Mr Scott Bremner v L-Tec Controls Ltd: 4121900/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 01 August 2019, 11:12
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract redundancy working-time-regulations
- country
- scotland
- decision date
- 2019-03-04
Official Documents
-
Mr Scott Bremner v L-Tec Controls Ltd: 4121900/2018 - Judgment
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
E.T. Z4 (WR)
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS (SCOTLAND)
Case No: 4121900/2018
5
Held in Glasgow on 28 February 2019 (Final Hearing)
Employment Judge: Ian McPherson
Mr Scott Bremner Claimant 10
In Person
L-Tec Controls Ltd Respondents
Not present and
Not represented 15
JUDGMENT OF THE EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNAL
The judgment of the Employment Tribunal is that: -
20
(1) Having heard the claimant in person at this Final Hearing, and the respondents not having lodged any ET3 response defending the claim, and further not having appeared nor been represented, despite being issued with copy Notice of Final Hearing issued on 19 January 2019, the Tribunal finds that, on the basis of the information and material available to the Tribunal, all 25 three heads of complaint succeed, and makes this determination as to the liability of the respondents for the complaints brought by the claimant of (a) failure to pay a redundancy payment, (b) breach of contract (failure to pay notice pay), and (c) failure to pay holiday accrued but untaken at the effective date of termination of the claimant’s employment on 20 April 2018. 30
(2) Further, having considered the claimant’s evidence and additional vouching information provided post-Hearing, the Tribunal orders that the specific remedies to which the claimant is entitled for each of those successful heads of complaint are as follows: 35
4121900/2018 Page 2
(a) the claimant was dismissed by reason of redundancy and he is
entitled to a redundancy payment of TEN THOUSAND, FOUR
HUNDRED AND FOURTEEN POUNDS (£10,414.00), which
the respondents are ordered to pay to him;
5
(b) the claimant was dismissed in breach of contract in respect of
notice and the respondents are ordered to pay to him damages
in the sum of NINE THOUSAND, NINE HUNDRED AND
FORTY-FIVE POUNDS, AND SIXTY PENCE (£9,945.60) and
10
(c) the respondents failed to pay the claimant’s holiday entitlement
in respect of annual leave accrued but untaken, and they are
ordered to pay the claimant the sum of ONE THOUSAND AND
THIRTY-ONE POUNDS, AND TWENTY-TWO PENCE
15 (£1,031.22)
(3) In total, the respondents shall pay to the claimant the total amount of
TWENTY-ONE THOUSAND, THREE HUNDRED AND NINETY POUNDS,
AND EIGHTY-TWO PENCE (£21,390.82).
20
(4) Further, the Tribunal instructs the clerk to the Tribunal to send a copy of this
Judgment to the Registrar of Companies, at Companies House, 4th Floor,
Edinburgh Quay 2, 139 Fountainbridge, Edinburgh EH3 9FF, for information,
and consideration by the Registrar in respect of the respondents’ pending
25 application for strike-off from the Register of Companies, company number
SC133303, and for the Registrar to consider suspending that strike-off
application pending the respondents paying the claimant the sums ordered in
this Judgment.
4121900/2018 Page 3
REASONS
Introduction
5 1. This case called before me at 10.00am on the morning of Thursday, 28
February 2019, as per Notice of Final Hearing issued to both parties by the
Tribunal by letter dated 19 January 2019 assigning a 3-hour Final Hearing for
full disposal of the case, including remedy, if appropriate.
10 Notice of Claim
2. On 22 October 2018, following ACAS early conciliation between 9 and 22
October 2018, the claimant, acting on his own behalf, submitted an ET1 claim
form against the respondents, in respect of various complaints, arising from
15 termination of his employment with them as an Electrical Engineer / Design
Engineer on 20 April 2018.
3. The claimant described his claim as “for 25 years working service with LTec”,
and he stated that he had an entitlement of 20.5 weeks, and 225 hours
20 holiday pay entitlement before being made redundant. While section 9.2 of
the ET1 claim form invited him to state the sums he was seeking and give as
much detail as possible on how he had calculated the sums being sought, no
such specification was provided by the claimant at that stage. He simply
provided his start and end dates of employment, and his weekly gross and
25 net pay.
4. Thereafter, by Notice of Claim and Notice of Final Hearing dated 29 October
2018, copy of the ET1 claim was served on the respondents at the address
for service provided in the ET1 claim form, being their place of business, as
30 also their company registered office. The respondents were advised that their
ET3 response should be submitted to the Glasgow Tribunal Office by 26
November 2018 at latest.
