Ms E Vankova v Contardo Imaging Ltd: 3333413/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 29 April 2020, 14:52
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract race-discrimination unfair-dismissal working-time-regulations
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2020-04-13
Official Documents
-
Ms E Vankova v Contardo Imaging Ltd: 3333413/2018 - Reserved Judgment
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number:3333 413/2018
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
MS E VANKOVA v CONTARDO IMAGING LIMITED
Heard at: Watford On: 16 and 17 March 2020
Before: Employment Judge Skehan
Members: Ms Telfer
Appearances
For the Claimant: In Person
For the Respondent: Mr Fuller, consultant
RESERVED JUDGMENT
1. The claimant’s claim for automatically unfair dismissal contrary to section
100 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 is unsuccessful and dismissed.
2. The claimant’s claim for direct race discrimination contrary to section 13 of
the Equality Act 2010 is unsuccessful and is dismissed.
3. The claimant’s claim for unpaid annual leave contrary to the working time
regulations was withdrawn by the claimant and is dismissed.
4. The claimant’s claim for breach of contract relating to her notice period is
successful.
5. This matter is listed for a remedy hearing on 16 September 2020 as the
tribunal heard evidence on liability only. It is hoped that the parties will be
able to resolve the issue of remedy by agreement without the need for
remedy hearing. The claimant was paid for one weeks’ notice. The claimant
was entitled to one months’ notice. The appropriate remedy amount will be
the claimant’s normal monthly basic salary, less one week’s pay. Figures
should be calculated on a net basis.
REASONS
1. During day one of the hearing, unfortunately, a tribunal member became ill.
Following discussion with the parties, both parties agreed and recorded in
writing that the tribunal should proceed to determine this matter with the
Employment Judge and a single employee member.
Case Number:3333 413/2018
2
2. The claimant issued proceedings in this matter on 23/09/2018. She claimed
automatically unfair dismissal because she brought health and safety
matters to the respondent’s attention, race discrimination, breach of contract
and a claim for unpaid accrued but untaken annual leave. The claim in
respect of annual leave was withdrawn at the outset of the hearing. The
claim was defended and the respondent’s form ET3 was submitted on
20/11/2018. The issues to be determined was set out as the case
management hearing of 10/05/2019 were revisited at the start of the hearing,
agreed by the parties and are not repeated herein.
3. As is not unusual in these cases the parties have referred in evidence to a
wider range of issues than we deal with in our findings. Where we fail to
deal with any issue raised by a party, or deal with it in the detail in which we
heard, it is not an oversight or an omission but reflects the extent to which
that point was of assistance. We only set out our principal findings of fact.
We make findings on the balance of probability taking into account all
witness evidence and considering its consistency or otherwise considered
alongside the contemporaneous documents.
4. We heard from the claimant on her own behalf and we also heard from Ms
Ke. We heard from Mr Childs on behalf of the respondent. All witnesses
gave evidence under oath or affirmation. Their witness statements were
adopted and accepted as evidence-in-chief. All witnesses were crossexamined.
5. The respondent is a specialist imaging printing company for both consumer
and commercial clients. They offer custom-made prints on a range of
products including fabrics, clothing, homeware and leather.
6. The claimant is Russian. She was employed by the respondent from
01/06/2017 to 20/08/2018. The claimant has less than 2 years’ service and
no ‘ordinary unfair dismissal’ claim. The claimant worked under a Tier 2
(general) Visa, sponsored by the respondent. According to Mr Childs, the
claimant’s Visa was awarded on a points-based system requiring the
claimant to have scored 70 points on the Tier 2 test to be eligible for a UK
Visa. The points system awards 30 points for having a valid ‘certificate of
sponsorship’. This requires the respondent as her sponsor to have a Tier 2
sponsorship licence, which it did. The points based system awards 20 points
for receiving the appropriate salary for the job in question. In the claimant’s
case she required a minimum salary of £30,000 per annum. Mr Childs told
us that it was his understanding that should the claimant not achieve a salary
of £30,000 per annum or more, she would not qualify for her Visa. The
points-based system offered 10 points each for English language and funds.
