Ms E Domagala v Eunice Artisan Bakery Ltd: 3305188/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 03 December 2019, 10:27
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
sex-discrimination unfair-dismissal unlawful-deduction-from-wages
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2019-10-10
Change History
-
Reasons attached.
-
Judgment attached.
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No: 3305188/2018
1.18 UDL – length of service - strike out judgment -.part claim
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Ms E Domagala
Respondent: Eunice Artisan Bakery Limited
Heard at: Cambridge On: 29 March 2019
Before: Employment Judge Foxwell (sitting alone)
Appearances
For the claimant: Ms D Janusz (Litigation Executive)
For the respondent: Mr M Laskowski (Director)
JUDGMENT
The complaint that the claimant was unfairly dismissed is struck out.
REASONS
1. The claimant complains of unfair dismissal.
2. Section 108 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 requires a claimant to
have not less than two years service to make an unfair dismissal
complaint.
3. The claimant was employed by the respondent for less than two years and
she does not allege that the reason for dismissal was one to which the
requirement for two years service does not apply.
4. Therefore the claimant is not entitled to bring such a complaint.
5. Accordingly, the complaint of unfair dismissal is struck out. The claimant’s
other complaints, including her claim that she was constructively
dismissed and that this was an act of sex discrimination, are not affected
by this judgment.
________________________
Employment Judge Foxwell
Case No: 3305188/2018
1.18 UDL – length of service - strike out judgment -.part claim
Date: 29 March 2019
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
17 April 2019
........................................................................
FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Case No: 3305188/2018
10.2 Judgment - rule 61 February
2018
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Ms. E. Domagala
Respondent: Eunice Artisan Bakery Limited
Heard at: Bury St. Edmunds On: 8th to 10th October 2019
Before: Employment Judge: Mr A. Spencer
Ms. S. Stones (non-legal member)
Mrs. S. Blunden (non-legal member)
Representation:
Claimant: Ms. D. Janusz (Litigation Executive)
Respondent: Mr. M. Laskowski (Director)
JUDGMENT
1. It is declared that the Respondent unlawfully discriminated against the
Claimant by sexual harassment of her; and
2. The Respondent is ordered to pay to the Claimant compensation of £8,915.40
to include:
(a) compensation for injury to feelings assessed at £8500; and
(b) an additional award pursuant to section 38 Employment Act 2002 of
£415.40.
3. It is declared that the Respondent unlawfully deducted the sum of £120 from
the Claimant’s wages; and
4. The Respondent is ordered to pay the said sum of £120 to the Claimant.
_____________________________
Employment Judge: Mr. A Spencer
Date___10 October 2019__________________
JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON
.....................................................................................
Case No: 3305188/2018
10.2 Judgment - rule 61 February
2018
......................................................................................
FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE
Notes
Reasons for the judgment having been given orally at the hearing, written reasons will not be
provided unless a request was made by either party at the hearing or a written request is presented
by either party within 14 days of the sending of this written record of the decision.
Public access to employment tribunal decisions
Judgments and reasons for the judgments are published, in full, online at www.gov.uk/employmenttribunal-
decisions shortly after a copy has been sent to the claimant(s) and respondent(s) in a case.
Case No: 3305188/2018
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Ms. E Domagala v Eunice Artisan Bakery Limited
Heard at: Bury St Edmunds On: 8, 9 & 10 October 2019
Before: Employment Judge: Mr. A Spencer
Ms. S Stones (non-legal member)
Mrs. S Blunden (non-legal member)
Appearances:
For the Claimant: Ms. D Janusz (Litigation Executive)
For the Respondent: Mr. M Laskowski (Director)
Interpreter: Ms. M Dubiel – Language: Polish.
JUDGMENT having been sent to the parties on 14 October 2019 and reasons
having been requested in accordance with Rule 62(3) of the Rules of Procedure
2013, the following reasons are provided:
REASONS
Introduction
1. The claimant worked for the respondent as a sales assistant from
October 2016. Her employment ended on about 14 November 2017 when
she resigned without giving notice. The claimant went through early
conciliation with ACAS between 6 February and 20 March 2018. She
presented her claim form to the tribunal on 23 March 2018. The claim form
raised complaints of unfair dismissal, sex discrimination, unlawful deduction
from wages and failure to pay holiday pay.