4121900/2018 Page 4
5. Along with that Notice of Claim, the respondents were given Notice of the
Final Hearing arranged for 11.30am on Wednesday, 9 January 2019, and
advised that if they wished to apply for an extension of time to submit their
response, then they must do so before 26 November 2018 and, if their
5 response was not received by that date, and no extension of time had been
agreed by an Employment Judge, they would not be entitled to defend the
claim.
No Accepted Response, and Further Information required from the Claimant
10
6. Following a Rule 21 referral to Employment Judge Muriel Robison, on 3
December 2018, no ET3 having been received from the respondents, she
instructed that while it was possible to issue a Judgment without the need for
a Hearing, she considered there was insufficient information to issue a
15 Judgment at that stage, and so she required the claimant to provide additional
information, and details of the sums claimed from the respondents, by 14
December 2018 to allow a Judgment to be issued.
7. On 17 December 2018, when the file was referred to Employment Judge Jane
20 Garvie, she noted that there had been no response received from the
claimant, and so she requested further information within 7 days. The
claimant replied by email on 22 December 2018, and when his
correspondence was referred to Employment Judge Lucy Wiseman, on 28
December 2018, she sought clarification about his claim for holiday pay to be
25 provided no later than 4 January 2019.
8. The claimant replied, by email, on 2 January 2019, stating that his
employment with the respondents was terminated in April 2018 and he had
not taken any holidays up to that point. He did not respond to Judge
30 Wiseman’s request for clarification of the holiday year with the respondents.
9. However, the claimant did state that when he got his new employment, with
a new employer (as from7 May 2018, according to his ET1 claim form), he
4121900/2018 Page 5
was not entitled to holidays at the point when he was going on holiday,
therefore he submitted that : “I should be entitled to my full holiday
entitlement to cover my loss of wages”, his additional information provided
to the Tribunal on 22 December 2018 having stated that he was entitled to 20
5 days holidays from the respondents, and 9 statutory / bank holidays.
10. When his reply of 2 January 2019 was then referred to Employment Judge
Claire McManus, on 7 January 2019, she directed that the case proceed to
the listed Final Hearing on 9 January 2019 at 11:30am, as she stated that
10 evidence was required on the claimant’s entitlement to holidays.
Final Hearing relisted by the Tribunal
11. When the case called before Judge McManus, on 9 January 2019, no party
15 was present or represented, and when the Tribunal clerk telephoned the
claimant, it emerged that he did not attend as he did not receive the Tribunal’s
email of 7 January 2019 as, due to administrative error by Tribunal staff, it
was sent to the wrong email address and, anyway, the claimant advised that
he could not attend as he was working that day.
20
12. Fresh Notice of Final Hearing was issued on 19 January 2019, on instructions
from Judge McManus, setting aside 3 hours for its full disposal, including
remedy if appropriate. The respondents were sent a copy, for information
only, as they had not submitted an ET3 response, and they were advised that
25 while entitled to attend this Final Hearing, they would only be able to
participate to the extent permitted by the Judge hearing the case.
13. As per standard practice, the letter advised both parties that they should bring
3 copies of any relevant documents which they considered relevant to their
30 case and which they wished the Judge to take into account. Further, as per
the original Notice of Final Hearing, issued to both parties on 29 October
2018, the claimant was advised that unless the figures by way of his
calculation of claim were set out in the claim (which they were not), then he
4121900/2018 Page 6
should send to the respondents, within 14 days of that date, details of the
amount claimed and how it was calculated, and a copy of his calculation
should be brought to the Final Hearing.
5 14. Having received the Tribunal’s letter of 19 January 2019, the claimant
emailed the Tribunal, on 22 January 2019, asking if he had to be present at
this Final Hearing, or was it just for the respondents to be there? On 24
January 2019, a clerk to the Tribunal emailed the claimant advising him that
both parties were required to attend, and that the letter sent to him on 19
10 January 2019 explained further what was required, and if he needed any
further guidance or assistance, then he should contact ACAS or his local
CAB.
Final Hearing before this Tribunal
15
15. When the case called before me, on Thursday, 28 February 2019, the
claimant was in attendance, unrepresented, and unaccompanied. There was
no appearance by, or representation, for the respondents, and as they had
not lodged any ET3 response defending the claim, I decided to proceed in
20 their absence. The claimant only brought one document to this Hearing, that
being a copy of the additional information provided to the Tribunal on 22
December 2018.
