Ms J Hyde-Walsh v Skillnet Ltd: 3333570/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 06 October 2020, 10:59
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
disability-discrimination time-limits
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2020-08-24
Official Documents
-
Ms J Hyde-Walsh v Skillnet Ltd: 3333570/2018 - Judgment with Reasons
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number: 3333570/2018
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Ms J Hyde-Walsh v Skillnet Limited
Heard at: Watford On: 27 & 28 July 2020
Before: Employment Judge Alliott
Ms Angela Brosnan
Mr Ian Bone
Appearances
For the Claimant: In person
For the Respondent: Mr Alan Williams (Solicitor)
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the tribunal is that:
1. The claimant’s claim is dismissed.
REASONS
Introduction
1. The claimant was employed by the respondent from 3 January 2018 as a
regional skills manager. She was dismissed on 2 July 2018 at the end of
her probation period having failed to demonstrate her suitability for the role.
2. By a claim form presented on 1 October 2018 she made a claim of disability
discrimination (failure to make reasonable adjustments) and raised an issue
concerning breach of the Working Time Regulations 1998. The respondent
defends the claims.
The issues
Case Number: 3333570/2018
2
3. The issues were set out in a Case Management Summary by Employment
Judge Skehan following a CPH held on 4 March 2019.
4. The issues between the parties which potentially fall to be determined by
the tribunal are as follows:
“Disability status
4.1 Does/did the claimant have a physical impairment at the relevant
time?
4.2 If so does/did the impairment have a substantial adverse effect on
the claimant’s ability to carry out normal day to day activities?
4.3 If so is that effect long term in particular, when did it start and:
4.3.1 Has the impairment lasted for at least 12 months;
4.3.2 Is or was the impairment likely to last at least 12 months or
the rest of the claimant’s life, if less than 12 months.
4.4 Are any measures being taken to treat or correct the impairment?
But for those measures would the impairment be likely to have a
substantial adverse effect on the claimant’s ability to carry out normal
day to day activities?
4.5 The respondent has received a copy of the claimant’s impact
statement. The claimant must disclose any medical evidence as set
out below.
Failure to make reasonable adjustments
4.6 Did the respondent know or could it reasonably have been expected
to know the claimant was a person with a disability?
4.7 Did the respondent apply the following provision, criteria or practice
(PCP):
4.7.1 Requiring the claimant to drive
4.7.2 Requiring the claimant to attend meetings with learners, her
manager, clients, team members and senior management
meetings.
4.8 Did any such PCP put the claimant at a substantial disadvantage in
relation to a relevant matter in comparison with persons who are not
disabled at any relevant time?
4.9 If so, did the respondent know or could it reasonably have been
expected to know that the claimant was likely to be placed at any
such disadvantage?
Case Number: 3333570/2018
3
4.10 If so, were there steps that were not taken that could have been
taken by the respondent to avoid any such disadvantage. The
burden of proof does not lie on the claimant; however, it is helpful to
know what steps the claimant alleges should have been taken and
they are identified as follows:
4.10.1 Holding meeting by Skype or virtually;
4.10.2 Making arrangements in particular cases (such as meetings
with her manager, Mr Lowry, for the meetings to happen at
the claimant’s home);
Breach of Working Time and Regulations
4.11 To be clarified by the claimant – see below directions.”
5. The Working Time Regulations issue
5.1 The claim as originally pleaded clearly relates to being persistently
required to work in excess of 48 hours per week in breach of the
Working Time Regulations. The claimant told us that at the CPH
Employment Judge Skehan told her that the employment tribunal had
no jurisdiction to entertain such a claim. Accordingly, the claimant
was directed to set out full details of her claim under the Working
Time Regulations.
