Mr S Tesfaye v Tower Transit Ltd 3200766/2016
Employment Tribunal
Published on 31 July 2017, 13:24
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
health-safety public-interest-disclosure race-discrimination
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2017-07-20
Official Documents
-
Mr S Tesfaye v Tower Transit Ltd 3200766/2016 Reserved
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
The unanimous Judgment of the Employment Tribunal was that:
1. The complaints of whistleblowing detriments under section 47B of
the Employment Rights Act 1996 are not well founded and are
dismissed.
2. The complaint of automatically unfair whistleblowing dismissal
under section 103A of the Employment Rights Act 1996 is not well
founded and is dismissed.
3. The complaints of direct race discrimination, race harassment and
victimisation under sections 13, 26 and 27 of the Equality Act 2010
are not well founded and are dismissed.
Case Number 3200766/2016
2
REASONS
Preliminaries
1. Reasons are provided in writing for the above judgment as it was reserved.
Further they are provided only to the extent that it is necessary to do so in order for the
parties to understand why they have won or lost; and only to the extent that it is
proportionate to do so.
2. All facts were found on the balance of probabilities.
3. The Claimant was employed by Tower Transit Operations Limited (“the
Respondent”) as an Engineering Supervisor at its Lea Interchange garage from
15 February 2016, until 23 June 2016 when he was dismissed for failing his probation.
4. By a claim form which was presented on 16 August 2016, Mr Tesfaye
complained about the termination of his employment. In short, by the time of the full
merits hearing, he alleged direct race discrimination, race harassment and victimisation
under the Equality Act 2010, that he had been subjected to detriment and automatically
unfairly dismissed following the making of protected interest disclosures in relation to
health and safety. The Issues to be decided were set out in detail in an agreed List of
Issues which was included in the trial bundle [pp33G – J]. The List of Issues is also set
out in full below.
5. Case Management Orders were made by Employment Judge Gilbert (“the Gilbert
Order”) without a hearing and sent to the parties on 10 October 2016. A closed
preliminary hearing then took place before Employment Judge Jones on 17 October
2016 at which there was a discussion of the Issues, the Respondent having prepared a
draft List in advance of the hearing, in accordance with the Gilbert Order. A document
setting out a summary of the discussion and the Case Management Orders made was
sent to the parties on 15 November 2016.
The Issues
6. The numbering from the Agreed List of Issues used during the hearing is used in
these Reasons for the purposes of consistency. It was not in dispute that the Claimant
did not have the requisite period of service to entitle him to bring a claim for ‘ordinary’
unfair dismissal under s.94 ERA 1996.
Public interest disclosure detriment: S.47B ERA 1996
1. Did C make qualifying disclosures to R on:
Case Number 3200766/2016
3
a. 13 April 2016 by emailing Jeff Twining (Workshop Manager) about engineers
disappearing from the workplace and taking excessive smoking breaks (which C
says are health and safety matters);
b. 11 May 2016 by allegedly informing Jeff Twining that it would be wrong to
release a defective bus on to the public highway;
c. 27 May 2016 by emailing Satnam Cheema (Engineering Director of The Impact
Group Limited) about alleged bad practices, as detailed in that email?
2. In C’s reasonable belief, were the disclosures made in the public interest and did they
tend to show that the health and safety of any individual had been, or was likely to be
endangered?
3. Was C subjected to any of the following alleged detriments by R and, if so, were they on
the ground that C had made any of the contended protected disclosures as identified at
paragraph 1 above:
a. Excluding him from a meeting on 31 March 2016 held with the Polish workers,
as well as another such meeting on 5 April 2016;
b. Being sworn at by Jeff Twining on 13 April 2016;
c. Being sworn at and threatened by Paul Lenihan on 14 April 2016;
d. Not being assessed by R on his return from a period of sickness absence on
3 May 2016 about his fitness for work;
e. Jeff Twining suspending C on 18 May 2016, telling him it was in relation to gross
misconduct, but failing to give him details of the allegations until the
investigation meeting on 23 May 2016;
f. Christine Gayle issuing C with a final written warning on 16 June 2016 regarding
the defective bus?
4. Have the claims been brought within time and, if not, should time be extended?
Direct race discrimination: S.13 EA 2010
5. Was C, a black African, treated less favourably than a white or non-African person by
reason of the following alleged matters:
a. R’s Polish engineers refusing to take instructions from him;
Case Number 3200766/2016
4
b. Being excluded by R from the meeting with the Polish engineers on 31 March
2016, as well as another such meeting on 5 April 2016;
c. Being dismissed on 23 June 2016 on grounds of unsatisfactory probation?
6. In relation to 5(a) above, did R take all reasonable steps to prevent the Polish engineers
from doing what is alleged or from doing anything of that description?
7. Have the claims been brought within time and, if not, should time be extended?
Victimisation (race): S.27EA 2010
8. Did C engage the following alleged protected acts on:
a. 13 April 2016 when he emailed Jeff Twining allegedly complaining of direct race
discrimination by making reference to “division and inequality”;
b. 11 May 2016 at a probationary review meeting where he allegedly spoke to
Malcom Venn about discrimination and/or segregation;
c. 1 June 2016 by mentioning “race discrimination” in a grievance?
9. Was C subjected by R to any of the following detriments and, if so, was he subjected to
them because he had done any of the alleged protected acts identified in paragraph 8
above:
a. Malcolm Venn allegedly ‘prejudging’ and rejecting C’s grievance dated 21 April
2016;
b. Jeff Twining allegedly forcing C to release a defective bus into service on 11 May
2016;
c. Malcolm Venn stating on 11 May 2016 at the probation review that C ‘must not
harbour conspiracy theories’;
d. Vince Dalzell allegedly prejudging the probation review on 27 May 2016 by
writing in an email dated 27 May 2016 that ‘…this guy has raised grievances and
it ties in with him being seen next week for unsatisfactory probation’;
Case Number 3200766/2016
5
e. Christine Gayle (Operations Manager) imposing a final written warning on 16
June 2016;
f. Being dismissed on 23 June 2016 on grounds of unsatisfactory probation?
10. Have the claims been brought within time and, if not, should time be extended?
Harassment (race): S.26 EqA 2010
11. Did R engage in unwanted conduct relating to C’s race, which had the purpose or effect
of violating his dignity or creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or
offensive environment for him by:
a. Dariusz Felter allegedly subjecting C to aggressive behaviour on 23 and
24 March 2016;
b. Failing to take any or any adequate action following C’s complaint against
Dariusz Felter made by email on 29 March 2016;
c. Paul Lenihan allegedly swearing at and threatening C on 14 April 2016;
d. Jeff Twining allegedly shouting and swearing at, and insulting and blackmailing C
on 11 May 2016;
e. Christine Gayle imposing a final written warning on 16 June 2016 relating to the
defective bus;
f. Failing to take any or any adequate action following C’s complaint about the
events of 14 April 2016 made by C’s emails dated 15 and 21 April 2016?
12. In relation to 11(a) and 11(c) above, did R take all reasonable steps to prevent them
from doing what is alleged or from doing anything of that description?
13. Have the claims been brought in time and, if not, should time be extended?
Automatic Unfair Dismissal – s.103A ERA 1996
14. Was the reason or the principal reason for C’s dismissal on 23 June 2016 the making of
any of the protected disclosures identified at paragraphs 1 and 2 above?
Case Number 3200766/2016
6
Evidence Adduced/Documents Produced
7. The parties agreed on the contents of a single bundle of documents in a lever
arch file, running to some 200 pages and marked [R1]. After the Tribunal had
adjourned until 2pm to read the witness statements and the documents referred to in
the bundle, the Claimant confirmed that he had had an opportunity to go through the
bundle from the witness table and that he had all the relevant documents.
