Ms N Brown v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd: 3300410/2017
Employment Tribunal
Published on 03 December 2018, 14:34
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
disability-discrimination
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2018-09-20
Official Documents
-
Ms N Brown v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd: 3300410/2017 - Preliminary.
-
Ms N Brown v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd: 3300410/2017 - Reserved Judgment
-
Ms N Brown v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd: 3300410/2017 REM Judgment
-
Ms N Brown v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd: 3300410/2017 - Judgment Reasons
-
Ms N Brown v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd: 3300410/2017 - Judgment
Decision Content
Read the full decision in
Read the full decision in .
Read the full decision in .
Read the full decision in .
Read the full decision in .
Change History
-
New Judgment
-
New Judgment
-
Reserved Judgment.
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case No: 3300410/2017
Page 1 of 1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
BETWEEN
Claimant Respondents
Ms N Brown and R1 – Network Rail Infrastructure Limited
R2 – Linda Pham
JUDGMENT
Upon withdrawal by the Claimant, the 2nd Respondent is dismissed from the
proceedings.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Vowles
Date: …19 July…………..… 2017
Sent to the parties on:
……19/08/17................
.......................................
For the Tribunals Office
Case Number: 3300410/2017
(J) Page 1 of 1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Ms Natalie Brown
Respondent: Network Rail Infrastructure Limited
Heard at: Reading On: 7 August 2018
Before: Employment Judge Gumbiti-Zimuto
Appearances
For the Claimant: Mr J Chegwidden (Counsel)
For the Respondent: Mr T Adkin (Counsel)
REMEDY JUDGMENT
The respondent is ordered to pay to the claimant the sum of £32,990.56.
_____________________________
Employment Judge Gumbiti-Zimuto
Date: 7 August 2018
Sent to the parties on: .14.08.18....
............................................................
For the Tribunals Office
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 1 of 9
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Respondent:
Ms N Brown v Network Rail Infrastructure
Limited
Heard at: Reading On: 7 August 2018
Before: Employment Judge Gumbiti-Zimuto
Appearances
For the Claimant: Mr J Chegwidden (Counsel)
For the Respondent: Mr T Adkin (Counsel)
JUDGMENT having been sent to the parties on 14 August 2018 and
reasons having been requested in accordance with Rule 62(3) of the Rules of
Procedure 2013, the following reasons are provided:
REASONS FOR REMEDY JUDGMENT
1. In a judgment sent to the parties on 19 June 2018, the Employment
Tribunal found that the Claimant’s complaints of direct disability
discrimination, discrimination arising from disability, disability harassment
and victimisation are well-founded and succeed. A remedy hearing was
listed to take place today. The Claimant provided a witness statement; the
Respondent provided a witness statement from Ms Pangbourne, Head of
Human Resources (Policy, Projects and Performance) for Infrastructure
Projects. The parties provided an agreed remedy bundle. We have Outline
Submissions on Remedy from the Respondent and a Note on Remedy
from the Claimant.
2. The issues that we have had to determine are the level of an award for
injury to feelings, whether the Claimant should be entitled to recover for
personal injuries, whether an award should be made in respect of
aggravated damages, whether the Claimant is entitled to an uplift as a
result of any breach of the ACAS Code, the level of interest that the
Claimant is entitled to recover, and whether the Tribunal should make any
recommendations.
3. The Claimant has also made a claim in respect of loss of bonus. The
Respondent conceded this and the Claimant is entitled to recover the sum
of £276.90.
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 2 of 9
Injury to Feelings
4. The Employment Tribunal has come to the conclusion that the Claimant is
entitled to recover the sum of £22,000.00 in respect of injury to feelings. In
arriving at our award for injury to feelings, we have taken into account the
following features of this case.
5. The Claimant’s statement relating to remedy has not been contested by
the Respondent.
6. We note that in respect of the incident on 4 November 2016, the Claimant
states that she “felt a total loss of control”, that she “felt anxious” and
“started to shake”, she “felt sick”, she “felt shortness of breath” and she
“felt dizzy”. The Claimant says: “I wanted to escape to a safe place i.e.
home. Later that day, she had a tremendous headache and just wanted to
sleep”.
7. In respect of the incident on 9 November, the Claimant describes how on
the day of the incident, she “was extremely upset. I had a lump in my
throat and was desperately trying to hold back my tears and keep myself
composed. I felt hot, flustered and angry. I had the shakes, palpitations
and … felt sick. I wanted to escape to a safe place, i.e. home, … Home is
how I distance myself from the outside world when I can’t cope”.
8. The Claimant described how she was unable to sleep, felt anxious, angry,
and worried about what her team would think if her “but also about
continuing to work with somebody who did not take my disabilities
seriously”. The Claimant describes how when she awoke, she sent
several text messages to Linda Pham expressing her anger and how
upset she felt by Linda Pham’s actions.
9. The Claimant describes how she felt emotional and tearful; explained how
the matter had damaged her trust; described how she was anxious about
her disability and felt as though she had been treated as if she had a
disease and had become the laughing stock of the office. The Claimant
describes how she suffered an exacerbation of her OCD symptoms. The
Claimant, describing the nature of her disability, sets out in her statement
a description of the effect of her OCD symptoms.