5.2 This the claimant did in a document entitled “Clarification of Health
and Safety” claim. This document reads mainly as if it is a personal
injury claim for negligence. The claimant acknowledges that as
regards working in excess of 48 hours is concerned, “… I understand
this is not an area covered by the jurisdiction of the employment
tribunal”. However, the document does refer in several places to a
lack of rest breaks. Obviously, a claim may be made to an
employment tribunal that an employer has refused to allow an
employee to exercise her right to rest breaks. Accordingly, we have
reviewed the position to determine if such a claim is before us.
5.3 The respondent pleaded an amended response to the claimant’s
further information, denying any breach and requesting details of the
dates and times that the claimant was alleging she was not provided
with rest breaks.
5.4 No such particulars have been provided by the claimant. The issue
of rest breaks is not dealt with at all in her witness statement. No
application to amend to include such a claim has been made.
5.5 The claimant’s contract of employment provides that her place of
work was her home and that she was entitled to a daily 60 minute
meal break. The claimant spent a considerable time driving and has
made reference to taking breaks at service stations. She was a
Case Number: 3333570/2018
4
senior manager who had a high degree of autonomy as to how to
structure her day, including the taking of breaks.
5.6 We decided that there is no pleaded or evidential claim before us of a
failure by the respondent to allow the claimant to take rest breaks
contrary to the Working Time Regulations. Accordingly, we record
that the claimant has not brought such a claim.
The evidence
6. We have been provided with a bundle running to 324 pages. In addition we
heard from the following witnesses:-
The claimant
Mr Eugene Lowry, the respondent’s operations director
Mr Lee Acton, the respondent’s chief executive officer
(by CVP) Mr David Whiffing, the respondent’s health and safety consultant
7. In addition we had a witness statement for the claimant from a Mr David
Walsh, a former skills coach assessor for the respondent. His evidence was
not challenged by the respondent and so we have taken his statement as
read.
The law
8. Disability
8.1 Although the respondent initially reserved its position on the issue of
disability, on 21 May 2019 the respondent conceded disability but
maintained that it did not have actual or constructive knowledge of
the claimant’s disability. Accordingly, we have treated the claimant
as disabled within the meaning of the Equality Act 2010 at all relevant
times.
8.2 Due to the respondent’s concession we have not had to deal with the
issues raised in relation to the claimant’s disability status.
8.3 Paragraph 20(1) of Schedule 8 to the Equality Act 2010 provides as
follows:-
“20. Lack of knowledge of disability, etc.
(1) A is not subject to a duty to make reasonable adjustments if A does not
know, and could not reasonably be expected to know-
…
(b) In any other case referred to in Part 2 of the schedule, that an interested
disabled person has a disability and is likely to be placed at the
disadvantage referred to in the first, second or third requirement.”
8.4 As per paragraph 21.8.5 of the IDS Employment Law Handbook
“Discrimination at Work”:-
Case Number: 3333570/2018
5
“It is clear from paragraph 20(1) that the employer will only come under the
duty to make reasonable adjustments if it knows not just that the relevant
person is disabled but also that his or her disability is likely to put him or her
at a substantial disadvantage in comparison with a non-disabled person.
Knowledge, in this regard, is not limited to actual knowledge but extends to
constructive knowledge (ie what the employer ought reasonably to have
known). In view of this, the EAT has held that a tribunal should approach this
aspect of a reasonable adjustments claim by considering two questions:
First, did the employer know both that the employee was disabled and
that his or her disability was liable to disadvantage him or her
substantially?
If not, ought the employer to have known both that the employee was
disabled and that his or her disability was liable to disadvantage him or
her substantially? – Secretary of State for Work & Pensions v Alam
[2010] ICR 665, EAT.
It is only if the answer to the second question is “No” that the employer avoids
the duty to make reasonable adjustments.”
8.5 The EHRC Code of Practice on Employment (2011) provides as
follows:-
“6.19 For disabled workers already in employment, an employer only has a
duty to make an adjustment if they know, or could reasonably be
expected to know, that a worker has a disability and is, or is likely to
be, placed at a substantial disadvantage. The employer must, however,
do all they can reasonably be expected to do to find out whether this is
the case. What is reasonable will depend on the circumstances. This
is an objective assessment. When making enquiries about disability,
employers should consider issues of dignity and privacy and ensure
that personal information is dealt with confidentially.
