Ms A Adeleke v Tesco Stores Ltd: 3302923/2020
Employment Tribunal
Published on 27 January 2023, 08:38
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract disability-discrimination unlawful-deduction-from-wages working-time-regulations
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2022-12-07
Change History
-
Judgment Added
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number:3302923/2020
ph judgment + cm Nov 1 2014 wip version
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Ms A Adeleke v Tesco Stores Limited
PRELIMINARY HEARING
Heard at: Watford On: 2 August 2021
Before: Employment Judge Alliott (sitting alone)
Appearances:
For the Claimant: In person
For the Respondents: Ms A Smith (Counsel)
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the tribunal is that:
1. At all material times from 15 April 2018 to 5 March 2020, the claimant was a
disabled person within the meaning of s.6 of the Equality Act 2010 by reason of
lumbar disc degeneration.
2. At all material times from 15 April 2018 to 5 March 2020, the claimant was not a
disabled person within the meaning of s.6 of the Equality Act 2010 by reason of
stress and anxiety.
REASONS
1. This open preliminary hearing was ordered by Employment Judge Bedeau on 16
November 2020 to determine the following issues:
1.1 Whether at all material times during the claimant’s employment with the
respondent she had a physical and mental impairment, namely lumbar
disc degeneration and stress and anxiety?
1.2 If so, do the impairments have a substantial adverse effect on the
claimant’s ability to carry out normal day to day activities?
1.3 If so, is that effect long-term. In particular:
Case Number:3302923/2020
ph judgment + cm Nov 2 2014 wip version
1.3.1 When did it start?
1.3.2 Have the impairments lasted at least 12 months?
1.3.3 Or were the impairments likely to last at least 12 months or for the
rest of the claimant’s life?
The law
2. Section 6 of the Equality Act 2010 provides as follows:
“6 Disability
(1) A person (P) has a disability if –
(a) P has a physical or mental impairment, and
(b) The impairment has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on P’s ability
to carry out normal day to day activities.”
3. In addition, I have the guidance on the definition of disability (2011). In particular:
“A7 It is not necessary to consider how an impairment is caused, even if the cause
is a consequence of a condition which is excluded… what is important to
consider is the effect of an impairment, not its cause.”
“B1 The requirement that an adverse effect on normal day to day activities should
be a substantial one reflects the general understanding of disability as a
limitation going beyond the normal differences in ability which may exist
among people. A substantial effect is one that is more than a minor or trivial
effect.”
4. The burden on establishing disability is on the claimant.
5. Ms Smith has cited two cases to me as follows:-
5.1 J v DLA Piper UK LLP [2010] ICR 1052 where Underhill J said there is a
distinction between:
“… two states of affairs which can produce broadly similar symptoms: Those
symptoms can be described in various ways, but will be sufficiently understood if we
refer to them as symptoms of low mood and anxiety. The first state of affairs is a
mental illness – or, if you prefer, a mental condition – which is conveniently referred
to as “clinical depression” and is unquestionably an impairment within the meaning
of the Act. The second is not characterised as a mental condition at all but simply as
a reaction to adverse circumstances (such as problems at work) or – if the jargon
may be forgiven – “adverse life events”. We dare say that the value or validity of
that distinction could be questioned at the level of deep theory; and even if it is
accepted in principle the borderline between the two states of affairs is bound often
to be very blurred in practice. But we are equally clear that it reflects a distinction
which is routinely made by clinicians… and which should in principle be recognised
for the purposes of the Act. We accept that it may be a difficult distinction to apply
in a particular case; and the difficulty can be exacerbated by the looseness with
Case Number:3302923/2020
ph judgment + cm Nov 3 2014 wip version
which some medical professionals, and most lay people, use such terms as
“depression” (“clinical” or otherwise), “anxiety” and “stress”. Fortunately, however,
we would not expect those difficulties often to cause a real problem in the context of
a claim under the Act. This is because of the long-term effect requirement. If, as we
recommend at paragraph 40(2) above, a Tribunal starts by considering the adverse
effect issue and finds that the claimant’s ability to carry out normal day to day
activities has been substantially impaired by symptoms characteristic of depression
for 12 months or more, it would in most cases be likely to conclude that he or she
was indeed suffering “clinical depression” rather than simply a reaction to adverse
circumstances: it is a common-sense observations that such reactions are not
normally long lived.”
5.2 The case of Herry v Dudley Metropolitan Council [2017] ICR 610 where Mr
Justice Richardson stated:-
“Although reactions to adverse circumstance are indeed not normally long lived,
experience shows there is a class of case where a reaction to circumstances
perceived as adverse can become entrenched; where a person concerned will not
give way or compromise over an issue at work, and refuses to return to work, yet in
other respects suffers no or little apparent adverse effect on normal day to day
activities. A doctor may be more likely to refer to the presentation of such an
entrenched position as stress than as anxiety or depression. An Employment
Tribunal is not bound to find that there is a mental impairment in such a case.