10. The Claimant was unwell and unable to work because of the effect of the
events which had occurred on 4, 9 and 10 November 2016. The Claimant
who was prescribed medication to treat various ailments, because of the
incidents which occurred, had an increase in her medication.
11. The Claimant explains how the delay in dealing with her grievance caused
her further distress. She believes that the way the grievance was dealt
with was designed to deliberately cause her distress. The Claimant’s GP
records indicate that the Claimant’s mental health symptoms became
worse in the period following the incidents in November 2016. The GP
records for 16 November 2016 indicate that the Claimant’s medication
increased and that at that time she was complaining of not sleeping and
being tearful. She was not fit to work.
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 3 of 9
12. The Claimant describes how her emotions were intense; how on some
days she would feel weak and suffer double vision and be hyperacusis1.
The Claimant describes how she was reliant on over the counter sleeping
pills. She describes herself as medicating “to switch my brain off and let
my brain rest”.
13. The delay in dealing with the Claimant’s grievance had an impact on her
health.
14. On the Claimant’s return to work, she was placed in a role where she was
not required to work with Linda Pham. She was able to cope better with
her work and life, although at times still suffering some symptoms resulting
from the way that she had been treated by the Respondent.
15. The Claimant describes show she felt that she had been isolated in the
period from November 2016 until February 2017 and states that this was a
matter which caused her stress and anxiety. The Claimant explained that
moving her from her usual place of work at Davidson House to an office
away from Linda Pham left her feeling that she was the one who was
considered to be the problem.
16. The Claimant describes how the change in her office environment caused
her isolation and how the changed routine resulted in the worsening of her
OCD symptoms and triggered panic attacks. The Claimant describes
instances where she suffered panic attacks while on overcrowded trains
and how she suffered from increased levels of paranoia. We were
provided with an Access to Work Mental Health Support Service Plan
which described her mental health symptoms at the time.
17. By December 2016, the Claimant was struggling to remain positive, had a
mix of emotions, felt angry, tearful, confused and insecure. Her confidence
was shattered. She felt extremely tired and was struggling with poor sleep
and relying on sleeping pills.
18. The Claimant has set out detriments as she saw them and which arose
from the delay in dealing with her grievance. She describes how this
caused her stress, anxiety and worry. She describes how during the
grievance process she felt excluded from the team and how she suffered
nightmares and night sweats.
19. By January 2017, the Claimant was suffering from extreme low mood. She
states that the failure to resolve her grievance caused an increase in her
symptoms. The Claimant was referred to the mental health service as a
result of her symptoms. At the time of her assessment by the mental
health services, she described how she was upset, angry, crying and
could not get to bed or leave the house.
20. It was not until February that the Claimant was told the outcome of the
grievance. The Claimant describes how the outcome to the grievance did
nothing to alleviate the impact of the matters that had happened to her.
1 Hyperacusis is the name for intolerance to everyday sounds that causes significant distress and
affects a person's day-to-day activities.
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 4 of 9
She describes how when she was asked to take garden leave, this left her
feeling that she was not wanted. She explained the disappointment that
she felt at the outcome of the grievance process and her feelings that
complaints that she made had not been taken seriously. She says that she
was shocked that colleagues who she considered to be friends had
described her in their statements as mentally unstable and portrayed her
as “something of a nutter”.
21. The Claimant described events in March 2017 which resulted in her having
to attend the A&E department of the hospital; she describes being under
considerable stress in about March 2017. The Claimant’s appeal to her
grievance outcome was made in April 2017.
22. It was not until June 2017 that she received a response to the grievance
appeal.
23. We are referred to parts of the report prepared by a Consultant
Psychiatrist. The Claimant describes how she has always suffered with
depression, anxiety and OCD but goes on to state that as a result of the
work-related issues, she had suffered poor sleep and had to rely on
sleeping pills, something that she had never experienced before. She
further described how she had suffered panic attacks and suffered
breathing difficulties as a result of the treatment at work. She also
describes periods when she had over-eaten and under-eaten and suffered
flashbacks of incidents. She described how her OCD became out of
control, all of these matters she puts down to the treatment that she
suffered at work.
24. The Claimant describes returning to work in May 2017 with a new
manager who has been supportive and built up her confidence. At one
point, it appeared as though Linda Pham was going to resume as the
Claimant’s line manager, however, following discussions with the Claimant
and her union representative, alternative arrangements are being put in
place to allow the Claimant to continue to work under the manager with
whom she has enjoyed a successful return to work.
25. Taking these matters into account and also having regard to all of the
matters which were set out in our findings of fact in the liability decision,
the Tribunal has had to consider what the appropriate level of award is in
respect of injury to feelings.
26. The Tribunal has helpfully been provided with an extract from the IDS
Employment Law Handbooks, Volume 4, Discrimination at Work, Chapter
7, the section headed “Injury to Feelings, Quantum Vento Guidelines. We
have considered the contents of this document which we have found
helpful and useful in arriving at our decision.