6.20 The act does not prevent a disabled person keeping a disability
confidential from an employer. But keeping a disability confidential is
likely to mean that unless the employer could reasonably be expected
to know about it anyway, the employer will not be under a duty to
make a reasonable adjustment. If a disabled person expects an
employer to make a reasonable adjustment, they will need to provide
the employer – or someone acting on their behalf, with sufficient
information to carry out that adjustment.”
8.6 As per the IDS Employment Law Handbook at 21.89:-
“While knowledge of the disability places a burden on employers to make
reasonable enquiries based on the information given to them, it does not
require them to make every possible enquiry, particularly where there is little
or no basis for so doing.”
Case Number: 3333570/2018
6
9. Reasonable adjustments
9.1 In this case we have concluded that the respondent did not know and
could not reasonably have been expected to know that the claimant
was a person with a disability and that a PCP would be likely to place
that employee at a substantial disadvantage. As such, a detailed
exposition of the law in relation to a failure to make reasonable
adjustments is not necessary.
9.2 However, the claimant bears the burden of establishing a prima facie
case that the duty to make reasonable adjustments has arisen and
that there are facts from which it could reasonably be inferred, absent
and explanation, that the duty has been breached.
9.3 In this case the claimant relies on the two PCPs set out in the list of
issues.
9.4 We have to consider whether the PCPs, if established, put the
claimant at a substantial disadvantage in relation to a relevant matter
and whether the respondent knew or could have reasonably have
been expected to know of that disadvantage.
9.5 We then need to consider the reasonableness of any proposed
adjustment.
The facts
10. The claimant was employed as Regional Skills Manager for the south-west
and Wales on 3 January 2018. She was managing four assessors in her
team plus, at some times, part-time/freelance assistants.
11. Her place of work was from home but there were regular management
meetings with clients, team members and senior management which
required her to travel by car. Latterly, when the claimant became
responsible for a departing team member’s caseload, her travels included
meetings with learners. After March 2018 approximately 80% of her time
was spent working away from home. Mr Acton told us and we accept that it
was open to the claimant to stay overnight in hotels at the respondent’s
expense and to cut short her working days whilst travelling.
12. On 15 January 2018 the claimant unfortunately had an accident whilst
descending stairs at the respondent’s offices in Croxley Green, Watford.
She stumbled and twisted her right knee and, after sitting through a
meeting, her knee swelled up badly. Later that evening she attended A&E.
In her witness statement the claimant states that she was told that she had
torn the meniscus ligament in her knee. We doubt that at that stage she
knew of the tear to her meniscus ligament or cartilage as it appears to have
been diagnosed following an MRI scan that took place on 24 January 2018.
13. Whether or not she was at that stage aware of the tear in her meniscus
ligament or cartilage, she does not appear to have reported it to her
Case Number: 3333570/2018
7
employers. Mr Lowry states that on 16 January 2018 she only reported that
she had been advised to rest her leg and keep it elevated.
14. On 16 January 2018 at 8:43 the claimant sent an email to the respondent
(name redacted) stating:-
“Meanwhile I twisted my right knee yesterday coming downstairs at Skillet. It’s
swollen and very painful and I went to A&E last night and they’ve given me a crutch
to aid walking.
I’ve notified Eugene and I’ll take the day off today to rest and will reschedule my
diary so that I can work from home until I regain some mobility.”
15. Later on 16 January 2018 at 11.54 the claimant sent another email to a
member of her team which stated as follows:-
“… I’m afraid I’m going to have to revise our meeting and the observation tomorrow
as I managed to twist and sprain my knee yesterday and spent the evening in A&E.
It’s now very swollen and painful so I’m having to rest and I’m not allowed to drive.