8. The Respondent prepared a chronology marked [R2]; and a cast list marked [R3]
which also stated the race of the relevant people. During the hearing, further
documents were produced by the Respondent to address issues raised by the Claimant
or at the Tribunal’s request. These were a bundle of new documents relating to
Respondent’s Counsel’s bus maintenance spreadsheet marked [R8]; Respondent’s
Counsel’s bus maintenance spreadsheet marked [R7]; an Audit Report marked [R9];
and an organigram marked [R10].
9. The Claimant gave evidence first, and relied on a witness statement for his
evidence in chief marked [C1]. He also relied on a medical report dated 20 January
2017 which was marked [C2].
10. On behalf of the Respondent, the Tribunal heard from the following witnesses:
a. Mr Dariusz Felter, Engineer, witness statement marked [R4];
b. Mr Malcolm Venn, former Engineering Manager, [R5];
c. Mr Darren Bull, Engineering Manager, [R6];
d. Mr Vince Dalzell, Head of Operations, [R10];
e. Ms Christine Gayle, Operations Manager, [R11]; and
f. Mr Andrew Edwards, Operations Director [R13 & 14].
Findings of Fact and Conclusions
11. The Claimant is of Ethiopian racial origin.
Chronology
15 February 2016:
12. The Claimant commenced employment. He was responsible for supervising a
team of Engineers on his shift, and working with other Engineering Supervisors at the
Respondent’s Lea Interchange bus depot. He worked under the direction of the
Workshop Planning Manager, a role which was performed at the material times by Jeff
Twining in an Acting capacity.
11 March 2016:
13. An incident occurred between the Claimant and Wayne Powell (Engineer - Black
British/Caribbean). Jeff Twining (former Workshop Supervisor – White British)
Case Number 3200766/2016
7
investigated and was told by Mr Powell that at the start of his shift that day his name
had not been put on the production board (a whiteboard allocating engineers to jobs).
He could not locate the Claimant and so assisted another engineer. When he returned
to the board, his name had been listed. He said the Claimant accused him of not
coming forward at the start of his shift and did not give him a chance to explain.
Mr Powell said that the Claimant allocated everyone else a task, but ignored him and
they then exchanged words and Mr Powell went to speak to Malcolm Venn (Engineering
Manager – White British).
14. Mr Twining also spoke to the Claimant, who told him that when he asked
Mr Powell why he did not start his duty on time Mr Powell’s approach had been ‘very
violent and aggressive’ and that he had called the Claimant an idiot. Mr Twining
concluded that there had been a misunderstanding between the two men and the
Claimant was given advice on how to deal with such situations.
29 March 2016:
15. The Claimant emailed Mr Twining to make a complaint about Dariusz Felter
(Engineer - White Polish) in relation to his ‘aggressive behaviour’ and ‘his bad attitude’
on 23 and 24 March 2016.
16. Mr Twining spoke with Mr Felter, who told him that he had got annoyed with the
Claimant because he had changed his job several times and had not listened to him.
He added that the Claimant had not been clear in his instruction and that Mr Felter was
only rude to him because the Claimant was rude.
30 March 2016:
17. Mr Twining met with the Claimant and gave him advice on how to deal with
Mr Felter and any difficulties arising with engineers going forward. Mr Twining
suggested that the Claimant should be clear in his instructions, especially with the
Polish engineers where language may be a problem.
31 March 2016:
18. Mr Twining met with the Polish engineers and explained that their behaviour was
not acceptable and they agreed to make an extra effort to assist the Claimant. The
Claimant was not invited to attend this meeting.
19. Mr Twining’s actions were fed back to the Claimant, who was also given advice
on his communication skills. The Respondent believed that the Claimant did not take
the advice well and disagreed with Mr Twining’s comments.
7 April 2016:
20. Mr Twining coached the Claimant on signing off and closing down service
sheets. He was concerned that the Claimant was signing off sheets that still showed
outstanding defects on the vehicles. Examples were given. He was praised for keeping
on top of inspection sheets.
Case Number 3200766/2016
8
8 April 2016:
21. The Claimant was reminded by HR that he needed to provide details of two
referees as requested in his offer letter, his continued employment being conditional on
receipt of satisfactory references.
13 April 2016:
22. The Claimant emailed Mr Twining raising an issue about the following:
22.1. engineers not following instructions from him and/or not complying with
workplace rules;
22.2. engineers disappearing from the workplace and taking excessive smoking
time;
22.3. the lack of speakers to call engineers when needed;
22.4. a division and inequality between the engineers; and
22.5. engineers being of one ethnic background and speaking their native
language at work, which he claimed had a negative effect on
communication and job performance.
14 - 21 April 2016:
23. An altercation took place between the Claimant and Paul Lenihan (Engineering
Supervisor – White British) sometime between 1230 and 1300 about the handover at
the end of the Claimant’s shift to Mr Lenihan.
24. It was not made clear during the Tribunal hearing whether the Claimant was at
work between 14 April and the date of his fit note, 19 April 2016.
25. By an email sent at 12.43 on 15 April 2016 (p74A), Mr Tesfaye informed
Mr Twining that he wished to report the incident on 14 April with Mr Lenihan as an
incident of bullying and harassment. He stated that the episode had caused a range of
emotional/psychological symptoms including sleeplessness and panic attacks. He
asked for confirmation of Mr Lenihan’s name in order that he could report the matter
formally.
26. Mr Lenihan then lodged a complaint about the Claimant by email at 6pm on
15 April (p75), addressed to Mr Twining. He reported ‘…not one but many instances of
incompetency and poor management skills and rude and unacceptable behaviour not
just towards myself but many of the engineering staff.’ He added, ‘I feel that many
workshop staff members are unacceptably being treated unfairly by poor supervisory
dissections…’ (sic) and, ‘I must stress that I have had members of staff and contractors
refusing to work with him saying that his attitude towards them was unacceptable over
the last 6 weeks or so.’ He then set out his version of the incident on 14 April 2016.
Case Number 3200766/2016
9
27. Mr Lenihan made no reference in his one page detailed email to having
knowledge of the Claimant’s complaint about him in relation to the same incident.
28. An occurrence report dated 18 April 2016 (p76) from a member of the
engineering staff was submitted to the Respondent. It stated that Mr Lenihan and the
Claimant had argued on 14 April 2016, but that Mr Lenihan had not threatened the
Claimant in any way.
29. The Claimant hand-delivered a medical certificate signing him off work due to
stress for two weeks. The fit note was dated 19 April 2016 (p76A) and both parties
agreed that it was handed by the Claimant to Mr Twining at the depot. It was unclear on
which date the Claimant did this. The Respondent’s initial case in the Grounds of
Resistance was that it was handed in on 14 April 2016. This was probably based on an
undated typed note of the conversation between Mr Twining and the Claimant when he
handed in the fit note. The account apparently written by Mr Twining was headed
‘Conversation with Solomon Tesfaye on 14 April 2016’. The note referred to the
conversation having taken place at approximately 1630 (p74). Mr Twining did not give
evidence to the Tribunal.
30. The Claimant’s case [C1 para 14] was that he handed in the sick note dated
19 April on 21 April 2016. Given the date on which the fit note was signed, the Tribunal
concluded that it must have been delivered either on or shortly after 19 April. On the
balance of probabilities, the Tribunal accepted the Claimant’s case that the fit note was
handed in on 21 April 2016.
31. Mr Twining’s note recorded that he had a long conversation with Mr Tesfaye,
lasting approximately one hour and 20 minutes. On Mr Twining’s account, the Claimant
was unable to say why he felt he was struggling with the supervisor role, but said that
he did not think he could do the job and referred to similar difficulties he had had in a
previous role, although he did not elaborate. He was given encouragement by
Mr Twining. In relation to Mr Lenihan, he said he was only after an apology. The
Claimant said he was unsure why Mr Lenihan had argued with him, but commented that
it might be because he was Black. The Claimant disputed the accuracy of this note.
21 April 2016:
32. The Claimant emailed his version of events about the incident with Mr Lenihan
(p77) on 14 April 2016 to Mr Twining. He claimed the incident ‘…looks like a systematic
campaign of bullying me at work, because I complained about unacceptable behaviour,
poor work relationship, divisions and improper workplace rules.’ He asked that the
matter be investigated.