27. The Tribunal has also had regard to the outline submissions provided by
the Respondent and the note on remedy prepared on behalf of the
Claimant.
28. The Claimant and the Respondent both agree that the appropriate Vento
band in respect of compensation is the middle band as set out in the
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 5 of 9
original Vento guidelines.
29. The Vento guidelines provided that the top band should normally be for
sums between the range of £15,000-25,000 and that sums in this range
should be awarded in the most serious cases such as where there has
been a lengthy campaign of discriminatory harassment on the grounds of
race or sex. Vento stated that the middle band was for cases between
£5,000 and £15,000 and should be used for serious cases which do not
merit an award in the highest band.
30. Having considered the specific features of this case, we consider that the
parties are correct to describe this as a serious case which should merit an
award which is not in the highest band. In arriving at our decision in this
case, we have regard to the fact that the Vento bands have been revised
in the case of Da’Bell v National Society for Prevention of Cruelty to
Children (2009) and also have had regard to the guidance of the Court of
Appeal in the case of De Souza v Vinci Construction (UK) Ltd (2017).
31. When we considered the circumstances of this case, we are satisfied that
the description that the Claimant gives of the impact that the discrimination
that she suffered shows that she has suffered serious harm as a result of
the discrimination. She has described a significant degree of injury to her
feelings. We note that there are features of the way that she was treated
by the Respondent which in our view would have resulted in an increase in
her injury to feelings.
32. In the manner in which the Respondent dealt with the grievance, we note
the delay not only in investigating the grievance but in also promulgating
the decision once there had been some investigation of the grievance. We
also note that the manner in which the grievance investigation was
conducted by the Respondent was inadequate for the reasons that we
have set out in our liability judgment and that this had a very real impact
on the Claimant.
33. We note the level of distress suffered by the Claimant which we consider
amounted to personal injury. She describes her lack of control, the anxiety
and illness that she suffered as a direct result of the stress that she was
suffering at this time.
34. The Tribunal notes and takes into account the fact that there were other
live factors which the Claimant sets out in her evidence which had an
impact on the Claimant’s condition during the relevant period but the
Tribunal is satisfied that the Claimant would have been generally dealing
with these stressors which occur in life in a way which enabled her to
function normally and appropriately at work but for the actions of the
respondent’s discrimination. It was only after the problems that arose at
work in respect of which she has been successful in bringing this claim
that the Claimant was tipped over the edge and suffered harm and
damage that resulted in her being unable to function properly and for a
significant period of time unable to work.
35. For these reasons, we are of the view that an award of compensation to
the Claimant is a matter which should be towards the top end of the middle
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 6 of 9
band of the Vento guidelines.
36. In arriving at the appropriate level of award in this case, we have looked at
the original Vento guidelines and in considering them we are of the view
that the Claimant should be awarded a figure which sits at 80% of the
middle band, that is a figure of about £13,000.00, applying the original
Vento award.
37. We have then gone on to consider the guidance set out in the Presidential
Guidance and applied a formula as described in the Presidential
Guidance.
“An Employment Tribunal may uprate the bands for inflation by
applying the formula x divided by y (178.5) multiplied by z and
where x is the relevant boundary of the relevant band in the original
Vento decision and z is the appropriate value from the RPI All Items
Index for the month and year closest to the date of presentation of
the claim (and, where the claim falls for consideration after 1 April
2013, then applying the Simmons v Castle 10% uplift).”2
38. To arrive at the figure at today’s date and we have therefore taken the
figure of £13,000.00 and divided that by 178.5 which is the RPI All Items
Index Value at the date of the Vento decision. We have then multiplied
that figure by 269.3 which is the RPI All Items Index Value for the month of
March 2017. We arrive at a figure of £19,612.88. We have applied a 10%
uplift as provided for in the case of Simmons v Castle and arrived at a
figure of about £21,574.17. The Tribunal has then rounded that figure up
to £22,000.00 which we consider to be an appropriate award in respect of
injury to feelings.
39. The Tribunal has then gone on to consider whether or not the Claimant
should be compensated for personal injury. The Tribunal has had the
opportunity of considering the medical evidence which was set out in the
trial bundle and also the Claimant’s evidence. It is the view of the Tribunal
that a fair reading of the evidence that has been presented to us shows
that the Claimant was generally affected by a variety of life events which
resulted in her becoming ill, in particular during the period from the end of
2016 into the first half of 2017.
40. The cause of her condition is life events which included the difficulties that
she faced at work and the discriminatory matters that she suffered. We are
satisfied that the Claimant’s personal injuries in this case were caused by
life events which included the way that she was treated at work.
