Paul Simons v GB Electronics Ltd: 1809879/2018
Employment Tribunal
Published on 20 February 2019, 11:03
- Summary
- Employment Tribunal decision.
- categories
-
breach-of-contract
- country
- england-and-wales
- decision date
- 2019-02-12
Official Documents
-
Paul Simons v GB Electronics Ltd: 1809879/2018 - Reasons
Change History
-
First published.
Full Decision Text
Raw text extracted from the official documents.
Case Number: 1809879/2018
1
EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS
Claimant Respondent
Paul Simons v GB Electronics Limited
Heard at: Hull On: 04 December 2018
Before: Employment Judge Wedderspoon
Appearance:
For the Claimant: In person
For the Respondent: Mr Darren John Fell, Director
JUDGMENT having been sent to the parties and written reasons having been
requested in accordance with Rule 62(3) of the Employment Tribunals Rules of
Procedure 2013, the following reasons are provided:
REASONS
1. By claim form dated 20 August 2018 the Claimant, Paul Simons, brought a
claim for breach of contract against his former employer, G.B. Electronics
Limited, the Respondent.
2. Judgment was given on the day of the hearing dismissing the Claimant’s claim.
These written reasons are provided pursuant to the Claimant’s application
dated 13 December 2018.
3. The Claimant’s claim is for notice pay. His case was that he had served notice
to terminate his employment with the Respondent. However, the Respondent
required him to serve his notice working on a project which would mean he was
continuing to live and work away from home. In the circumstances, the Claimant
stated he had no alternative to resign before his contractual notice period
expired because he was concerned for his health working away from home.
4. The issue identified at the commencement of the hearing was whether the
Respondent was in repudiatory breach of contract by requiring the Claimant to
undertake work on the Anvil project (which meant working away from home)
during his contractual notice period.
Case Number: 1809879/2018
2
5. The Tribunal was provided with an agreed bundle of 79 pages. The Tribunal
heard from the Claimant and from Mr. Fell, Director of the Respondent
Company. The Respondent also relied upon two written statements of Mr.
McLaren and Mr. Phelps. Due to the fact there was no opportunity to challenge
their witness evidence at the hearing, the Tribunal has attached limited weight
to their evidence.
6. At the commencement of the hearing, it was clear that the terms of the
Claimant’s employment contract were relevant to the identified issue in the
case. At the Tribunal’s request, the Respondent obtained a copy of the
Claimant’s written contractual terms and the Claimant agreed that the terms
provided by the Respondent were applicable to his employment with them.
7. The Claimant was employed by the Respondent from 1 October 2007 until 31
May 2018; latterly his role was Senior Project Manager. The Respondent
contracts with third parties and installs life safety, security and data network
installations at different sites.
8. In November 2013, the Claimant suffered work related stress and was absent
from work for a period of about 5 weeks. From 2017/2018 the Claimant worked
on a project for the Respondent for 4 days per week based in Norwich and lived
away from home for a period of about 15 months.
9. On 18 January 2018, the Respondent informed the Claimant that Mr. Tommy
McLaren (the Claimant’s assistant) was being moved to another contract on 29
January 2018. The Claimant objected to this but was informed by the
Respondent that it was unable to afford to keep Mr. McLaren with the Claimant
on the “Norwich” contract.
10. The Claimant did receive some assistance from Shaun Raven but he was
already on site full time as owner of the sub-contract company carrying out fire
alarm and security systems installation for the Respondent.
11. The Claimant became increasingly stressed. He was working long hours to
complete the work. On 23 January 2018 he was informed he was required to
stay on site 5 days per week. The Claimant complained about this to Mr. Fell
who informed him that there was no other option and if the Claimant was
unhappy he could resign but wanted to know the Claimant’s decision by 9 am
on 24 January 2018.
12. On 24 January 2018 James Morrison, the Claimant’s line manager contacted
the Claimant and asked him what he had decided to do. The Claimant stated he
had no choice but to accept.