2. The unfair dismissal claim was struck out following a hearing on
29 March 2019 because the claimant did not have 2 years’ service with the
respondent by the time her employment ended.
3. The claimant withdrew her claim for holiday pay during this hearing.
4. That left the following complaints for us to determine:
4.1 a complaint of sex discrimination; and
4.2 a claim for failure to pay wages.
Case No: 3305188/2018
2
5. The claims and the issues arising from those claims were clarified at the
hearing on 29 March 2019. The key allegations and the legal provisions
under which the claims are brought are set out in paragraph 8 of the case
management summary prepared following the hearing on 29 March.
6. The respondent denies the claims for the reasons set out in its Response.
Witnesses
7. The claimant submitted witness evidence from two witnesses, they were the
claimant herself Mr. Rafal Kalinowski. Mr. Kalinowski did not attend to give
evidence before us. We were asked to take his written statement into
account.
8. For the respondent we heard evidence from two witnesses,
Mr. Marcin Laskowski the owner of the respondent company and
Mr. Krzysztof Szydlowski a confectioner employed by the respondent.
9. With the exception of Mr. Kalinowski the witnesses gave evidence under
affirmation and confirmed the truth of their written statements. We had the
benefit of seeing the evidence of each witness tested under cross
examination and the opportunity to put questions to each witness ourselves.
Documentary Evidence
10. We took into account the contents of an agreed hearing bundle and six
additional pages of text messages exchanged between the claimant and
Mr. Szydlowski in November 2017. These additional documents were
produced by the claimant on the morning of the first day of the hearing. We
provided the respondent with additional time to consider these new
documents and on this basis the respondent did not object to these
additional documents being taken into account.
11. The claimant sought to rely on further evidence that she produced on the
morning of the second day of the hearing. This consisted of text messages
from another witness. The claimant sought to rely on the evidence of that
new witness. The evidence of that witness was set out in the form of a text
message rather than a witness statement. The respondent objected to us
taking into account this new material from a witness who was not being
called to give evidence before us. We refused the claimant’s application for
the reasons we gave at the time. We have not taken that additional evidence
into account.
Findings of Fact
12. Having heard the evidence our findings of fact are as follows:
12.1 The respondent is a company in business as a bakery. They employ
approximately 18 employees at a single site. The company is owned
and run by Mr. Laskowski.
Case No: 3305188/2018
3
12.2 The claimant was employed by the respondent from October 2016
as a sales assistant.
12.3 Mr. Krzysztof Szydlowski is employed by the respondent as a
confectioner. He began employment with the respondent in
May 2017.
12.4 The claimant and Mr. Szydlowski were work colleagues and had
common acquaintances. However, they were not friends outside
work other than assisting each other from time to time. For example,
the claimant helped Mr. Szydlowski with a mobile phone and by
collecting him from the airport.
12.5 The claimant was not provided with a written contract of employment
or a written statement setting out the main terms and conditions of
her employment. The only document she was provided with was a
brief email which is at page 60 of the hearing bundle which merely
confirmed the claimant’s employment status, working hours, pay, job
title, annual holiday entitlement and prohibited smoking on the
premises.
12.6 The respondent has a harassment and bullying policy, and a
grievance procedure. However, these documents were kept in a
manager’s office and the staff were not aware of them or their terms.
Mr. Laskowski’s evidence was that the documents were not provided
to the employees who were simply told that if they had a problem at
work, they should raise it with their manager in the first instance,
failing which they should raise it with him. Consequently, the policy
had little practical relevance.
12.7 The claimant worked on a part time basis. She worked a total of
16 hours per week, working two days a week on a Saturday and a
Monday. She was paid £450 per month by the time her employment
ended. We calculate this to be £6.49 per hour. That calculation
starts with annual pay of £5,400 which is £450 per month multiplied
by 12 months. The claimant’s annual working hours were 832 hours
which is 16 hours per week multiplied by 52 weeks. Dividing the
annual pay by the annual hours gives a figure of £6.49 per hour. That
figure is below the applicable National Minimum Wage rate which at
the time was £7.50 per hour.
