Mrs C Lofty v Mr S Harris: 3400331/2016
Employment Tribunal
Published on 22 June 2017, 14:00
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract disability-discrimination unfair-dismissal working-time-regulations
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2017-05-16
Change History
-
A certificate of correction and a new decision has been issued.
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number: 3400331/2016
Judgment - Rule 61 1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Mrs C Lofty
Respondent Mr S Hamis
HEARD AT: NORWICH ON: 23rd March 2017
BEFORE: Employment Judge Postle
MEMBERS: Mrs B Handley Howarth
REPRESENTATION
For the Claimant: Ms R Snoken (Counsel)
For the Respondent: Mr S Hamis (In person)
REMEDY JUDGMENT
1. The Respondent is ordered to pay to the Claimant a basic award of £4026.
2. The Respondent is ordered to pay to the Claimant a compensatory award in
the sum of £2165.50.
3. The Respondents are ordered to pay to the Claimant the issue and setting
down fee total £1200.
4. The award is subject to Recoupment.
5. Total award payable to the Claimant is £7,391.50.
REASONS
1. This is a Remedy Judgment pursuant to the liability hearing before the
Tribunal between the 24th and 27th October 2016. A Reserved Judgment
being promulgated on the 9th December in which the Tribunal found the
Claimant did not satisfy the definition of disability under Section 6 of the
Case Number: 3400331/2016
Judgment - Rule 61 2
Equality Act 2010. The Tribunal did find that the Claimants dismissal under
the Employment Rights Act 1996 was procedurally unfair.
2. In this Remedy Hearing it was agreed with the parties consent that the
Tribunal could be comprised of one member in the absence of Mr Briggs who
sat on the Liability Hearing. Mr Briggs has now retired and was unable to
attend today’s hearing due to a medical appointment.
3. In this Tribunal we heard evidence from the Claimant through a prepared
witness statement. The Tribunal also heard evidence from the proprietor of
the respondents Mr Hamis again through a prepared witness statement. The
Tribunal also had the benefit of a bundle of documents consisting of
140 pages.
4. The first port of call is the basic award and under Section 120 of the
Employment Rights Act 1996 the Claimant is entitled to a basic award and
that sum given the Claimants age, the date of dismissal and the number of
complete years of service equates to £4026 – that amount the Tribunal
understand there is no dispute about.
5. As to the compensatory award that is dealt with under Section 123 the
Employment Rights Act and the amount of the compensatory award shall be
such amount as the Tribunal considers just and equitable in all the
circumstances having regard to the loss sustained by the Complainant in
consequence of the dismissal in so far as that loss is attributable to action
taken by the employer. Claims for damages at common law are subject to
rule that the Claimant must take all reasonable steps to mitigate their losses.
The mitigation rule is given statutory force in it’s application to compensatory
awards in unfair dismissal cases under Section 123, sub-section 4 again of
the Employment Rights Act provides that in ascertaining the loss sustained
by the Claimant the Tribunal shall apply the same rule concerning the duty of
a person to mitigate his or her loss as applies to damages recoverable under
the common law of England and Wales or as the case may be Scotland.
6. Therefore, an employee who has been unfairly dismissed should take all
reasonable steps to find alternative employment and thus mitigate their loss.
Now as to mitigation the Tribunal have seen little evidence of the Claimant
actually looking for employment roles following her dismissal, or even parttime
ones immediately after her dismissal. Indeed as early as the Claimant
was making her claim for Employment Support Allowance [and that seems to
be certainly from the documentation in the bundle around about the
4th December] she was being advised that she was fit for work and should
apply for part-time roles. On the 23rd February the Claimant is converted to
Job Seekers Allowance presumably on the basis at that stage she was now
deemed fit for work equivalent to that which she had formerly performed in
hours for the Respondents (approximately 30 hours). Again the Tribunal
have seen little or no evidence of the Claimant applying for roles equivalent
in hours to that which she previously worked namely 30 hours per week. In
fact the Tribunal has seen only one form from the Job Seekers showing that
the Claimant applied for two jobs both through Norse in which she was
certainly successful in obtaining one position from the 11th April 2016 for
12.5 hours per week term time only. There is no evidence to support the fact
Case Number: 3400331/2016
Judgment - Rule 61 3
the Claimant was applying for further jobs thereafter to make up her hours
until a further part-time position was obtained in December 2016.
