Ms M Janiga v Thistle Recycling Solution Ltd: 2503336/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 10 July 2019, 13:11
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
maternity-and-pregnancy-rights sex-discrimination unfair-dismissal unlawful-deduction-from-wages
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2019-05-30
Official Documents
-
Ms M Janiga v Thistle Recycling Solution Ltd: 2503336/2018 - Rule 21 Judgment
-
Ms M Janiga v Thistle Recycling Solution Ltd and Mr Mateusz Szramke: 2503336/2018 - Judgment
-
Ms M Janiga v Thistle Recycling Solution Ltd and Mr Mateusz Szramke: 2503336/2018 - Certificate of Correction
Change History
-
New judgment
-
Judgment added.
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number 2503336 /18
1
THE EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Ms M Janiga Thistle Recycling Solution Limited
EMPLOYMENT JUDGE GARNON
MADE AT MIDDLESBROUGH ON 11 March 2019
JUDGMENT (Liability Only )
Employment Tribunals Rules of Procedure 2013 –Rule 21
1. The name of the respondent is amended to that shown above without the need
for re-service.
2. The claims are well founded.
3.A Hearing will be listed on the first available date after 15 May 2019 to decide
remedy at which the respondent may attend to be heard on remedy only.
REASONS
1. The claimant, who is Polish, was employed from January 2018 as a shop assistant in
the Hartlepool shop of a company she thought was called Thistle Recycling Solutions
Limited. The shop named “Cash 4 Clothes” bought and sold second-hand clothes .The
claimant knows it has shops in Sunderland and Glasgow and believes it has more.
2. In April 2018 she told her manager, a man she knows as “Miron”, she was pregnant.
After speaking with a man the claimant believes in charge of finance, called Karol
Gocyka, Miron confirmed she would be permitted to work up to the start of her maternity
leave. At Mr Gocyka’s request she completed a pregnancy risk assessment form. She
was the only member of staff in the shop, working her contracted 20 hours a week plus
overtime, so when she was not present the shop was closed. She still has the key.
From May 2018 onwards, although she continued to receive payslips, no money was
paid into her bank and she was told the shop should not be opened.
3. She used text messages in an attempt to contact both these gentlemen but was
ignored. She also sent emails to the office in Glasgow which were unanswered. On 16
July, Miron telephoned her saying she no longer would be working for the company.
Case Number 2503336 /18
2
4. This was done on the instruction of a person she describes as the “boss” whose
name she knows as Mateusz. After trying without success to find out what was
happening and why, she commenced Early Conciliation (EC) on 12 September, which
ran its full course until 12 October when an EC Certificate was issued.
5. She presented her claim on 27 October but it was not served until 2 January, by post
to the registered office of the respondent which, as revealed by a company search is
called Thistle Recycling Solution (without an “s”) Limited. A minor amendment to the
respondent’s name without the need for re-service in my view does no injustice . A
claim may be validly served on a limited company at its registered office. A response
was due by 30 January 2019 but none was received.
5.The respondent was incorporated on 9 June 2017 and its registered office is Unit 4
South Douglas Street,, Clydebank, Glasgow G81 1PD. Its status is shown as active . It
last filed a confirmation statement on 8 February 2019. On 31 January 2019 Mr
Mateusz Edward Szramke and Ms Aleksandra Ewa Figacz filed notice they had ceased
to have significant control of the company on 11 October 2017. On 13 October 2017 it
changed its registered office from 4D Auchingramont Road, Hamilton,ML3 6JT.
following the termination of Mr Mateusz Szramke as a director and the appointment of
Ms Figacz as such and Mr Andrzej Szramke as company secretary on 5 October
2017. The claimant knows Mr Andrzej Szramke is the father of Mr Mateusz Szramke.
6. On 31 January 2019 the Tribunal received an email from someone signing herself
“Alexandra” of “Glasgow Recycling”. It said “We have received a letter from
Employment Tribunal, person who has been dealing with this case has left our company
,we would like to know what is the progress of the case now” . A company called
Glasgow Recycling Ltd (Company Number SC573016) had its registered office at 140
Broxburn Road Glasgow G53 5RY. It was dissolved on 8 January 2019 having been
incorporated on 7 August 2017. Another company called Glasgow Recycling Ltd
(Company Number SC386348) had its registered office at 4D Auchingramont Road
Hamilton, ML3 6JT. It was dissolved on 28 March 2014 having been incorporated on 1
October 2010.A company may trade under a name other than its own. On 4 February
2019 Employment Judge Johnson extended the time for the respondent to file a
response to 28 February and ordered a preliminary hearing to clarify the correct identity
of the respondents who could be liable to the claimant. This was explained in a letter
sent to both parties on 7 February 2019 . Still no response was received and no further
word from anyone on behalf of the respondent.
7. On 11 March 2019 I conducted that preliminary hearing, having first performed
company searches. When I told the claimant what they showed, her response was that
the respondent had changed its trading name and she had been told its “owners” had
changed . When she asked Miron for contact details for Mr Mateusz Szramke he said
he could not provide them.