13. The Claimant explained that he was unable to sleep and was becoming
increasingly ill. Although at the Tribunal hearing Mr. Fell, on the part of the
Respondent, stated it was sympathetic to the Claimant, the Tribunal does not
Case Number: 1809879/2018
3
find any evidence of this. Despite alerting the Respondent to his situation, the
Respondent failed to undertake any risk assessment for the Claimant.
14. By May 2018 the “Norwich” contract was drawing to a close and the
Respondent informed the Claimant he was required to work on another contract
at RAF Marham on completion of the Norwich contract. The Claimant
complained that this meant him working away from home and he did not want to
work on this contract. The Respondent told the Claimant there was no
alternative. On this basis the Claimant discussed the matter with his wife and
concluded he would leave the Respondent’s employment in the best interests of
his health. It is agreed between the parties that it was an express term of the
contract that the Claimant had to give the Respondent three months’ notice.
15. On 25 May 2018, the Claimant wrote a letter of resignation explaining he was
retiring because of ongoing ill health due to work related stress and extreme
pressure and working away from home for so long has affected his personal
home life. He stated he was prepared to finish the “Norwich” job but did not see
any point continuing with works on the Anvil project (at Marham). He stated in
his notice of resignation that he could work his notice period on completing the
build documentation for the Norwich job but did not feel able to work on the
Anvil job at Marham. He sought to agree a leaving date.
16. Mr. Fell, replied to the Claimant’s notice of resignation. The Respondent wished
to discuss the Claimant’s refusal to work his notice face to face. He asked the
Claimant to attend a meeting on 29 May 2018. Initially the Claimant refused to
attend the meeting. Mr. Fell replied that the Claimant was seeing his “proposal
as the only solution to the situation with no consideration of operation of the
business and live projects impacted.” He stated that the Claimant’s failure to
work his notice period puts him in breach of his contract of employment. He
asked to meet the Claimant again.
17. At the meeting on 29 May 2018 with the Claimant and Ian Phelps, Group
Operations Director and Darren Fell, the Claimant explained to the Respondent
how he was feeling mentally and that he would not work his notice on project
Anvil. Darren Fell stated that the Claimant had been on the project since day
one and that the Respondent did not have any other work for the Claimant to go
to whilst he worked his notice. The Respondent stated that the Claimant was
required to attend the Anvil contract at Marham. The Claimant stated he did not
think he could do that. The Claimant stated that he felt he needed to take 8
months off all work and would decide what he wanted to do after that period
which could include working in a superstore. The Respondent stated that as the
Claimant was going on a two week holiday in June 2018, the Respondent could
get a temporary Project manager to cover the Claimant’s notice period and the
duration of the project. The Claimant asked if the Respondent would try and
claim back the cost of the temporary project manager if he did not work his
notice period. Mr. Fell stated that the Respondent would be entitled to do so but
if the Claimant agreed his last pay day would be 30 May the Claimant’s salary
could, be used to pay for the temporary Project Manager. The Claimant agreed
to leave the Respondent’s employment on 30 May 2018 on this basis.
Case Number: 1809879/2018
4
18. Under cross examination, the Claimant accepted that the client required the
Respondent to have management present on site 5 days per week. However,
he further stated custom and practice meant that he was not required to be on
site on all 5 days. He accepted that the Respondent was entitled to allocate him
a job/site to work on. Mr. Fell gave evidence that the Respondent was required
to fulfill the contract for the client on site. He stated that third parties do require
managers to be present on site. On balance the Tribunal concluded that
although the Claimant had been permitted to work on some sites at times four
days per week by January 2018 there was a requirement in his role to be on
site five days per week.
19. The Tribunal finds that the Respondent did require the Claimant to undertake
this Project and they required his expertise on site 5 days per week but the
Claimant because of his health was intransigent that he could not do so.
Submissions
20. The Claimant’s evidence is that he was forced to resign. No confidential
counselling services were offered or provided to the Claimant. He submitted
that if it had not been for the stress or if the Respondent had addressed his
mental state he would still be working there.