7. Therefore, subject to any deductions the Tribunal would make further on we
are satisfied that the Claimant has not fully applied her common law duty to
mitigate her loss and therefore we would stop any damages at the date of
11th April. The Tribunal drawing on their experience and knowledge of the
job market in the area are satisfied there were an abundance of jobs working
in a similar field of catering, with similar hours the Claimant could and should
have applied for and could have obtained by April 2016.
8. The Claimant having been paid twelve weeks notice pay brings it to the
29th February 2016 that means the amount payable for the compensatory
award is six weeks from 29th February to 12th April. It is agreed that the net
pay is £188.50 per week, six weeks amounts to £1,131.
9. The next area to look at under Section 123 of the Employment Rights Act is
Polkey whether the unfairly dismissed employee could have been dismissed
fairly at a later stage or if a proper procedure had been followed. In that
respect a Polkey deduction has particular features, first the assessment is a
predictive matter – could the employer fairly have dismissed and if so what
were the chances that the employer would have done so, the chances may
have been at the extreme certainly that it would have dismissed or certainly
that it would not have dismissed though more usually will fall somewhere on
a spectrum between those two extremes. That is to recognize the
uncertainties in dealing with a Polkey deduction. A Tribunal is not called
upon to decide the question on balance, it is not answering the question what
it would have done if it were the employer, it is assessing the chances of
what another person the actual employer would have done. The Tribunal
repeat it is predictive as to what this employer would have done. In our view
had the Claimant attended a meeting with Mr Hamis before dismissal and
explained a prognosis and gave a possible planned return or a hopeful return
in the next month there was a 100% chance the Claimant would not have
been dismissed, therefore there is no Polkey deduction.
10. On the issue of contribution under Section 123 sub-section 6 of the
Employment Rights Act; where the Tribunal finds that the dismissal was to
any extent caused or contributed to or by any action of the employee the
Tribunal shall reduce the compensation payable by such proportion as it
considers is just and equitable. What constitutes contributory conduct; the
relevant action must be culpable or blame worthy, it must have actually
caused or contributed to the dismissal and it must be just and equitable to
reduce the compensation.
11. The Tribunal reminds itself again the decision at the Liability Hearing and the
reason for dismissal was the failure of the Claimant to engage or attend
meetings with her employer Mr Hamis and discuss her health position,
possible return to work and, planned phased return or otherwise. There was
a failure to engage by the Claimant. Had she have done so we might not
have been here today. An employer is entitled to have information when he
reasonably requests it about the likely return to work. The Claimant had
been off since around the 17th August with minor surgery, the biopsy
Case Number: 3400331/2016
Judgment - Rule 61 4
fortunately for the Claimant proved non-malignant, a skin graft was
necessary and by December the Claimant was still not engaging and not
able to provide her employer with any meaningful return date to work. The
operation or the last operation for the skin graft concluded at the latest in
September and thereafter the Claimant was recovering and despite one
meeting in October the Claimant was unwilling to attend or engage with her
employer or give any indication of a likely return to work despite at least four
requests from her employer to come in and talk about it, and a request for
consent to approach her GP. That failure to engage with Mr Hamis the
Tribunal believe is culpable and blame worthy conduct. In those
circumstances the Tribunal concluded it is appropriate to reduce
compensation, it actually caused the Claimants dismissal had she engaged
reasonably and properly with Mr Hamis, the Tribunal repeat we would not be
here today.
12. Therefore the compensation referred to above of £1,131 will be reduced by
50% giving a sum of £565.50. To that sum add to basic award of £4026;
loss of Statutory Rights we assess at £400, we make no award for the bus
pass. The Claimant is clearly entitled to her issue fee of £250 and setting
down fee of £950 which makes a total award payable by Mr Hamis of
£7391.50.
13. This award is subject to recoupment for the period 29th February 2016 to
11th April 2016.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Postle, Norwich
Date: 16 May 2017
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
........................................................................
........................................................................
FOR THE SECRETARY TO THE TRIBUNALS
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.