12.8 By late 2017 the claimant was not intending to remain in the
respondent’s employment for much longer. She was finding the job
difficult to juggle with childcare and intended to leave. She intended
to begin looking for another job in December 2017 and to leave once
she found suitable work. That would most likely have been by the
end of January 2018. The claimant informed Mr. Laskowski of this.
Mr. Laskowski said the claimant had given notice but we do not
accept this. The claimant did not make any clear statement that she
would leave on a particular date. The claimant had children to
support, she was intending to start looking for other work and was
unlikely to agree a leaving date without another job to go to. We are
not persuaded that the claimant gave notice to end her employment.
Case No: 3305188/2018
4
She did nothing more than indicate that she intended to leave at
some point in the near future. However, it is likely that she would
have left by the end of January 2018.
12.9 Mr. Szydlowski perceived the claimant as being, as he put it, “very
flirty with males”. However, this perception was drawn from gossip
and not from direct personal experience. However, this perception
no doubt informed Mr. Szydlowski’s treatment of the claimant.
12.10 The respondent’s business consisted of a shop and a bakery. There
were also offices upstairs which were used as a rest room or
common room and a kitchen for use by staff. There was a dispute
as to whether employees lived upstairs on a permanent basis.
12.11 The claimant’s evidence was that employees rented rooms from
Mr. Laskowski. Both the respondent’s witnesses denied this.
12.12 However, Mr. Szydlowski accepted that he had slept there on at least
one occasion after a night shift. He accepted that there was a bed
for him to sleep in.
12.13 We find that it is more likely than not that the claimant’s evidence on
this point is true. Employees were living on-site. Both Mr. Szydlowski
and Mr. Laskowski were keen to deny this. Mr. Laskowski in
particular was evasive about answering the question put to him in
cross examination and on balance we accept the claimant’s evidence
on this point which is corroborated by Mr. Kalinowski's evidence. We
do not place much weight on Mr. Kalinowski’s evidence, it was not
given under oath and it was not tested under cross examination.
However, we give it some limited weight. It corroborates the
claimant’s account.
12.14 The claimant swapped two work shifts with a work colleague in
August or September 2017. She worked two shifts that had been
allocated to her colleague. The effect of this was that the colleague
was paid despite the claimant doing the work. The intention was that
the colleague would cover two shifts for the claimant in return, but as
the claimant left her employment that never happened.
12.15 The first allegation of sexual harassment arises from events on
23 October 2017. There is a conflict of evidence on the point
between the claimant and Mr. Szydlowski. The claimant’s account is
set out at paragraph 11 of her witness statement. In contrast
Mr. Szydlowski simply denies that the incident happened.
12.16 We prefer the claimant’s evidence on this point. She appeared to be
truthful and genuine when giving evidence before us. Her evidence
on the point has been consistent throughout and was consistent with
text messages that she sent to Mr. Szydlowski on 12 November
2017. Her evidence is also entirely plausible. She was intending to
leave and Mr. Szydlowski’s comment is entirely consistent with that
intention. We were much less impressed with Mr. Szydlowski as a
witness and did not find him to be truthful on the point. For those
Case No: 3305188/2018
5
reasons we find that what happened on 23 October 2017 is as set
out in paragraph 11 of the claimant’s witness statement. Specifically,
Mr. Szydlowski said to her, “That he would have to have sex with her
before Christmas”.
12.17 There was limited material in the claimant’s witness evidence about
the effect this had upon her. We accept however that she was very
shocked by Mr. Szydlowski’s words.
12.18 The second incident of harassment is said to have taken place on
28 October 2017. On that day the claimant was working in the shop.
She was serving a customer who was collecting a cake. The
customer complained about the way the cake had been decorated.
It was said to have been decorated differently to the way they had
requested. The claimant went upstairs to speak to Mr. Szydlowski
about the issue. The claimant says that when she did so
Mr. Szydlowski closed the door behind her and made a comment to
her that “there would be a rape”.
12.19 Again, Mr. Szydlowski denies the claimant’s account of the incident.
12.20 Again, we prefer the evidence of the claimant on the point. We had
some concerns about the claimant’s consistency on this point. She
did give a slightly different account in her particulars of claim to the
account set out in her witness statement. However, what has been
consistent throughout is that she says that she went into a room with
Mr. Szydlowski and others, he closed the door behind her and said,
“Now there will be a rape”. That evidence is consistent with the
evidence of Mr. Kalinowski, the claimant’s text message to
Mr. Laskowski on 11 November and the claimant’s text message
exchanges with Mr. Szydlowski on 12 November. We find that the
event did occur as the claimant sets out in her witness evidence. We
reject Mr. Szydlowski’s evidence on the point.