21. The Respondent’s case is that the Claimant had been employed on two
projects; the Quadrum Institute at Norwich and the Project Anvil (Marham). The
Claimant confirmed he was unwilling to work at Marham. The Claimant was
required to work at Marham. To avoid any future dispute, the Respondent
agreed with the Claimant he could leave his employment early but would forfeit
his entitlement to notice pay. The Respondent is therefore surprised he has
brought a breach of contract claim.
Conclusions
22. The starting point is the terms of the Claimant’s employment contract with the
Respondent. Express terms contained in the contract of employment determine
the obligations of the employer and employee.
23. It was agreed that it was an express term of the Claimant’s employment
contract that the Claimant must provide three months’ notice to terminate his
contract of employment.
24. The contract of employment states that the Claimant’s role involves “a
considerable amount of travel and may involve travelling overseas” (see letter
of appointment dated 29.8.2007).
25. The contract dated 6 January 2009 states at clause 3 “the Claimant is to
perform all acts, duties and obligations to comply with such orders as may be
assigned by the company reasonably consistent with that position… Not being
assigned to duties you cannot reasonably perform”.
Case Number: 1809879/2018
5
26. Clause 5 states “You may also be required to work at any other company
premises with reasonable travelling distance from your home. During the course
of your employment you may also be required to work at various premises
belonging to the Company…and to travel both with the UK and abroad.”
27. Pursuant to clause 14.3 of the company handbook it states, “although you will
usually be employed at one specific site it is a condition of your employment
that you are prepared wherever applicable to transfer to any other of our sites”.
28. The Respondent was entitled under the contract to determine where the
Claimant worked. This included travel overseas. The Claimant was a senior
project manager with expertise and significant skill. The Respondent required
the Claimant to work at the Anvil project during his notice period because it did
not have any other work for the Claimant to complete. This project required the
Claimant to be present on the site 5 days per week.
29. The Claimant had been working away from home for a long period. The
Tribunal accepts that this inevitably placed pressure and stress on the Claimant
and his family life. However, the Tribunal finds that the Respondent was
contractually entitled to require the Claimant to work on the Anvil project; it had
no other work for the Claimant to do during his notice period. An employee
cannot dictate to its employer where he/she can work. Further, the Claimant
was in a senior position and was required to continue in his role at Anvil.
30. The terms of the employment contract were drafted widely enough by virtue of
clause 5 to permit the Respondent to require the Claimant to work in the UK
and abroad. In fact, the Claimant had on his own admission in evidence been
working away from home for about 15 months on the Norwich project and
previously worked abroad for some months for the Respondent.
31. The Tribunal finds working at the Anvil site was a reasonable distance from the
Claimant’s home in the context of the drafting of the contractual term and the
way in which it had historically been interpreted; the custom and practice has
meant that the Claimant worked some distance in Norwich (and in fact abroad)
historically. The idea of continuing on the Anvil project and the distance from
the Claimant’s home may have been a stressful idea for the Claimant but was
not an unreasonable distance and was not in breach of the employment
contract.
32. When the Respondent required the Claimant to work at Anvil during his notice
period, it was contractually entitled to do so. The Claimant was bound to
comply. The parties in the circumstances reached a mutually acceptable
compromise. There was no breach of contract. This is not a claim for disability
discrimination whereby if an employee is disabled the employer must make a
reasonable adjustment to a usual place of work that places the Claimant at a
disadvantage. The Claimant has brought a breach of contract claim only.
Case Number: 1809879/2018
6
33. I also consider the position as regards implied terms. An employment contract
also contains an implied term that the parties to the contract will not without
reasonable and proper cause conduct themselves in a manner calculated or
likely to destroy or seriously damage the relationship of confidence and trust
which should exist between employer and employee (Malik v BCCI SA (in
liquidation) (1998) AC 20 and Baldwin v Brighton & Hove City Council
(2007) ICR 680. It is a severe test and there is no breach of the implied term if
any conduct destroys trust and confidence where there is a reasonable cause
for it. On the basis that there was a contractual right to require the Claimant to
work at Anvil, there is no breach of contract in requiring the Claimant to do so
although the Claimant found the idea stressful.
34. The breach of contract claim fails.
Employment Judge Wedderspoon
12 February 2019
Related Parties
Search the database for other cases involving these individuals or companies.