25 April 2016:
33. Mr Lenihan was interviewed by Mr Venn about the 14 April incident and stated
(p80) that he had arrived early for work on 14 April 2016 and the Claimant had
immediately approached him and rather aggressively instructed him to do the handover.
Mr Lenihan said he was unhappy about being spoken to in this way and told the
Claimant so. He added that he was not ready to do the handover as he did not start
Case Number 3200766/2016
10
work for another 20 minutes. Mr Lenihan said he had been forceful in his response to
the Claimant, but not aggressive. He was not aware of any malicious rumours being
spread about the Claimant, nor any campaign of bullying.
34. Mr Venn also interviewed Mr Twining, who had observed the events on 14 April
2016 (p78). He confirmed that both Mr Lenihan and the Claimant had raised their
voices. He denied the allegations made by the Claimant of a campaign of bullying and
highlighted that he had tried to help the Claimant in his role.
35. Mr Mehmet Ahmed (Skilled Engineer/Chargehand – White British) was
interviewed as part of the investigation by Mr Venn. The notes of the interview (p79)
record that he stated that he had not heard what was said, but reported that the incident
was not aggressive, although there was a disagreement. He denied the allegations
made by the Claimant.
36. Although the Occurrence Report (p76) referred to above dated 18 April 2016
about the incident on 14 April was signed, the signature was difficult to decipher and
there was a dispute about whose signature it was. The Claimant believed it was
Mr Ahmed’s and the Respondent contended that it was signed by Romaine Davidson.
Both men were said by the Claimant in his email of complaint on 21 April 2016 (p77) to
have been present during the incident, although on the Claimant’s account,
Mr Davidson was more closely involved. The Tribunal was unable to resolve that
dispute as there was no corroborating evidence. When interviewed, Mr Ahmed made
no reference to the Occurrence Report, and Mr Davidson was not interviewed as part of
the investigation. As the Claimant accepted that both men were witnesses, it probably
did not matter which one had written the Occurrence Report.
6 May 2016:
37. Mr Venn held a meeting with the Claimant and Mr Lenihan to try and find a way
forward. Both reluctantly agreed to draw a line under the matter. Mr Venn considered
the matter closed.
11 May 2016:
38. The Claimant who was on the early shift had been told by Mr Twining to release
certain buses into service. Mr Tesfaye believed that they were still defective and
therefore not fit to be in service and therefore refused to do this. This took place at
about 07:10 [C1 para 18]. The Claimant’s case, which the Tribunal was unable to
uphold on the facts despite examining a considerable amount of documentation relating
to the maintaining and servicing of the vehicles, was that Mr Twining had directed him to
release defective buses on a number of occasions previously. This issue is also dealt
with below in the context of the disclosures. The implication from the Claimant was that
Mr Twining had ordered buses to go on the road knowing that they were unroadworthy.
39. A conversation which was heated in parts then took place sometime thereafter
between the Claimant, Mr Twining and Mr Lenihan. Mr Tesfaye recorded part of it
surreptitiously and the transcript was in the bundle (pp81B – C). The Claimant relied on
this recording as evidence of one of the public interest disclosures. It was also relevant
Case Number 3200766/2016
11
to one of the harassment allegations (11d). The Tribunal also considered that the
transcript of the recording gave the Tribunal a useful insight into the interpersonal
relationships at the time. Blunt language was used by Mr Twining, but the Tribunal was
satisfied from the contents of the transcript, that he directed this equally at Mr Tesfaye
and Mr Paul Lenihan. The transcript began with Mr Twining expressing considerable
exasperation about the performance of the Claimant and Mr Lenihan, which meant that
Mr Twining, as he saw it, was having to put things right after them. Further into the
recording however, Mr Twining apologised profusely to Mr Tesfaye for having wrongly
accused him of taking incorrect action in relation to the procedure for marking that a
vehicle was to be kept off the road.
40. At about midday on 11 May 2016 Mr Venn conducted a probationary review with
the Claimant (pp82 – 83), who referred to his email dated 21 April 2016, which he
termed a grievance. He was reminded that those matters had been concluded. The
Claimant was argumentative towards Mr Venn (p84) during the review. The Tribunal
accepted Mr Venn’s evidence that he made the notes of the meeting
contemporaneously.
41. The Claimant was informed that building a relationship with staff under his control
was a fundamental part of his role and had to be addressed. He was advised that his
style of management was aggressive and he needed to adopt softer skills, whilst
managing a tight ship. Mr Venn advised the Claimant to work on these aspects,
amongst others, and that the position would be reviewed on 25 May 2016.
17 May 2016:
42. Mr Venn wrote to the Claimant (p85) to confirm that the grievance dated 21 April
2016 had been investigated and concluded. Mr Venn explained that he could find no
evidence to support the allegations made. Mr Tesfaye’s case was that he had received
this letter on 26 May, but that he had not received the document at p83A to the same
effect until 8 August 2016 when a copy was sent to him by the Human Resources
Department at Westbourne Park. The Tribunal considered that the document at p83A
was merely an unsigned draft of the letter which Mr Tesfaye accepted he received on
26 May 2016. It did not take matters any further.
18 May 2016:
43. The Claimant was suspended by Mr Twining for permitting vehicle 36118 to go
out in service on 6 May 2016 with category ‘X’ defects (serious defects rendering the
vehicle un-roadworthy), having signed off the relevant engineering sheet to confirm it
was ‘approved, fit for service’. Amongst other things, the vehicle had a brake test
outstanding.
19 May 2016:
44. The Claimant’s suspension was upheld by Amir Shaikh (Staff Manager) at a
suspension review meeting. Mooragosub Naidoo (Unite) accompanied the Claimant.
The serious nature of the alleged offence was referred during the review meeting (pp 88
& 89)
Case Number 3200766/2016
12
23 May 2016:
45. At a fact-finding meeting to investigate the disciplinary charges (at which
Mr Naidoo accompanied the Claimant once more), Scott O’Neil (Panel Staff Manager)
found that there was a case to answer and referred the matter to Mr Venn. The
Claimant objected to seeing Mr Venn due to what he referred to as ‘an outstanding
grievance’.
25 May 2016:
46. Mr Venn wrote to the Claimant confirming that the meeting had been moved from
25 May to 27 May 2016 due to the unavailability of the Claimant’s Unite representative.
Mr Venn also acknowledged that his letter of 17 May 2016 confirming the outcome of
the grievance had not set out the right of appeal. He apologised and confirmed that the
Claimant had seven days from 26 May 2016 to appeal, if he wanted to.
27 May 2016:
47. The Claimant emailed Mr Venn setting out a chronology of events. For the first
time, he alleged that on 11 May 2016 Mr Twining had shouted at him, insulting him,
‘(called me an F word and said I am a disgraceful person)’ He claimed Mr Twining had
organised certain engineers to set things up to get him out of the company because he
had (a) complained about engineers’ ‘clock time cards’, (b) made reports on 13 April
2016 about unacceptable behaviour, and (c) submitted a grievance dated 21 April 2016.
The Claimant further claimed that his grievance had been concluded by Mr Venn
without proper investigation. This email was forwarded to Darren Bull (Engineering
Manager) on 1 June 2016.
48. The Claimant also emailed Satnam Cheema (Engineering Director of The Impact
Group Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary of the Respondent) to make him aware of
what he termed ‘bad practices’ at the depot. He referred to problems concerning ‘clock
cards’ (later said to be an isolated occurrence), shift patterns, inspection schedules, and
made a serious allegation that buses with defects were being allowed out in service.
49. Mr Venn met with the Claimant, accompanied by Mr Naidoo, to conduct a
probation review. Mr Naidoo explained that the Claimant would not proceed with the
meeting as he had not been given ‘the pack’ to prepare his case. A pack was not
normally prepared by the Respondent’s managers ahead of probation review meetings
as they were not disciplinary hearings. The meeting was adjourned whilst a pack was
prepared and copied for the Claimant. His email of 27 May 2016 was discussed and
Mr Venn informed him that Mr Bull would meet with him on 31 May 2016 and address
the allegations made.