12.21 Again, there is limited material in the claimant’s witness statement
about the impact that event had upon her. However, we accept that
the claimant felt embarrassed about the events and was also
understandably scared by Mr. Szydlowski’s conduct and concerned
about him waiting outside the bakery to fulfill his threat. She felt
unsafe as a result.
12.22 The third key event relied by the claimant took place on
11 November 2017. The claimant was working at the time, and it is
common ground that there was an altercation between her and
Mr. Szydlowski.
12.23 Mr. Szydlowski accepted that during this argument he shouted at the
claimant and was aggressive towards her.
12.24 We also accept the claimant’s evidence that he also said that if the
two were alone he would have spoken to her in another way. We
accept that this was said by Mr. Szydlowski. The claimant
interpreted this to have a sexual connotation because of
Case No: 3305188/2018
6
Mr. Szydlowski’s previous comments. However, we find that it was
not intended in that way. It was said in the heat of the moment, during
an argument between the two, that could be overheard by others.
We find that it is more likely that what Mr. Szydlowski meant by the
comment was that if others were not present, he would be less
retrained about telling the claimant precisely what he thought of her.
There was nothing obviously sexual about the comment and in the
context in which it was made, it was unlikely to be a comment related
to sex.
12.25 The claimant reported the rape comment to her manager, who
advised her to report it to Mr. Laskowski. On 11 November the
claimant sent a text message to Mr. Laskowski who was away in
Poland at the time. In that message she complained that she had
been shouted at and threatened by Mr. Szydlowski that day and at
the end of the message she also referred to the rape comment.
12.26 Mr. Laskowski responded to say that he would not tolerate the
behavior and that he would resolve matters when he returned to the
bakery on Monday 13 November.
12.27 Mr. Laskowski contacted Mr. Szydlowski to confirm that a complaint
had been made. He re-arranged Mr. Szydlowski’s shifts so that he
and the claimant would not come into contact on the Monday. He
did not suspend Mr. Szydlowski from work.
12.28 On Sunday 12 November the claimant and Mr. Szydlowski
exchanged several text messages with each other. The messages
show that the two individuals were extremely angry with each other.
Mr. Szydlowski was clearly aware of the claimant’s allegations by this
stage. His opening message to the claimant referred to her having
made the complaint about the rape comment. The messages quickly
became abusive on both sides, with both parties responding rapidly
to each other’s messages and clearly being angry with each other.
During the exchange the claimant referred to the events on 23 and
28 October and Mr. Szydlowski denied the allegations accusing the
claimant of lying about them.
12.29 Mr. Laskowski returned from Poland late on Sunday 12 November
2017. He met with the claimant the following day and the claimant
told him what had happened. Mr. Laskowski took no steps to
investigate matters apart from talking to the claimant. There was no
attempt to identify and interview witnesses which any reasonable
employer would do given the serious nature of the claimant’s
allegations. He also failed to investigate the claimant’s references to
Mr. Szydlowski and others drinking on the premises despite giving
evidence before us that this was strictly prohibited.
12.30 Mr. Laskowski decided to hold a meeting with the claimant and
Mr. Szydlowski. The meeting took place on Tuesday 14 November.
The purpose of the meeting was to clear the air. The meeting was
attended by the claimant, Mr. Laskowski, Mr. Szydlowski and
Mr. Grzegorz Laskowski the general manager of the bakery. The
Case No: 3305188/2018
7
claimant was not told that this would be a grievance meeting, she
was simply told the meeting was to try and calm the situation down
between her and Mr. Szydlowski. The claimant was not given any
opportunity to be accompanied to the meeting.