Mr Childs told that it was his understanding that any role taken by the
claimant would also need to meet the skills shortage test. This involved, inn
general terms, the role being advertised with a subsequent inability to fill it.
7. Mr Childs told us during the course of cross examination that the respondent
was subject to a spot check by the Home Office recently. He considered
that he had good understanding of the sponsorship scheme and the Home
Office rules and requirements as they applied to the claimant’s Visa.
8. The claimant said during the course of her evidence that she could earn a
salary lower than £30,000 and that would be acceptable by the Home Office
to retain her Visa, however the claimant’s evidence was unclear. The
claimant was asked if she agreed with the respondent’s evidence that the
Case Number:3333 413/2018
3
Visa required her to earn £30,000 or more. The claimant responded ‘I don’t
know for sure, I can’t remember.’
9. The claimant initially joined the respondent’s content marketing team. She
became the online public relations manager within search engine
optimisation (SEO) towards the end of January 2018. Her line manager was
Leo Cerda, a British national. The respondent describes the claimant as a
valued and diligent employee. Mr Childs said that there had never been any
question over her capability, her commitment or her value to the respondent.
During her employment the claimant performed well within her role and the
respondent acknowledged her successes and her hard work.
Notwithstanding the claimant’s hard work, Mr Childs said that although time
and resources had been put into making the claimant’s role a success the
return on the respondent’s investment was meagre. Revenue streams were
not significant enough to break even and for that reason, the claimant’s role
was identified as a loss-making role for the respondent. The respondent
stresses that there is no criticism of the claimant within this scenario.
10. Mr Childs said that he made the decision to place the claimant’s role at risk
of redundancy owing to declining sales and in the absence of success from
the online strategy. Mr Childs told us that other areas of the business were
doing well and the company has expanded operations in India.
11. In July 2018, Mr Childs had considered creating a role of Digital Project
manager on 04/07/2018. He wrote text for a possible role and this was
placed on the website to see how it looked in context. However, on review
Mr Childs decided that this was not a role that was required. Mr Childs told
the tribunal that no person was ever interviewed for this role and it was never
filled.
12. In addition to identifying the claimant’s role at risk of redundancy, Mr Childs
also identified Mr Leo Cedra’s role as at risk of redundancy as he worked in
the SEO department also. The respondent undertook consultation meetings
with the claimant prior to confirming her position as redundant and
terminating her employment.
13. The claimant said that there was no real or genuine reason for the
termination of her employment. She said that her department was
successful and her position had been successful.
14. There was a heatwave in the UK in July 2018. Shavita Kerai works within
the respondent’s HR department. Daniel Monoz and Fabio Rodrigues work
within the respondent’s IT department. On 05/07/2018 the claimant
contacted Shavita Kerai as follows:
EV 17:03 Hello dear Shavita, hope you are well. Do you think
there is something we can do with the Air conditioner? We have an
hour to go and we are all boiling here and sweaty ha ha
SK: 17:04 I will get someone to reset it. Thanks
15. The claimant says that she raised her message as a joke to get her point
across and to get someone to fix it.
16. On 23/07/2018 the claimant messaged her colleague Daniel Monoz. The
exchange is as follows:
Case Number:3333 413/2018
4
a. 13:21 EV Hello Daniel Hope you are well and had a good
weekend. Could you please help me with a little fan on my
desk? I could not find a free socket to connect it thanks
b. 14:47 EV: hello?
c. 14:59 DM: hello
d. 15:20 EV: are you coming?
e. 15:39 DM: what do you need. We have had some problems with
one webpage and am working on it. I can go in a few minutes
f. 15:40 EV: a socket to connect my fan to. Cool thanks
g. 15:42 DM I don’t know if I have any…. I will try to find one
h. 15:42 EV maybe there is a free one under my desk - I just
cannot reach it myself!
i. 16:3 EV I am dying from the heat here; it’s been 3# hours since I
called you
17. On 23/07/2018 the claimant emailed Daniel Munoz and Shavita Kerai, and
copied Fabio Rodrigues at 17:27. The email says:
Hello dear all
Can please someone come and help me to turn on the fan at my
desk? I bought it myself and brought to the office but there is no free
[socket] under my desk, and there is a lot of mouse poo under my
desk too.