… I’m going to rest today and get back to work tomorrow as I should be able to work
from home until I regain some mobility.”
16. Later on 16 January 2018 at 13:15 the claimant sent an email to two other
members of her team as follows:-
“I managed to twist and sprain my knee yesterday while coming down the stairs at
Skillnet so as a result my mobility is going to be restricted for the next few weeks. At
the moment my knee is really swollen and very painful and I’ve been told not to drive
and I’ve been told to rest.
I don’t however plan to take much time off work and hope to get back either tomorrow
or Thursday as I’ll be able to work from home and I how (sic – hope) to do our 1-2-1
meetings by Skype and I’ll just have to postpone the planned observations until I can
get back on the road.”
17. On 17 January 2018 at 07:53 the claimant sent an email to Mr Lowry as
follows:-
“Just to let you know that my knee is still very painful and I’m unable to weight bear
so I’m planning to rest and keep my leg elevated again today.”
18. Later on 17 January 2018 at 09:19 Mr Lowry sent an email to Mr Whiffing
which states as follows:-
“I hope you are well. One of my new managers Jane Hyde-Walsh twisted her knee on
the stairs on Monday at Croxley not technically an accident but she did injure herself
enough to end up in hospital and took a half day sick yesterday as a result.
Anything I need to do?”
19. At 09:36 on 17 January 2018 Mr Whiffing replied to Mr Lowry as follows:-
Case Number: 3333570/2018
8
“It is classed as an accident and you need to record it in the accident book at Croxley
and make sure a copy is scanned to me so that I can record it.”
20. On 17 January 2018 at 10:20 Mr Lowry emailed Mr Whiffing again stating:-
“Let me know if I need to do anything else please.
She is off again today so two days off.
Advised rest and elevation of leg as some fluid on the knee.
Taking painkillers no other medication.”
21. Later that day Mr Whiffing replied:-
“Thanks Eugene, I have recorded the accident and left it open until she makes a full
recovery and return to work.
If she goes past seven days off can you let me know so that I can do the HSE
paperwork to notify them. On the other hand if she makes a full recovery and returns
to work within seven days also please let me know and I will close the accident log.”
22. The accident report was filled in on 17 January 2018. This records:-
“Give details of how the accident occurred with cause if known: Twisted knee as
turning corner on stairs…
Give details of any injury suffered by person involved: Twisted and sprained knee
required hospital visit rest recommended and painkillers advised MRI scan not
booked.”
23. The claimant resumed working from home on 18 January 2018.
24. Mr Lowry completed a return to work interview by telephone on 19 January
2018. This contains the following:-
“Discussed reasons for absence: Twisted knee in workplace on Monday 15 January.
Sprained knee resulted in hospital appointment. Recommended to rest and ice knee to
reduce swelling. Provided with crutch and now able to move and walk.”
“Summarise agreements and next steps. Jane has returned to work slightly restricted
mobility. Two days absent. Review again on Monday.”
25. On 23 January 2018 at 15:44 the claimant sent an email to Mr Lowry
concerning one of her team, Mr Walsh. This states:-
“I been working on profiling [Mr Walsh’s] learners and have found that 26 of them
should be terminated.
…
This termination exercise leaves [Mr Walsh] with a current and I feel manageable
workload of 31 at the moment. I therefore don’t think it’s worthwhile looking for
another skills coach at this point in time…”
26. Also on 23 January 2018 at 15:45 the claimant sent an email to Mr Lowry,
“Subject: update about knee injury”. This stated:-
Case Number: 3333570/2018
9
“I just wanted to update you on my knee injury, which is getting a bit better but is still
very painful. I have been offered a cancellation appointment for an MRI scan
tomorrow so I’ll be out of my office for a maximum of three hours…”
27. The claimant had the MRI scan on 24 January 2018.
28. On 25 January 2018 the claimant sent an email at 10:56 stating:-
“It’s improving slowly but surely. I had an MRI scan yesterday so I should know the
extent of the damage soon.”