12.31 At the meeting Mr. Szydlowski accepted that he had been rude and
had shouted at the claimant on 11 November, however he denied
the comment about there being a rape. He had agreed with
Mr. Laskowski that he would apologise for shouting at the claimant
and being rude to her. However, he refused to apologise to the
claimant about the rape comments saying that he had not made such
a comment. It is common ground that after Mr. Szydlowski denied
this the claimant became upset and left the meeting. It is also
common ground that Mr. Szydlowski and the two Mr. Laskowskis
caught up with the claimant before she left the site and that
Mr. Szydlowski apologised to the claimant and two shook hands.
The claimant accepted the apology at the time. However, she felt
under pressure and intimidated into doing so. Mr. Laskowski said
that he would arrange the work rota such that the claimant and
Mr. Szydlowski would not meet in future and he also gave
Mr. Szydlowski what he described as a verbal warning telling him
that he would face disciplinary action if there were any further
complaints.
12.32 The claimant considered the situation overnight. She concluded that
she could no longer continue to work for the respondent, she had no
confidence that the matters had been resolved and that Mr. Szydlowski
would cease his behavior towards her. Quite reasonably, she no longer
felt safe given the nature of Mr. Szydlowski’s comments towards her
and the inadequacy of the respondent’s response. She did not return
to work and it is common ground that her employment ended at this
stage by reason of resignation.
12.33 Whilst working for the respondent the claimant had also worked in a
cleaning job. She had worked 2-3 hours per week and was paid £10
per hour. After her employment with the respondent ended, she
increased her cleaning hours to a total of 15 hours per week, thus
she earned an extra £120-£130 per week. She therefore suffered no
loss of earnings as a result of losing the job with the respondent and
fully mitigated her loss.
Applicable Law: Sex Discrimination
13. There is no dispute that that claimant was an employee of the respondent.
Sections 39 and 40 of the Equality Act 2010 (“the Act”) prohibit the
discrimination and harassment of employees by employers.
14. The two types of discrimination relied on in this case are harassment and
direct discrimination.
15. Harassment is defined in s.26 of the Act and direct discrimination is defined
in s.13 of the Act.
Case No: 3305188/2018
8
16. In discrimination claims, claimants benefit from a slightly more favourable
burden of proof rule. This is set out in s.136 of the Act. Broadly speaking,
this provides that once a claimant has proved facts from which an
Employment Tribunal could decide that an unlawful act has taken place the
burden of proof then shifts to the respondent to prove a non-discriminatory
explanation for those facts.
17. Under s.109 of the Act anything done by an employee in the course of their
employment must be treated as having been done by the employer. This is
known as vicarious liability.
18. Finally, if a complaint of discrimination is upheld s.124 of the Act sets out
the remedies that the Tribunal can award.
Applicable Law: Wages Claim
19. Workers have a right under s.13 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 (ERA)
not to suffer unauthorised deductions from their wages. A deduction will be
unauthorised unless it falls within the scope of s. 13(1)(a) or (b) of the ERA.
A worker can present a complaint of unauthorised deductions from wages
under s.23 of the ERA and s.24 of the ERA sets out the remedies that the
Tribunal can award if there has been an unauthorised deduction.
Applicable Law: section 38 Employment Act 2002
20. Finally, s.38 of the Employment Act 2002 requires an Employment Tribunal
to increase an award of compensation in certain circumstances. Broadly
speaking this is where an employer has failed to provide a written statement
of terms and conditions.
Discussion/Conclusions
21. Applying the law to the facts of this case our conclusions are as follows:
Incident on 23 October 2017
22. Firstly, starting with the incident on 23 October 2017:
23. The claimant asserts that Mr. Szydlowski’s conduct towards her amounted
to sexual harassment contrary to s.26(2) of the Equality Act 2010. We refer
to the findings of fact that we have made as to what occurred on 23 October.
Taking the essential elements of the s.26(2) definition in turn we conclude
as follows:
23.1 Mr. Szydlowski’s conduct was plainly unwanted by the claimant, she
did nothing to encourage it, and the comment was entirely uninvited.
23.2 That conduct is also plainly of a sexual nature. This is self-evident
from the words used.
23.3 We also find that Mr. Szydlowski’s conduct violated the claimant’s
dignity. The word violate is a strong word. Merely offending against
dignity or hurting it is not sufficient. However, Mr. Szydlowski’s
Case No: 3305188/2018
9
comment was not a trivial comment. The comment was so offensive
as to violate the claimant’s dignity.