16. That additional information, which he told me he had submitted by using
25 information on the Gov.Uk website, and from ACAS, stated that he was due
a redundancy payment for 25 years’ loyal service, holiday pay for 20 days’,
plus 9 days’ statutory / bank holidays, and 12 weeks’ pay in lieu of notice, but
no financial quantification was provided by the claimant of the actual mounts
sought by him.
30
17. When I enquired if the claimant had any “relevant documents” to produce
to the Tribunal, as per the Notice of Final Hearing, he stated that the
Tribunal’s correspondence was not clear, and he thought he had already
4121900/2018 Page 7
given what had been requested. That said, he stated he might have some
documents at home, and he could provide them as evidence of his former
employment with the respondents, and his wages, and holiday entitlement as
at 20 April 2018.
5
18. The claimant, in giving short, formal evidence to the Tribunal, confirmed the
terms of his ET1 claim form, and spoke of how, when he had been made
redundant by the respondents “out of the blue”, he and other employees had
been called in to attend a 12 noon meeting, convened by the company MD,
10 Bill Lavender, and Mr Lavender advising staff that they were being made
redundant, and the business ceasing to trade, with the doors shut, and the
company looking into insolvency.
19. Further, the claimant advised that he was aware from correspondence to him
15 from Companies House that the company, while not trading, had made an
application to be struck off the Companies Register, but he did not understand
it had gone into insolvency. The Tribunal clerk’s check of Companies House
showed the company as “Active - Active proposal to strike off”.
20 Reserved Judgment, and Documents received from the Claimant
20. The Final Hearing having concluded by 10.40am, I found the 3 heads of
complaint successful, but I otherwise reserved Judgment as I required to
assess in chambers any sums to be awarded against the respondents as
25 payable to the claimant, and I stated that I would give the case private
deliberation in chambers, as soon as possible, after the claimant provided me
with any relevant documents he wished me to take into account.
21. On the afternoon following the Hearing, by email dated 28 February 2019,
30 sent to the Glasgow Tribunal office at 13:40, the claimant submitted further
documents supporting his claim, being 3 copy pay slips from the respondents,
his P45 and P60 from them, and his P45 from his subsequent employer. His
copy payslips issued 4 weekly, were for weeks 48, 51 and 3, showing his
4121900/2018 Page 8
basic pay varied with the number of hours worked, and whether or not he had
any overtime or travel time added. They all showed a car allowance of £200
per 4 weeks. His final payslip, dated 20 April 2018, shows only basic pay at
£3,115.20, plus car allowance of £200, giving gross wages of £3,315.20, and
5 net wages of £2,426.37. Dividing those figures by 4, to get a weekly
equivalent, I compute that to be £828.80 gross, and £606.59 net per week.
Findings in Fact
10 22. Although not subject to any cross-examination, the claim being undefended,
and the respondents not present nor represented, the claimant’s evidence
was clarified by me as presiding Employment Judge asking him some
questions. I found the claimant to be a credible and reliable witness as to the
essential facts.
15
23. He spoke in evidence to the narrative of his claim, as set forth in the ET1
claim form, providing some further detail to what was stated there, and he
has now produced some additional documents supporting his claim against
the respondents. I have taken these vouching documents into account in
20 drafting my findings in fact.
24. On the basis of the evidence from the claimant heard by the Tribunal, and the
information provided in his ET1 claim form, and the copy documents
produced by the claimant and lodged with the Tribunal after the Hearing, I
25 have found the following essential facts established: -
(1) The claimant, aged 43 at the date of the Tribunal Hearing, was previously
employed by the respondents as an Electrical Engineer / Design Engineer.
30 (2) He worked out of the respondents’ business premises in Cumbernauld, where
Mr Bill Lavender, MD of the respondents, was the owner and operator of that
business, employing the claimant, and other staff.
4121900/2018 Page 9
(3) As at the effective date of termination of the claimant’s employment with the
respondents, being 20 April 2018, the claimant was working a 40-hour week,
Monday to Friday, for what he stated was £778 per week gross pay before
tax, and £606 per week net, normal take home pay, according to his ET1
5 claim form, along with a £200 per month car allowance from the
respondents. From the copy payslips produced to the Tribunal, after the
Hearing, I have computed a weekly £828.80 gross, and £606.59 net per
week.