29. We have a chain of emails between 17 January and 25 January 2018
wherein the claimant was requesting assistance from the respondent’s IT
department to hold meetings by Skype or other platform. The respondent’s
IT department provided the claimant with Webex login and password details
along with advice and follow up help. It would appear this was not pursued
as the claimant’s team members had not downloaded the necessary
software to link in to it. However, the respondent was clearly endeavouring
to offer Skype following a request from the claimant for it.
30. It is clear to us that the claimant had been advised to rest at home and not
drive following her accident. This the respondent allowed her to do.
31. In her witness statement at paragraphs 8 and 9 the claimant sets out that
she had to alter her workplans to accommodate her injury so that she would
not need to undertake one-to-one meetings with her team and that she dealt
with them remotely rather than face-to-face. In a Month 1 review form
completed on 21 February 2018 the claimant reported to the respondent:-
“This has been a challenging first month partly since I tore a ligament in my right knee
on 15 January 2018 – this has really slowed me down and has meant that I have had to
adjust my plans accordingly as I haven’t been able to make the face to face visits I
originally planned with each of my team members. However, I feel I have adjusted
quite well to the limitations caused by my injury and have spent a lot of valuable time
building relationships with both team members, colleagues, clients and learners.”
32. We find that the claimant had a high degree of autonomy as to how she did
her work and was allowed and able to restructure her working day around
her injury. She was allowed to miss a meeting due to be held on 30
January due to a footbridge making access difficult.
33. On 3 February 2018 Mr Whiffing emailed the claimant stating:-
“As I have not heard anything I am just checking to see if you are well and at work
after your accident? Please let me know”
34. On 5 February 2018 the claimant replied:-
“Many thanks for checking in and I was back at work within two days of my accident
as I am able to do my work from home.
Case Number: 3333570/2018
10
I’ve torn the cartilage in my right knee and I’m waiting to see what the doctor
recommends in terms of treatment. In the meantime I am being treated by a private
physio and have some exercises to do and it’s improving.”
35. On or about 9 February 2018 a member of the claimant’s team, Mr Walsh,
resigned. His case load reverted to the claimant as was the respondent’s
policy. How the claimant dealt with the extra caseload we find was down to
her. Mr Acton told us the options were:-
35.1 Recruit a new team leader
35.2 Utilise peripatetic resources (freelance/part-timers)
35.3 Allocate existing resources. The expectation was that the caseload
per team member would be 55. However, Mr Acton told us and we
accept that that figure could rise and fall seasonally and Mr Walsh’s
caseload could have been distributed amongst the remaining team
members.
35.4 Borrow resources from other regions.
36. The claimant did recruit a temporary assistant for one month in February
and this temp was approved for a second month in May.
37. The claimant did interview two candidates for team member but neither
were deemed suitable. However, it is clear to us that the respondent was
making the resource available to the claimant. The claimant does not
appear to have reallocated Mr Walsh’s caseload to her team members and
took on most of them herself. This did involve the claimant in some extra
travel. However, as manager of the team we find that that was her decision.
38. The claimant was required to meet Mr Walsh to conduct an exit interview.
She arranged this at a pub 30 minutes’ drive from her home. She was able
to attend but tells us it was difficult and painful as she was still on crutches.
We note that Mr Walsh, as junior to the claimant, could have been
instructed to attend her home. Be that as it may, had the claimant been too
unfit to drive it was open to her to decline on sickness or health grounds.
39. On 12 March Mr Whiffing emailed the claimant as follows:-
“Just checking on how your recovery is going after your accident. Are you fully
recovered now? Please let me know.”
40. On 12 March 2018 the claimant replied as follows:-
“Many thanks for your email and I’m making good progress.
I had an MRI scan which revealed a major tear in my meniscus ligament on my right
knee. I have seen a consultant and have been treated by a private physio and I’m now
in the NHS system receiving regular physio appointments and have a series of
exercises to do which I am doing.