23.4 We are also satisfied that Mr. Szydlowski’s conduct, particularly
when added to his conduct on 28 October, had the effect of creating
an intimidating, hostile, degrading and humiliating or offensive
environment for the claimant. Mr. Szydlowski’s behavior made the
claimant feel unsafe to be around him at work.
23.5 It follows from these conclusions that all the essential elements of
the s26(2) definition are met and Mr. Szydlowski’s conduct toward
the claimant on 23 October amounts to unlawful sexual harassment.
Incident on 28 October 2017
24. The claimant asserts that the incident on 28 October also amounts to sexual
harassment. Again, we refer to out earlier findings as to what was done and
said by Mr. Szydlowski on that date. Again, taking the essential elements
of the s.26(2) definition we find that Mr. Szydlowski’s conduct on 28 October
also amounts to unlawful sexual harassment. In particular, the conduct was
plainly unwanted by the claimant, she did nothing to encourage it and the
conduct comment was entirely uninvited. The comment was also plainly of
a sexual nature, this is self-evident from the words used and the suggestion
that the claimant might be about to be raped by Mr. Szydlowski violated the
claimant’s dignity and created an intimidating, hostile, degrading,
humiliating or offensive environment for the claimant.
Incident/comments made on 11 November 2017
25. The third event that the claimant relies on in support of her claim is the
comment made by Mr. Szydlowski on 11 November that he would talk to
her differently if they were alone. We refer to our earlier findings as to what
occurred on 11 November. Taking the essential elements for the s.26(2)
definition in turn we find:
25.1 The conduct was unwanted by the claimant.
25.2 However, we are not persuaded that the comment was of a sexual
nature. We find that the reference to talking differently to the claimant
if they were not alone, was not a comment that had any obvious
sexual connotation, it was not an overtly sexual comment. It might
have had sexual connotations depending on the context. However,
the context here was a heated argument between the claimant and
Mr. Szydlowski. We find that what he was referring to was that he
would be freer to express his views about the claimant if they were
alone. His comment was not a reference to making sexual
comments to the claimant if they were alone.
25.3 In the circumstances Mr. Szydlowski’s conduct towards the claimant
on 11 November does not amount to unlawful sexual harassment.
Case No: 3305188/2018
10
26. We referred earlier to vicarious liability. Under s.109 of the Equality Act 2010
the respondent is liable for the discriminatory actions of Mr. Szydlowski
where those actions took place in the course of employment. We find that
Mr. Szydlowski’s conduct on both 23 and 28 October was sexual
harassment and took place in the course of his employment. Both
discriminatory comments took place on the respondent’s premises and in
the context of work. The respondent is therefore vicariously liable for
Mr. Szydlowski’s actions.
27. In some circumstances an employer can defeat liability under s.109 if they
can show that they took all reasonable steps to prevent the discrimination.
No such defense is raised in this case and this is plainly not a case where
such a defense could succeed on the facts.
28. The claimant also alleges that the respondent’s failure to deal with her
complaints amounted to harassment. This claim is brought under the
definition of harassment in s.26(1) of the Act. In other words, it is brought
under the ordinary definition of harassment as opposed to the more specific
definition of sexual harassment in s.26(2). We do not uphold this claim for
the following reasons:
28.1 We accept that there has plainly been a failure on the part of the
respondent. The respondent dealt inadequately with the claimant’s
complaints. They were serious complaints, Mr. Szydlowski’s
behavior was appalling, it was conduct of the grossest type and it
would warrant instant dismissal. The respondent singularly failed to
appreciate the seriousness of those allegations and failed to deal
with them appropriately. There was no proper investigation of the
claimant’s allegations, no interviewing of witnesses and taking the
step of having a meeting to clear the air was wholly inadequate. The
disciplinary action taken against Mr. Szydlowski was also wholly
inadequate given the gravity of his behavior.
28.2 The respondent’s failure to act was plainly unwanted by the claimant.
She wanted the respondent to take much more robust action and she
was entitled to expect that. However, for the respondent’s conduct
to amount to harassment under s.26(1) it must be related to a
relevant protected characteristic. The characteristic relied on is the
claimant’s sex.