41. We have then attempted to determine the extent to which the treatment at
work had an impact on the Claimant, the extent to which it tipped her over
the edge and/or caused the specific injury that she sustained, and we are
satisfied that the appropriate level of award should reflect 70% to the
impact of events at work. We come to this conclusion because it is clear
2 Employment Tribunal awards for injury to feelings and psychiatric injury PRESIDENTIAL
GUIDANCE (5 SEPTEMBER 2017)
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 7 of 9
from the Claimant’s evidence that whilst she suffered a variety of
difficulties and stresses, it was the impact of the discrimination at work
which caused the Claimant to sustain a level of injury which meant that
she was not able to operate in a normal way. It damaged her health and
made it impossible for her to be able to continue to work in ordinary
circumstances as she describes in her witness statement.
42. Having come to the conclusion that the Claimant is entitled to recover a
figure representing 70% of the sum which she is entitled to recover by way
of personal injury having regard to the medical evidence produced, we
note that the parties are agreed that the appropriate point to pitch the
Claimant’s award for personal injury in this case is the sum of £4,900.00.
The arrive at this by reference to the Judicial College Guidelines section
relating to psychiatric injuries. Bearing this in mind we consider that an
award of £3,500.00 is an appropriate sum to award in respect of personal
injury, that being approximately 70% of the sum of £4,900.00.
Aggravated damages
43. There are in this case things that could classically be described as
aggravating features: the delay in dealing with the Claimant’s grievance
investigation; the delay in promulgating the decision once it was
investigated; the failure to investigate the complaints properly; the failure
to deal with the Claimant’s case in a timely way in circumstances where
the Respondent was aware of the Claimant’s illness. However, all those
matters have been expressly taken into account in considering the
appropriate level of award for injury to feelings.
44. The question we have asked ourselves is whether this Respondent has in
this case demonstrated a highhandedness or oppressiveness towards the
Claimant so as to justify an award of aggravated damages. We remind
ourselves that aggravated damages are compensatory and to be awarded
in cases where the behaviour of the respondent, in causing injury to the
claimant, has been high handed malicious or oppressive.
45. In this case we do not consider that there is a level of harm to the claimant
caused by the respondent’s conduct which has not been compensated in
the award for injury to feelings to justify a further award for aggravated
damages.
Breach of ACAS Code
46. The Tribunal considers that the manner in which the Respondent delayed
in dealing with the Claimant’s grievance investigation, the failure to
properly investigate the Claimant’s complaints, the delay in promulgating
the Claimant’s decision are all factors that indicate a breach of the ACAS
code of practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures.
47. The Tribunal accepts that this was a case where the Respondent made a
genuine effort to deal with the Claimant’s grievances. We noted in the
liability decision the way that the matter was conducted by Phil Mear. The
fact that there was a genuine attempt to deal with the Claimant’s
grievances does not in our view remedy the fact that there was a failure to
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 8 of 9
deal with them in a way which is compliant with the ACAS code. The
Tribunal also notes that in dealing with the Claimant’s appeal on the
grievance, the actions of the Respondent entirely failed to address the
faults and defects which had been identified in the way that they had been
originally dealt with.
48. We consider that these were serious breaches. We do not however
consider that they were the most serious breaches of the ACAS code but
we consider that they were significant and in the circumstances the
Tribunal has come to the conclusion that there ought to be an award of
compensation to the Claimant which is increased by 15% for the breach of
the ACAS code.
49. The parties are agreed that the appropriate level of interest in this case is
8% and the number of days as 643 days. The Tribunal has considered
whether in its discretion it ought to make an alternative award in respect of
interest and the Tribunal has concluded that the figure of 8% interest over
the relevant period of 643 days is appropriate in this case and we would
therefore not seek to alter or vary the agreement of the parties in this
regard.
50. The Tribunal has gone on to consider whether this was an appropriate
case in which to make recommendations. We do not consider that this is a
case where recommendations can be made. We note that the purpose of
recommendations is to take specified steps for the purpose of obviating or
reducing the adverse effect on the Claimant of any matter to which the
proceedings related. The general nature of the recommendations sought
by the Claimant in our view suggest that it is not appropriate to make the
recommendations. We spent some time discussing whether
recommendations were appropriate having regard to the nature of the
difficulties that the Claimant faced with Linda Pham, especially in view of
the fact that there had recently been some suggestion that the Claimant
may have ended up once more under the line management of Linda
Pham. However, the Tribunal did not consider that it would be appropriate
for us to make a recommendation relating to where and when the Claimant
works or who is her line manager as we consider that these are matters
which are for the determination of the Respondent in the way that they run
their business. However, the Tribunal also takes into account that the
Respondent itself has very responsibly been alive to the difficulties which
have arisen between the Claimant and Linda Pham and that steps and
action have been taken by the Respondent in carrying out discussions
with the Claimant and her trade union representative in order to find a
solution which would mean that the Claimant does not have to work under
the line management of Linda Pham. Whilst it is not for the Tribunal to
make any determination that the Claimant is never to work under the line
management of Linda Pham, we do consider that it is appropriate for the
Respondent to be alive to this problem and to continue to seek to take
such steps as are necessary in order to avoid the Claimant having the
difficulties which have arisen from the line management of Linda Pham
occurring in the future. We note the witness evidence which was given by
Mrs Pangbourne and the steps that the Respondent has taken since the
promulgation of the liability decision in this case. In all the circumstances
we are confident that the Respondent would act responsibly in relation to
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 9 of 9
the Claimant and be alive to the problems that the Claimant being linemanaged
by Linda Pham might present.