I am dying from the heat here, and I asked Daniel at 13.20 over
Skype. Why is it taking so long? Who shall I ask?
@Shavita Kerai, if Daniel is so super busy with his work, maybe we
can have someone else from the production to come please? I really
need this working.
Many thanks
18. The claimant says that she was sweating in the office through the hottest
summer in the UK. She was not ‘dying’ but was feeling terrible. She was
trying to work in the heat. The claimant says that following her email,
Shavita ’called me out’ publicly in front of other colleagues. By way of
explanation the claimant says that rather than discuss the matter with her in
a private room, Shavita said to the claimant in front of her colleagues ‘ Eka,
mouse droppings, heat situation, what’s wrong with you?’ The claimant
considered that Shavita behaved unprofessionally. The claimant said she
did not complain as there was no one to complain to. The claimant said she
believed that her comments would have been raised with Mr Childs
straightaway and the claimant said that she was sure Mr Childs would have
been aware of her complaints.
19. Mr Childs says that he was entirely aware of the above correspondence and
at no time had any complaint relating to any health and safety matter, mouse
droppings or temperature made by the claimant been brought to his
attention, prior to these proceedings.
Case Number:3333 413/2018
5
20. Mr Childs said that the respondent displayed standard health and safety
posters within the office and that he was named within these posters as the
health and safety officer. These were placed in the kitchen and in the
corridor and referenced in the respondent’s handbook.
21. The claimant said she did not complain formally to Mr Childs as she wished
to keep her job. She was trying to make peace with the respondent and
retain her employment. She was intimidated by Mr Childs but needed her
job to keep her visa.
22. Mr Childs said that there was a heatwave in June /July 2018. It was not
impossible to work but it was uncomfortable. This was the case across the
country. The respondent had and continues to have air-conditioning units to
avoid uncomfortable temperatures but their units may have been less
efficient due to the unusually high demand for it at that time of year. Fans
were provided to keep people as comfortable as possible. Mr Childs did not
consider the temperature within the office to be at such a level that it could
have been considered dangerous to employees.
23. Mr Childs told the tribunal that the respondent’s offices had mice. There was
a local supermarket nearby that contributed to the problem. Staff eating at
their desks had not helped the situation and notices had been put up by the
respondent. Mr Childs said it was not a significant problem within the
respondent as they employed pest control to regularly attend the offices
together with a daily cleaner to remove any traces that may attract mice. Mr
Childs considered this to be a commonplace problem within offices and one
which was acknowledged and under control. Mr Childs said that he would
have welcomed complaints from the claimant as it would have highlighted
that his steps to address the mice problem were not working and he would
have had the opportunity to take further measures.
24. The respondent has a very diverse workforce. It employed 104 individuals of
which only 13 are of UK nationality. 73 are EU nationals and 18 are from the
rest of the world. The claimant told the tribunal that she believed Mr Childs
employed so many foreign nationals because he wanted to treat them less
favourably. The claimant says that she knew this was a strong statement
but believed that she was evidence of her allegations. She told the tribunal
that she believed Mr Childs could pay people less than those from the UK
and that those people not from the UK are less likely to stand up to him if
they have concerns. People depending upon Visa’s cannot raise issues and
there was a culture of fear in the respondent company. The claimant
referred to an email sent by Mr Childs following the Brexit referendum dated
27/06/2016, prior to the commencement of the claimant’s employment,
indicating that Mr Childs had welcomed the outcome. The claimant says that
this email showed Mr Childs to the anti-immigrant. This email states interalia:
As you know there has been a massive change in UK status with the
EU with vote for leave. It’s not a vote against European people… I
voted leave, and after initial surprise, I feel a huge wave of opportunity
ahead of us. It is better for us – all nationalities.… Your job, your
lifestyle your place in Britain is secure. This vote is not antiimmigration,
despite how the news media presented it. We are pro
movement of people, have been for 1000 years and will continue. If
anyone has a problem or question, or is having a bad experience in
Case Number:3333 413/2018
6
work or outside, please discuss it with me as I am keen to hear
feedback and help. You have our support.…
25. The claimant says in her witness statement that Mr Childs informed her that
the fact that she was not British was the reason why they did not consider
her for other roles in her department. During the course of crossexamination
the claimant told the tribunal that those words were not used.