28.3 The conduct concerned was the respondent’s failure to act on the
claimant’s complaints and the relevant protected characteristic was
the claimant’s sex. Thus, the key question for us to determine is
whether that conduct related to the claimant’s sex. Under the
previous harassment legislation, the conduct had to be “on grounds
of” a particular characteristic. However, the definition under the
Equality Act 2010 is wider than that, s.26(1) uses the words “related
to”. Thus, the question for us is whether the respondent’s conduct
was related to the claimant’s sex.
28.4 The current legislation still requires there be a link between the
conduct and the protected characteristic. This claim would plainly
have failed under the old law because the respondent’s failure to act
was in our view not because of or on grounds of the claimant’s sex.
Case No: 3305188/2018
11
We are satisfied on the evidence that the respondent in this case is
an employer which plainly has little knowledge or expertise of good
employment practice That is the reason for their failure to act. It was
not because of the claimant’s sex nor was it related to the claimant’s
sex and so although we remind ourselves that the current statutory
definition is somewhat wider than the old definition the claim fails as
the necessary link between the conduct and the protected
characteristic is not present.
29. The claimant also brings a complaint of direct discrimination, she asserts
that the respondent’s failure to deal with her complaints was an act of direct
discrimination and that she was constructively dismissed and that this also
amounted to direct discrimination. Under s.13 of the Equality Act 2010 a
complaint of direct discrimination requires us to undertake a comparison
exercise. In this case we must compare the way the respondent treated the
claimant with the way the respondent would have treated a hypothetical
male employee in materially the same circumstances. In other words, a
male employee making similar complaints of sexual harassment. The
question is, whether the respondent treated the claimant less favourably
than they would have treated such a comparator. We conclude that the
answer is no. We are satisfied that the respondent would have treated a
male employee in the same way.
30. The reason the employer failed to act adequately was because they have
little or no knowledge or expertise of good employment practice. We are
satisfied that the respondent would also have similarly failed to act had it
been a male employee in the same position.
31. It follows from this that both claims of direct discrimination fail. The
respondent’s treatment of the claimant was not because of her sex.
32. Turning to the wages claim, the respondent now accepts that the claimant
should be paid for the two shifts that she covered for her colleague. There
is no longer any dispute that the claimant was not paid for working these
shifts and that this failure to pay amounts to a deduction from the claimant’s
wages. The respondent does not seek to argue that that deduction was
authorised. The respondent agrees that the sum payable should be £100,
that is £50 per shift.
33. We have however found that the claimant was paid less than the applicable
National Minimum Wage. We have taken into account the decision of the
Employment Appeal Tribunal in the case of Paggetti v Cobb. That case is
authority the proposition that an Employment Tribunal is under a duty to
consider the National Minimum Wage when deciding a week's pay for the
purposes of assessing the loss of earnings element of a compensatory
award under s.123(1) of the Employment Rights Act 1996. This is because
the effect of the National Minimum Wage legislation is to amend a worker’s
contract of employment to set a minimum rate per hour below which they
should not be paid. Although the Paggetti case concerned assessing
compensation for unfair dismissal we consider that there is no reason why
the principle should not also apply in the context of assessing the
appropriate sum to award for an unauthorised deduction from wages.
Case No: 3305188/2018
12
34. We consider that we must take into account the National Minimum Wage
when calculating the sums due. In this case there are two shifts, and
16 hours work in total. The national minimum wage rate applicable at the
time was £7.50 per hour which gives a total award of £120. We will make
an award of this sum and make a declaration that the respondent unlawfully
deducted this sum from the claimant’s pay.
35. Finally, having upheld the claimant’s complaints of sexual harassment we
turn to the question of remedy. The power to award a remedy arises under
s.124 of the Equality Act 2010. We will make a declaration that there has
been unlawful sexual discrimination in this case and we will also order the
respondent to pay compensation to the claimant for that discrimination.
36. The claimant seeks compensation for injury to feelings and also for loss of
earnings. Taking each in turn, we deal first with injury to feelings. We
remind ourselves that the purpose of the award is to compensate the
claimant. It is not to punish the respondent for wrongdoing. Our focus must
be on the impact the discrimination had upon the claimant. The claimant’s
representative invites us to award £10,000. The respondent suggests that
no award should be made.