51. For those reasons, we do not consider that it is appropriate to make any
recommendations in this case.
52. Having regard to the matters we have set out above, it is the judgment of
the Tribunal that the Respondent is ordered to pay to the Claimant the
sum of £32,990.56. This award of compensation breaks down in the
following way:
Injury to Feelings Award: £22,000.00
An award for personal injuries: £3,500.00
ACAS Uplift: £3,866.54
Interest: £3,347.12
A payment in respect of bonus
In the sum of: £276.90
Grand Total £32,990.56
________________________________
Employment Judge Gumbiti-Zimuto
Date: 20 September 2018
Reasons sent to the parties on
......16.10.18..................................
......................................................
For the Tribunal office
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 1 of 9
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant: Respondent:
Ms N Brown v Network Rail Infrastructure
Limited
Heard at: Reading On: 7 August 2018
Before: Employment Judge Gumbiti-Zimuto
Appearances
For the Claimant: Mr J Chegwidden (Counsel)
For the Respondent: Mr T Adkin (Counsel)
JUDGMENT having been sent to the parties on 14 August 2018 and
reasons having been requested in accordance with Rule 62(3) of the Rules of
Procedure 2013, the following reasons are provided:
REASONS FOR REMEDY JUDGMENT
1. In a judgment sent to the parties on 19 June 2018, the Employment
Tribunal found that the Claimant’s complaints of direct disability
discrimination, discrimination arising from disability, disability harassment
and victimisation are well-founded and succeed. A remedy hearing was
listed to take place today. The Claimant provided a witness statement; the
Respondent provided a witness statement from Ms Pangbourne, Head of
Human Resources (Policy, Projects and Performance) for Infrastructure
Projects. The parties provided an agreed remedy bundle. We have Outline
Submissions on Remedy from the Respondent and a Note on Remedy
from the Claimant.
2. The issues that we have had to determine are the level of an award for
injury to feelings, whether the Claimant should be entitled to recover for
personal injuries, whether an award should be made in respect of
aggravated damages, whether the Claimant is entitled to an uplift as a
result of any breach of the ACAS Code, the level of interest that the
Claimant is entitled to recover, and whether the Tribunal should make any
recommendations.
3. The Claimant has also made a claim in respect of loss of bonus. The
Respondent conceded this and the Claimant is entitled to recover the sum
of £276.90.
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 2 of 9
Injury to Feelings
4. The Employment Tribunal has come to the conclusion that the Claimant is
entitled to recover the sum of £22,000.00 in respect of injury to feelings. In
arriving at our award for injury to feelings, we have taken into account the
following features of this case.
5. The Claimant’s statement relating to remedy has not been contested by
the Respondent.
6. We note that in respect of the incident on 4 November 2016, the Claimant
states that she “felt a total loss of control”, that she “felt anxious” and
“started to shake”, she “felt sick”, she “felt shortness of breath” and she
“felt dizzy”. The Claimant says: “I wanted to escape to a safe place i.e.
home. Later that day, she had a tremendous headache and just wanted to
sleep”.
7. In respect of the incident on 9 November, the Claimant describes how on
the day of the incident, she “was extremely upset. I had a lump in my
throat and was desperately trying to hold back my tears and keep myself
composed. I felt hot, flustered and angry. I had the shakes, palpitations
and … felt sick. I wanted to escape to a safe place, i.e. home, … Home is
how I distance myself from the outside world when I can’t cope”.
8. The Claimant described how she was unable to sleep, felt anxious, angry,
and worried about what her team would think if her “but also about
continuing to work with somebody who did not take my disabilities
seriously”. The Claimant describes how when she awoke, she sent
several text messages to Linda Pham expressing her anger and how
upset she felt by Linda Pham’s actions.
9. The Claimant describes how she felt emotional and tearful; explained how
the matter had damaged her trust; described how she was anxious about
her disability and felt as though she had been treated as if she had a
disease and had become the laughing stock of the office. The Claimant
describes how she suffered an exacerbation of her OCD symptoms. The
Claimant, describing the nature of her disability, sets out in her statement
a description of the effect of her OCD symptoms.
10. The Claimant was unwell and unable to work because of the effect of the
events which had occurred on 4, 9 and 10 November 2016. The Claimant
who was prescribed medication to treat various ailments, because of the
incidents which occurred, had an increase in her medication.
11. The Claimant explains how the delay in dealing with her grievance caused
her further distress. She believes that the way the grievance was dealt
with was designed to deliberately cause her distress. The Claimant’s GP
records indicate that the Claimant’s mental health symptoms became
worse in the period following the incidents in November 2016. The GP
records for 16 November 2016 indicate that the Claimant’s medication
increased and that at that time she was complaining of not sleeping and
being tearful. She was not fit to work.
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 3 of 9
12. The Claimant describes how her emotions were intense; how on some
days she would feel weak and suffer double vision and be hyperacusis1.