31 May 2016:
50. Mr Bull met with the Claimant (who was still suspended) and Mr Naidoo to
discuss the email sent to Mr Cheema. Notes of the discussion were made (pp100 –
105). The notes suggested that the meeting was for the purpose of a probation review.
Case Number 3200766/2016
13
51. During the meeting the Claimant alleged that there was favouritism between
black and white members of staff. He claimed that invoices were being sent to the
Respondent by a company that was not genuine and where work was not being carried
out, and further alleged that the Workshop Manager was allowing defective buses to go
out in service. Mr Bull took a copy of the documents that the Claimant said supported
this last allegation and confirmed he would investigate.
1 June 2016:
52. The Claimant emailed Christine Gayle (Operations Manager) attaching an appeal
against Mr Venn’s grievance outcome. He said the Respondent was not recognising its
duties in respect of his health and safety at work and repeated his allegations against
Mr Twining and Mr Lenihan, alleging bullying and harassment because of race. Vince
Dalzell (Head of Operations) responded and advised that Mrs Gayle was responsible for
the operational side of the business and so his email had been forwarded to Mr Bull.
9 June 2016:
53. A second request was made for the Claimant to urgently provide details of two
referees and he was reminded that his employment was conditional on the Respondent
obtaining satisfactory references.
13 June 2016:
54. Mr Bull wrote to the Claimant responding to the allegations made in his email to
Mr Cheema on 27 May 2016 about engineering practices. Mr Bull did not find any
evidence to support any of the allegations. In any event, given the seriousness of the
allegations, the Respondent instructed an external contractor to undertake an
independent audit of the allegations made.
55. Mr O’Neill wrote to the Claimant instructing him to attend a disciplinary hearing
with Mrs Gayle on 16 June 2016, in relation to the incident on 6 May 2016, when the
Respondent believed that the Claimant authorised a defective unroadworthy vehicle for
use on the road. The charge he was warned he would have to answer was one of
‘failure to observe rules/procedures affecting the safety of employees or the public’ (an
example of gross misconduct, set out in the Respondent’s disciplinary procedure)
(p122). He was advised of his right to be accompanied and that dismissal was a
potential outcome of the hearing.
16 June 2016:
56. The Claimant attended the hearing accompanied by Mr Naidoo. At the
commencement of the hearing Mrs Gayle (Black British/Caribbean) amended the
wording of the charge to make it clear that she understood that the management
needed to establish that Mr Tesfaye’s actions or omissions constituted gross
misconduct. Mrs Gayle found the charge proved. Despite the seriousness, she
decided not to dismiss the Claimant, given assurances from the Claimant that incidents
of this nature would not happen again. She awarded a final written warning to remain
live for two years. He was advised of his right of appeal. This was confirmed in writing
(pp 130 - 133).
Case Number 3200766/2016
14
57. By an email sent on the same day, the Claimant was informed by Mr Venn that
his probation would be reviewed at a meeting at midday on 20 June 2016 (p122E). The
Claimant wrote to Mr Venn seeking clarification, among other things, about why
Mr Venn would be dealing with the probation review once again, having previously told
the Claimant that this would be transferred to Mr Bull (p132B – C).
58. He also raised a number of concerns about the conduct of the forthcoming
meeting and Mr Venn’s involvement with it in that letter.
23 June 2016:
59. The Claimant emailed Mr Dalzell, chasing a grievance appeal hearing (p139).
He clarified that his complaints related to harassment, discrimination because of race,
breaches of health and safety obligations and detrimental treatment as a result of
whistleblowing, and victimisation.
60. Mr Venn conducted the probation review with the Claimant, who was
accompanied by Mr Naidoo.
61. Mr Venn’s decision was that the Claimant had failed his probation. He referred to
issues with staff and his managerial style, as well as a period of 14 days’ sickness
absence. He believed that the Claimant had demonstrated an aggressive manner and
failed to listen to what was being said or asked of him. Mr Venn found that this attitude
was evident in the review meeting itself. He advised the Claimant that he was
dismissed, with payment in lieu of his notice period.
29 June 2016:
62. The Claimant emailed Sonia Gentles (HR Administrator) appealing against both
the outcome of the disciplinary hearing (final written warning imposed by Mrs Gayle),
and his dismissal following the probation review (pp143 – 145). His grounds of appeal
against the dismissal mentioned discrimination and that he believed he had been
singled out by individuals and groups within the workplace.
22 July 2016:
63. A letter (p151) was sent to the Claimant notifying him of an appeal hearing
against the decision to dismiss.
8 August 2016:
64. The appeal hearing was conducted by Mr Andrew Edwards (Operations Director)
and Mr Dalzell. The Claimant was accompanied by Joe Welch, the Unite Convenor.
The Claimant’s request to record the proceedings was refused.
65. The hearing was adjourned as Mr Welch had another appointment to attend. A
resumed hearing date on 19 August was agreed at the time.
Case Number 3200766/2016
15
19 August 2016:
66. The appeal hearing was adjourned again. The Claimant did not feel he could
take his own notes because of the state of his health and his second request to record
the proceedings was refused. It was agreed that the hearing would reconvene when
the Claimant was fit enough. It was proposed that the Claimant would make contact
with the Respondent after 31 August 2016.
67. The appeal against dismissal was finally completed on 4 November 2016 when
the Claimant was well enough to attend. Mr Edwards wrote to the Claimant to confirm
the outcome in a letter dated 22 December 2016. The appeal was not upheld. In
particular they found no unfairness in the dismissal and no evidence of discrimination.
General
68. The undisputed evidence before the Tribunal (p63) was that of 1045 drivers and
engineers employed at the Lea Interchange depot, 337 were White, and 133 were
African. The remaining 575 came from a range of racial backgrounds which fell into
about 18 categories including British and Other White (95 under each of those
categories), Caribbean (83), and a couple of categories reflecting Indian Subcontinental
origins which together numbered about 159. In short the work force was
very mixed racially.
69. The further document R3 which listed the approximately 20 engineers and
managers who were relevant to this case, portrayed a similar picture of diversity in the
workforce.
Public Interest Disclosures
70. The first matter said to constitute a public interest disclosure was as set out in
1(a) of the Agreed Issues as follows: 13 April 2016 by emailing Jeff Twining (Workshop Manager)
about engineers disappearing from the workplace and taking excessive smoking breaks (which C says are
health and safety matters).
71. As submitted by the Respondent on the basis of the case of Kilraine v L B
Wandsworth [2016] IRLR 422, the Tribunal considered that this was merely an
allegation and not the provision of information. The email provided no detail about the
individuals involved or the dates or times of the alleged incidents. Further the email did
not raise any health and safety issues. The Claimant struggled in evidence to
demonstrate this and could only contend that if there were a fire during the working day
it would be difficult to account for the engineers or, he argued, they could steal a bus
during any time that was not accounted for. Finally, the Tribunal accepted that there
was no basis for a reasonable belief by the Claimant that a disclosure about the issues
covered in the email was in the public interest, as opposed to being a purely private
matter: Morgan v Royal Mencap Society [2016] IRLR 428. It was apparent from the
email read as a whole, that as Mr Tesfaye stated in the opening sentence of the email
(p72), he was seeking help from Mr Twining with the discharge of his work duties, and
in particular in relation to his management of the engineers.
Case Number 3200766/2016
16
72. The second matter said to constitute a protected disclosure was: 11 May 2016 by
allegedly informing Jeff Twining that it would be wrong to release a defective bus on to the public
highway (Issue 1(b).
73. The Claimant’s witness statement provided no further elaboration of his case on
the alleged disclosure (C1, para 18). However, his position in relation to this matter
changed somewhat in that he alleged there that he had been repeatedly told to release
defective buses on to the road. He did not make this point at the suspension review
meeting or indeed at the fact-finding meeting. Importantly, in relation to an employee
who readily committed less serious matters to writing, Mr Tesfaye made no
contemporaneous written complaint about this.