She says that Mr Childs referred to the skills shortage test and the Visa
requirements within consultation meetings and these requirements only
applied to the claimant because she was not British.
26. At the time of the claimant’s redundancy, the claimant believes that she
should have been considered for the following vacancies:
a. The role of digital project manager. The claimant disputes Mr Child’s
evidence that this was never a finalised role as she saw the role
description.
b. Content manager/copywriter. This role was accepted by Jonella on
25/07/2018. The salary agreed for this role was £20,000 per annum.
Mr Childs says that this role was not considered for the claimant as it
could be was filled and did not provide sufficient salary in any event
for the claimant’s Visa requirements.
c. Content manager. This role was filled by Becca in May 2018 on a
salary of £25,500 per annum. Mr Childs says that this role was not
considered for the claimant as it was not vacant and did not provide
sufficient salary in any event for the claimant’s Visa requirements.
27. Both parties’ evidence in relation to the claimant’s notice period was
somewhat confused.
a. We were not provided with a copy of the original contract of
employment supplied to the claimant. The claimant emailed Mr
Childs on 27/03/2017 telling him inter-alia that ‘I have noticed that
there is only one week of notice period in the contract, which is
extremely difficult for me (as I would need to find the company who
can provide sponsorship). Is there a chance that we could do at least
one month in my contract? Please let me know [as ] this is very
important in my Visa situation.’
b. Mr Childs replied on the same day saying, ‘one month’ notice is fine
for your contract, except in the unlikely concern of misconduct or
grievance. We will amend this’
c. The claimant received a written contract of employment with the
following notice provision:
i. notice period to be given by the employer to the employee
… Less than 1 months’ service -nil
1 months’ service but less than 2 years - one month.
d. Mr Childs told us that regardless of the written contract he would
expect the claimant’s notice period to be one month from the
commencement of her employment as this was the deal that they had
reached by email.
Case Number:3333 413/2018
7
e. Towards the end of February 2018, the respondent wrote to all of its
staff highlighting various changes that were to be made to their terms
and conditions of employment. The respondent sought, amongst
other things to increase employees’ annual leave and introduce a
company sick pay scheme.
f. Mr Childs told us that the claimant’s bespoke one month’ notice
period was overlooked and there was no express intention on the
respondent’s part to change the claimant’s notice period at this time.
g. A new contract was provided to the claimant and her colleagues. The
relevant parts of the contract are:
We are introducing new benefits in proposing the following
changes to the terms and conditions of employment contracts.
Please read carefully and sign if you are in agreement with
them. All additions/changes are highlighted in green. [The
tribunal was provided with a colour copy of the document.]…….
Notice period to be given by the employer to the employee:
the company has the right to serve notice of termination of your
employment at any time in accordance with the notice
provisions below.
One months’ service but less than 2 years - one week……..
[The notice period provisions were not highlighted in green.]
h. The claimant said, during the course of cross examination, that she
spoke to the respondent’s HR person Barbara who explained that the
company were changing the sick pay provisions. The claimant was
unclear as to whether or not she had realised at the time that the new
contract purported to change her notice period.
i. The claimant said that as she had a bespoke agreement in respect of
her notice period, the document says that all changes were in green,
the notice provision was not in green and therefore it was not
envisaged that the notice provision would be changed by the new
document. The claimant signed the document but did not retain a
copy.
j. Ms Ke said that her terms and conditions changed at the same time.
She did not know and it was not brought to her attention that the
respondent intended to change notice periods.
28. By letter dated 13/08/2018 the respondent terminated the claimant’s
employment. The claimant was provided with one weeks’ notice and her
final day of employment was stated to be 20/08/2018.
29. We note the Home Office letter to the claimant regarding her immigration
status dated 17/09/2018 which states that it was informed by the respondent
on 15 August that the claimant had ceased to be employed. Mr Childs said
that the respondent updated the information it was required to provide to the
Home Office once it had made its decision to terminate the claimant’s
employment.