37. The claimant and her representative provided us with little material on which
to assess the impact upon the claimant. The claimant’s witness statement
contained very little material on the issue. When the claimant gave
evidence, we asked her for further details, and she provided some further
limited details. The claimant was shocked, embarrassed, threatened and
intimidated by Mr. Szydlowski’s behavior. Quite reasonably she feared that
he might rape her or sexually assault her. She was frightened to go into
work. She felt unable to continue in her work and lost her job as a result.
She had a family to support and the loss of the job no doubt caused her
further stress.
38. In the case of Vento v The Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police the
Court of Appeal gave guidance to Employment Tribunals about how we
should approach the assessment of compensation for injury to feelings.
That resulted in three bands of compensation. Those financial bands have
been increased over time and following the applicable Presidential
Guidance on the issue the so called ‘Vento bands’ are as follows:
38.1 A lower band of between £800 and £8,400 for less serious cases
such as where the act of discrimination is an isolated or one-off
occurrence;
38.2 A middle band of between £8,400 and up to £25,200 for serious
cases that do not merit an award in the highest band; and
38.3 An upper band of between £25,200 and £42,000 to be applied only
in the most serious cases for example where there has been a
lengthy campaign of discriminatory harassment.
39. The claimant says that this case should fall within the middle band. We
agree. This is plainly not a lower band case. It is not a one-off, isolated or
less serious occurrence. It is however not appropriate for the top band
Case No: 3305188/2018
13
either. The case concerns two incidents of harassment. However, both
were particularly serious, and this is a case where the claimant lost her job
as a result of the harassment and the respondent’s failure to take sufficient
action to protect her. As we have said the evidence that we have been
provided with about injury to feelings is limited but given our findings about
the impact on the claimant we make an award at the lower end of the middle
band. We make an award of £8,500.
40. We make no award to the claimant for compensation for loss of earnings.
There is no financial loss in this case. In her remedy statement the claimant
assessed her loss at £2,600. However, that figure did not give credit for the
additional earnings from her increased hours for her cleaning work following
her resignation from the respondent’s employment. Those earnings
exceeded the earnings she would have received from the respondent and
so no loss of earnings has been suffered.
41. Finally, we come to the respondent’s failure to issue a written statement of
terms and conditions. Under s.38 of the Employment Act 2002 a Tribunal
must make an additional award of compensation in certain circumstances.
42. The claimant has not sought such an award in this case, however the use
of the word “must” in s.38 is such that we are compelled to consider such
an award regardless.
43. In this case the conditions for such an award are present. We have upheld
the sex discrimination complaint at least in part. That is a claim within
schedule 5 of the 2002 Act. Further, we are satisfied that when this case
began the respondent was in breach of the duty under s.1 of the
Employment Rights Act 1996 to provide a statement of main terms and
conditions of employment. The short document issued to the claimant to
confirm her terms and conditions was wholly inadequate. In those
circumstances we must make an additional award of compensation.
44. We must award at least 2 weeks’ pay and if it is just and equitable to do so
we may award the higher amount of 4 weeks’ pay. When calculating a
weeks’ pay we must take into account the National Minimum Wage for the
reasons given earlier. In this case we calculate a weeks’ pay as being
£103.85, which is £5,400 per annum divided by 52 weeks. We consider
that the higher amount of 4 weeks’ pay is just and equitable to award in this
case. In deciding that we take into account the fact that the respondent is
an established business. Mr. Laskowski said he had been trading for
10 years. It is also a relatively large business employing approximately 18
people and the email setting out terms of the claimant’s work was woefully
inadequate to comply with s.1.
45. For those reasons we will issue a judgment to address the following:
45.1 A declaration that the respondent unlawfully discriminated against
the claimant;
45.2 A declaration that the respondent made an unauthorised deduction
from wages;
45.3 An order for the respondent to pay £120 for unlawful deduction from
wages;
Case No: 3305188/2018
14
45.4 An order for the respondent to pay an additional £8,500 as
compensation for sex discrimination; and
45.5 An order for the respondent to pay a further £415.40 for the failure to
provide the claimant with a s.1 statement of terms and conditions.
_____________________________
Employment Judge: Mr. A Spencer
Date: ……19 November 2019……….
Judgment sent to the parties on
......................................................
......................................................
For the Tribunal office
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.