74. In respect of this alleged disclosure, the Tribunal also considered that this was
not a disclosure of information, but a statement of opinion.
75. The third matter said to constitute a public interest disclosure was as set out in
para 1(c) of the List of Issues: 27 May 2016 by emailing Satnam Cheema (Engineering Director of
The Impact Group Limited) about alleged bad practices, as detailed in that email.
76. The Claimant told Mr Cheema and others in that email (p98) that there were a
number of ongoing bad practices at the garage, the most serious of which was that
buses were being released onto the road with dangerous defects. The Tribunal did not
accept the Respondent’s assertion that these were mere generalised allegations.
Further we were satisfied that if buses were indeed being released on to the roads into
service in an unfit state, the health and safety ground and the public interest
requirement were both sufficiently engaged.
77. The Claimant provided detail of the fleet numbers and the dates on which they
were supposed to have been sent out with defects, on various specified occasions
between 25 April and 12 May 2016. The Tribunal considered that the detail provided
was sufficient. It was used by the Respondent’s managers to assess the accuracy of
the report.
78. Indeed, the list in the Claimant’s email formed the basis of a good deal of the
Tribunal’s review of the records of maintenance and work done on the vehicles to
assess whether there was any substance to the allegations, such that we could be
satisfied that the Claimant had reasonable grounds for believing that the reports were
likely to endanger the health and safety of others on the highway.
79. Mr Parry provided information to supplement the investigations carried out by
Mr Bull into the instances referred to in the Claimant’s email, by email to Darren Bull,
Engineering Manager at Westbourne Park dated 9 June 2016 (pp118A – B). The
summary spreadsheet setting out the position after it had been investigated by the
Respondent was contained in [R7], prepared by Counsel for the Respondent. The
Tribunal took into account when considering the paperwork, that the Claimant should
have been extremely familiar with this documentation as he worked with it daily. The
detailed examination of the paperwork in the Tribunal Hearing did not lead to the
conclusion that the breaches of procedure alleged by the Claimant had taken place, or
more importantly, that the Claimant could reasonably have believed that to be the case.
Case Number 3200766/2016
17
The Tribunal was persuaded by the point made that the documents which the Claimant
provided in support of his contentions that work had not been carried out were
photocopies of the Vehicle Inspection Sheets. These were a ‘snapshot’ of the position
at a particular point in time. The entries had to be cross checked with other documents
which recorded the movements of and maintenance of the buses in order for a true
picture to emerge in relation to the allegations. This exercise was carried out by Mr Bull
when the allegations were investigated. Further, information could have been added or
changed on the original sheets after the Claimant photocopied them, or before the
vehicles went out to service. The Tribunal accepted the Respondent’s case that
engineering activities are continuous and therefore the sheets were continually updated.
This was apparent from consideration of the sheets.
80. The evidence before the Tribunal did not cast any doubt on Mr Bull’s findings
namely that there was no evidence to support the Claimant’s allegations in the email of
27 May 2016. The Tribunal considered in all the circumstances therefore that the
Claimant had insufficient grounds for believing that the bad practices he alleged were
likely to endanger the health and safety of others.
81. The Tribunal also considered an engineering documentation audit report
prepared in July 2016 for the Respondent [R9] at the request of the Engineering
Director, Mr Cheema, to whom the email in May 2016 was sent. The audit report
covered a different and subsequent time frame to the period the Claimant had reported
on in his May 2017 email. The Tribunal considered that this was evidence which
suggested that the senior manager, Mr Cheema was keen to ensure that the
Respondent complied with the appropriate procedures. Even if the Tribunal were wrong
about concluding that the Claimant did not have reasonable grounds for making the
disclosure, the evidence of the audit tended to suggest that the Respondent was not
likely to have victimised the Claimant for reporting issues of vehicle safety, but that they
took the claims seriously and investigated them appropriately.
82. The Tribunal also considered the Respondent’s case that this email of 27 May
was sent by the Claimant as a counterattack to disciplinary charges being levelled
against him (suspension 18 May 2016) for a serious offence of the same type as
Mr Tesfaye claimed others had done. However the paperwork presented to the
Tribunal substantiated the Respondent’s belief that the Claimant had done the acts of
misconduct alleged.
83. Those background circumstances of the suspension, and ongoing disciplinary
investigation were also consistent with an absence of reasonable belief by the Claimant
in the claims in his email to Mr Cheema.
84. The Tribunal concluded in all the circumstances that the three matters relied
upon as whistle blowing disclosures did not meet the statutory definition for the reasons
set out above. As the Claimant had not established that he had made any
whistleblowing disclosures, the complaints alleging detriments and unfair dismissal by
reason of having made whistleblowing disclosures could not succeed. Those
complaints were therefore not well founded and were dismissed.
Case Number 3200766/2016
18
Discrimination and Victimisation Complaints
85. The first allegation of direct race discrimination (5a) was that the Respondent’s
Polish engineers refused to take instructions from the Claimant. This generalised
allegation was never particularised. In his witness statement the Claimant described (at
para 7) that he reported aggressive behaviour by one of the Polish engineers (Mr Felter)
towards him (p67). The report was in an email dated 29 March 2016. The incident
which involved the alleged use of bad language by Mr Felter to the Claimant was
somewhat similar to the earlier incident involving Mr Powell. Both men used ‘industrial
language’ to question the Claimant’s competence at his job. Indeed when he was
spoken to about the incident at the time, Mr Felter expressed his exasperation with the
Claimant’s method of allocating jobs. Further Mr Felter’s uncontradicted evidence was
that he had previously had a Black manager and had encountered no difficulties with
him.
86. On the face of it there was nothing racial in the interaction, or in the criticism of
the Claimant.
87. There were no particulars or evidence provided of episodes of other Polish
engineers (of whom there were several) refusing to take instructions from the Claimant.
88. The evidence before the Tribunal did not establish the primary facts on the
balance of probabilities. There was evidence of a generalised complaint about this by
the Claimant in his email to Mr Twining dated 13 April 2016 (p72), but he did not
suggest in the email that the issue related to engineers of one particular race or indeed
that there was a racial element to that issue.
89. Further, the undisputed evidence was that the Claimant had encountered
difficulties with other colleagues who were White British (Mr Lenihan and to a lesser
extent Mr Twining) and with a colleague who was Black British/Caribbean (Mr Wayne
Powell). The Probation review meetings highlighted the need for the Claimant to work
better with his team.
90. The second direct race discrimination complaint was about the meeting which
Mr Twining held p69) with five of the Polish engineers on 31 March 2016 (Allegation
5b); and a further meeting on 5 April 2016, neither of which the Claimant was invited to
attend. There were a number of other Polish Engineers working for the Respondent
who were not called to the first meeting. The complaint was that the Claimant felt
excluded by not being in attendance at the meeting.
91. Although Mr Twining did not give evidence to the Tribunal, his notes of the
meetings were available. Further his actions in this respect were examined as part of
the appeal process (p159AA).
92. The Tribunal was satisfied that Mr Twining as Workshop Supervisor simply
decided to speak first to the Claimant on his own on 30 March 2016 to advise him about
how to deal more effectively with Mr Felter, about whom complaint had been made,
and, as Mr Twining described them, “difficult engineers”. In the circumstances the
Tribunal considered that the advice to the Claimant about being clear in his instructions
Case Number 3200766/2016
19
was a genuine attempt by a manager to improve communications within the team.
Given the angry words which had been spoken already, the Tribunal did not consider
the decision to speak to the five Polish engineers was unwise or inappropriate, or called
for explanation. As the Appeal Panel found, it was Mr Twining’s way of trying to get to
the bottom of the ‘conflict’.