Case Number:3333 413/2018
8
The Law, Deliberations and Findings
Unfair dismissal
30. Section 100 (1)(c) of the Employment Rights Act 1996 provides that an
employee who is dismissed shall be regarded as unfairly dismissed if the
reason (or, if more than one, the principal reason) for the dismissal is that
…being an employee at a place where there was no workers health and
safety representative or safety committee, she brought to her employer’s
attention, by reasonable means, circumstances connected with her work
which she reasonably believed were harmful or potentially harmful to health
or safety.
31. It was submitted that Mr Childs was the ‘representative of workers on
matters of health and safety at work or member of a safety committee’ by
reference to his name being on the health and safety posters as designated
health and safety officer. The employment tribunal does not consider the
health and safety officer to be the designated representative of workers or
members of a safety committee. We conclude that the respondent’s
workplace is one where neither post exists as envisaged under section
100(1) (c) of the Employment Rights Act 1996.
32. What was the reason for the claimant’s dismissal? The decision to dismiss
the claimant was made by Mr Childs. Generally the tribunal found Mr Childs
to be a straightforward, open and helpful witness.
33. We note that the claimant relies upon three exchanges set out above. the
claimant’s reference to mice droppings is made with reference to difficulties
in operating her fan rather than being the primary purpose of the email.
Further, these references are made in the context of an acknowledged
problem within the respondent’s offices that was known and had been
openly addressed by Mr Childs. Steps, including pest control and cleaners
have been taken by the respondent to try to deal with the mice problem.
The claimant’s reference to high temperatures are made in the context of a
heatwave. The first email is ‘jokey’ in nature. The others are practical
requesting help with a fan. The emails are addressed to the IT/HR support
workers. The tribunal concludes that the purpose of these emails was to
gain assistance with access to a socket rather than to bring any health and
safety concern to the respondent’s attention. The respondent did not treat
these emails as a health and safety complaint, and the tribunal considers
this unsurprising. We consider this relevant in assessing the likelihood of the
claimant’s complaints being passed to Mr Childs. Taking the entirety of the
available evidence into account we conclude, on the balance of probability,
that the claimant’s exchanges as referenced above were not brought to Mr
Childs attention and Mr Childs did not know of these complaints as he has
stated in his evidence.
34. In the circumstances, the burden of proof in establishing an automatically
unfair reason lies with the claimant. The evidence provided by the
respondent leads us to conclude that the respondent had identified a
reduced requirement for and redundancy situation within its SEO operation.
The fact that the respondent’s business in other areas may be prospering or
the respondent may be expanding in other geographical locations is
irrelevant in the circumstances. Both the claimant and her line manager
were placed at risk of redundancy. We conclude on the balance of
probability that the reason for the termination of the claimant’s employment
related to redundancy. The claimant’s claim for automatically unfair
Case Number:3333 413/2018
9
dismissal contrary to section 100 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 fails
and is dismissed.
35. In light of our findings as to the reason for the claimant’s dismissal and in
particular our finding that it was unconnected to the claimant’s allegations,
we have not considered whether the claimant’s allegations fall within the
statutory framework of bringing circumstances connected with her work
which she reasonably believes were harmful and potentially harmful to
health and safety.
Direct Disability discrimination contrary to section 13 Equality Act 2010
(EQA)
36. To establish a claim of direct discrimination, the claimant must show that she
has been treated less favourably in some way than a real or hypothetical
comparator. Section 23(1) of the EQA provides that there must be no
material difference between the circumstances of the claimant and the
comparator. The tribunal must ensure that it is comparing like with like,
except for the protected characteristic of race. The burden of proof
provisions in the EQA 2010 are set out in section 136(2) and (3) and states:
"(2) If there are facts from which the court [or tribunal] could decide, in the
absence of any other explanation, that a person (A) contravened the
provision concerned, the court must hold that the contravention occurred. (3)
But subsection (2) does not apply if A shows that A did not contravene the
provision." This is effectively a 2 stage approach: Stage 1: can the claimant
show a prima facie case? If no, the claim fails. If yes, the burden shifts to the
respondent. Stage 2: is the respondent's explanation sufficient to show that it
did not discriminate?