The Claimant describes how she was reliant on over the counter sleeping
pills. She describes herself as medicating “to switch my brain off and let
my brain rest”.
13. The delay in dealing with the Claimant’s grievance had an impact on her
health.
14. On the Claimant’s return to work, she was placed in a role where she was
not required to work with Linda Pham. She was able to cope better with
her work and life, although at times still suffering some symptoms resulting
from the way that she had been treated by the Respondent.
15. The Claimant describes show she felt that she had been isolated in the
period from November 2016 until February 2017 and states that this was a
matter which caused her stress and anxiety. The Claimant explained that
moving her from her usual place of work at Davidson House to an office
away from Linda Pham left her feeling that she was the one who was
considered to be the problem.
16. The Claimant describes how the change in her office environment caused
her isolation and how the changed routine resulted in the worsening of her
OCD symptoms and triggered panic attacks. The Claimant describes
instances where she suffered panic attacks while on overcrowded trains
and how she suffered from increased levels of paranoia. We were
provided with an Access to Work Mental Health Support Service Plan
which described her mental health symptoms at the time.
17. By December 2016, the Claimant was struggling to remain positive, had a
mix of emotions, felt angry, tearful, confused and insecure. Her confidence
was shattered. She felt extremely tired and was struggling with poor sleep
and relying on sleeping pills.
18. The Claimant has set out detriments as she saw them and which arose
from the delay in dealing with her grievance. She describes how this
caused her stress, anxiety and worry. She describes how during the
grievance process she felt excluded from the team and how she suffered
nightmares and night sweats.
19. By January 2017, the Claimant was suffering from extreme low mood. She
states that the failure to resolve her grievance caused an increase in her
symptoms. The Claimant was referred to the mental health service as a
result of her symptoms. At the time of her assessment by the mental
health services, she described how she was upset, angry, crying and
could not get to bed or leave the house.
20. It was not until February that the Claimant was told the outcome of the
grievance. The Claimant describes how the outcome to the grievance did
nothing to alleviate the impact of the matters that had happened to her.
1 Hyperacusis is the name for intolerance to everyday sounds that causes significant distress and
affects a person's day-to-day activities.
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 4 of 9
She describes how when she was asked to take garden leave, this left her
feeling that she was not wanted. She explained the disappointment that
she felt at the outcome of the grievance process and her feelings that
complaints that she made had not been taken seriously. She says that she
was shocked that colleagues who she considered to be friends had
described her in their statements as mentally unstable and portrayed her
as “something of a nutter”.
21. The Claimant described events in March 2017 which resulted in her having
to attend the A&E department of the hospital; she describes being under
considerable stress in about March 2017. The Claimant’s appeal to her
grievance outcome was made in April 2017.
22. It was not until June 2017 that she received a response to the grievance
appeal.
23. We are referred to parts of the report prepared by a Consultant
Psychiatrist. The Claimant describes how she has always suffered with
depression, anxiety and OCD but goes on to state that as a result of the
work-related issues, she had suffered poor sleep and had to rely on
sleeping pills, something that she had never experienced before. She
further described how she had suffered panic attacks and suffered
breathing difficulties as a result of the treatment at work. She also
describes periods when she had over-eaten and under-eaten and suffered
flashbacks of incidents. She described how her OCD became out of
control, all of these matters she puts down to the treatment that she
suffered at work.
24. The Claimant describes returning to work in May 2017 with a new
manager who has been supportive and built up her confidence. At one
point, it appeared as though Linda Pham was going to resume as the
Claimant’s line manager, however, following discussions with the Claimant
and her union representative, alternative arrangements are being put in
place to allow the Claimant to continue to work under the manager with
whom she has enjoyed a successful return to work.
25. Taking these matters into account and also having regard to all of the
matters which were set out in our findings of fact in the liability decision,
the Tribunal has had to consider what the appropriate level of award is in
respect of injury to feelings.
26. The Tribunal has helpfully been provided with an extract from the IDS
Employment Law Handbooks, Volume 4, Discrimination at Work, Chapter
7, the section headed “Injury to Feelings, Quantum Vento Guidelines. We
have considered the contents of this document which we have found
helpful and useful in arriving at our decision.
27. The Tribunal has also had regard to the outline submissions provided by
the Respondent and the note on remedy prepared on behalf of the
Claimant.
28. The Claimant and the Respondent both agree that the appropriate Vento
band in respect of compensation is the middle band as set out in the
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 5 of 9
original Vento guidelines.
29. The Vento guidelines provided that the top band should normally be for
sums between the range of £15,000-25,000 and that sums in this range
should be awarded in the most serious cases such as where there has
been a lengthy campaign of discriminatory harassment on the grounds of
race or sex. Vento stated that the middle band was for cases between
£5,000 and £15,000 and should be used for serious cases which do not
merit an award in the highest band.