The prognosis is that it should be fully healed by the end of April all being well.
Case Number: 3333570/2018
11
I’ll keep you posted about any changes to this but I am able to walk around alright
although not massive distances and stairs are difficult of [sic] me to navigate and it’s
still painful but nothing like it was before.”
41. On 20 April 2018 Mr Whiffing emailed the claimant as follows:-
“How are you? Are you recovered yet?”
42. On 20 April 2018 the claimant replied as follows:-
“Thanks for asking and I’m getting there. Still under the care of physio and although I
had a setback earlier this month from overdoing things it seems to be healing slowly
but surely.”
43. On 2 May 2018 the claimant’s probation period was extended.
44. As regards the two PCPs recorded in the list of issues, there is no real
dispute that they did form part of the claimant’s job. She was required to
drive and she was required to attend meetings with learners, her manager,
clients, team members and senior management meetings.
45. The substantial disadvantage alleged by the claimant to flow from these
PCPs is not set out in the list of issues. At the outset of this hearing we
invited the claimant to identify the substantial disadvantage that she claims
she was put at as a result of the PCPs. She explained to us that the extent
of driving that her job entailed caused an exacerbation of the pain in her
right knee which made it very difficult. She says that she was in constant
pain and could not straighten her leg.
46. It is fair to say that in her claim form the claimant set out:-
“The increasing amount of travel and hours I worked in order to meet KPIs caused
increased…?... discomfort to my right leg and had a severe impact on my wellbeing.”
(On every copy part of the sentence is obliterated)
47. However that quote was very much in the context of working excessive
hours.
48. In her witness statement the claimant barely alludes to the alleged
difficulties in driving. The meeting with Mr Walsh on 9 February 2018 was
clearly difficult as she was still on crutches and she says she suffered pain
driving there and back. However, apart from that, the only incident she
refers to is one in early June when she had to go to Plymouth for three days
of delivery time. She states:-
“My knee injury made it daunting for me to repeat this journey, which I’d previously
undertaken in April…”
49. In a bid to mitigate the effects of driving a long way the claimant’s partner
drove her. Again the context of this complaint is very much being required
to work excessive hours.
Case Number: 3333570/2018
12
50. We have considered whether the requirement to drive considerable
distances for considerable periods of time put the claimant at a substantial
disadvantage compared with persons who weren’t disabled. We find that
the claimant steadily increased her driving time between March and June
2018 from 1,050 miles to 2,097. Apart from the initial month from her
accident, there is no contemporaneous documentation indicating that the
claimant at any stage informed the respondent that driving caused an
exacerbation of pain and discomfort, the substantial disadvantage that she
now claims.
51. On 22 June 2018 Mr Whiffing emailed the claimant as follows:-
“How are you? Are you fit and well or still under recovery? Please let me know.”
52. On 22 June 2018 the claimant replied as follows:-
“Many thanks for checking in and I’m lots better thank you. I’ve been discharged
from the physio and have an exercise regime to follow so I continue to strengthen the
muscles around the injury. It can still ache from time to time but I can walk quite far
now but just have to be careful – no marathon walks for me any me [sic]!
On another subject I’m finding I’m working major hours and have raised this with
Eugene. I got home at 8pm last night having clocked 55 hours for the week. Still
working again today – so will probably clock 63 or 64 hours for this week. Can you
please give me some guidance on how to manage this as I haven’t opted out of the
working time directive and know I’m in breach?”
53. Once again it appears to us that the nature of the claimant’s complaint is not
so much the fact of having to drive but the fact that she was having to drive
excessive hours. Nevertheless, since it may be said that establishing a
substantial disadvantage represents a relatively low threshold, we accept
that being required to drive and attend meetings did place the claimant at a
substantial disadvantage compared with an able bodied individual in that it
caused her pain.