93. The Tribunal noted that Mr Twining then met the Claimant after the meeting on
31 March and fed back to him what was said and gave Mr Tesfaye further advice in the
light of what Mr Twining had heard from the engineers. Mr Twining noted that he
reinforced his advice with examples of incidents he had personally observed. This very
strongly suggested that there was some validity to the criticisms made by the engineers,
and that their dissatisfaction with working with the Claimant was unrelated to his race.
94. There was no documentary record of the meeting which the Claimant said took
place on 5 April 2016 (Allegation 5b). The Claimant complained of it in paragraph 10 of
his witness statement. His description was very similar to a description of the meeting
on 31 March 2016 except that he said that all seven Polish engineers were in
attendance. As the Claimant did not attend the meeting the Tribunal was unable to
reach any further conclusions about what had transpired. There was no actual
comparator whose treatment could be compared to that of the Claimant. The
circumstances of the engineers who attended were different from those of the Claimant
who was a Supervisor.
95. The Tribunal did not consider that the Claimant had thus established the primary
facts on which his complaint was based, or even if the meeting took place, that it was
likely that he was treated less favourably on racial grounds by not being called to it.
There was nothing other than some differences in race, to support an inference of race
discrimination. It is now well established that that is insufficient: Madarassy
96. The third complaint of direct race discrimination, (Allegation 5c) was about the
Claimant being dismissed on 23 June 2016 on the grounds of unsatisfactory probation.
The Tribunal’s finding above that there was ample evidence to support the
Respondent’s belief that the Claimant was guilty of serious misconduct when he was
suspended and thereafter, completely undermine this allegation. Further, when the
Claimant appealed against the Final Written Warning imposed by Mrs Gayle, he did not
allege racial grounds.
97. Indeed the appeal outcome letter records that the Claimant did not challenge the
allegation that he had signed off a bus as fit for duty when it was not and had a major
defect. The letter records that he could not explain this actions, but sought to blame
someone else for ‘tricking’ him into doing it (p159AA). The Appeal Panel considered
that the Final Written Warning awarded by Mrs Gale had been lenient given the nature
of the conduct and the Claimant’s role as Supervisor.
98. Against the background of the outcome to the disciplinary proceedings, and the
background of well-founded concerns about the Claimant’s management style and
communication skills, the decision to terminate his employment on the ground of
unsatisfactory probation was hardly surprising.
Case Number 3200766/2016
20
99. Having concluded that none of the direct race discrimination complaints was well
founded, the Tribunal next dealt with the race harassment allegations under section
26 of the 2010 Act (Allegations 11a – f).
100. Allegation 11a was about Mr Felter subjecting the Claimant to aggressive
behaviour on 23 and 24 March 2016. In his witness statement at para 7, the Claimant
described the use of rude gestures and ‘industrial language’ by Mr Felter on 23 March
2016, as was also complained about above in Allegation 5a (direct race discrimination).
The language used by Mr Felter (“bullshit”) was coarse but not racial. Further the
transcript of the conversation recorded by the Claimant between himself, Mr Twining
and Mr Lenihan on 11 May 2016 confirmed that the use of ‘industrial language’ was not
unusual in this workplace. The Tribunal found that on 11 May, Mr Twining directed the
language at both the Claimant and Mr Lenihan. Mr Twining’s language was similarly
coarse but not racial (p81B).
101. Finally the Tribunal did not consider that Mr Felter’s epithet was aggressive,
albeit it was somewhat disrespectful.
102. As to 24 March 2016, the facts alleged by the Claimant (para 7 of [C1]) did not
constitute aggressive behaviour as alleged. At the very highest, Mr Tesfaye alleged
that Mr Felter dragged his feet about completing the allocated work and absented
himself from duty for a while on 24 March 2016. There was no supportive evidence of
this allegation in any event.
103. The Tribunal considered therefore that the primary facts alleging aggressive
behaviour by Mr Felter were not made out, and the complaint (Allegation 11a) was
therefore not well-founded.
104. The next complaint of race harassment was that Mr Twining failed to take any or
any adequate action following the Claimant’s complaint against Mr Felter in the email
sent on 29 March 2016 (p67). The Tribunal’s findings above about the appropriateness
of the action taken by Mr Twining following receipt of the email sufficiently deal with this
complaint. The Claimant certainly failed to establish that Mr Twining took no action, and
the Tribunal was satisfied that the action he took, some of which the Claimant agreed
with and indeed complained about, was more than adequate and appropriate.
105. Finally there was no basis whatsoever for concluding that Mr Twining’s actions
were in any way affected by the Claimant’s race. The burden of proof would in any
event not have shifted to the Respondent.
106. This allegation also was not well-founded and was dismissed.
107. Next the Claimant alleged that Paul Lenihan swore at and threatened the
Claimant on 14 April 2016 (Allegation 11c). This complaint arises out of the occasion
when the Claimant and Mr Lenihan ‘had words’ due to a disagreement about the timing
of a handover conversation between the two men.
Case Number 3200766/2016
21
108. There was a dispute on the facts as to where the fault lay. However the
preponderance of the contemporaneous documentary evidence pointed to the Claimant
being at fault. In any event, the dispute was about Mr Lenihan’s start time. This was
not in any way related to race.
109. On that later ground alone, even if the Claimant established the primary facts, the
complaint of race harassment in this respect could not succeed. Allegation 11c was not
well founded and was dismissed.
110. The fourth complaint of race harassment (allegation 11d) was about Mr Twining
shouting and swearing at and insulting and blackmailing the Claimant on 11 May 2016.
The Claimant had surreptitiously recorded the exchange and the Tribunal had the
benefit of the Claimant’s transcript (pp81B – C).
111. The transcript did not corroborate this allegation. It was apparent from the outset
of the transcript that Mr Twining was directing his wrath at both the Claimant and
Mr Lenihan. Thus, for example he stated: ”Let me get one fucking thing straight here,
and I am talking to the fucking pair of you now because I have fucking well had enough
here”. He made other strong remarks in a similar vein, expressly directed at both men.
Once again, strong language was used, but none of it was racial. Further, although the
transcript was not completely clear, it was agreed during the Claimant’s evidence, that
when Mr Twining realised he had incorrectly criticised the Claimant for something, he
promptly apologised for having done so.
112. Towards the end of the transcript, there was an exchange about Mr Twining
accusing the Claimant of ‘playing games’ with him and telling the Claimant that he
would take him on in that respect. This appeared to be the basis for the Claimant’s
allegation that he was blackmailed by Mr Twining. The Tribunal did not consider that
this was a fair inference to draw from the text of the transcript. However most
importantly, in relation to this allegation also, there was absolutely no material from
which the Tribunal could infer that Mr Twining’s actions were in any way related to race.
113. Allegation 11d was therefore not well-founded and was dismissed.
114. The fifth allegation of race harassment was that Mrs Christine Gayle had
imposed a final written warning on 16 June 2016 relating to the Claimant signing off as
fit for duty a defective bus. Mrs Gayle’s race has already been noted above. Whilst this
did not render a successful race complaint against her impossible, it tended to make it
unlikely. The Tribunal also had regard to the findings of the Appeal Panel that her
decision to impose a final written warning was in the circumstances lenient. The
Tribunal agreed with the Appeal Panel’s reasoning, not least because of the gravity of
the potential consequences of the Claimant’s action, and his role as Supervisor. The
note of the disciplinary hearing (p127) recorded the closing remarks of both the
Claimant and his Trade Union representative. Their observations about the
circumstances of the misconduct justify the finding of guilt and the sanction imposed by
Mrs Gayle.
Case Number 3200766/2016
22
115. On the facts found by the Tribunal, no actual comparator having in any event
been identified by the Claimant, the Claimant had failed to establish that he had been
subjected to less favourable treatment than a hypothetical comparator.
116. Allegation 11e was therefore not well founded and was dismissed.
117. The final race harassment complaint was (Allegation 11f) that the Respondent
failed to take any or any adequate action following the Claimant’s complaint about the
events of 14 April 2016 made by the Claimant in emails dated 15 and 21 April 2016.