30. Having considered the specific features of this case, we consider that the
parties are correct to describe this as a serious case which should merit an
award which is not in the highest band. In arriving at our decision in this
case, we have regard to the fact that the Vento bands have been revised
in the case of Da’Bell v National Society for Prevention of Cruelty to
Children (2009) and also have had regard to the guidance of the Court of
Appeal in the case of De Souza v Vinci Construction (UK) Ltd (2017).
31. When we considered the circumstances of this case, we are satisfied that
the description that the Claimant gives of the impact that the discrimination
that she suffered shows that she has suffered serious harm as a result of
the discrimination. She has described a significant degree of injury to her
feelings. We note that there are features of the way that she was treated
by the Respondent which in our view would have resulted in an increase in
her injury to feelings.
32. In the manner in which the Respondent dealt with the grievance, we note
the delay not only in investigating the grievance but in also promulgating
the decision once there had been some investigation of the grievance. We
also note that the manner in which the grievance investigation was
conducted by the Respondent was inadequate for the reasons that we
have set out in our liability judgment and that this had a very real impact
on the Claimant.
33. We note the level of distress suffered by the Claimant which we consider
amounted to personal injury. She describes her lack of control, the anxiety
and illness that she suffered as a direct result of the stress that she was
suffering at this time.
34. The Tribunal notes and takes into account the fact that there were other
live factors which the Claimant sets out in her evidence which had an
impact on the Claimant’s condition during the relevant period but the
Tribunal is satisfied that the Claimant would have been generally dealing
with these stressors which occur in life in a way which enabled her to
function normally and appropriately at work but for the actions of the
respondent’s discrimination. It was only after the problems that arose at
work in respect of which she has been successful in bringing this claim
that the Claimant was tipped over the edge and suffered harm and
damage that resulted in her being unable to function properly and for a
significant period of time unable to work.
35. For these reasons, we are of the view that an award of compensation to
the Claimant is a matter which should be towards the top end of the middle
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 6 of 9
band of the Vento guidelines.
36. In arriving at the appropriate level of award in this case, we have looked at
the original Vento guidelines and in considering them we are of the view
that the Claimant should be awarded a figure which sits at 80% of the
middle band, that is a figure of about £13,000.00, applying the original
Vento award.
37. We have then gone on to consider the guidance set out in the Presidential
Guidance and applied a formula as described in the Presidential
Guidance.
“An Employment Tribunal may uprate the bands for inflation by
applying the formula x divided by y (178.5) multiplied by z and
where x is the relevant boundary of the relevant band in the original
Vento decision and z is the appropriate value from the RPI All Items
Index for the month and year closest to the date of presentation of
the claim (and, where the claim falls for consideration after 1 April
2013, then applying the Simmons v Castle 10% uplift).”2
38. To arrive at the figure at today’s date and we have therefore taken the
figure of £13,000.00 and divided that by 178.5 which is the RPI All Items
Index Value at the date of the Vento decision. We have then multiplied
that figure by 269.3 which is the RPI All Items Index Value for the month of
March 2017. We arrive at a figure of £19,612.88. We have applied a 10%
uplift as provided for in the case of Simmons v Castle and arrived at a
figure of about £21,574.17. The Tribunal has then rounded that figure up
to £22,000.00 which we consider to be an appropriate award in respect of
injury to feelings.
39. The Tribunal has then gone on to consider whether or not the Claimant
should be compensated for personal injury. The Tribunal has had the
opportunity of considering the medical evidence which was set out in the
trial bundle and also the Claimant’s evidence. It is the view of the Tribunal
that a fair reading of the evidence that has been presented to us shows
that the Claimant was generally affected by a variety of life events which
resulted in her becoming ill, in particular during the period from the end of
2016 into the first half of 2017.
40. The cause of her condition is life events which included the difficulties that
she faced at work and the discriminatory matters that she suffered. We are
satisfied that the Claimant’s personal injuries in this case were caused by
life events which included the way that she was treated at work.
41. We have then attempted to determine the extent to which the treatment at
work had an impact on the Claimant, the extent to which it tipped her over
the edge and/or caused the specific injury that she sustained, and we are
satisfied that the appropriate level of award should reflect 70% to the
impact of events at work. We come to this conclusion because it is clear
2 Employment Tribunal awards for injury to feelings and psychiatric injury PRESIDENTIAL
GUIDANCE (5 SEPTEMBER 2017)
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 7 of 9
from the Claimant’s evidence that whilst she suffered a variety of
difficulties and stresses, it was the impact of the discrimination at work
which caused the Claimant to sustain a level of injury which meant that
she was not able to operate in a normal way. It damaged her health and
made it impossible for her to be able to continue to work in ordinary
circumstances as she describes in her witness statement.
42. Having come to the conclusion that the Claimant is entitled to recover a
figure representing 70% of the sum which she is entitled to recover by way
of personal injury having regard to the medical evidence produced, we
note that the parties are agreed that the appropriate point to pitch the
Claimant’s award for personal injury in this case is the sum of £4,900.00.
The arrive at this by reference to the Judicial College Guidelines section
relating to psychiatric injuries. Bearing this in mind we consider that an
award of £3,500.00 is an appropriate sum to award in respect of personal
injury, that being approximately 70% of the sum of £4,900.00.