Unhappiness with a decision or a colleague, a tendency to nurse grievances, or a
refusal to compromise (if these or similar findings are made by an Employment
Tribunal) are not of themselves mental impairments: They may simply reflect a
person’s character or personality. Any medical evidence in support of a diagnosis of
mental impairment must of course be considered by an Employment Tribunal with
great care; so must any evidence of adverse effect over an above an unwillingness to
return to work until an issue is resolved to the employee’s satisfaction; but in the end
the question whether there is a mental impairment is one for the Employment
Tribunal to assess.”
6. The evidence
6.1 I heard oral evidence from the claimant. In addition, I was provided with a
265-page preliminary hearing bundle which included the claimant’s impact
statement.
7. The facts
7.1 I have been provided with a letter dated 5 May 2016 from a consultant
psychiatrist from the Tavistock Trauma Service. This states:-
“Ms Adeleke has been under my care in the Tavistock Trauma Service since 2010.
She has a diagnosis of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and depression which is
treated with a combination of medication and psychotherapy.”
7.2 I have little hesitation in finding that the claimant does have the mental
impairments of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and depression, and that
that has been long lasting. I have taken this diagnosis into account in my
assessment of this case. In particular, the claimant told me that she was
discharged from the Tavistock Trauma Service in January 2018.
Case Number:3302923/2020
ph judgment + cm Nov 4 2014 wip version
7.3 An Occupational Health Report dated 4 July 2019 states:-
“[The claimant] states she was diagnosed with depression relating to personal issues
which are now resolved and she is not on any medication for this.”
7.4 The claimant agrees that the diagnosis of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
and depression was different from the disability that she relies upon in this
case.
7.5 The disability that the claimant relies upon is anxiety/stress. Being an
allegation of mental impairment so, for obvious reasons, I have relied
significantly on the contemporaneous medical evidence and description of
its impact.
7.6 The claimant has disclosed her GP notes, though it appears there may be
some gaps. It can be seen that in March and April 2018, prior to the
claimant’s employment with the respondent, the claimant attended her GP
with depressed mood and the presenting problem is recorded as “anxiety
with depression”.
7.7 On 10 April 2018, prior to the claimant’s contract of employment starting,
the claimant completed a customer service assessment health
questionnaire form. The claimant ticked “No” to questions relating to her
ability to deal with customers in a calm way and to a question asking if the
claimant had any disability health problem or illness that the respondent
needed to consider when placing her. However, I place little reliance on
this document as the claimant was seeking employment and may well not
have flagged up her depression. There are, after all, entries in her GP
notes for 11 and 13 April 2018 referring to anxiety with depression.
7.8 On 22 May 2018 the claimant went to her GP with the presenting problem
being described as “stress at work”. The history is set out as follows:
“Patient is having stress at work, working at Tesco’s – night shifts and issues are
with the management, it is causing a lot of anxiety…”
7.9 In the examination section the following is recorded:
“Well, systemically mentally.”
7.10 On 22 May 2018 the claimant presented a fit note citing “stress at work”.
7.11 On the claimant’s return to work a stress risk assessment was undertaken
by the respondent on 30 May 2018. In particular, the claimant was asked
if there was anything else at work or home that caused her to feel stressed
or may have contributed to work related stress and her answer “no” is
recorded.
7.12 On 3 September 2018 the claimant attended her GP. The initial
presenting history is as follows:-
Case Number:3302923/2020
ph judgment + cm Nov 5 2014 wip version
“Says two days ago for the first time had panic attack. Explained to describe her
symptoms, she said, that she was walking fast (she works at Tesco) and she got SOB
(shortness of breath) and had to breathe quickly and shallow. No palpitations ?? and
rather slow HR (heart rate).”
7.13 Later on that day the claimant was seen by another doctor who records
the presenting history as follows:-
“Very stressful job, at dot.com on Saturday was feeling v stressed and out of depth,
had episode where she could feel her heartbeat very slow, room “felt dark” and felt
she had to breathe deeply says has been feeling anxious for past few months, but also
these symptoms
on Saturday quit job …. feels relieved now.”
7.14 Following that consultation the claimant’s GP wrote a “To whom it may
concern” letter dated 3 September 2018 stating as follows:-
“This is a letter to confirm that the above patient came to see me today at the GP
surgery with symptoms of breathlessness and episodes which may be related to
anxiety and stress.”
7.15 On 25 March 2019 the claimant presented a fit note citing “Lower back
pains and work related stress”. There is no corresponding entry in the GP
records for that date which leads me to believe that some of those records
are missing.