37. The claimant defines her race for the purpose of the proceedings as being a
Russian national or not being a UK or an EU national. It appears to the
tribunal that the real basis of the claimant’s claims is that she was
discriminated against due to the application of the Home Office Immigration
Rules by the respondent. The claimant would not have been subject to the
application of the Immigration Rules had she been a UK or EU national. The
tribunal section 9 of the EQA states that race includes colour, nationality or
ethnic or national origins. It is established that discrimination on the basis of
immigration status will not amount to race discrimination. In Taiwo v Olaigbe
and another; Onu v Akwiwu and another [2016] UKSC 31, the Supreme
Court held that two Nigerian employees, whose employers felt able to treat
them badly because of their status as vulnerable domestic migrant workers,
did not suffer direct race discrimination. Although immigration status is a
function of nationality, identified by the claimant in the circumstances, it is
not so closely associated with nationality as to be indissociable from it. The
court held that Parliament could have chosen to include immigration status in
the list of protected characteristics in the EqA 2010, but had not done so.
38. The claimant has asked us to draw inferences of discrimination from:
a. Mr Childs stated position in respect of Brexit. We have carefully
considered the email wording. This email expressly deals with the
anti-immigration rhetoric that accompanied much of the Brexit debate
and seeks to distance Mr Childs from it. It offers support to EU
workers and reassures them of their position within the workforce.
We conclude that no reasonable anti-immigration message can be
taken from this email or in Mr Childs case, his position on Brexit.
Case Number:3333 413/2018
10
b. The respondent’s employment of a large number of non-EU workers
and an allegation that the claimant as a non-EU worker and her non-
EU colleagues were unable to raise issues with Mr Childs as they
were afraid. We have considered the claimant’s allegations carefully.
The claimant worked hard within her role and her personal
performance was good. This performance was recognised openly by
the respondent. There was no evidence of any inability within the
respondent’s workforce to raise issues. The claimant has a law
degree from Russia and a Masters from Durham University. The
claimant throughout her correspondence with the respondent has
been forthright. There was nothing within the documentation to
support the claimant’s allegations that she was in any way afraid of or
intimidated by Mr Childs. There was no evidence of any desire by the
respondent to treat non EU workers less favourably than others. We
repeat our findings in respect of the reasons for the claimant’s
dismissal. No inference of discrimination is drawn by the tribunal by
the numbers of foreign nationals employed by the respondent.
39. Mr Childs provided us with detailed information in relation to his
understanding of the Immigration Rules. Mr Childs was familiar with the
Immigration Rules having held a sponsorship licence and recently
undergone and successfully passed a Home Office spot inspection We were
not referred by the claimant to any alternative provisions other than the
claimant says that she did not believe the £30,000 salary requirement
applied to her and we were invited to Google the Immigration Rules as they
applied to the claimant’s Visa. It was explained to the parties that the
tribunal was applying the Equality Act 2010, not the Immigration Rules. The
tribunal is concerned with Mr Childs’ understanding of the Immigration Rules
at the time he made his decision and it was for the parties to present
evidence to the employment tribunal rather than the employment tribunal to
seek or Google that evidence independently. We find on the balance of
probability that it was Mr Childs genuine belief that for the claimant to retain
her Visa that she required a salary of at least £30,000. Further, the role that
she occupied would need to meet the skills shortage test, that required the
respondent advertise but be unable to fill the role by those normally resident
in the UK.
40. The Respondent accepts that it selected the claimant for redundancy, failed
to offer her alternative roles and dismissed the claimant. We turn to the first
question of the claimant’s selection for redundancy. The tribunal has
considered the material circumstances of the real or hypothetical comparator
and concludes that any comparator would be a British person who also
worked in the SEO area. There is a real comparator available to the tribunal
being Mr Leo Cerda, a British national. Mr Cerda worked in the SEO area
and was also selected for redundancy. In taking the entirety of the
circumstances into account, and repeating our findings made above in
relation to the reason for the claimant’s dismissal, the employment tribunal is
unable to identify any prima facie case of discrimination. If we are wrong, we
conclude that the respondent has demonstrated a non-discriminatory reason
for the selection of the claimant’s role for redundancy. Mr Leo Cerda and the
claimant were both selected for redundancy as they worked within the
respondent’s SEO offering. The claimant’s claim for direct race
discrimination on this basis must fail.