10 (4) The claimant’s employment with the respondent started on 20 March 1993,
and ended on 24 April 2018, when his employment with the respondents
ended on account of redundancy. Post the Hearing, the claimant produced
copy of his P45 from the respondents, dated 23 April 2018, showing his
leaving date as 20 April 2018, with total earnings to date of £2,965.41
15
(5) The claimant advised the Tribunal that there had been no notification of
pending redundancies and no consultation process. Redundancy had come
“out of the blue” to him, and other employees.
20 (6) Further, the claimant advised that he had never been issued with written
particulars of employment by the respondents, and for that reason, he could
not produce a copy to the Tribunal. The claimant advised the Tribunal that he
was continuously employed by the respondents without any break in
continuity of service. Based on his start and end dates, he stated he had 25
25 years’ service with the respondents.
(7) He further advised that the company’s holiday year was January 1 to
December 31 each year, and that he had used his holidays in calendar year
2017, and been paid holiday pay, but he had not used any holidays in 2018,
30 and he had not been paid for any accrued annual leave untaken at 20 April
2018.
4121900/2018 Page 10
(8) The claimant also produced copy P60 from the respondents for the tax year
to 5 April 2018 showing total pay that tax year of £45,524.69.
(9) The claimant further advised the Tribunal that when he received his final pay,
5 he did not receive any pay in lieu of notice, nor holiday pay, and these sums
were still outstanding to him as at the date of this Final Hearing, as was a
redundancy payment from the respondents.
(10) No notice pay, or holiday pay, were included in his final payslip produced to
10 the Tribunal, dated 20 April 2018. He had not made any claim to the
Insolvency Service as the respondents were not insolvent, as far as he was
aware.
(11) While he knew the business premises in Cumbernauld were no longer
15 operating, and signs for “L-Tec Controls” had been removed, the claimant
understood that Mr Lavender’s company still owned those premises, and
while the company was seeking to be struck off the Companies Register, he
did not understand it had taken any steps to go into insolvency.
20 (12) Since his employment with the respondents ended, on 20 April 2018, the
claimant secured new employment with Clyde Control Engineers, as from 7
May 2018, paying him around £552 per week net.
(13) He stated that he worked there for 2 months or so, and, post the Hearing, he
25 produced copy of his P45 from that subsequent employer, dated 19 June
2018, showing his leaving date as 15 June 2018, and total pay to date of
33,926.66. He advised the Tribunal that he has since then been employed
and he is currently employed at Enterprise Control Engineers.
30 (14) In competing his ET1 claim form for the Tribunal, on advice from ACAS, the
claimant stated that he did not complete the box to state that he was
complaining of unfair dismissal, explaining that he did not believe the
respondents would answer that complaint, and he simply sought a
4121900/2018 Page 11
redundancy payment, with notice and holiday pay, following the guidance he
received from ACAS, advising that an unfair dismissal claim (although
mentioned on the ET1) “simply didn’t cross my mind.”
5 (15) As the claimant stated in evidence that he had only suffered one or two
months’ wage loss, by comparison of his earnings at Clyde Control
Engineers, compared with what he would have earned if still employed by the
respondents, he confirmed at this Final Hearing that he did not seek leave of
the Tribunal to amend his claim to seek a finding and compensation for unfair
10 dismissal, given he had not brought that complaint when lodging his ET1
claim form against the respondents.
Discussion and Deliberation
15 25. Having reflected on the case, I have now come to my final Judgment. I deal
with each of the 3 heads of complaint, separately, as in the following parts of
these my Written Reasons.
Redundancy Payment
20
26. In terms of Section 135 of the Employment Rights Act 1996, an employer
shall pay a redundancy payment to an employee of his, if the employee is
dismissed by the employer by reason of redundancy.
25 27. Redundancy is defined in Section 139, which provides that an employee who
is dismissed shall be taken to be dismissed by reason of redundancy, if the
dismissal is wholly or mainly attributable to the fact that his employer has
ceased or intends to cease to carry on the business for the purposes of which
the employee was employed by him, or to carry on that business in the place
30 where the employee was so employed, or the fact that the requirements of
that business for employees to carry out work of a particular kind, or for
employees to carry out work of a particular kind in the place where the
4121900/2018 Page 12
employee was employed by the employer, have ceased or diminished or are
expected to cease or diminish.
28. The claimant’s claim to the Tribunal for a redundancy payment constitutes a
5 reference to the Tribunal under Section 163. For the purposes of any such
reference, an employee who has been dismissed by his employer shall,
unless the contrary is proved, be presumed, in terms of Section 163 (2), to
have been so dismissed by reason of redundancy.