Aggravated damages
43. There are in this case things that could classically be described as
aggravating features: the delay in dealing with the Claimant’s grievance
investigation; the delay in promulgating the decision once it was
investigated; the failure to investigate the complaints properly; the failure
to deal with the Claimant’s case in a timely way in circumstances where
the Respondent was aware of the Claimant’s illness. However, all those
matters have been expressly taken into account in considering the
appropriate level of award for injury to feelings.
44. The question we have asked ourselves is whether this Respondent has in
this case demonstrated a highhandedness or oppressiveness towards the
Claimant so as to justify an award of aggravated damages. We remind
ourselves that aggravated damages are compensatory and to be awarded
in cases where the behaviour of the respondent, in causing injury to the
claimant, has been high handed malicious or oppressive.
45. In this case we do not consider that there is a level of harm to the claimant
caused by the respondent’s conduct which has not been compensated in
the award for injury to feelings to justify a further award for aggravated
damages.
Breach of ACAS Code
46. The Tribunal considers that the manner in which the Respondent delayed
in dealing with the Claimant’s grievance investigation, the failure to
properly investigate the Claimant’s complaints, the delay in promulgating
the Claimant’s decision are all factors that indicate a breach of the ACAS
code of practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures.
47. The Tribunal accepts that this was a case where the Respondent made a
genuine effort to deal with the Claimant’s grievances. We noted in the
liability decision the way that the matter was conducted by Phil Mear. The
fact that there was a genuine attempt to deal with the Claimant’s
grievances does not in our view remedy the fact that there was a failure to
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 8 of 9
deal with them in a way which is compliant with the ACAS code. The
Tribunal also notes that in dealing with the Claimant’s appeal on the
grievance, the actions of the Respondent entirely failed to address the
faults and defects which had been identified in the way that they had been
originally dealt with.
48. We consider that these were serious breaches. We do not however
consider that they were the most serious breaches of the ACAS code but
we consider that they were significant and in the circumstances the
Tribunal has come to the conclusion that there ought to be an award of
compensation to the Claimant which is increased by 15% for the breach of
the ACAS code.
49. The parties are agreed that the appropriate level of interest in this case is
8% and the number of days as 643 days. The Tribunal has considered
whether in its discretion it ought to make an alternative award in respect of
interest and the Tribunal has concluded that the figure of 8% interest over
the relevant period of 643 days is appropriate in this case and we would
therefore not seek to alter or vary the agreement of the parties in this
regard.
50. The Tribunal has gone on to consider whether this was an appropriate
case in which to make recommendations. We do not consider that this is a
case where recommendations can be made. We note that the purpose of
recommendations is to take specified steps for the purpose of obviating or
reducing the adverse effect on the Claimant of any matter to which the
proceedings related. The general nature of the recommendations sought
by the Claimant in our view suggest that it is not appropriate to make the
recommendations. We spent some time discussing whether
recommendations were appropriate having regard to the nature of the
difficulties that the Claimant faced with Linda Pham, especially in view of
the fact that there had recently been some suggestion that the Claimant
may have ended up once more under the line management of Linda
Pham. However, the Tribunal did not consider that it would be appropriate
for us to make a recommendation relating to where and when the Claimant
works or who is her line manager as we consider that these are matters
which are for the determination of the Respondent in the way that they run
their business. However, the Tribunal also takes into account that the
Respondent itself has very responsibly been alive to the difficulties which
have arisen between the Claimant and Linda Pham and that steps and
action have been taken by the Respondent in carrying out discussions
with the Claimant and her trade union representative in order to find a
solution which would mean that the Claimant does not have to work under
the line management of Linda Pham. Whilst it is not for the Tribunal to
make any determination that the Claimant is never to work under the line
management of Linda Pham, we do consider that it is appropriate for the
Respondent to be alive to this problem and to continue to seek to take
such steps as are necessary in order to avoid the Claimant having the
difficulties which have arisen from the line management of Linda Pham
occurring in the future. We note the witness evidence which was given by
Mrs Pangbourne and the steps that the Respondent has taken since the
promulgation of the liability decision in this case. In all the circumstances
we are confident that the Respondent would act responsibly in relation to
Case No: 3300410/2017
(R) Page 9 of 9
the Claimant and be alive to the problems that the Claimant being linemanaged
by Linda Pham might present.
51. For those reasons, we do not consider that it is appropriate to make any
recommendations in this case.
52. Having regard to the matters we have set out above, it is the judgment of
the Tribunal that the Respondent is ordered to pay to the Claimant the
sum of £32,990.56. This award of compensation breaks down in the
following way:
Injury to Feelings Award: £22,000.00
An award for personal injuries: £3,500.00
ACAS Uplift: £3,866.54
Interest: £3,347.12
A payment in respect of bonus
In the sum of: £276.90
Grand Total £32,990.56
________________________________
Employment Judge Gumbiti-Zimuto
Date: 20 September 2018
Reasons sent to the parties on
......16.10.18..................................
......................................................
For the Tribunal office
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.