54. We go on to consider whether the respondent knew or ought to have known
that the requirement to drive and attend meetings was likely to place the
claimant at such a disadvantage.
55. We note that the claimant was well able to complain about having to work
for excessive hours. We find that had she suffered significant problems with
driving then she would have raised it with the respondent. That she did not
suggests that she did not suffer the claimed disadvantage to any great
extent. In any event we find that the respondent was unaware of any such
alleged disadvantage. The impression we have formed is that the claimant
was initially advised not to drive but then gradually increased her mobility,
increasing the number of miles covered per month steadily. This was all
against a background where every time she was asked how she was
progressing she was positive and suggesting steady progress.
56. It is now clear that the claimant’s injury has not progressed as initially
expected. In her witness statement the claimant states that:-
Case Number: 3333570/2018
13
“Medical staff were optimistic that it could improve over time with physiotherapy
treatment and adjustments in my lifestyle.”
57. It is noticeable that in her claim form the claimant states:-
“I was unaware at the time that the severity of my injury met the definition of a
disability under the Equality Act and I was entitled to have reasonable adjustments
made to my job role.”
58. She also states in her claim form:-
“As I was still on probation and given the way staff were treated in the business I was
loathe to complain or ask for any special treatment.”
59. Indeed Mr Acton reports the claimant as stating during her appeal hearing
that she had not “shouted loud enough” about what she felt she needed.
60. Whether or not an employee knows she is disabled and whether or not the
employee asks for adjustments does not, in our judgment, absolve the
employer from making reasonable enquiries if circumstances warrant such
enquiries. However, it does provide some context as to both the claimant’s
and the respondent’s knowledge of her injury and the likely prognosis. We
find that the claimant was optimistic about making a recovery and that this
was what she was reporting to the respondent.
61. Following a review of the claimant’s probation period on 25 June 2018 the
claimant was dismissed on 2 July and her appeal was unsuccessful.
Conclusions
62. We find that the claimant was disabled within the meaning of the Equality
Act 2010.
63. We find that the respondent did not know that the claimant was disabled at
any relevant time within the meaning of the Equality Act 2010.
64. We have carefully considered whether the respondent did all they could
reasonably be expected to do to find out whether the claimant was disabled
and whether a PCP was likely to place her at a substantial disadvantage.
65. We find that the claimant at all times was very optimistic about her
prospects of making a full recovery, for example her indication to the
respondent on 12 March that the prognosis was for a full recovery by the
end of April.
66. It may be that the claimant was underplaying the impact of her injury on her
work, but we find that she presented as coping and able to do her job.
Regular enquiries were made of her as to her progress and she provided
information of ongoing treatment and steady progress. Further, the claimant
made no contemporaneous complaints about the driving she was required
Case Number: 3333570/2018
14
to do putting her at a disadvantage in the sense that it caused her excessive
pain.
67. We find that the enquiries that the respondent made as to the claimant’s
wellbeing following her accident were entirely reasonable in the light of the
information she was providing to the respondent. We find that the severity
and implications of a torn meniscus are potentially variable and could result
in a range of outcomes. In our judgment a torn meniscus does not
automatically constitute an injury of such severity that disability should be
assumed probably to arise. On the facts of this case we find that such
enquiries as the respondent made in the context of the information available
at the time were entirely reasonable. We find that the claimant did all that it
could reasonably be expected to inform itself as to the nature, extent and
prognosis of the claimant’s injury. Consequently we find that the
respondent could not reasonably have been expected to know of the
claimant’s disability and could not reasonably have been expected to know
of the specific disadvantage alleged in this case.
68. Accordingly the claimant’s claim is dismissed.
69. We do not go on to consider the adequacy of the adjustments that were in
fact provided to the claimant as to do so is unnecessary.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Alliott
Date: …24/08/2020.…………………..
Sent to the parties on: .02/09/2020.....
..............S.Kent …..............................
For the Tribunal Office
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.