8. I am required by rule 21 of the Employment Tribunals Rules of Procedure 2013 to
decide on the available material whether a determination can be made and, if so,
Case Number 2503336 /18
3
obliged to issue a judgment which may determine liability only or liability and remedy. I
have in the claim form, and what the claimant told me at the preliminary hearing,
sufficient information to enable me to find the claims proved on a balance of probability
but not enough to determine the sums to be awarded. For reasons I will record in a
separate Order, the claim will now be amended to add a further respondent, Mr
Mateusz Szramke, and the remedy hearing listed far enough ahead to enable him to
respond on his own behalf.
------------------------------------------------
TM Garnon Employment Judge
Date signed 11 March 2019 .
Case Number 2503336/18
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Ms M Janiga
First Respondent: Thistle Recycling Solution Limited
Second Respondent: Mr Mateusz Szramke
Held at: Middlesbrough On: 30 May 2019
Employment Judge Shepherd
Appearances
For the Claimant: In person
Interpreter: Mr R Zaborniak
For the First Respondent: No attendance
For the Second Respondent: No attendance
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the Tribunal is as follows:
1. The claims of unfair dismissal, unauthorised deduction from wages and
discrimination by reason of pregnancy or maternity against the second respondent
are well founded and succeed.
2. Judgment on liability having been given against the first respondent by
Employment Judge Garnon on 11 March 2019 and sent to the parties on 13 March
2019. The following remedy is awarded:
2.1. Unfair dismissal and discrimination by reason of pregnancy and maternity
– the respondents are jointly and severally ordered to pay to the claimant the
sum of ££14,384.80
2. 2. Unauthorised deduction from wages- the sum of £2,192.40 was the
amount of unauthorised deductions from wages pursuant to section 13 of the
Employment Rights Act 1996. The deduction of these wages was also a
detriment and the figures included within the award for discrimination and is
not awarded twice.
The total amount the respondent to ordered to pay to the claimant is £14,384.80.
Case Number 2503336/18
2
Employment Judge Shepherd
30 May 2019
Note: Reasons for the judgment having been given orally at the hearing, written reasons will not be
provided unless a request was made by either party at the hearing or a written request is presented
by either party within 14 days of the sending of this written record of the decision.
All judgments and reasons for the judgments are published, in full, online at
www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions shortly after a copy has been sent to the
claimant(s) and respondent(s) in a case.
Case No: 2503336/2018
10.15 Certificate of Correction – rule 69 March 2017
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Ms M Janiga
First Respondent: Thistle Recycling Solution Ltd
Second Respondent: Mr Mateusz Szramke
CERTIFICATE OF CORRECTION
Employment Tribunals Rules of Procedure 2013
Under the provisions of Rule 69, the Judgment sent to the parties on 8 June 2019,
is corrected as set out in BOLD type and are underlined in the final sentence of
the judgment.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Shepherd
______________________________
19 June 2019
Important note to parties:
Any dates for the filing of appeals or reviews are not changed by this certificate of
correction and corrected judgment. These time limits still run from the date of the original
judgment, or original judgment with reasons, when appealing.
Case No: 2503336/2018
10.15 Certificate of Correction – rule 69 March 2017
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Ms M Janiga
First Respondent: Thistle Recycling Solution Limited
Second Respondent: Mr Mateusz Szramke
Held at: Middlesbrough On: 30 May 2019
Employment Judge Shepherd
Appearances
For the Claimant: In person
Interpreter: Mr R Zaborniak
For the First Respondent: No attendance
For the Second Respondent: No attendance
JUDGMENT
The judgment of the Tribunal is as follows:
1. The claims of unfair dismissal, unauthorised deduction from wages and discrimination
by reason of pregnancy or maternity against the second respondent are well founded and
succeed.
2. Judgment on liability having been given against the first respondent by Employment
Judge Garnon on 11 March 2019 and sent to the parties on 13 March 2019. The following
remedy is awarded:
2.1. Unfair dismissal and discrimination by reason of pregnancy and maternity
– the respondents are jointly and severally ordered to pay to the claimant the
sum of £14,384.80
2. 2. Unauthorised deduction from wages- the sum of £2,192.40 was the
amount of unauthorised deductions from wages pursuant to section 13 of the
Employment Rights Act 1996. The deduction of these wages was also a
detriment and the figures included within the award for discrimination and is
not awarded twice.
The total amount the respondents are ordered to pay to the claimant is £14,384.80.
Employment Judge Shepherd
30 May 2019
Case No: 2503336/2018
10.15 Certificate of Correction – rule 69 March 2017
Sent to the parties on
8 June 2019
Julie Davies
Note: Reasons for the judgment having been given orally at the hearing, written reasons will not be
provided unless a request was made by either party at the hearing or a written request is presented
by either party within 14 days of the sending of this written record of the decision.
All judgments and reasons for the judgments are published, in full, online at
www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions shortly after a copy has been sent to the
claimant(s) and respondent(s) in a case.
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.