118. In his witness statement, Mr Tesfaye characterised Mr Lenihan’s actions on
14 April as acts of bullying and harassment as a result of the Claimant having made a
whistle blowing disclosure [C1, para 12].
119. The contemporaneous documentation confirms that action was indeed taken by
the Respondent following the Claimant’s complaints. An investigation was undertaken
which tended to attribute blame to the Claimant (pp74A – 76, 77 – 81, 83A – 85). The
contemporaneous documents also established on the balance of probabilities, although
the Claimant subsequently disputed their accuracy, that it was agreed that he and
Mr Lenihan would move on, and to confirm this, they shook hands at a meeting in
Mr Venn’s office on 6 May 2016 (pp83A, 85). The Tribunal accepted the Respondent’s
case that this was how matters were resolved because that was the more credible
account in the light of the contemporaneous documents.
120. In the Tribunal hearing, the Claimant explained that his complaint here was was
about the handling of the appeal and that Mrs Gayle should have dealt with it. There
appeared to have been a misunderstanding on the Respondent’s part when the
Claimant lodged his appeal about what his letter dated 1 June 2016 headed “Grievance
Letter Appeal” and addressed to Mrs Gayle (pp109 – 114) was intended to be. The
letter was sent by email to Mrs Gayle, but was also copied to Mr Dalzell, Mr Cheema
and the Unite representative, Naidoo Mooragosub (pp116 – 117).
121. Mr Dalzell, Head of Operations, treated it (p116) as part of the Claimant’s
grievance to Mr Satnam Cheema, Group Engineering Director which was being dealt
with by Darren Bull. Mr Dalzell informed the Claimant of this at the time (p116). At the
Tribunal hearing the Respondent acknowledged that the Claimant had probably
intended it to be an appeal against what he contended was an unresolved grievance
heard by Malcolm Venn, former Engineering Manager – a reference to the disputed
handshake (pp83A, 85).
122. In the event this issue was dealt with by consent at the appeal hearing against
the final written warning (imposed by Mrs Gayle) and against the decision to dismiss
(pp159P-R). The Appeal Panel did not uphold the appeal.
123. In relation to this allegation also, the Claimant failed to establish the primary facts
on the balance of probabilities. It was in any event apparent from the facts that there
was no racial element to the Respondent’s actions, even if the burden of proof had
shifted.
Case Number 3200766/2016
23
124. Allegation 11f was thus not well-founded and was dismissed.
125. The Tribunal then considered the victimisation complaints. The first issue for
determination was whether the matters put forward as protected acts (Paras 8a – c of
List of Issues) were established. The Respondent did not accept that the first of the
three matters relied upon was a protected act.
126. The definition of a protected act is set out in section 27(2) of the Equality Act
2010 and is very wide. In particular it includes under section 27(2)(c), “doing any other
thing for the purposes of or in connection with ..” the 2010 Act, and under section
27(2)(d), making an allegation, which can be implied, that another person has
contravened the 2010 Act. A protected act also occurs when someone believes that the
claimant has done, or may do one, even if they have not. There is a limitation to
exclude certain acts that would otherwise be protected, if they were done in bad faith:
section 27(3). That issue did not arise in this case.
127. In para 8a of the List of Issues, the Claimant relied on the act of emailing Jeff
Twining on 13 April 2016 (p73) allegedly complaining of race discrimination by making
reference to “division and inequality”. The Tribunal rejected the Respondent’s
submissions to the effect that this email did not constitute the doing of a protected act.
Mr Bailey argued that the allegation of division and inequality was not made on a
specific basis. Alternatively, he submitted that it related to a group of workers speaking
their mother tongue to one another which was not a claim of discrimination.
128. The Tribunal considered that the Claimant raised a context of racial difference in
referring his concerns to Mr Twining in the email. He referred to the majority of the
engineers being from one ethnic background and his concern that most of them spoke
their non-English “native language” at work was having a detrimental effect on
workplace communication and job performance. He also complained that English
speaking colleagues did not therefore understand the conversations and were upset
and felt excluded.
129. The Tribunal considered that there was sufficient reference to concerns about the
actions of one particular ethnic group in the workforce for it to fall within the definition
27 section of the 2010 Act. It was not necessary for the Claimant’s email to have
asserted a valid claim under the 2010 Act – the definition was wide enough in the
Tribunal’s view to cover the raising of concerns which arose out of racial or ethnic
differences.
130. The second matter said to be a protected act was that at a probationary meeting
on 11 May 2016, the Claimant spoke to Malcolm Venn about and/or segregation (Para
8b of List of Issues). Mr Venn made brief notes during the meeting (p84), and
afterwards he wrote up a note of the meeting to be given to the Claimant. Only the
Claimant and Mr Venn were present at the meeting. It included notification of a further
review of the Claimant’s probationary period to be held on 25 May.
131. This was the second of two discussions of note on 11 May 2016. The first was
the earlier dressing down by Mr Twining of the Claimant and Mr Lenihan referred to
above. In the probationary review meeting the Claimant raised the issue of his
Case Number 3200766/2016
24
grievance to Mr Twining of 21 April about the disagreement with Mr Lenihan on 14 April
about the timing of their handover discussion. As the Claimant raised this issue during
the probation review meeting on 11 May, Mr Venn wrote a letter/note to him confirming
the position (pp83A and 85).
132. In Mr Venn’s contemporaneous notes of the meeting, but not in the later minute,
he recorded “Black or White – There is racism”. The Tribunal considered that this was
compelling evidence that the Claimant had done the second protected act alleged. The
Respondent conceded that the Claimant had done a protected act here.
133. The third matter relied upon as a protected act, which the Respondent also
accepted, was that in a grievance dated 1 June 2016, the Claimant had mentioned
“race discrimination”. This is a reference to the grievance addressed to Mrs Gayle and
copied to others described above (at p110).
134. The first victimisation detriment complained about was that Malcolm Venn
allegedly prejudged and rejected the Claimant’s grievance dated 21 April 2016 (Para 9a
of List of Issues).
135. The Tribunal has already made findings above about the way the Respondent
dealt with the issue of the altercation between the Claimant and Mr Lenihan on 14 April,
and about the amicable solution of shaking hands on 6 May 2016. The conclusions
Mr Venn reached were based on the available evidence after an investigation.
136. The Claimant had not satisfied the Tribunal that Mr Venn had prejudged the
grievance or inappropriately rejected his grievance about Mr Lenihan. The claim failed
on that ground.
137. Further, in any event, there was no basis for inferring a connection with the first
protected act of 13 April 2016. That was an issue relating to an ethnic group (the Polish
workers) which did not include or have any connection with Mr Lenihan, or Mr Twining
or Mr Venn, all three of whom were White British. Further there was no evidence that
Mr Venn was aware of the 13 April email which was sent to Mr Twining. There was no
evidential basis put forward on which the Tribunal could rely to infer causation resulting
from the first protected act.
138. The second and third protected acts occurred after the detriment complained of,
so were not material.
139. In the circumstances this victimisation complaint was not well founded and was
dismissed on the basis that the Claimant had failed to establish the primary facts
alleged.
140. The second victimisation complaint was that Jeff Twining forced the Claimant to
release a defective bus into service on 11 May 2016. Only the first protected act had
taken place by the time of the conversation with Mr Twining on 11 May 2016 (transcript
p81B).
Case Number 3200766/2016
25
141. The Claimant had failed to establish that a defective bus was released into
service. The relevant contemporaneous evidence which was the transcript of the
dressing down conversation on 11 May 2016 recorded by the Claimant without the
knowledge of the other parties, suggested that Mr Twining backed down and apologised
once he realised that he was in error about the repair status of the bus. There was no
other explanation given. The error by Mr Twining was credible given the confusion
recorded about whether the bus was VOR. The error was also completely unrelated to
the doing of the protected act by the Claimant.
142. This complaint was also not well founded because the Claimant had failed to
establish the primary facts on the balance of probabilities. If the Tribunal had needed to
address the reason why, the evidence pointed overwhelmingly in the direction of an
innocent error by Mr Twining unrelated to the doing of the first protected act.