Case Number:3333 413/2018
11
41. We now turn to examine the respondent’s actions in dealing with potential
alternative opportunities for the claimant.
a. We conclude that Mr Childs has shown on the balance of probability
that the role digital project manager was a draft job description that
was at no stage ‘live’. This was a potential wish list and not a real job
vacancy available for any individual including the claimant at the time
of the termination of her employment.
b. We conclude on the balance of probability that the claimant was not
considered for the content manager role filled by Jonella as the
existence of Jonella indicates that the skills shortage test could not be
met for this role and the salary offered would not be sufficient to allow
the claimant to retain her Visa.
c. We note the content manager role occupied by Becca. This was not
a vacant position in July 2018. There is no obligation to ‘bump’ a
relatively new starter from an alternative position to make space for
the claimant. In any event, the claimant could not have undertaken
this role for the same reason as set out above, being the existence of
an employee within this role suggests that it could not meet the skills
shortage test and the salary does not meet the minimum required by
the claimant for her Visa.
42. In relation to the correct comparator for the alternative roles, we conclude
that the comparator is a hypothetical comparator who must, to lawfully work
under the Immigration Rules, earn a salary of at least £30,000 and any role
offered must meet the skills shortage test.
43. In taking the entirety of the evidence into account we conclude that the
claimant has not shown any prima facie case of direct discrimination. If we
are wrong, we conclude that the respondent has shown on the balance of
probability non-discriminatory reasons as set out above for the claimant not
to be offered the various alleged alternative roles. In light of the above
findings, we conclude that the claimant’s claims for direct discrimination are
unsuccessful and dismissed.
Notice
44. The claimant was given one weeks’ notice of the termination of her
employment. The claimant claims that her correct notice period was one
months’ notice. The respondent says that the notice period is clearly set out
in writing in the contract of employment signed by the claimant on
22/02/2018 reflecting a notice entitlement of one week.
45. The terms of a contract are the rights and obligations that bind the parties to
the contract. They can be express, implied or incorporated from other
sources. The basic principles of contract law are that there must be: an
intention to create legal relations, offer and acceptance, consideration
between the parties and certainty. Mr Childs was open in his evidence in that
the claimant’s bespoke agreement in respect of notice was forgotten by the
respondent when it was changing all employees’ terms and conditions. It
was not the respondent’s intention to change the claimant’s notice period. In
light of the starting point, we conclude on the balance of probability that the
claimant had a discussion with the HR person as she has described and
received reassurance prior to signing the document that there was to be no
Case Number:3333 413/2018
12
change to her existing notice period. This was at odds with what is stated on
the face of the documentation provided. When a dispute arises in the
employment context, the starting point for ascertaining the intention of the
parties is usually the written contract, in this case one weeks’ notice.
However, the tribunal considers it necessary to look beyond the written
document to the dealings between the parties and their subjective beliefs
about what obligations they have entered into. This appears to the tribunal
to be a situation whereby the written document signed by the parties does
not reflect the true intention of the parties. We conclude on the balance of
probability that there was no intention or belief by either party at the time this
contract was amended that the claimant’s notice period would be reduced.
In the circumstances the employment tribunal concludes that the proper
interpretation of the claimant’s contract of employment entitles her to one
months’ notice. The claimant’s claim for breach of contract succeeds.
46. For the sake of completeness, we note the incorrect end date of employment
recorded by the Home Office within their correspondence. We consider this
is a matter that should be addressed by the claimant with the Home Office
and does not give rise to any claim within these proceedings against the
respondent.
47. The employment tribunal heard evidence on liability only. As stated above it
is hoped that the parties will be able to agree remedy in the circumstances
without the need for a further hearing. To assist the party we note that the
claimant was paid for one weeks’ notice. The claimant was entitled to one
months’ notice. The appropriate remedy amount will be the claimant’s
normal monthly basic salary, less one week’s pay. These figures should be
calculated on a net basis.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Skehan
Date: 13 April 2020
Sent to the parties on: 21 April 2020
............................................................
For the Tribunal Office
.
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.