental impairment and the
impairment has a substantial and long term adverse effect on a person’s
ability to carry out normal day to day activities”.
5. The EAT has said that requires the tribunal to look at the evidence by
reference to four different questions or conditions:
a. did the claimant have a mental and / or physical impairment?
b. did the impairment affect the claimant’s ability to carry out normal
day to day activities?
c. was the adverse condition substantial, or minor, or trivial?
d. was the adverse condition long term?
These four questions should be posed sequentially and not together.
6. The tribunal are also required, and have considered the 2010 guidance on
disability contained in the Equality and Human Rights Commission and the
Employment Code of Practice, and although they do not impose legal
obligations they are matters to be taken into account. The focus should be
on what a person cannot do, or can only do with difficulty rather than
things he or she can do.
7. It has been agreed in this tribunal that we are looking at three areas.
There is August to 7 February 2017; 7 February 2017 to 5 September
2017; and 5 September 2017 to 3 November 2017.
8. We know, in August 2016 the claimant was put in charge as I understand it
of the Siemens’ contract. There was a period of getting ready for this
contract called ‘the mobilisation’ and that was to go live so to speak, on
1 December. It was no doubt a busy period for all concerned with the
contract. The claimant says that on 30 November in an email to his line
manager, that he was going to see the doctor as he was falling apart. The
evidence does not suggest that he did go and see his doctor. He said he
went to see his doctor, but we have comprehensive and complete GP
records and there is simply no evidence that the claimant visited his GP in
November at all nor in December for anything to do with stress.
9. The claimant himself says in evidence, that at the time he did not feel he
was suffering from stress and was more concerned about spasms that
might lead to an epileptic fit.
10. On 7 February 2017, the claimant was informed by his line manager that
there were issues with his work over the performance of the contract with
Siemens and these had been raised by the client Siemens and they were
to be discussed at a meeting on 10 February. The claimant was, perhaps
Case Number: 3352830/2017
3
at that stage, concerned. In the meantime, the claimant was told to stay at
home until the meeting.
11. The claimant cancels the meeting and attends his GP on 13 February, he
raises the issue of work, that he is stressed for the first time and the
claimant discussed with his GP that he was stressed at work. The
claimant was signed off. The claimant in the following period receives
periods of counselling with psychiatrists and he is, in the course of this,
asked to complete self-analysis forms which are commonly known as the
GAD questionnaire about the level of anxiety and stress.
12. The first that we see in the bundle is 449 and 450, that is in March. They
suggest at that stage that he was suffering from severe anxiety and severe
depression. He scored 18 and 17 and that is high.
13. By June, after the neurologist has confirmed that a medication Sertraline is
compatible with his epilepsy, he is prescribed it. He ultimately has the
benefit and improves. By 7 September, on the self-analysis GAD forms,
the claimant scores 1 and 3 and is not at all anxious and doesn’t have
severe depression. We see those at 425.
14. Indeed, the claimant and the GP agreed that the claimant was fit to return
to work. The claimant, if he did not feel he was fit to return to work at that
stage would no doubt have told his GP. It appears, around this time as
well, his medication for Sertraline was not renewed.
15. During the period while the claimant was off, noticeably, there were
occupational health reports and they themselves, after seeing the
claimant, did not believe although they accept it is a legal matter, that the
claimant would be protected by the Equality Act 2010 in respect of his
depression / anxiety.
16. The claimant was signed back fit to work. The claimant did not challenge
that with his GP and at a consultation meeting on 3 October with the
respondents, notes of which are at 124, the claimant confirms that he has
not been diagnosed with depression or anxiety before and, “it’s not
affecting me now”. The claimant’s GP records show thereafter, and after
his dismissal, that he only visits his GP for routine matters. Nothing
related to depression, anxiety and stress in the following year until August
2018. During those routine visits, up until that date, I emphasise there is
no mention of any stress related depression or anxiety and it is only after
the case management hearing in July which required the provision of
medical reports, GP notes an impact statement which were requested by
the claimant’s solicitors that on 9 August the claimant visits his GP for the
first time since 2017 in relation to, certainly, depression, stress and anxiety
and says he now has problems of anxiety and depression. That, it has to
be said, is more than a coincidence.
Case Number: 3352830/2017
4
17. Therefore, in the tribunal’s view, the substantive and adverse effect is
simply not made out. The period of disability is not long term lasting 12
months or more, at most it is seven to eight months, commencing in
February 2017 and clearly at no point after 5 September 2017 until the
claimant’s dismissal in November, did the claimant suffer stress or anxiety
or depression. The claimant, I repeat, signed back as fit for work on 5
September, if he was not so fit he would have said so. The condition was
no longer there and could not be considered long term as it no longer had
a substantial or adverse effect on the claimant’s ability to carry out normal
day to day activities.
18. The only disability that will go forward to the full merits hearing, and I
emphasise the issue of knowledge remains to be determined, is the
epilepsy.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Postle
Date: …18.01.19…………..
Sent to the parties on: .18.01.19.......
............................................................
For the Tribunal Office
Case No: 3352830/2017
Page 1 of 1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
BETWEEN
Claimant Respondent
Mr R Gerard-Sharp and Emcor Group (UK) plc
Preliminary Hearing (Case
Management) held at Reading on:
15 August 2019
Appearances:
For the Claimant: Mr A Johnston, counsel
For the Respondent:
Employment Judge:
Mr D Hobbs, counsel
Vowles
JUDGMENT
Made under rule 52 of Schedule 1 to the Employment Tribunals (Constitution
and Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2013
1. The claims of Disability Discrimination (discrimination arising from disability
and failure to make reasonable adjustments) and Breach of Contract are
dismissed upon withdrawal by the Claimant.
2. The claim of Unfair Dismissal will proceed to a full merits hearing.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Vowles
Date: ……15.08.19
Sent to the parties on:
…02.09.19......................
.......................................
For the Tribunals Office
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.