143. The third victimisation complaint was that Mr Venn told him during the probation
review meeting on 11 may 2016 that the Claimant must not “harbour conspiracy
theories”. The fact of those words having been used was not in dispute and appeared
in Mr Venn’s minute of the meeting (p82) which was addressed to the Claimant. The
context, as set out in the minute, was that Mr Venn understood the Claimant to be
alleging that Mr Twining had sent Mr Lenihan to provoke him in a systematic campaign
of harassment. This latter phrase and the description of Mr Twining’s alleged motives
were also captured in Mr Venn’s contemporaneous note (p84). It was noted in both
documents as having been discussed towards the end of the conversation. The
Claimant did not dispute that he had made the allegation about Mr Twining’s motives
that was noted. Mr Venn’s note was therefore accurate.
144. When he was questioned about what was objectionable about the comment, the
Claimant explained in his oral evidence that he believed that the reference to a
conspiracy implied that Mr Venn was saying that he was a terrorist. The Tribunal
accepted the Respondent’s submission that the Claimant appeared to have reached an
erroneous conclusion about the effect of Mr Venn’s words. The Tribunal did not
consider that the expression Mr Venn used referred to anything other than the
circumstances that the Claimant had just described to him. Further, it was clear from
the minute sent to the Claimant subsequently, that Mr Venn’s motive in referring to this
issue was to urge the Claimant to approach the remainder of his probation
constructively and not to become distracted by imputations of malevolent motives on the
part of his first line manager, Mr Twining. Mr Venn described in his note of the meeting
(at p83), that he had discussed with the Claimant if he had experienced similar
difficulties in other employment. It appeared to the Tribunal that this was yet further
evidence of his attempt to discuss the Claimant’s concerns and to encourage him to
complete his probation successfully
145. The Tribunal did not consider that there was any proper basis for concluding that
by using the phraseology which Mr Venn did, he thereby subjected the Claimant to a
detriment, in the circumstances.
146. The third victimisation complaint was therefore not well founded and was
dismissed.
Case Number 3200766/2016
26
147. The fourth victimisation complaint was that Vince Dalzell had prejudged the
probation review on 27 May 2016 by writing in an email on that date (pp96 – 97) that
‘…this guy has raised grievances and it ties in with him being seen next week for
unsatisfactory probation’. The email from Mr Dalzell followed Mr Tesfaye’s email to
Mr Cheema at 11.02 on 27 May in which he made allegations about poor standards of
work in the engineering Department, and bad practices. Mr Dalzell was copied in to that
email. Mr Dalzell’s comments were in an email he wrote to Mr Edwards and copied to
Mr Cheema. Apart from giving the background referred to above about the Claimant’s
probation, he went on in the brief email to suggest that Mr Edwards may want to
consider bringing someone in to audit the issues raised by the Claimant in his email to
Mr Cheema, as he anticipated that the Claimant may well make a claim. The Tribunal
accepted Mr Dalzell’s evidence about what he meant by these remarks (para 6 of his
witness statement [R10]).
148. These events pre-dated the third protected act. There was no direct evidence
that Mr Dalzell was aware of the detail of the first two protected acts, but he referred in
the email to the fact that the Claimant had by 27 May raised grievances. His evidence
was that he learnt this from Mr Venn who he had spoken to briefly in the seventeen
minutes between the time of the Claimant’s email and his email to Mr Edwards. There
was no evidence that there was any reference to the grievances being about race or
other protected characteristics under the Equality Act.
149. First, Mr Dalzell did not deal with the probation review. That was dealt with by
Mr Venn. Indeed, Mr Dalzell was not involved in any internal processes which related to
the Claimant. Mr Dalzell’s reference to the Claimant’s probationary review meeting was
clearly made as it was relevant to his view that the bad practices email from the
Claimant may well have been in response to his own job being under possible threat by
reason of unsatisfactory performance in his probation period.
150. Thus, it appeared to the Tribunal that even if Mr Dalzell had prejudged the
probation review, of which there was no evidence, he did not subject the Claimant to
any detriment as a result. Further, there was no adequate evidential basis for a
conclusion that his view about the Claimant was related to the fact that the Claimant
had done protected acts under the Equality Act 2010.
151. The fourth victimisation complaint therefore failed on the basis that the Claimant
had not been subjected to a detriment by Mr Dalzell. The complaint was not wellfounded
therefore, and was dismissed.
152. The fifth victimisation complaint was that Mrs Gayle (Operations Manager)
imposed a final written warning on the Claimant on 16 June 2016. This sanction was
imposed in relation to the serious disciplinary offence of failing to observe the
Respondent’s rules/procedures affecting the safety of employees or the public in
relation to the incident on 6 May 2016 when the Claimant signed the log confirming the
bus as fit for service when in fact it was carrying a major defect. The Tribunal has made
findings above about Mrs Gayle’s sanction. Here the Tribunal merely records that the
Claimant agreed that he had done what he was accused of doing, and that he had failed
to check for himself whether the bus was indeed fit for service, as he was required to
do.
Case Number 3200766/2016
27
153. Further, in relation to the allegation of race victimisation, there was no evidence
before the Tribunal that Mrs Gayle knew about the first two protected acts. The third
was in the text of a long letter attached to an email addressed to her and copied to three
others as described above (p116). It was sent on 1 June 2016. Mrs Gayle’s evidence
was that she did not take much note of the email as she was not dealing with the
grievance matters and Mr Dalzell said he would deal with it. She did not take the issue
any further with the Claimant.
154. The manager who responded to the email from the Claimant was indeed
Mr Dalzell on 6 June 2016 (p116). He explained to the Claimant that (1) Mrs Gayle was
dealing with the operational side of the depot and not the engineering department; (2)
he understood that the matters in Mr Tesfaye’s email were being investigated by
Mr Darren Bull, Engineering Manager; and (3) therefore Mr Dalzell would therefore be
forwarding the correspondence to Mr Bull. He concluding by suggesting that the
Claimant should address any future correspondence to Mr Bull. In all the
circumstances, there was no good reason to reject Mrs Gayle’s evidence about the
attention she gave to the letter of 1 June 2016 containing the third protected act, on the
balance of probabilities.
155. The Tribunal concluded that whilst the primary facts alleged were established in
relation to the fifth victimisation complaint, there was no reason to consider that the
penalty imposed was unjustified or too severe. The tribunal found above that it was
indeed lenient. In those circumstances, there was no proper basis for an inference that
the reason for the final written warning being imposed was because of the Claimant
having done a protected act.
156. The sixth and final alleged act of victimisation was the act of being dismissed on
23 June 2016 on the grounds of unsatisfactory probation. The Tribunal has already
made findings above in relation to the dismissal in the context of the direct race
discrimination complaints above.
157. In relation to the protected acts, all three had taken place before the decision to
dismiss. The first involved Mr Twining, and there was no evidence that Mr Venn was
aware of it. The second protected act occurred at a meeting with Mr Venn on 11 May to
review the probation. There was no evidence he saw the letter of 1 June to Mrs Gayle
or was aware of its contents.
158. The Tribunal concluded that the Claimant was dismissed because he failed his
probation for the reasons set out in the probation review outcome letter (pp136 – 137).
The evidence of interpersonal conflicts with a range of colleagues supported the
Respondent’s finding that he lacked interpersonal and communication skills. Further,
the contemporaneous documentary records confirmed the Respondent’s impression
that he was unable or unwilling to accept any shortcomings on his part. This meant that
there was no realistic prospect of improvement. The evidence confirmed that these
matters had been raised with the Claimant in the initial probation review in May (pp82 –
83). Further, as the Claimant had been the subject of an adverse disciplinary finding
which was not only serious but also reflected poorly on his communication skills in his
role, the decision to terminate the employment was fully explained.
Case Number 3200766/2016
28
159. In all the circumstances the Tribunal concluded that the sixth victimisation
complaint was not well founded and was dismissed.
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.