7.16 On 4 July 2019 Occupational Health reported on the claimant. This report
states:-
“[The claimant] complained of work-related issues and I understand this was the
reason for her recent absence… [The claimant] states that she was diagnosed with
depression relating to personal issues, which are now resolved, and she is not on any
medication for this. Although, she occasionally experiences low mood (especially
during winter period) but presently, she states that her symptom is not troublesome.”
7.17 The Occupational Health practitioner who made that report is a specialist
practitioner in Occupational Health.
7.18 On 21 August 2019 the claimant attended at her GP. The presenting
problem is recorded as “anxiety states” but it would appear that I am
missing the rest of that entry.
7.19 On 18 September 2019 the claimant presented a fit-note citing “back
pain/stress”.
7.20 On 8 October 2019 the claimant attended at her GP with the presenting
history being described as follows:-
“Patient been booked in for asthma review, but does not have any asthma diagnosis.
Explained that she suffers from anxiety and this has caused her to have some heavy
breathing.”
Case Number:3302923/2020
ph judgment + cm Nov 6 2014 wip version
7.21 The problem is described as “anxiety with depression”
7.21 In addition I have the claimant’s impact statement. Having re-read her
impact statement the claimant told me right at the outset that it was really
dealing with her lumbar condition. During the course of her evidence the
claimant accepted it did not adequately address any adverse effects
resulting from her anxiety/stress. I have considered the impact statement
carefully and it is true that it does refer to a number of issues such as
insomnia and lack of motivation. However, in my judgment, it falls short of
establishing that any anxiety or stress had a substantial adverse effect on
the claimant’s ability to undertake day to day activities. The restriction on
the claimant’s day to day activities, whether physical or in terms of
motivation, in my judgment and I find, are restricted to those generated by
the claimant’s lumbar disc degeneration.
7.22 The claimant referred to a massive decline in her mental health and
indeed feeling suicidal. In my judgment, the medical evidence I have
simply does not bear out these matters. The medical evidence that has
been placed before me, such as it is, is limited. The GP notes appear to
record six relevant visits at best between the start of her employment in
April 2018 to December 2019. These are periodic visits citing stress at
work or raising breathing issues. At a mid point in July 2019 occupational
health reports occasional low mood which was not troublesome at that
time.
7.23 The claimant has pointed to her absence record of 17% as being relevant
to the assessment of whether she had a mental impairment. I accept that
the fit note cited back pain as well as stress but that does not assist me in
coming to a conclusion as to whether or not the claimant has a mental
impairment.
7.24 In my judgment, the claimant does not have a mental impairment of
stress/anxiety. In my judgment, the claimant’s evidence demonstrates that
in this case and at that time she fell to the side whereby such stress as
she experienced was an adverse reaction to her work situation which was
perceived to be unpleasant.
7.25 Accordingly, I find that the claimant did not have a mental impairment of
anxiety/stress at all relevant times.
7.26 Even if I were wrong about that, my review of the contemporaneous
medical records demonstrates that any such condition did not have a
substantial adverse effect on the claimant’s ability to undertake normal day
to day activities. The restrictions recorded in the GP notes relate to
breathlessness and being short of breath when walking quickly. In my
judgment these are not substantial adverse effects. The impact statement
essentially describes the impact of pain from her back and lacks any
specific examples relating to the anxiety/stress.
Case Number:3302923/2020
ph judgment + cm Nov 7 2014 wip version
____________________
Employment Judge Alliott
Date: 18/8/2021
Sent to the parties on:
26/8/2021
N Gotecha
For the Tribunal:
3302923/2020
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Adejumoke Adeleke
Respondent: Tesco Stores Limited
JUDGMENT
The claim is struck out.
REASONS
1. By a letter dated 18 September 2022 the Tribunal notified the claimant of a hearing in
which the respondent’s strike out application would be considered on 7 December 2022. The
respondent’s grounds are
The manner in which the proceedings have been conducted by the claimant has been
scandalous, unreasonable or vexatious.
For non-compliance with order osf the tribunal namely of 17 May 2022 and 24 July 2022.
The claim has not been actively pursued.
It is no longer possible to have a fair trial in respect of the claim.
2. The claimant has failed to make any sufficient representations, why this should not be
done. The parties were ordered to exchange statements giving evidence they wished to rely on
in respect of the strike out issues together with documents upon which they intended to rely. The
claimant did not provide a written statement or attend the hearing. She indicated she did not
intend to join the hearing as ‘there is no justice and the tribunal had won’.
The claim is therefore struck out.
_____________________________
7 December 2022
Employment Judge Allen
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
19/1/2023
NG - FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.