10 29. The respondents, although sent Notice of Claim, Notice of Final Hearing to
their place of business, which is also their registered office, did not contest
the claim, and while the statutory presumption of redundancy therefore
applies, I am satisfied on the evidence available to the Tribunal that there was
indeed a redundancy situation in the respondents’ business as at 20 April
15 2018. On the evidence before the Tribunal, it is clear that the claimant’s post
was made redundant with immediate effect as of that date.
30. Section 155 further provides that an employee does not have any right to a
redundancy payment unless the employee has been continuously employed
20 for a period of not less than 2 years ending with the date of redundancy.
Again, on the evidence before the Tribunal, it is clear that the claimant had
more than sufficient qualifying service to be entitled to a redundancy
payment.
25 31. The amount of a redundancy payment is calculated in accordance with
Section 162, and it is based on the individual claimant’s wages, age and
length of continuous employment with the employer. As at the effective date
of termination of employment on 20 April 2018, the claimant (date of birth: 11
January 1976) was aged 42, and he had 25 years’ continuous employment
30 with the respondents, giving him a right to a redundancy payment of 20.5
weeks’ pay.
4121900/2018 Page 13
32 In his ET1 claim form, the claimant stated his entitlement as 20.5 weeks, but
he did not specify the amount he believed he was due from the respondents.
His gross weekly wages from the respondent were £828.80 per week, based
on his gross 4 weekly wages payslip produced to the Tribunal. However, in
5 terms of Section 227 of the Employment Rights Act 1996, there is a
statutory limit on the amount of a weeks’ pay, and, as at 20 April 2018, that
statutory limit was £508 per week. Accordingly, the Tribunal has ordered that
the respondents shall pay to the claimant a redundancy payment in the sum
of £10,414, being £508 x 20.5, which is the appropriate sum.
10
Breach of Contract: Notice Pay
33. Next, I have considered the claim for breach of contract for failure to pay
notice pay to the claimant. Under the Employment Tribunals Extension of
15 Jurisdiction (Scotland) Order 1994, a breach of contract claim may be
brought before the Tribunal in respect of an employee’s claim for the recovery
of damages or any other sum if the claim arises or is outstanding on the
termination of employment. In this case, the claimant complains that he was
not paid any pay in lieu of notice.
20
34. Section 86 (1) of the Employment Rights Act 1996 provides rights for
employees to statutory minimum notice. The claimant having been employed
continuously by the respondents for 25 complete years, he is entitled to the
statutory maximum of 12 weeks’ pay in lieu of notice. The respondents are
25 in breach of contract by not paying the claimant his statutory minimum period
of notice.
35. Damages for breach of contract should be assessed on the basis of gross
weekly pay. Based on the claimant’s gross weekly pay of £828.80, I compute
30 that the sum payable is £9,945.60, being £828.80 x 12. Accordingly, the
Tribunal orders the respondents to pay that sum to the claimant as damages
for breach of contract.
4121900/2018 Page 14
Accrued Holiday Pay
36. I turn finally to accrued holiday pay. This aspect of the claim proceeds as a
complaint under Regulation 30 of the Working Time Regulations 1998.
5 On the basis of the evidence before the Tribunal, I am satisfied that the
claimant took no holidays, and was paid no holiday pay, for his employment
between 1 January and 20 April 2018. While the claimant sought payment for
a whole year’s holiday entitlement of 29 days, that is not his right, and I cannot
award more than is his legal entitlement.
10
37. Based on the claimant’s actual net weekly wages, assessed at £606.59 per
week, calculated from his vouched net weekly wages, shown on his payslips
produced to the Tribunal, that gives a daily rate @ £121.32. Applying that
rate to his entitlement of 8.5 days, as calculated by the GOV.UK online
15 holiday pay calculator, it produces a sum of £1,031.22, which is the sum that
the Tribunal has ordered the respondents to pay to him, as the appropriate
and proportionate annual leave entitlement accrued but not taken by him from
I January 2018, the start of the calendar holiday year, to 20 April 2018, the
latter date being the effective date of termination of his employment with the
20 respondents.
Intimation to Registrar of Companies, Edinburgh
38. In writing up this Judgment, given the pending application for Strike-Off, I
25 have instructed the clerk to the Tribunal to send a copy of this Judgment to
Companies House for information, and consideration by the Registrar in
respect of the respondents’ pending application for strike-off from the
Register of Companies.
30
Employment Judge Ian McPherson
35 Date of Judgment 04 March 2019
4121900/2018 Page 15
Entered in register
and copied to parties 04 March 2019
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.